Stereoselectivity Seems To Be the Hardest Word: Tracking the Evolution of Asymmetric API Syntheses from Medicinal Chemistry to Process Development

Abstract

While medicinal chemistry campaigns are frequently carried out using non-stereoselective syntheses, the goal of most small molecule drug discovery programs involving chiral drug substances is to nominate and subsequently develop a single, unichiral entity. One of the consequences of this is that fit-for-purpose solutions like chiral SFC and HPLC, which are routinely employed during the discovery phase, must be replaced with more efficient approaches to obtaining the stereoisomer of interest as the program enters development. In this review, we examine twenty case studies from the last two decades of R&D in the pharmaceutical industry where non-stereoselective routes identified during medicinal chemistry campaigns were revised and new solutions for the stereoselective API candidate syntheses were identified during process development.

1 Introduction

2 Case Studies

3 Conclusion and Outlook

Key words

drug discovery - discovery chemistry - process development - route scouting - asymmetric synthesis

Publikationsverlauf

Eingereicht: 14. März 2025

Angenommen nach Revision: 08. Mai 2025

Accepted Manuscript online:
08. Mai 2025

Artikel online veröffentlicht:
11. Juni 2025

• References

• 1 Ariens EJ, Wuis EW. Clin Pharmacol. Ther. 1987; 42: 361
• 2 Gal J. Chiral Drugs from a Historical Point of View . In Chirality in Drug Research . Francotte E, Lindner W. Wiley; Weinheim: 2006: 3-26
• 3a Lovering F, Bikker J, Humblet C. J. Med. Chem. 2009; 52: 6752
• 3b Lovering F. Med. Chem. Commun. 2013; 4: 515
• 4a Cabrera DG, Smith DA, Basarab GS, Duffy J, Spangenberg T, Chibale K. ACS Med. Chem. Lett. 2023; 14: 875
• 4b McVicker RU, O’Boyle NM. J. Med. Chem. 2024; 67: 2305
• 5 Cornwall P, Diorazio LJ, Monks N. Bioorg. Med. Chem. 2018; 26: 4336
• 6 Hulshof LA. Right First Time in Fine-Chemical Process Scale-up. Scientific Update; Crowborough: 2013
• 7 Anderson NG. Practical Process Research & Development, 2nd ed. Elsevier; Amsterdam: 2012
• 8 FDA, Guidance Document: Development of New Stereoisomeric Drugs 1992 (accessed May 23, 2025): https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/development-new-stereoisomeric-drugs
• 9 ICH Harmonized Tripartite Guideline: Impurities in New Drug Substances Q3A(R2), 2006 (accessed May 23, 2025): https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/ich-q3a-r2-impurities-new-drug-substances-scientific-guideline
• 10 Mangin D, Puel F, Veesler S. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2009; 13: 1241
• 11 Owen DR, Allerton CM. N, Anderson AS, Aschenbrenner L, Avery M, Berritt S, Boras B, Cardin RD, Carlo A, Coffman KJ, Dantonio A, Di L, Eng H, Ferre R, Gajiwala KS, Gibson SA, Greasley SE, Hurst BL, Kadar EP, Kalgutkar AS, Lee JC, Lee J, Liu W, Mason SW, Noell S, Novak JJ, Obach RS, Ogilvie K, Patel NC, Pettersson M, Rai DK, Reese MR, Sammons MF, Sathish JG, Singh RR. P, Steppan CM, Stewart AE, Tuttle JB, Updyke L, Verhoest PR, Wei L, Yang Q, Zhu Y. Science 2021; 374: 1586
• 12 Algera RF, Allais C, Baldwin AF, Becirovic H, Bowles P, Brown AR, Buske JM, Clarke HJ, Do NM, Doyle K, Fifer J, Gray K, Happe A, Hardink M, Hubbell AK, James C, Khadamkar HP, Magano J, McInturff EL, Mustakis J, Ozbuyukkaya G, Piper JL, Place DW, Ragan JA, Rauschenberger B, Reyes G, Shehadeh R, Stanchina C, Stanley M, Weekly RM, Weinstein E, Weisenburger GA, Wood E, Yayla HG, Yu S. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2023; 27: 2240
• 13 Algera RF, Allais C, Baldwin AF, Busch T, Colombo F, Colombo M, Depretz C, Dumond YR, Quintero AR. F, Heredia M, Jung J, Lall A, Lee T, Liu Y, Mandelli S, Mantel M, Morris R, Mustakis J, Nguyen B, Pearson R, Piper JL, Ragan JA, Ruffin B, Talicska C, Tcyrulnikov S, Uyeda C, Weekly RM, Zeng M. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2023; 27: 2260
• 14 Zhang R, Mamai A, Madalengoitia JS. J. Org. Chem. 1999; 64: 547
• 15 Zhang Z, Madalengoitia JS. J. Org. Chem. 1999; 64: 330
• 16 Park J, Sudhakar A, Wong G, Chen M, Weber J, Yang X, Kwok D.-i, Jeon I, Raghavan RR, Tamarez M, Tong W, Vater EJ. WO 2004113295A1, 2004
• 17 Wu G, Chen FX, Rashatasakhon P, Eckert JM, Wong GS, Lee H.-C, Erickson NC, Vance JA, Nirchio PC, Weber J, Tsai DJ.-S, Nanfei Z. WO 2007075790A1, 2007
• 18 Li T, Liang J, Ambrogelly A, Brennan T, Gloor G, Huisman G, Lalonde J, Lekhal A, Mijts B, Muley S, Newman L, Tobin M, Wong G, Zaks A, Zhang X. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2012; 134: 6467
• 19 Werth J, Uyeda C. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2018; 57: 13902
• 20 Chen CH, Dong H. WO 2023009521A1, 2023
• 21 Avery S, Buske JM, Chen D, Chen H, Chen X, Davidson AR, Desrosiers J.-N, Dong H, Fellah N, Fernández DF, Grosso J, Han L, Hochdorfer T, Johnson AM, Jones BP, Kalinowski M, Launer-Felty KD, Lopez J, Makowski T, Mastriano C, Nguyen TN, Patel ND, Peng Z, Potter T, Pritchard RP, Rane AM, Reeve M, Richins MC, Salazar CA, Salisbury JJ, Simpson R, Tabshey L, Tweed EJ, Wahome PG, Walsh-Sayles N, Willie JA, Wood E. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2024; 28: 4079
• 22 Bernhardson DJ, Lara-Boykin S, McWilliams JC, Nieves-Quinones Y, Sharninghausen LS, Singer RA, Wang Z, Girvin ZC. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2024; 28: 4420
• 23 Reck F, Alm RA, Brassil P, Newman JV, Ciaccio P, McNulty J, Barthlow H, Goteti K, Breen J, Comita-Prevoir J, Cronin M, Ehmann DE, Geng B, Godfrey AA, Fisher SL. J. Med. Chem. 2012; 55: 6916
• 24 Benson H, Bones K, Churchill G, Ford G, Frodsham L, Janbon S, Millington F, Powell L, Raw SA, Reid J, Stark A, Steven A. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2020; 24: 588
• 25 Bender JA, Ding M, Gentles RG, Hewawasan P. US 20070270405A1, 2007
• 26 Bien J, Davulcu A, DelMonte AJ, Fraunhoffer KJ, Gao Z, Hang C, Hsiao Y, Hu W, Katipally K, Littke A, Pedro A, Qiu Y, Sandoval M, Schild R, Soltani M, Tedesco A, Vanyo D, Vemishetti P, Waltermire RE. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2018; 22: 1393
• 27 DeGoey DA, DeAnda FJr, Dombrowski AW, Dubovyk I, Greszler SN, Khrakovsky D, Lee C.-H, Newton JN, Noey EL, Okano A, Sippy KB, Souers AJ, Wang L, Wilson NS, Zablocki JA. WO 2022132997A1, 2022
• 28 Brady PB, Harper KC, Sorensen BK, Greszler SN, Lai C, Florjancic AS, Zhao G, Shelat BH, Storer GE, Henry RF, Hansen TM. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2024; 28: 3152
• 29 DeGoey DA, DeAnda FJr, Dombrowski AW, Dubovyk I, Greszler SN, Khrakovsky D, Lee C.-H, Newton JN, Noey EL, Okano A, Sippy KB, Souers AJ, Wang L, Wilson NS, Zablocki JA. US 20220213092A1, 2022
• 30 Terrett JA, Chen H, Constantineau-Forget L, Larouche-Gauthier R, Lépissier L, Beaumier F, Déry M, Grand-Maître C, Sturino C, Volgraf M, Villemure E. US 20190284179A1, 2019
• 31 Terrett JA, Chen H, Shore DG, Villemure E, Larouche-Gauthier R, Déry M, Beaumier F, Constantineau-Forget L, Grand-Maître C, Lépissier L, Ciblat S, Sturino C, Chen Y, Hu B, Lu A, Wang Y, Cridland AP, Ward SI, Hackos DH, Reese RM, Shields SD, Chen J, Balestrini A, Riol-Blanco L, Lee WP, Liu J, Suto E, Wu X, Zhang J, Ly JQ, La H, Johnson K, Baumgardner M, Chou K.-J, Rohou A, Rougé L, Safina BS, Magnuson S, Volgraf M. J. Med. Chem. 2021; 64: 3843
• 32 Terrett JA, Ly JQ, Katavolos P, Hasselgren C, Laing S, Zhong F, Villemure E, Déry M, Larouche-Gauthier R, Chen H, Shore DG, Lee WP, Suto E, Johnson K, Brooks M, Stablein A, Beaumier F, Constantineau-Forget L, Grand-Maître C, Lépissier L, Ciblat S, Sturino C, Chen Y, Hu B, Elstrott J, Gandham V, Joseph V, Booler H, Cain G, Chou C, Fullerton A, Lepherd M, Stainton S, Torres E, Urban K, Yu L, Zhong Y, Bao L, Chou K.-J, Lin J, Zhang W, La H, Liu L, Mulder T, Chen J, Chernov-Rogan T, Johnson AR, Hackos DH, Leahey R, Shields SD, Balestrini A, Riol-Blanco L, Safina BS, Volgraf M, Magnuson S, Kakiuchi-Kiyota S. J. Med. Chem. 2024; 67: 3287
• 33 Hong AY, Piechowicz KA, Timmerman JC, Zhang H, Molinaro C, Gosselin F. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2024; 28: 2325
• 34 Hecker S, Reddy RK, Glinka T, Rodny O. WO 2018005662A1, 2018
• 35 Hecker SJ, Reddy KR, Lomovskaya O, Griffith DC, Rubio-Aparicio D, Nelson K, Tsivkovski R, Sun D, Sabet M, Tarazi Z, Parkinson J, Totrov M, Boyer SH, Glinka TW, Pemberton OA, Chen Y, Dudley MN. J. Med. Chem. 2020; 63: 7491
• 36 Boyer SH, Gonzalez-de-Castro A, Hubertus-Dielemans JA, Lefort L, Zhu Z, Gnahn M, Schörghuber J, Steinhofer S, de Vries AH. M, Hecker SJ. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2022; 26: 925
• 37 Goossen K, Kuhn O, Berwe M, Krüger J, Militzer H.-C. WO 2006133822A1, 2006
• 38 Humphrey GR, Dalby SM, Andreani T, Xiang B, Luzung MR, Song ZJ, Shevlin M, Christensen M, Belyk KM, Tschaen DM. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2016; 20: 1097
• 39 Broeker J, Abbott J, Cui J, Fesik SW, Gollner A, Hodges T, Little A, Mantoulidis A, Phan J, Sarkar D. WO 2023099592A1, 2023
• 40 Leung JC, Xu Y, Radomkit S, Lee J, Kim WS, Reeves JT, Dong W, Jang H, Hou X, Lorenz JC, Shao X, Byrne D, Johnson J, Brundage A, Valentin C, Beyer P, DiMeo SV, Qu B, Li R, Sarvestani M, Song JJ. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2024; 28: 67
• 41 Tan Z, Ju X, Wu H, Dong W, Leung JC, Hou X, Lee H, Granger A, Paolillo JM, DiMeo SV, Chen C, Wu L, Lorenz JC, Sarvestani M, Buono F, Frutos R, Tampone TG, Huang X, Zhang G, Wang Y, Spinelli E, Lei Z, Song JJ. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2024; 28: 78
• 42 Kuvshinov AM, Gulevskaya VI, Rozhkov VV, Shevelev SA. Synthesis 2000; 1474
• 43 Jones P, Ontoria JM, Scarpelli R, Schultz-Fademrecht C. WO 2008084261A1, 2008
• 44 Wallace DJ, Baxter CA, Brands KJ. M, Bremeyer N, Brewer SE, Desmond R, Emerson KM, Foley J, Fernandez P, Hu W, Keen SP, Mullens P, Muzzio D, Sajonz P, Tan L, Wilson RD, Zhou G, Zhou G. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2011; 15: 831
• 45 Chung CK, Bulger PG, Kosjek B, Belyk KM, Rivera N, Scott ME, Humphrey GR, Limanto J, Bachert DC, Emerson KM. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2014; 18: 215
• 46 Sherer BA. WO 2016037026A1, 2016
• 47 Crescenzi C, Fuchss T, Ippoliti D, Langella A, Di Mola A, Massa A, Rozzi D. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2020; 24: 1018
• 48 Campbell BT, Chang W, Hartingh TJ, Hurzy DM, Kelly MJ. III, Klinger F.-M, Layton ME, McCauley JA, Nawrat CC, Parish CA, Perkins JJ, Roecker AJ, de Lera Ruiz M, Schreier JD, Shurtleff VW, Su J, Truong QT.
• 49 Peng F, Qi J, Zhang J, Wang E, Cao X, Chen L, Fan C, Fan W, Feng C, Lin M, Liu M, Nawrat CC, Schultz DM, Song C, Wang F, Yin J, Zhang Y. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2024; 28: 2150
• 50 Zhong W, Zhu X, Feng S, Sun X, Yang M. WO 2021000855A1, 2021
• 51 Feng S, Zhang H, Tang Z, Peng X, Yang M, Wei X, Zhong W. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2022; 26: 3089
• 52 EMA, ICH guideline Q3D (R2) on elemental impurities (accessed May 23, 2025): https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/documents/scientific-guideline/international-conference-harmonisation-technical-requirements-registration-pharmaceuticals-human-use-ich-q3d-elemental-impurities-step-5-revision-2_en.pdf
• 53 Cadieux J.-J, Chafeev M, Chowdhury S, Fu J, Jia Q, Abel S, El-Sayed E, Huthmann E, Isarno T. US 8742109B2, 2014
• 54 Sclafani JA, Chen J, Levy DV, Reese H, Dimitri M, Mudipalli P, Christie M, Neville CJ, Olsen M, Bakale RP. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2017; 21: 1616
• 55 Dixon DD, Grina J, Josey JA, Rizzi JP, Schlachter ST, Wallace EM, Wang B, Wehn P, Xu R, Yang H. WO 2015035223A1, 2015
• 56 Wehn PM, Rizzi JP, Dixon DD, Grina JA, Schlachter ST, Wang B, Xu R, Yang H, Du X, Han G, Wang K, Cao Z, Cheng T, Czerwinski RM, Goggin BS, Huang H, Halfmann MM, Maddie MA, Morton EL, Olive SR, Tan H, Xie S, Wong T, Josey JA, Wallace EM. J. Med. Chem. 2018; 61: 9691
• 57 Xu R, Wang K, Rizzi JP, Huang H, Grina JA, Schlachter ST, Wang B, Wehn PM, Yang H, Dixon DD, Czerwinski RM, Du X, Ged EL, Han G, Tan H, Wong T, Xie S, Josey JA, Wallace EM. J. Med. Chem. 2019; 62: 6876
• 58 Peng F, Tan L, Chen L, Dalby SM, DiRocco DA, Duan J, Feng M, Gong G, Guo H, Hethcox JC, Jin L, Johnson HC, Kim J, Le D, Lin Y, Liu W, Shen J, Wan Y, Xiao C, Xiang B, Xiang Q, Xu J, Yan L, Yang W, Ye H, Yu Y, Zhang J. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2022; 26: 508
• 59 Bottecchia C, Lévesque F, McMullen JP, Ji Y, Reibarkh M, Peng F, Tan L, Spencer G, Nappi J, Lehnherr D, Narsimhan K, Wismer MK, Chen L, Lin Y, Dalby SM. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2022; 26: 516
• 60 Chen Z, Marzijarani NS, Quirie S, Pirrone GF, Dalby SM, Wang T, Kim J, Peng F, Fine AJ. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2022; 26: 525
• 61 Marzijarani NS, Fine AJ, Dalby SM, Gangam R, Poudyal S, Behre T, Ekkati AR, Armstrong BM, Schultz CS, Dance ZE. X. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2022; 26: 533
• 62 Wang T, Phillips EM, Dalby SM, Sirota E, Axnanda S, Schultz CS, Patel P, Waldman JH, Alwedi E, Wang X, Zawatzky K, Chow M, Padivitage N, Weisel M, Whittington M, Duan J, Lu T. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2022; 26: 543
• 63 Pirnot M, Stone K, Wright TJ, Lamberto DJ, Schoell J, Lam Y.-h, Zawatzky K, Wang X, Dalby SM, Fine AJ, McMullen JP. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2022; 26: 551
• 64 DiRocco DA, Zhong Y.-L, Le DN, McCann SD, Hethcox JC, Kim J, Koley JN, Kosjek B, Dalby SM, McMullen JP, Gangam R, Morris WJ. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2024; 28: 404
• 65 Hethcox JC, Kim J, Johnson HC, Ji Y, Chow M, Newman JA, DiRocco DA, McMullen JP. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2024; 28: 413
• 66 Kim J, Zhang V, Abe K, Qin Y, DiRocco DA, McMullen JP, Sun A, Gangam R, Chow M, Pitts-McCoy A, Malkani AS. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2024; 28: 422
• 67 McCann SD, Dubina SH, Kosjek B, Alwedi E, Behre T, Burgess SA, Poggetto GD, DiRocco DA, Hartmanshenn C, McMullen JP, Padivitage N, Sun AC. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2024; 28: 441
• 68 Le DN, Wright TJ, Alwedi E, Hartmanshenn C, Li H, McMullen JP, DiRocco DA. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2024; 28: 451
• 69 Silverman RB, Andruszkiewicz R, Yuen P.-W, Sobieray DM, Franklin LC, Schwindt MA. WO 9323383, 1993
• 70 Hoekstra MS, Sobieray DM, Schwindt MA, Mulhern TA, Grote TM, Huckabee BK, Hendrickson VS, Franklin LC, Granger EJ, Karrick GL. Org. Process Res. Dev. 1997; 1: 26
• 71 Burk MJ, de Koning PD, Grote TM, Hoekstra MS, Hoge G, Jennings RA, Kissel WS, Le TV, Lennon IC, Mulhern TA, Ramsden JA, Wade RA. J. Org. Chem. 2003; 68: 5731
• 72 Martinez CA, Hu S, Dumond Y, Tao J, Kelleher P, Tully L. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2008; 12: 392
• 73 Debarge S, McDaid P, O’Neill P, Frahill J, Wong JW, Carr D, Burrell A, Davies S, Karmilowicz M, Steflik J. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2014; 18: 109
• 74 Moccia M, Cortigiani M, Monasterolo C, Torri F, Del Fiandra C, Fuller G, Kelly B, Adamo MF. A. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2015; 19: 1274
• 75 Suzuki Y, Lehmann I, Bichsel HU, Bader T, Thamapipol S. WO 2015189068A1, 2015
• 76 Carlone A, Bernardi L, McCormack P, Warr T, Oruganti S, Cobley CJ. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2021; 25: 2795
• 77 Giovannini R, Bertani B, Ferrara M, Lingard I, Mazzaferro R, Rosenbrock H. WO 2013017657A1, 2013
• 78 Frutos R, Tampone TG, Mulder J, Gao J, Sieber JD, Rodriguez S, Haddad N, Baer K, Brown J, Yang B.-S, Giovannini R, Song JJ, Grinberg N, Lee H, Senanayake CH. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2023; 27: 505
• 79 Sieber JD, Rodriguez S, Frutos R, Buono F, Zhang Y, Li N, Qu B, Premasiri A, Li Z, Han ZS, Xu Y, Byrne D, Haddad N, Lorenz J, Grinberg N, Kurouski D, Lee H, Narayanan B, Nummy L, Mulder J, Brown JD, Granger A, Gao J, Krawiec M, Williams Z, Pennino S, Song JJ, Hossain A, Yee NK, Busacca C, Roschangar F, Xin Y, Mao Z, Zhang X, Hong Y, Senanayake CH. J. Org. Chem. 2018; 83: 1448
• 80 Barlaam B, Cosulich S, Degorce S, Fitzek M, Green S, Hancox U, Lambert-van der Brempt C, Lohmann J.-J, Maudet M, Morgentin R, Pasquet M.-J, Péru A, Plé P, Saleh T, Vautier M, Walker M, Ward L, Warin N. J. Med. Chem. 2015; 58: 943
• 81 Moore PR, Muir JC, Dubiez J, Leslie KW, Tomlin P, McCormick M, Janbon SL, Cornwall P, Ryberg P, Berg R. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2021; 25: 1889
• 82 Bartkovitz DJ, Chu X.-J, Ding Q, Jiang N, Liu J.-J, Ross TM, Zhang J, Zhang Z. US 20100152190A1, 2010
• 83 Rimmler G, Alker A, Bosco M, Diodone R, Fishlock D, Hildbrand S, Kuhn B, Moessner C, Peters C, Rege PD, Schantz M. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2016; 20: 2057
• 84 Shu L, Gu C, Fishlock D, Li Z. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2016; 20: 2050
• 85 Batt DG, Bertrand MB, Delucca G, Galella MA, Ko SS, Langevine CM, Liu Q, Shi Q, Srivastava AS, Tino JA, Watterson SH. US 20140378475A1, 2014
• 86 Conaghan PG, Nowak M, Du S, Luo Y, Landis J, Pachai C, Fura A, Catlett IM, Grasela DM, Østergaard M. Lancet Rheumatol. 2023; 5: e263
• 87 Wisniewski SR, Carrasquillo-Flores R, Lora-Gonzalez F, Ramirez A, Casey M, Soumeillant M, Razler TM, Mack B. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2018; 22: 1426
• 88 Beutner G, Carrasquillo R, Geng P, Hsiao Y, Huang EC, Janey J, Katipally K, Kolotuchin S, La Porte T, Lee A, Lobben P, Lora-Gonzalez F, Mack B, Mudryk B, Qiu Y, Qian X, Ramirez A, Razler TM, Rosner T, Shi Z, Simmons E, Stevens J, Wang J, Wei C, Wisniewski SR, Zhu Y. Org. Lett. 2018; 20: 3736