Download PDF
Semin Respir Crit Care Med 2012; 33(04): 413-420
DOI: 10.1055/s-0032-1322411
Thieme Medical Publishers 333 Seventh Avenue, New York, NY 10001, USA.

Cost-Effective Critical Care: Cost Containment and Rationing

Gordon D. Rubenfeld
1   Department of Medicine, University of Toronto School of Medicine, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
2   Department of Medicine, Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
› Author Affiliations
Further Information

Publication History

Publication Date:
08 August 2012 (online)

    Permissions and Reprints

Abstract

Rationing occurs whenever the demand for a good or service exceeds its supply. Therefore rationing is an inevitable occurrence in medicine and in critical care where the potential demand for effective medical care will exceed supply. Although there are many strategies to allocate medical resources one that is often considered is based on cost-effectiveness. Cost-effectiveness analysis attempts to estimate the value of individual medical treatments in terms of dollars and outcomes. Allocation of medical treatments based on cost-effectiveness analysis requires valid estimates of both the costs and the effectiveness of treatments as well as some overarching body with the authority to enforce allocation based on these analyses.

Limitations of allocation based on cost-effectiveness analysis in critical care include difficulties in estimating marginal costs of critical care treatments, limited evidence for any treatments with efficacy, and the ethical principle of rescuing identifiable lives in imminent risk of death. The prospect of a pandemic influenza-like infection has stimulated a lot of interest in hypothetical rationing strategies for the intensive care unit, none of which has been tested in actual pandemic scenarios. Given the burden of critical illness and the wide variation in resources a global approach to rationing is untenable. The article concludes with a vision of the future of allocation in critical care.

Keywords

cost containment - rationing - critical care - ethics - resources
 

  • References

  • 1 Asch DA, Ubel PA. Rationing by any other name. N Engl J Med 1997; 336 (23) 1668-1671
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 2 Schroeder SA. Personal reflections on the high cost of American medical care: many causes but few politically sustainable solutions. Arch Intern Med 2011; 171 (8) 722-727
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 3 Mehlman MJ. The legal implications of health care cost containment: a symposium: health care cost containment and medical technology: a critique of waste theory. Case Western Reserve Law Rev 1986; 36: 778-877
    PubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 4 Brook RH, Chassin MR, Fink A, Solomon DH, Kosecoff J, Park RE. A method for the detailed assessment of the appropriateness of medical technologies. Int J Technol Assess Health Care 1986; 2 (1) 53-63
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 5 Hébert PC, Wells G, Blajchman MA , et al. A multicenter, randomized, controlled clinical trial of transfusion requirements in critical care. Transfusion Requirements in Critical Care Investigators, Canadian Critical Care Trials Group. N Engl J Med 1999; 340 (6) 409-417
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 6 Takala J, Ruokonen E, Webster NR , et al. Increased mortality associated with growth hormone treatment in critically ill adults. N Engl J Med 1999; 341 (11) 785-792
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 7 Rubenfeld GD. Understanding why we agree on the evidence but disagree on the medicine. Respir Care 2001; 46 (12) 1442-1449
    PubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 8 Kahneman D, Slovic P, Tversky A. Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases. Cambridge; New York: Cambridge University Press; 1987
    Google Scholar
  • 9 Jonsen AR. Bentham in a box: technology assessment and health care allocation. Law Med Health Care 1986; 14 (3–4) 172-174
    PubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 10 Alderson P, Schierhout G, Roberts I, Bunn F. Colloids versus crystalloids for fluid resuscitation in critically ill patients. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2000; (2) CD000567-CD000567
    PubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 11 Bodenheimer T. The Oregon Health Plan—lessons for the nation. First of two parts. N Engl J Med 1997; 337 (9) 651-655
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 12 Tengs TO, Meyer G, Siegel JE, Pliskin JS, Graham JD, Weinstein MC. Oregon's Medicaid ranking and cost-effectiveness: is there any relationship?. Med Decis Making 1996; 16 (2) 99-107
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 13 Rettig RA. False Hope: Bone Marrow Transplantation for Breast Cancer. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2007
    Google Scholar
  • 14 Groeger JS, Strosberg MA, Halpern NA , et al. Descriptive analysis of critical care units in the United States. Crit Care Med 1992; 20 (6) 846-863
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 15 Hadorn DC. Setting health care priorities in Oregon: cost-effectiveness meets the rule of rescue. JAMA 1991; 265 (17) 2218-2225
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 16 Ubel PA, Richardson J, Menzel P. Societal value, the person trade-off, and the dilemma of whose values to measure for cost-effectiveness analysis. Health Econ 2000; 9 (2) 127-136
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 17 Doubilet P, Weinstein MC, McNeil BJ. Use and misuse of the term “cost effective” in medicine. N Engl J Med 1986; 314 (4) 253-256
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 18 Eisenberg JM. Clinical economics: a guide to the economic analysis of clinical practices. JAMA 1989; 262 (20) 2879-2886
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 19 Ely EW, Baker AM, Dunagan DP , et al. Effect on the duration of mechanical ventilation of identifying patients capable of breathing spontaneously. N Engl J Med 1996; 335 (25) 1864-1869
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 20 Cook D, Guyatt G, Marshall J , et al; Canadian Critical Care Trials Group. A comparison of sucralfate and ranitidine for the prevention of upper gastrointestinal bleeding in patients requiring mechanical ventilation. N Engl J Med 1998; 338 (12) 791-797
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 21 Darouiche RO, Raad II, Heard SO , et al; Catheter Study Group. A comparison of two antimicrobial-impregnated central venous catheters. N Engl J Med 1999; 340 (1) 1-8
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 22 Ben-Menachem T, McCarthy BD, Fogel R , et al. Prophylaxis for stress-related gastrointestinal hemorrhage: a cost effectiveness analysis. Crit Care Med 1996; 24 (2) 338-345
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 23 Inman KJ, Sibbald WJ, Rutledge FS, Clark BJ. Clinical utility and cost-effectiveness of an air suspension bed in the prevention of pressure ulcers. JAMA 1993; 269 (9) 1139-1143
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 24 Morgan A, Daly C, Murawski BJ. Dollar and human costs of intensive care. J Surg Res 1973; 14 (5) 441-448
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 25 Jegers M, Edbrooke DL, Hibbert CL, Chalfin DB, Burchardi H. Definitions and methods of cost assessment: an intensivist's guide. ESICM section on health research and outcome working group on cost effectiveness. Intensive Care Med 2002; 28 (6) 680-685
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 26 Veenstra DL, Saint S, Sullivan SD. Cost-effectiveness of antiseptic-impregnated central venous catheters for the prevention of catheter-related bloodstream infection. JAMA 1999; 282 (6) 554-560
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 27 Digiovine B, Chenoweth C, Watts C, Higgins M. The attributable mortality and costs of primary nosocomial bloodstream infections in the intensive care unit. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1999; 160 (3) 976-981
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 28 Rapoport J, Teres D, Zhao Y, Lemeshow S. Length of stay data as a guide to hospital economic performance for ICU patients. Med Care 2003; 41 (3) 386-397
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 29 Reinhardt UE. Spending more through ‘cost control:’ our obsessive quest to gut the hospital. Health Aff (Millwood) 1996; 15 (2) 145-154
    PubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 30 Luce JM, Rubenfeld GD. Can health care costs be reduced by limiting intensive care at the end of life?. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2002; 165 (6) 750-754
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 31 Strauss MJ, LoGerfo JP, Yeltatzie JA, Temkin N, Hudson LD. Rationing of intensive care unit services. An everyday occurrence. JAMA 1986; 255 (9) 1143-1146
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 32 Sinuff T, Kahnamoui K, Cook DJ, Luce JM, Levy MM ; Values Ethics and Rationing in Critical Care Task Force. Rationing critical care beds: a systematic review. Crit Care Med 2004; 32 (7) 1588-1597
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 33 Ward NS, Teno JM, Curtis JR, Rubenfeld GD, Levy MM. Perceptions of cost constraints, resource limitations, and rationing in United States intensive care units: results of a national survey. Crit Care Med 2008; 36 (2) 471-476
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 34 Marshall MF, Schwenzer KJ, Orsina M, Fletcher JC, Durbin Jr CG. Influence of political power, medical provincialism, and economic incentives on the rationing of surgical intensive care unit beds. Crit Care Med 1992; 20 (3) 387-394
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 35 Alexander S. They decide who lives, who dies: medical miracle puts moral burden on small committee. Life 1962; 53: 102-125
    PubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 36 Indiana University Center for Bioethics. Pandemic Influenza Ethics Toolkit. Ethics guide for health care practitioners: working under conditions of an influenza pandemic: plan, prepare, practice 2009. http://bioethics.iu.edu/programs/other/pandemic/pandemic-influenza-ethics-toolkit/ . Accessed September 20, 2011
    PubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 37 White DB, Katz MH, Luce JM, Lo B. Who should receive life support during a public health emergency? Using ethical principles to improve allocation decisions. Ann Intern Med 2009; 150 (2) 132-138
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 38 Persad G, Wertheimer A, Emanuel EJ. Principles for allocation of scarce medical interventions. Lancet 2009; 373 (9661) 423-431
    Google Scholar
  • 39 Rubenfeld GD, Crawford SW. Withdrawing life support from mechanically ventilated recipients of bone marrow transplants: a case for evidence-based guidelines. Ann Intern Med 1996; 125 (8) 625-633
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 40 Hunt L. 'Death by computer' proposition dismissed. The Independent. August 25, 1994
    PubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 41 Christian MD, Joynt GM, Hick JL, Colvin J, Danis M, Sprung CL ; European Society of Intensive Care Medicine's Task Force for intensive care unit triage during an influenza epidemic or mass disaster. Chapter 7. Critical care triage. Recommendations and standard operating procedures for intensive care unit and hospital preparations for an influenza epidemic or mass disaster. Intensive Care Med 2010; 36 (Suppl. 01) S55-S64
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 42 Christian MD, Hamielec C, Lazar NM , et al. A retrospective cohort pilot study to evaluate a triage tool for use in a pandemic. Crit Care 2009; 13 (5) R170
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 43 Committee for Disaster Medicine Reform. http://www.cdmr.org/ . Accessed September 20, 2011
    PubMedGoogle Scholar
  • 44 Adhikari NK, Fowler RA, Bhagwanjee S, Rubenfeld GD. Critical care and the global burden of critical illness in adults. Lancet 2010; 376 (9749) 1339-1346
    CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar