Optimal Chest Drain Size: The Rise of the Small-Bore Pleural Catheter

ABSTRACT

Drainage of the pleural space is not a modern concept, but the optimal size of chest drains to use remains debated. Conventional teaching advocates blunt dissection and large-bore tubes; but in recent years, small-bore catheters have gained popularity. In the absence of high-quality randomized data, this review summarizes the available literature on the choice of chest drains. The objective data supporting the use of large-bore tubes is scarce in most pleural diseases. Increasing evidence shows that small-bore catheters induce less pain and are of comparable efficacy to large-bore tubes, including in the management of pleural infection, malignant effusion, and pneumothoraces. The onus now is on those who favor large tubes to produce clinical data to justify the more invasive approach.

KEYWORDS

Pleural effusion - pneumothorax - empyema - chest drain - intercostal - pleura

REFERENCES

• 1 Hutchins R A, ed Hippocrates, Writings. Chicago: Encyclopedia Britannica; 1952
• 2 Playfair W. S. Paracentesis in pleurisy and empyema.  Br Med J. 1872;  1 183
• 3 Miller K S, Sahn S A. Chest tubes: indications, technique, management and complications.  Chest. 1987;  91 258-264
• 4 Dev S P, Nascimiento Jr B, Simone C, Chien V. Videos in clinical medicine: chest-tube insertion.  N Engl J Med. 2007;  357 e15
• 5 Crouch J D, Keagy B A, Delany D J. “Pigtail” catheter drainage in thoracic surgery.  Am Rev Respir Dis. 1987;  136 174-175
• 6 Benton I J, Benfield GFA. Comparison of a large and small-calibre tube drain for managing spontaneous pneumothoraces.  Respir Med. 2009;  103 1436-1440
• 7 Tattersall D J, Traill Z C, Gleeson F V. Chest drains: does size matter? Review.  Clin Radiol. 2000;  55 415-421
• 8 Rahman N M, Maskell N A, Davies CWH et al.. The relationship between chest tube size and clinical outcome in pleural infection.  Chest. 2010;  137 536-543
• 9 Laws D, Neville E, Duffy J. Pleural Diseases Group, Standards of Care Committee, British Thoracic Society . BTS guidelines for the insertion of a chest drain.  Thorax. 2003;  58(Suppl 2) ii53-ii59
• 10 Duncan D R, Morgenthaler T I, Ryu J H, Daniels C E. Reducing iatrogenic risk in thoracentesis: establishing best practice via experiential training in a zero-risk environment.  Chest. 2009;  135 1315-1320
• 11 Horsley A, Jones L, White J, Henry M. Efficacy and complications of small-bore, wire-guided chest drains.  Chest. 2006;  130 1857-1863
• 12 Baumann M H. Management of spontaneous pneumothorax.  Clin Chest Med. 2006;  27 369-381
• 13 Havelock T, Teoh R, Laws D, Gleeson F. BTS Pleural Diseases Guideline Group . Pleural procedures and thoracic ultrasound: British Thoracic Society Pleural Disease Guideline 2010.  Thorax. 2010;  65(Suppl 2) ii61-76
• 14 Niinami H, Tabata M, Takeuchi Y, Umezu M. Experimental assessment of the drainage capacity of small Silastic chest drains.  Asian Cardiovasc Thorac Ann. 2006;  14 223-226
• 15 Park J K, Kraus F C, Haaga J R. Fluid flow during percutaneous drainage procedures: an in vitro study of the effects of fluid viscosity, catheter size, and adjunctive urokinase.  AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1993;  160 165-169
• 16 Baumann M H. What size chest tube? What drainage system is ideal? And other chest tube management questions.  Curr Opin Pulm Med. 2003;  9 276-281
• 17 Baumann M H. Death to the garden hose?.  Chest. 2010;  137 512-514
• 18 Yamaguchi M, Yoshino I, Kameyama T et al.. Use of small-bore Silastic drains in general thoracic surgery.  Ann Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2007;  13 156-158
• 19 Clementsen P, Evald T, Grode G, Hansen M, Krag Jacobsen G, Faurschou P. Treatment of malignant pleural effusion: pleurodesis using a small percutaneous catheter. A prospective randomized study.  Respir Med. 1998;  92 593-596
• 20 Parulekar W, Di Primio G, Matzinger F, Dennie C, Bociek G. Use of small-bore vs large-bore chest tubes for treatment of malignant pleural effusions.  Chest. 2001;  120 19-25
• 21 Collop N A, Kim S, Sahn S A. Analysis of tube thoracostomy performed by pulmonologists at a teaching hospital.  Chest. 1997;  112 709-713
• 22 Davies H E, Merchant S, McGown A. A study of the complications of small bore ‘Seldinger’ intercostal chest drains.  Respirology. 2008;  13 603-607
• 23 Maskell N A, Davies CWH, Nunn A J First Multicenter Intrapleural Sepsis Trial (MIST1) Group et al. U.K. controlled trial of intrapleural streptokinase for pleural infection.  N Engl J Med. 2005;  352 865-874
• 24 Davies CWH, Traill Z C, Gleeson F V, Davies RJO. Intrapleural streptokinase in the management of malignant multiloculated pleural effusions.  Chest. 1999;  115 729-733
• 25 Gilkeson R C, Silverman P, Haaga J R. Using urokinase to treat malignant pleural effusions.  AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1999;  173 781-783
• 26 Balamugesh T, Christopher D J, Rajesh T, Prince J. Fibrinolysis of loculated pleural effusion in malignant mesothelioma.  Singapore Med J. 2004;  45 594-595
• 27 Malhotra P, Graham A, Heaton R. Complications of small bore chest drains.  Respirology. 2008;  13 1096 author reply 1097
• 28 Maskell N A, Medford A, Gleeson F V. Seldinger chest drain insertion: simpler but not necessarily safer.  Thorax. 2010;  65 5-6
• 29 Wrightson J M, Fysh E, Maskell N A, Lee YCG. Risk reduction in pleural procedures: sonography, simulation and supervision.  Curr Opin Pulm Med. 2010;  16 340-350
• 30 Risks of Chest Drain Insertion. NPSA Safety Alert. 2008 [updated 2008 01/07/2010; cited]. Available at: http://www.info.doh.gov.uk/sar2/cmopatie.nsf/0/7602af27ade29f1c8025744a0046350c/$FILE/NPSA_2008_RRR003%20Chest%20Drain%20Insertion.pdf
• 31 Heffner J E. Diagnosis and management of malignant pleural effusions.  Respirology. 2008;  13 5-20
• 32 Efthymiou C A, Masudi T, Thorpe J A, Papagiannopoulos K. Malignant pleural effusion in the presence of trapped lung. Five-year experience of PleurX tunnelled catheters.  Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg. 2009;  9 961-964
• 33 Musani A I. Treatment options for malignant pleural effusion.  Curr Opin Pulm Med. 2009;  15 380-387
• 34 Khaleeq G, Musani A I. Emerging paradigms in the management of malignant pleural effusions.  Respir Med. 2008;  102 939-948
• 35 Warren W H, Kalimi R, Khodadadian L M, Kim A W. Management of malignant pleural effusions using the Pleur(x) catheter.  Ann Thorac Surg. 2008;  85 1049-1055
• 36 Monsky W L, Yoneda K Y, MacMillan J et al.. Peritoneal and pleural ports for management of refractory ascites and pleural effusions: assessment of impact on patient quality of life and hospice/home nursing care.  J Palliat Med. 2009;  12 811-817
• 37 Tremblay A, Michaud G. Single-center experience with 250 tunnelled pleural catheter insertions for malignant pleural effusion.  Chest. 2006;  129 362-368
• 38 Putnam Jr J B, Light R W, Rodriguez R M et al.. A randomized comparison of indwelling pleural catheter and doxycycline pleurodesis in the management of malignant pleural effusions.  Cancer. 1999;  86 1992-1999
• 39 Sioris T, Sihvo E, Salo J, Räsänen J, Knuuttila A. Long-term indwelling pleural catheter (PleurX) for malignant pleural effusion unsuitable for talc pleurodesis.  Eur J Surg Oncol. 2009;  35 546-551 (EJSO)
• 40 Pien G W, Gant M J, Washam C L, Sterman D H. Use of an implantable pleural catheter for trapped lung syndrome in patients with malignant pleural effusion.  Chest. 2001;  119 1641-1646
• 41 Díez-Porres L, Alonso-Babarro A, Iglesias-Docampo A, Díaz-Agero P. Outpatient management of malignant pleural effusion with chronic pleural catheter.  Palliat Med. 2008;  22 775-776
• 42 Putnam Jr J B, Walsh G L, Swisher S G et al.. Outpatient management of malignant pleural effusion by a chronic indwelling pleural catheter.  Ann Thorac Surg. 2000;  69 369-375
• 43 Daniel C, Kriegel I, Di Maria S et al.. Use of a pleural implantable access system for the management of malignant pleural effusion: the Institut Curie experience.  Ann Thorac Surg. 2007;  84 1367-1370
• 44 Ohm C, Park D, Vogen M et al.. Use of an indwelling pleural catheter compared with thorascopic talc pleurodesis in the management of malignant pleural effusions.  Am Surg. 2003;  69 198-202, discussion 202
• 45 Vedam H, Barnes D J. Comparison of large- and small-bore intercostal catheters in the management of spontaneous pneumothorax.  Intern Med J. 2003;  33 495-499
• 46 Laub M, Milman N, Müller D, Struve-Christensen E. Role of small calibre chest tube drainage for iatrogenic pneumothorax.  Thorax. 1990;  45 748-749
• 47 Conces Jr D J, Tarver R D, Gray W C, Pearcy E A. Treatment of pneumothoraces utilizing small caliber chest tubes.  Chest. 1988;  94 55-57
• 48 Liu C-M, Hang L-W, Chen W-K, Hsia T-C, Hsu W-H. Pigtail tube drainage in the treatment of spontaneous pneumothorax.  Am J Emerg Med. 2003;  21 241-244
• 49 Chapman S J, Davies RJO. The management of pleural space infections.  Respirology. 2004;  9 4-11
• 50 Keeling A N, Leong S, Logan P M, Lee M J. Empyema and effusion: outcome of image-guided small-bore catheter drainage.  Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol. 2008;  31 135-141
• 51 Chen C-H, Chen W, Chen H-J et al.. Transthoracic ultrasonography in predicting the outcome of small-bore catheter drainage in empyemas or complicated parapneumonic effusions.  Ultrasound Med Biol. 2009;  35 1468-1474
• 52 Rahman N M, Maskel N A, Davies C WH et al.. Primary result of the 2nd Multi-centre Intrapleural Sepsis (MIST2) trial; Randomised trial of intrapleural tPA and DNAse in pleural infection. Paper presented at: British Thoracic Society Winter Meeting December 2–4, 2009 London, UK; Thorax 2009 64 (Suppl 4): A1-A174
• 53 Colice G L, Curtis A, Deslauriers J et al.. Medical and surgical treatment of parapneumonic effusions: an evidence-based guideline.  Chest. 2000;  118 1158-1171
• 54 Gammie J S, Banks M C, Fuhrman C R et al.. The pigtail catheter for pleural drainage: a less invasive alternative to tube thoracostomy.  JSLS. 1999;  3 57-61
• 55 Heng K, Bystrzycki A, Fitzgerald M et al.. Complications of intercostal catheter insertion using EMST techniques for chest trauma.  ANZ J Surg. 2004;  74 420-423
• 56 Aylwin C J, Brohi K, Davies G D, Walsh M S. Pre-hospital and in-hospital thoracostomy: indications and complications.  Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 2008;  90 54-57