Towards a National Patient Card System in Japan

Abstract:

Patient Card Systems (PCS) have been applied on a regional level to improve access to patient information. However, current projects lack a vision of future integration on a national level. In addition, Integrated Circuit cards and optical cards were introduced without considering that their cost and capacity limits impose significant constraints for future integration. The major arguments against PCS are the huge costs incurred by such a system and the limitations of the card capacities. In addition, standards and legislation have not been sufficiently developed. In this study, we propose a new model of PCS that employs recent communication and card technologies as a key to access a national medical information center. We demonstrate that PCS are feasible if implemented in several distinct phases and if the acceptance and cooperation of physicians and patients are achieved. However, political consensus about the necessity of reform in the health care sector must be established so that the necessary legislation can be enacted.

Keywords

Health Care - Medical Information Systems - Patient Information - Patient Card Systems - IC cards - Optical cards

• REFERENCES

• 1 Kaihara S, Iwasaki S. What influence do hospital information systems have on hospitals?. Hospital 1993; 52: 856-63 (in Japanese).
• 2 Takahashi T, Tachizawa N, Nagao K. Various problems associated with the introduction of cards in the fields of insurance, medical care and welfare. JCMI 1993; 13: 68-71 (in Japanese).
• 3 Kojima K. Automatic Card system. Japan Med Ass J 1992; 108: 1935-9 (in Japanese).
• 4 Sherman DH. Hospital efficiency measurement and evaluation, empirical test of a new technique. Medical Care 1984; 22: 922-38.
• 5 Tanaka S. Advances in health economics and health services research in Japan. London: J AI Press INC, 1990; Supplement 1 169-78.
• 6 Vallbona C, Brown J, Albin J, Norris J, Fowler M. Application of an optical card medical record system in a community health center. Medical Documentation Update 1989; 7: 91-6.
• 7 Alkhateeb A. A structural model of integrating patient card system into a national medical information network. Nagoya University, The Economics Science 1995; 43: 115-44.
• 8 Englbrecht R, Hildebrand C, Jung E. The smart card: an ideal tool for a computer-based patient record. In: Medinfo '95. Vancouver; 1995: 307-9.
• 9 Dick R, Steen E. The Computer Based Patient Record: An essential Technology for Health Care. Washington DC: National Academy Press; 1991
• 10 Rienhoff O, Hornung B, Farroukh H. Professional cards of the european future. In: Health Cards '95. Amsterdam: IOS Press; 1995
• 11 Hahne-Reulecke K. Legal aspects of introducing the health insurance card and effects on medical confidentiality. In: Health Cards '95. Amsterdam: IOS Press; 1995
• 12 Vuillet-Tavernier S. The French experience on health cards – ethical and legal issues. In: Health Cards '95. Köhler CO. et al eds. Amsterdam: IOS Press; 1995
• 13 Beruhe J, Papillon MJ, Lavoi G, Durant P, Fortin JP. Can a patient smart card improve decision making in a clinical setting?. In: Medinfo '95. Vancouver: 1995: 337-9.
• 14 Newhouse PJ. Pricing and imperfections in the medical care marketplace. In: Health Economics Worldwide. Dordrecht: Kluwer Acad Publ; 1992: 3-22.
• 15 Warner K, Luce B. Cost-Benefit and Cost-Effectiveness Analysis in Health Care. Michigan: Health Administration Press; 1982