Climate in the Treatment of Pulmonary Tuberculosis in the First Half 19^th Century: The Case of Frederic Chopin

Abstract

Background The famous Polish composer Frederic Chopin (1810–1849) suffered almost all his short life from pulmonary tuberculosis. Physical treatment and climate therapy are the only aspect of Chopin’s disease history that has not yet been thoroughly studied. The etiology of tuberculosis in Chopin’s time was not yet known, so physical means and changes in climate in the first half of the 19^th century were the most important part of the physicians’ therapeutic arsenal in the treatment of pulmonary tuberculosis. Objectives are to study the use of physical methods and climate therapy in the treatment of Frederic Chopin.

Methods Scopus, WoS, MedLine, and PubMed data-bases, electronic archives were searched without time restriction for information on the use of physical methods and climate therapy in the treatment of pulmonary tuberculosis in the first half of the 19^th century in Europe. The analysis was also made of Chopin’s letters and the work of his most respected biographers in order to identify information about physical therapy in his treatment.

Results Chopin’s disease had been actively progressing since 1835. According to the proper 19^th-century tuberculosis treatment plan which was set out in the treatises of prominent European physicians, Chopin was treated with physical means: blister plasters, cupping, creosote inhalations, sulfur baths, opium and belladonna plasters. Changing the climate in winter (southern France or Italy) was also a standard recommendation. In October 1838, Chopin, who was still recovering from another seasonal exacerbation of pulmonary tuberculosis, took a trip to Mallorca, where he spent the winter.

Conclusions Chopin had the advanced stage of consumption, which was already regarded at that time as a contraindication to climate change. The destination was also unsuitable for patients with pulmonary tuberculosis: winter climate of Majorca, characterized by high humidity and strong winds, negatively affected Chopin’s health. The disease was manifested by fever, hemoptysis, shortness of breath and exhaustion, which indicated tuberculosis intoxication and destruction of lung tissue. Chopin’s trip to Majorca 1838/1839 will forever go down in the history of climate therapy as an example of the negative consequences of ignoring contraindications to climate change.

Zusammenfassung

Der Hintergrund Der berühmte polnische Komponist Frédéric Chopin (1810–1849) litt fast sein ganzes kurzes Leben lang an Lungentuberkulose. Physikalische Behandlung und Klimatherapie sind der einzige Aspekt der Krankheitsgeschichte von Chopin, der noch nicht gründlich untersucht wurde. Die Ätiologie der Tuberkulose war zu Chopins Zeiten noch nicht bekannt, daher waren physikalische Maßnahmen und Klimaveränderungen in der ersten Hälfte des 19. Jahrhunderts der wichtigste Teil des therapeutischen Arsenals der Ärzte bei der Behandlung von Lungentuberkulose.Das Ziel dieser Arbeit ist es, den Einsatz physikalischer Methoden und Klimatherapie bei der Behandlung von Frédéric Chopin zu untersuchen.

Die Methoden Die Datenbanken Scopus, WoS, MedLine und PubMed sowie elektronische Archive wurden zeitlich unbegrenzt nach Informationen zum Einsatz physikalischer Methoden und Klimatherapie bei der Behandlung von Lungentuberkulose in der ersten Hälfte des 19. Jahrhunderts in Europa durchsucht. Die Analyse erfolgte auch an Chopins Briefen und der Arbeit seiner angesehensten Biographen, um Informationen über die Physiotherapie in seiner Behandlung zu ermitteln.

Die Ergebnisse Seit 1835, schritt Chopins Krankheit voran. Gemäß dem richtigen Behandlungsplan für Tuberkulose aus dem 19. Jahrhundert, der in den Abhandlungen prominenter europäischer Ärzte dargelegt wurde, wurde Chopin mit physikalischen Mitteln behandelt: Blasenpflaster, Schröpfen, Kreosot-Inhalationen, Schwefelbäder, Opium und Belladonna Pflaster. Auch ein Klimawechsel im Winter (Südfrankreich oder Italien) war eine Standardempfehlung. Im Oktober 1838 unternahm Chopin, der sich immer noch von einer weiteren saisonalen Verschlimmerung seiner Lungentuberkulose erholte, eine Reise nach Mallorca, wo er den Winter verbrachte.

Die Schlussfolgerung Chopin hatte ein fortgeschrittenes Stadium der Schwindsucht, die bereits damals als Kontraindikation für den Klimawandel galt. Auch für Patienten mit Lungentuberkulose war das Reiseziel ungeeignet: das winterliche Klima Mallorcas, das durch hohe Luftfeuchtigkeit und starke Winde gekennzeichnet ist, wirkte sich negativ auf Chopins Gesundheit aus. Die Krankheit äußerte sich durch Fieber, Hämoptyse, Kurzatmigkeit und Erschöpfung, was auf eine Vergiftung und Zerstörung des Lungengewebes hindeutete. Chopins Reise nach Mallorca 1838/1839 wird als Beispiel für die negativen Folgen des Ignorierens von Kontraindikationen für den Klimawandel in die Geschichte der Klimatherapie eingehen.

Keywords

balneology - physical therapies - physiotherapy - physiotherapy prescription - spa resorts

Schlüsselwörter

physikalische Therapien - Balneologie - Spa-Resorts - Physiotherapie-Rezept - Physiotherapie

Publication History

Received: 15 October 2023

Accepted: 05 March 2024

Article published online:
28 March 2024

• References

• 1 Ollivier AA. De la Tuberculose a Paris. Et Sa Prophylaxie. Etudes d'Hygiène Publique. 1886; 1: 84-182. (French) [Ollivier AA. Tuberculosis in Paris. And Its Prophylaxis. Public health studies 1886; 1: 84-182
• 2 Laennec RTH. A treatise on the diseases of the chest: in which they are described according to their anatomical characters, and their diagnosis established on a new principle by means of acoustick instruments. Forbes J. translator from French. London: Printed for T. and G. Underwood; 1827: 722
• 3 Broussais F. History of chronic phlegmasiae, or inflammations: founded on clinical experience and pathological anatomy, exhibiting a view of the different varieties and complications of these diseases; with their various methods of treatment. Vol. I. Translated from French by Hays I. and Griffith R. Philadelphia: Carey & Lea; 1831. 497.
• 4 Clark J. A Treatise on Tubercular Phthisis, or Pulmonary Consumption: Reprinted from the Cyclopoedia of Practical Medicine. London: Marchant Printer; 1834. 88.
• 5 Witt M, Dobosz T. Inheritance vs. infectivity as a mechanism of malady and death of Frederic Chopin. Journal of Applied Genetics 2021; 62: 607-611 DOI: 10.1007/s13353-021-00651-2.
• 6 Laennec RTH. A treatise on the diseases of the chest: in which they are described according to their anatomical characters, and their diagnosis established on a new principle by means of acoustick instruments. Forbes J. translator from French. London: Printed for T. and G. Underwood; 1821. 437.
• 7 Migliori GB, Zellweger JP, Abubakar I. et al. European Union standards for tuberculosis care. European Respiratory Journal 2012; 39: 807-819 DOI: 10.1183/09031936.00203811.
• 8 Sieluzycki, Czeslaw. “O zdrowiu Chopina. Prawdy, domniemania, legendy” [About Chopin’s health: Truths, conjectures, legends]. Rocznik Chopinowski. 1983; 15: 69–116. An assessment of Chopin’s health, much taken from the letters. Offers a list of Chopin’s physicians
• 9 Walker A. Fryderyk Chopin: A Life and Times. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux; 2018. 768.
• 10 Gavoty B. Frederic Chopin. New York: Scribner; 1977. 472.
• 11 Esquirol E. Mental Diseases, considered in a Medical, Hygienic, and Medico-Legal point of view. The Edinburgh Medical and Surgical Journal 1839; 51: 133-165
• 12 Morton S. Illustrations of pulmonary consumption, its anatomical characters, causes, symptoms and treatment. With twelve plates, drawn and coloured from nature. Philadelphia: Key & Biddle; 1834. 183.
• 13 Louis PCA. Pathological researches on phthisis. Translate from the French by Charles Cowan. London: Edward Portwine; 1835. 388.
• 14 Chopin F. Chopin’s letters. Collected by Henryk Opienski. Translated from the original Polish and French with a Preface and Editorial notes by E. L. Voynich. New York: Published by Alfred A. Knopf; 1931. 435.
• 15 Szulc T. Chopin in Paris: The life and times of the romantic composer. New York: Simon and Schuster; 1999. 448.
• 16 Hedley A. Selected correspondence of Fryderyk Chopin. Heinemann; London: 1962. 400.
• 17 Zamoyski A. Chopin: a new biography. New York: Doubleday; 1980. 416.
• 18 Franken FH. Diseases of famous composers: Twenty-two pathographies from Bach to Bartok. Transcribed from the German and edited by Karel B. Absolon. Rockville: Kabel Publishers; 1996. 361.
• 19 Neumayr A. Music and Medicine: Chopin, Smetana, Tchaikovsky, Mahler: notes on their lives, works, and medical histories. Lansing: Medi-Ed Press; 1994. 400.
• 20 Niecks F. Frederick Chopin as a man and musician. Vol. II. London: Novello, Ewer & Co.; 1888. 340.
• 21 Wierzynski C. The life and death of Chopin. Guterman N, translator. New York: Simon and Schuster; 1949. 445.
• 22 Hoesick F. Chopin. Życie i twórczość. Tom II. (1831 — 1845) Kraków: Nakładem księgarni F. Hoesick., G. Gebethner I spółka; 1911: 431 (Polish) [Chopin. Life and creation. Volume II. (1831 — 1845). Krakow: Published by F. Hoesick's bookstore, G. Gebethner & Co; 1911: 431 ]
• 23 Galignani JA. Galignani's New Paris Guide Or, Stranger's Companion Through the French Metropolis; Containing a Detailed and Accurate Description of All the Public Edifices, Gardens, Etc.; an Account of the Political, Scientific, Commercial, Religoius, and Moral Institutions of the Capital; with an Historical Sketch of Paris, and All Necessary. Paris: A. and W. Galignani; 1827: 838
• 24 Raciborski А. New and complete manual of auscultation and percussion, applied to the diagnosis of diseases. Translated by Fitzherbert W. London: Baily AH. and Co.; 1835: 201
• 25 Cormack JR. A Treatise on the Chemical, Medicinal, and Physiological Properties of Creosote: Illustrated by Experiments on the Lower Animals: with Some Considerations on the Embalment of the Egyptians. Edinburgh: Balfour and Jack, Printers. J Carfrae & Son 1836; 210
• 26 Robertson J. An Improved Mode of Managing Blisters. The Western Journal of Medicine and Surger 1845; 3: 167
• 27 Karasowski М. Frederic Chopin; his life, letters, and works. In two volumes. Vol. II. London: W. Reeves 1879; 380
• 28 Sand G. Story of My Life. The Autobiography of George Sand. Jurgrau T, translator. New York (NY): State University of New York Press; 1991. 1168.
• 29 Sand G. Letters of George Sand. de Beafort RL, translator. Vol. I. London (UK): Ward & Downey; 1886. 397.
• 30 Maurois A. Lélia: the life of George Sand. New York: Harper; 1954. 482.
• 31 Clark J. The Influence of Climate in the Prevention and Cure of Chronic Diseases, More Particularly of the Chest and Digestive Organs: Comprising an Account of the Principal Places Resorted to by Invalids in England, the South of Europe, &c.: a Comparative Estimate of Their Merits in Particular Diseases, and General Directions for Invalids While Travelling and Residing Abroad: with an Appendix, Containing a Series of Tables on Climate. London: T. & G. Underwood; 1829. 328.
• 32 Liszt F. Life of Chopin. Translated from the French by Martha Walker Cook, 4th editionrevised. New York: C. H. Ditson & Co.; 1900. 170.
• 33 Playfair J. A System of Geography Ancient and Modern. In six volumes. Vol. I. Edinburgh: Printed for Peter Hill; 1808. 500.
• 34 Fischer AC. A Picture of Valencia. Taken on the Spot. A Geographical and Statistical Survey of Valencia, and of the Balearic and Pithpusian Islands; Together with Remarks on the Moors in Spain. Second Edition. Translated from the German. London: Printed for Henry Colburn; 1811. 310.
• 35 Bell J. A System of Geography, Popular and Scientific, or a Physical, Political, and Statistical Account of the World and Its Various Divisions. Vol. II. Glasgow: Archibald Fullarton and Co; 1832. 614.
• 36 Sand G. Winter in Majorca. Translated and annotated Graves Robert. Chicago: Academy Chicago Publishers; 1992. 224.
• 37 The obligatory Declaration of Consumption Under Ferdinand VI, King of Spain, in 1751-Revival of Old Contagion Doctrines. The Cincinnati Lancet-Clinic 1903; 90: 21-25
• 38 Graves R. Clinical lecture. Lecture XVI. Pathology of phthisis concluded. The London Medical and Surgical Journal 1833; 3: 262-267
• 39 Daniel TM. Captain of Death: The Story of Tuberculosis. Rochester: University of Rochester Press; 1999. 296.
• 40 De Pourtales G. Polonaise-The Life of Chopin. Translated from the French by Charles Bayly. New York: Henry Holt and Cо; 1927. 349.
• 41 Spriggs EA. Rest and exercise in pulmonary tuberculosis: A study of fashions in treatment. Tubercle 1960; 41: 455-462 DOI: 10.1016/S0041-3879(60)80056-6.
• 42 Rogers FB. The rise and decline of the altitude therapy of tuberculosis. Bulletin of the History of Medicine 1969; 43: 1-16
• 43 Maharjan B, Gopali RS, Zhang Y. A scoping review on climate change and tuberculosis. International Journal of Biometeorology 2021; 65: 1579-1595 DOI: 10.1007/s00484-021-02117-w.
• 44 Kharwadkar S, Attanayake V, Duncan J. et al. The impact of climate change on the risk factors for tuberculosis: A systematic review. Environmental Research 2022; 212: 113436 DOI: 10.1016/j.envres.2022.113436.