Key-words:
Computed tomographic angiography source image Alberta Stroke Program Early Computed
Tomography Score - final infarct volume - increase Alberta Stroke Program Early Computed
Tomography Score - stroke outcome
Introduction
Stroke is a major worldwide health burden and is the leading cause of death and long-term
disability. Imaging is crucial in acute stroke diagnosis and management. Noncontrast
computed tomography (NCCT) is presently the imaging method of choice since it is faster
and more widely available than magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).[[1]],[[2]],[[3]] The Alberta Stroke Program Early Computed Tomography Score (ASPECTS) from the baseline
NCCT is a simple grading system developed to assess early infarct and is currently
used worldwide during the decision-making process before revascularization with intravenous
(IV) thrombolysis or endovascular thrombectomy.
Preoperative computed tomographic angiography (CTA) is recommended in patients who
are indicated for endovascular thrombectomy.[[2]] CTA is able to assess the site of vessel occlusion and rapidly provide useful information
that may affect management, such as collateral status and the source image of preoperative
CTA (CTA-SI) to predict final infarct, which can affect patient clinical outcomes.[[4]]
Various studies have confirmed that good collateral status on preoperative multiphase
CTA improves clinical outcomes in relation to final infarct size.[[5]],[[6]],[[7]],[[8]],[[9]],[[10]],[[11]],[[12]] Meanwhile, CTA-SI hypoattenuated areas have been found to have correlations with
final infarct size and clinical outcomes in comparison to NCCT.[[11]],[[13]],[[14]],[[15]],[[16]],[[17]] Some studies also show that CTA-SI hypoattenuated areas represent infarct core.[[11]],[[13]],[[14]],[[15]] However, we observe that a number of patients who had undergone endovascular thrombectomy
in our center showed increased ASPECTS in 24-h NCCT from CTA-SI ASPECTS and these
patients showed good clinical outcomes. We therefore hypothesize that increasing ASPECTS
in postoperative NCCT may be associated with good clinical outcomes for acute ischemic
stroke patients.
Subjects and Methods
Study protocol and population
In this retrospective cross-sectional study, the researchers assessed clinical and
imaging information from postendovascular thrombectomy patients in the researcher's
center from January 2012 to September 2017. Ninety-three postendovascular thrombectomy
patients were enrolled in the study.
Patients were excluded if there was posterior circulation acute ischemic stroke (n
= 15) and no CTA brain images present in our data system (n = 26). A total of 52 patients
were enrolled in the final analysis. Baseline demographic data included age, sex,
underlying diseases associated vascular risk factors, initial National Institutes
of Health Stroke Scale (NIHSS) scores, IV recombinant tissue plasminogen activator
(r-TPA) treatment, site of vessel occlusion, NCCT ASPECTS, preoperative CTA-SI ASPECTS,
and follow-up NCCT ASPECTS of at least 24 h, hemorrhagic transformation, collateral
status, time from symptom onset to recanalization, time from CTA to recanalization,
the endovascular thrombectomy method, the thrombolysis in cerebral infarct score (TICI),
and the modified Rankin Scale (mRS) for outcome analysis. The study was approved by
the local ethics committee on human right related to research involving human subjects,
based on the Declaration of Helsinki.
Imaging techniques
Multislice NCCT, preoperative multiphase CTA-SI, and follow-up NCCT of at least 24
h to assess the final infarct size were performed in our center with (1) A 320-detector
Toshiba (Aquillion One Toshiba Medical Systems Co., Tokyo, Japan), (2) A 64-detector
Toshiba (Aquillion CX Toshiba Medical Systems Co., Tokyo, Japan), and (3) A 64-detector
Philips (IQon Philips Healthcare, USA).
Continuous axial sections parallel to the orbitomeatal line of NCCT were obtained
from the base of the skull to vertex. Coverage of CTA varied from skull base to vertex,
C7 to vertex, and aortic arch to vertex. The contrast was injected at a flow rate
of 4–5 cc/s with a total volume of 70–90 cc. The patients from other hospitals that
indicated for endovascular thrombectomy performed multislice NCCT with single-phase
CTA before referring to our center.
Imaging analysis
All images were independently evaluated by one interventional neuroradiologist and
one radiologist. Images from preoperative NCCT, preoperative multiphase and single-phase
CTA-SI, and the follow-up NCCT at least 24 h for each patient were interpreted at
an interval that was at least 1 week between reading sessions. The images were randomized,
and the researcher was blind to the clinical information beyond the side on which
the symptoms of stroke occurred. All images were digitally reviewed at the workstation
with the same large high-resolution monitor and the same optimal window setting.
Definition and imaging interpretation
Alberta Stroke Program Early Computed Tomography Score interpretation
The interpreters used the ASPECTS method to evaluate NCCT, CTA-SI, and NCCT at least
24 h. A normal CT scan should receive an ASPECTS score of 10 points. Evidence of parenchymal
hypoattenuation, loss of gray-white differentiation and sulci effacement on NCCT images,
and diminished contrast enhancement of the parenchyma relative to the contralateral
hemisphere on CTA-SI images were not scored.
Increased Alberta Stroke Program Early Computed Tomography Score
ASPECTS increase in 24-hour NCCT ≥1 point compared with preoperative CTA-SI ASPECTS
or preoperative NCCT [[Figure 1]].
Figure 1: (a-f) Preoperative noncontrast computed tomography, preoperative computed tomographic
angiography source image, and 24-h noncontrast computed tomography of the postthrombectomy
patient shows increased Alberta Stroke Program Early Computed Tomography Score in
24-h noncontrast computed tomography compared with computed tomographic angiography
source image (a and b) preoperative noncontrast computed tomography shows Alberta
Stroke Program Early Computed Tomography Score = 10 (c and d) preoperative computed
tomographic angiography source image Alberta Stroke Program Early Computed Tomography
Score = 4 (e and f) 24-h noncontrast computed tomography Alberta Stroke Program Early
Computed Tomography Score = 10
Good collateral status
Good collateral status in multiphase and single-phase CTA were described by García-Tornel
et al.[[12]] as score 4–5 points in the first and second phases of multiphase CTA or score 2-–3
points in single phase CTA [[Table 1]].
Table 1: Collateral status in multiphase and single-phase CTA were described by Garcia-Tornel
et al. as score 4-5 points in the first and second phases of multiphase CTA or score
2-3 points in single phase CTA
Good clinical outcome
Three months mRS <2.
Statistical analysis
Demographic, clinical, and imaging results were expressed as number with percentage,
mean (standard deviation [SD]), and median (range). To determine the differences between
the two groups, the researchers used a t-test or Mann–Whitney test for continuous
variables and a Chi-square or exact test for categorical data. The t-test was used
to determine the difference between NCCT ASPECTS, CTA-SI ASPECTS, and 24-hour NCCT
ASPECTS. The concordance correlation coefficiency was utilized to evaluate two interrater
agreements for total ASPECTS grading and agreement of infarct size between NCCT, CTA-SI,
and 24-h NCCT ASPECTS, with adjusted 95% limited of the agreement.
For preoperative CTA-SI ASPECTS, the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve
was employed to identify the best cutoff point of the standard guideline, maximum
sensitivity, and specificity for discriminating between patients with good clinical
outcomes. Subgroup analysis was used as (1) ASPECTS increase or reversible ASPECTS
(24-h NCCT ASPECTS higher than CTA-SI ASPECTS), (2) irreversible ASPECTS (24-h NCCT
ASPECTS equal or lower than CTA-SI ASPECTS), and t-test was used to determine the
difference between these groups.
Logistic regression and multivariate analysis were applied to determine the predictor
of the increased ASPECTS score and good clinical outcomes. The results are presented
as odds ratio (OR), 95% confidence interval (CI) with P value. Statistical analysis
was performed using STRATA 15.1 (StataCorp, Texas, USA).
Results
Interrater agreement for Alberta Stroke Program Early Computed Tomography Score interpretation
In the Bland–Altman analysis, there was a small difference between the mean NCCT ASPECTS
(0.11; P < 0.05; 95% limit of agreement −0.63–0.86), the mean CTA-SI ASPECTS (0.2;
P < 0.05; 95% limit of agreement −0.91–1.33), and the mean follow-up NCCT ASPECTS
at least 24 h (0.10; P < 0.05; 95% limit of agreement − 1.00–0.81). There was a substantial
interrater agreement for ASPECTS grading with an excellent concordance correlation.
Demographic data
The analysis included a total of 52 patients who had received endovascular thrombectomy
between January 2012 and September 2017. The mean patient age was 64.7 ± 15.9 years,
and twenty-nine of the patients (55.8%) were women. Underlying disease-associated
ischemic stroke risk factors, including hypertension, diabetes mellitus, atrial fibrillation,
and dyslipidemia, were present in 24 (48.8%), 8 (16.0%), 23 (46.0%), and 10 (20.4%)
patients, respectively. The mean baseline NIHSS score was 17.2 ± 5.2. The researchers
treated 19 patients (38%) with combined IV r-TPA and endovascular thrombectomy, while
33 patients (62%) were treated with endovascular thrombectomy alone. The mean (SD)
NCCT ASPECTS and CTA-SI ASPECTS were 8.1 ± 1.6 and 5.1 ± 2.5. The median (range) follow-up
NCCT ASPECTS at least 24 h was 6.5 h (0–10). In follow-up imaging, fifteen patients
(29.4%) had hemorrhagic transformation of an infarct. Twenty-three patients (44.2%)
had good collateral status. Internal carotid artery occlusion was identified in 31
patients (59.6%), followed by M1 middle cerebral artery (MCA) occlusion in 17 patients
(32.7%) and M2 MCA occlusion in 4 patients (7.7%). The median time (range) of stroke
onset to recanalization was 5.5 h (2.7–20.4) and the mean (SD) time of CTA onset to
recanalization was 2.5 ± 0.9 h. Endovascular thrombectomy was performed with stent
retrievers in 27 cases (55.1%), aspiration catheter in 10 cases (20.4%), and combined
methods were used in 12 cases (24.5%). Successful reperfusion (TICI 2b/3) was achieved
in 36 patients (61.5%), and favorable outcomes were observed in 15 patients (36.6%)
[[Table 2]].
Table 2: Baseline characteristics
Twenty-four hour noncontrast computed tomography Alberta Stroke Program Early Computed
Tomography Score compared with computed tomographic angiography source image Alberta
Stroke Program Early Computed Tomography Score and preoperative noncontrast computed
tomography Alberta Stroke Program Early Computed Tomography Score
The 24-h NCCT ASPECTS was lower than preoperative NCCT ASPECTS in 40 patients (76.9%),
and there was no difference in 12 patients (23.1%). The 24-h NCCT ASPECTS was higher
than CTA-SI in 21 patients (40.4%), no difference in 24 patients (46.1%), and lower
than CTA-SI ASPECTS in 7 patients (13.4%) [[Table 3]]. Using t-test to compare between preoperative NCCT, CTA-SI, and 24-h NCCT ASPECTS
showed that the 24-hour NCCT ASPECTS (mean/SD 5.82 ± 2.90) tended to lower than preoperative
NCCT ASPECTS (mean/SD 8.13 ± 1.57) with a mean difference of 2.30 (P < 0.0001) and
also tended to be higher than the mean CTA-SI ASPECTS (mean/SD 5.10 ± 2.51) with a
mean difference of 0.78 (P = 0.01) [[Table 4]].
Table 3: Subgroup analysis as higher, equal, or lower 24-h Alberta Stroke Program Early Computed
Tomography Score than preoperative noncontrast computed tomography and computed tomography
angiography source image groups
Table 4: Different Alberta stroke program early computed tomography score of preoperative
noncontrast computed tomography, computed tomography angiography source image, and
24-h noncontrast computed tomography
Univariate analysis
Multiple demographic, clinical, and imaging results were analyzed to determine the
correlation between (1) increased ASPECTS in NCCT and (2) good clinical outcome. The
CTA-SI ASPECTS score was found to be one of the most interesting associated factors.
The researchers used a ROC curve to identify the best cutoff point of CTA-SI ASPECTS
which included maximum sensitivity and specificity to predict patient outcomes. The
best CTA-SI ASPECTS cutoff value to predict good clinical outcomes is given as >5
with 86.67% sensitivity, 61.54% specificity, and a ROC area 0.73 (95% CI 0.56–0.90).
Univariate analysis contains various predictive factors, including sex, age <60, hypertension,
diabetes, atrial fibrillation, dyslipidemia, previous IV r-TPA, onset to recanalization
time, CTA to recanalization time, TICI 2b/3, ASPECTS of preoperative NCCT, CTA-SI
and 24-h NCCT, increased ASPECTS, CTA ASPECTS >5, good collateral CTA, and a history
of asymptomatic or symptomatic hemorrhagic transformation. The statistically significant
factors associated with an increased ASPECTS score in 24-hour NCCT were TICI 2b/3
(OR 5.84, P = 0.008) and good collateral status in CTA (OR 4.92, P = 0.008). Furthermore,
the statistically significant factors associated with good outcome were age <60 (OR
0.94, P = 0.01), CTA-SI ASPECTS (OR 1.37, P = 0.01), CTA-SI ASPECTS >5 (OR 3.8, P
= 0.03), increased in ASPECTS (OR 4.98, P = 0.01), and good collateral status in CTA
(OR 38.25, P < 0.0001) [[Table 5]].
Table 5: Univariate and multivariate analyses
Multivariate analysis
In the multivariate analysis, TICI 2b/3 (OR 5 P = 0.02) and good collateral status
in CTA (OR 4.2, P = 0.02) were found to be statistically associated with increased
ASPECTS in 24-h NCCT. Four factors were found to be statistically associated with
outcome prediction, which included age <60 (OR 0.92, P = 0.04), good collateral status
in CTA-SI (OR 38.25, P = 0.02), CTA-SI ASPECTS >5 (OR 8.71, P = 0.01), and increased
ASPECTS in 24-h NCCT (CTA-SI ASPECTS <24-h NCCT ASPECTS) (OR 7.11, P = 0.05) [[Table 5]].
Discussion
Factors predicting increased Alberta Stroke Program Early Computed Tomography Score
in 24-h noncontrast computed tomography
Although the 2018 guidelines for the management of acute strokes included a selection
criterion for patients to receive endovascular thrombectomy up to 24 after stroke
onset using additional CT perfusion or MRI [[2]] with automated software, this may not be available in every hospital. Moreover,
the researchers observed that a number of patients in our center who had undergone
endovascular thrombectomy showed increased ASPECTS score in 24-h NCCT from CTA-SI
and achieved good clinical outcomes. This subsequently inspired the researchers to
study the CTA-SI-related and patient-related factors that affect decision-making before
endovascular thrombectomy in our center.
Earlier studies suggest that CTA-SI hypoattenuated areas represent only infarct core,[[11]],[[13]],[[14]],[[15]] in concordance with one group of the present study's results in 24 patients (46.1%).
However, the present study also demonstrated that 24-h NCCT ASPECTS tended to be higher
than CTA-SI (increased ASPECTS) in 21 patients (40.4%). Moreover, the factors that
significantly associated with increased ASPECTS are TICI 2b/3 and good collateral
status. This result corresponds with Sharma et al.[[18]] and findings from recent studies [[16]],[[18]],[[19]] that the CTA-SI hypoattenuated area may be similar to the infarct core with a penumbra
zone and be closely correlated with cerebral blood flow on the perfusion CT, which
may imply that the salvageable brain tissue may survive if good recanalization (TICI
2b/3) is achieved and the patients have a good collateral status.
Factors predicting clinical outcome of acute ischemic stroke
To the best of the researchers' knowledge, previous studies have successfully established
the importance of collateral supply in predicting the final infarct volume and clinical
outcomes.[[5]],[[6]],[[9]],[[10]] Good collateral supply may help prevent or limit the extent of infarction until
the reperfusion of ischemic penumbra is achieved.[[5]] In contrast, inadequate collateral flow may cause irreversible neuronal damage
within minutes. In addition, the researchers suggest that the best cutoff value of
CTA-SI ASPECTS >5 can indicate good clinical outcomes for acute ischemic stroke patients.
These findings correspond with CTA-SI ASPECTS >5 by Sallustio et al.[[15]] and a recent meta-analysis study of five endovascular stroke trials.[[20]] These factors concur with the findings of the present study that age <60, CTA-SI
ASPECTS, and good collateral status were factors that were significantly associated
with good clinical outcomes and should be used as important indicators to influence
decision-making for endovascular thrombectomy. Moreover, the increased ASPECTS (24-h
NCCT ASPECTS > CTA-SI) is the additional factor that significantly associated with
good clinical outcome.
One of the useful factors to predict the postthrombectomy outcome and complication
is good collateral status in brain CTA. The published data show that chronic hypertension,[[21]] metabolic disease (e.g., diabetes and hyperlipidemia), and older age [[22]] could be a detrimental effect on leptomeningeal collateral status in large vessel
occlusion acute ischemic stroke patient. In our study, hyperlipidemia was found in
20.4%, 86.3% were 60 years or more, and 48.8% of cases have had chronic hypertension.
These factors may affect our patients and result in only 44.2% of cases have had good
collateral status.
A lot of previously published data elucidates how good recanalization status (TICI
2b/3) positively affects positive clinical outcomes,[[2]],[[3]],[[23]] but the results of the present study are discordant with those findings. This is
likely since our onset-to-recanalization time is prolonged with meantime 354.9 min
(±173.9 SD). Some published results [[24]],[[25]],[[26]],[[27]] show that good clinical outcomes may not be obtained even where TICI 2b/3 is achieved
if the onset to recanalization time window is prolonged. Moreover, the present results
show higher hemorrhagic transformation than previous data,[[28]] and there are only 44.2% of the patients in our study that have had good collateral
status, which may also affect the clinical outcome.
The limitations of the present study include that it was a retrospective fashion and
the small sample size which may decrease the statistical power of the study. Second,
the acute ischemic stroke patient with good collateral status CTA may have NIHSS <6,
which may not indicate for endovascular thrombectomy or enrolled into the present
study, causing selection bias to our result. Moreover, the time interval between NCCT
ASPECTS, CTA-SI ASPECTS, and follow-up NCCT ASPECTS in the evaluation of final infarct
size is prolonged, and multiple confounding factors are not included in the present
study such as pre-/post-operative blood pressure, which may affect the outcome. Furthermore,
previous studies used additional perfusion imaging for evaluating the final infarct,[[16]],[[18]],[[19]] while the researchers' institute only performs NCCT and preoperative CTA for routinely
patient selection for endovascular thrombectomy.
Conclusions
CTA-SI ASPECTS more closely approximates final infarct size than preoperative NCCT.
However, if good collateral CTA present and TICI 2b/3 achieved, the final infarct
was shown to be smaller than CTA-SI, which predicted a good clinical outcome as well
as age <60, CTA-SI ASPECTS >5, and good collateral status. These findings may play
a relevant role in predicting patient clinical outcomes and patient selection for
endovascular thrombectomy. However, the use of pre- or post-operative brain CTA as
the screening tool in acute ischemic stroke patients, contrast media-related complication,
iodine-induced renal intoxication, and radiation protection issues, as well as the
cost-effectiveness of the CTA should be considered, to prevent the sequential adverse
events or further financial problem to the patient.