Biomechanical Rationale of Endoscopic Decompression for Lumbar Spondylolysis as an Effective Minimally Invasive Procedure - A Study Based on the Finite Element Analysis

Abstract

We evaluated the biomechanical behavior of the endoscopic decompression for lumbar spondylolysis using the finite element technique. An experimentally validated, 3-dimensional, non-linear finite element model of the intact L3 - 5 segment was modified to create the L4 bilateral spondylolysis and left-sided endoscopic decompression. The model of Gill's laminectomy (conventional decompression surgery of the spondylolysis) was also created. The stress distributions in the disc and endplate regions were analyzed in response to 400 N compression and 10.6 Nm moment in clinically relevant modes. The results were compared among three models. During the flexion motion, the pressure in the L4/5 nucleus pulposus was 0.09, 0.09 and 0.16 (MPa) for spondylolysis, endoscopic decompression and Gill's procedure, respectively. The corresponding stresses in the annulus fibrosus were 0.65, 0.65 and 1.25 (MPa), respectively. The stress at the adjoining endplates showed an about 2-fold increase in the Gill's procedure compared to the other two models. The stress values for the endoscopic and spondylolysis models were of similar magnitudes. In the other motions, i. e., extension, lateral bending, or axial rotation, the results were similar among all of the models. These results indicate that the Gill's procedure may lead to an increase in intradiscal pressure (IDP) and other biomechanical parameters after the surgery during flexion, whereas the endoscopic decompression did not change the segment mechanics after the surgery, as compared to the spondylolysis alone case. In conclusion, endoscopic decompression of the spondylolysis, as a minimally invasive surgery, does not alert mechanical stability by itself.

Key words

Spondylolysis - finite element method - biomechanics - endoscopic surgery

References

• 1 Sairyo K, Katoh S, Sakamaki T, Komatsubara S, Endo K, Yasui N. Three successive stress fractures at the same vertebral level in an adolescent baseball player.  Am J Sports Med. 2003;  31 606-610
• 2 Wiltse L L, Wilden Jr E H, Jackson D W. Fatigue fracture. The basic lesion in isthmic spondylolisthesis.  J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1975;  57 17-22
• 3 Beutler W J, Fredrickson B E, Murtland A, Sweeney C A, Grant W D, Baker D. The natural history of spondylolysis and spondylolisthesis: 45-year follow-up evaluation.  Spine. 2003;  28 1027-1035
• 4 Fredrickson B E, Baker D, McHolick W J. et al . The natural history of spondylolysis and spondylolisthesis.  J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1984;  66 699-707
• 5 Buck J E. Direct repair of the defect in spondylolisthesis. Preliminary report.  J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1970;  52 432-437
• 6 Nicol R O, Scott J H. Lytic spondylolysis. Repair by wiring.  Spine. 1986;  11 1027-1030
• 7 Gill G G, Manning J G, White H L. Surgical treatment of spondylolisthesis without spine fusion.  J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1955;  37 493-520
• 8 DeWald R L, Faut M M, Taddonio R F, Neuwirth M G. Severe lumbosacral spondylolisthesis in adolescents and children. Reduction and staged circumferential fusion.  J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1981;  63 619-626
• 9 Seitsalo S. Operative and conservative treatment of moderate spondylolisthesis in young patients.  J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1990;  72 908-913
• 10 Davis I S, Bailey R W. Spondylolisthesis. Indications for lumbar nerve root decompression and operative technique.  Clin Orthop. 1976;  117 129-134
• 11 Osterman K, Lindholm T S, Laurent L E. Late results of removal of the loose posterior element (Gill's operation) in the treatment of lytic lumbar spondylolisthesis.  Clin Orthop. 1976;  117 121-128
• 12 Sairyo K, Katoh S, Sakamaki T, Komatsubara S, Yasui N. A new endoscopic technique to decompress lumbar nerve roots affected by spondylolysis. Technical note.  J Neurosurg. 2003;  98 (3 Suppl) 290-293
• 13 Dooris A P, Goel V K, Grosland N M, Gilbertson L G, Wilder D G. Load sharing between anterior and posterior elements in a lumbar motion segment with an artificial Disc.  Spine. 2001;  26 E122-129
• 14 Goel V K, Lim T H, Gwon J, Chen J Y, Winterbottom J M, Park J B, Weinstein J N, Ahn J Y. Effects of rigidity of an internal fixation device - A comprehensive biomechanical investigation.  Spine. 1991;  16 (Suppl) S155-S161
• 15 Goel V K, Monroe B T, Gilbertson L G, Brinckmann P. lnterlaminar shear stresses and laminae separation in a disc: Finite element analysis of the L3 - 4 motion segment subjected to axial compressive loads.  Spine. 1995;  20 689-698
• 16 Goel V K, Ramirez S A, Kong W Z, Gilbertson L G. Cancellous bone Young's modulus variation within the vertebral body of a ligamentous lumbar spine - Application of bone adaptive remodeling concepts.  J Biomech Engrg. 1995;  117 266-271
• 17 Kong W Z, Goel V K. Ability of the finite element models to predict response of the human spine to sinusoidal vertical vibration.  Spine. 2003;  28 1961-1967
• 18 Konz R J, Goel V K, Grobler L J, Grosland N M, Spratt K F, Seifert J L, Sairyo K. The pathomechanics of spondylolytic spondylolisthesis in immature primate lumbar spines - In vitro and finite element studies.  Spine. 2001;  26 E38-E49
• 19 Sairyo K, Katoh S, Sasa T, Yasui N, Goel V K, Vadapalli S, Masuda A, Biyani A, Ebraheim N. Athletes with unilateral spondylolysis are at risk of stress fracture at the contralateral pedicle and pars interarticularis: A clinical and biomechanical study.  Am J Sports Med. 2005;  33 583-590
• 20 Foley K T, Smith M M. Microendoscopic discectomy.  Techniques in Neurosurgery. 1997;  3 301-307
• 21 Khoo L T, Fessler R G. Microendoscopic decompressive laminotomy for the treatment of lumbar stenosis.  Neurosurgery. 2002;  51 146-154
• 22 Saringer W F, Reddy B, Nobauer-Huhmann I, Regatschnig R, Reddy M, Tschabitscher M, Knosp E. Endoscopic anterior cervical foraminotomy for unilateral radiculopathy: anatomical morphometric analysis and preliminary clinical experience.  J Neurosurg Spine. 2003;  98 171-180
• 23 Yuguchi T, Nishio M, Akiyama C, Ito M, Yoshimine T. Posterior microendoscopic surgical approach for the degenerative cervical spine.  Neurol Res. 2003;  25 17-21
• 24 Adamson T E. Microendoscopic posterior cervical laminoforaminotomy for unilateral radiculopathy: results of a new technique in 100 cases.  J Neurosurg Spine. 2001;  95 51-57
• 25 Ahn Y, Lee S H, Park W M, Lee H Y. Posterolateral percutaneous endoscopic lumbar foraminotomy for L5 - S1 foraminal or lateral exit zone stenosis. Technical note.  J Neurosurg Spine. 2003;  99 320-323