Factors Influencing Seed : Ovule Ratios and Reproductive Success in Four Cleistogamous Species: A Comparison between Two Flower Types

Abstract

Ovule and seed numbers, and the ratio between the two, were determined in chasmogamous (CH) and cleistogamous (CL) flowers/fruits in four perennial herbs: Viola hirta, V. mirabilis, V. riviniana, and Oxalis acetosella. The results were applied to data from earlier studies on fruit set and progeny performance in these species, to find implications for factors influencing seed : ovule (S : O) ratio, to relate S : O ratio to other fitness components, and to compare final numbers of seedlings per initiated ovule between the two reproductive modes. Mechanisms considered to have a potential impact on S : O ratios were pollen limitation, resource limitation, and “genetic load”. In V. mirabilis and O. acetosella, mean S : O ratio was significantly higher in the CL phase than in the CH phase; in V. hirta and V. riviniana, there was no difference. Pollen limitation seemed improbable as a factor important for seed set in all species, and no indication was found of resource limitation. There was a negative correlation between S : O ratio and seed germination rate in O. acetosella, indicating that seed abortion, particularly in CH fruits, may be a way to purge inferior zygotes. The high CH S : O ratios in all species suggest that substantial selfing also occurs in this phase. The final number of seedlings per ovule did not differ significantly between modes in any of the species, partly due to poorer germination in CL seeds. This indicates that, despite the often lower pre-emergent reproductive success (fruit and seed set) in the CH phase, total reproductive success will not differ between the two modes because post-emergent selection is stronger on CL progeny. The strongest limitation on pre-emergent reproductive success in both phases is apparently related to flower/fruit abortion.

Key words

Chasmogamous - Oxalis acetosella - seed abortion - selfing - Viola hirta - Viola mirabilis - Viola riviniana

References

• 1 Andersson S.. No evidence for selective seed maturation in Anchusa officinalis (Boraginaceae).  Oikos. (1990);  57 88-93
• 2 Andersson S.. The potential for selective seed maturation in Achillea ptarmica (Asteraceae).  Oikos. (1993);  66 36-42
• 3 Barrett S. C. H., Helenurm K.. The reproductive biology of boreal forest herbs.  I. Breeding systems and pollination. Canadian Journal of Botany. (1987);  65 2036-2046
• 4 Bawa K. S., Webb C. J.. Flower, fruit and seed abortion in tropical forest trees: implications for the evolution of paternal and maternal reproductive patterns.  American Journal of Botany. (1984);  71 736-751
• 5 Beattie A. J.. The floral biology of three species of Viola. .  The New Phytologist. (1969);  68 1187-1201
• 6 Beattie A. J.. Plant dispersion, pollination and gene flow in Viola. .  Oecologia (Berlin). (1976);  25 291-300
• 7 Berg H.. Population dynamics in Oxalis acetosella: the significance of sexual reproduction in a clonal, cleistogamous forest herb.  Ecography. (2002);  25 233-243
• 8 Berg H., Redbo-Torstensson P.. Cleistogamy as a bet-hedging strategy in Oxalis acetosella, a perennial herb.  Journal of Ecology. (1998);  86 491-500
• 9 Berg H., Redbo-Torstensson P.. Offspring performance in three cleistogamous Viola species.  Plant Ecology. (1999);  145 49-58
• 10 Berg H., Redbo-Torstensson P.. Offspring performance in Oxalis acetosella, a cleistogamous perennial herb.  Plant Biology. (2000);  2 638-645
• 11 Charlesworth D.. Evolution of low female fertility in plants: pollen limitation, resource allocation and genetic load.  Trends in Ecology and Evolution. (1989);  4 289-292
• 12 Darwin C.. The different forms of flowers on plants of the same species. London; John Murray (1877): 311-345
• 13 Ehrlén J.. Proximate limits to seed production in a herbaceous perennial legume, Lathyrus vernus. .  Ecology. (1992);  73 1820-1831
• 14 Gorb S. N., Gorb E. V.. Removal rates of seeds of five myrmecochorous plants by the ant Formica polyctena (Hymenoptera: Formicidae).  Oikos. (1995);  73 367-374
• 15 Gorchov D. L.. Effects of pollen and resources on seed number and other fitness components in Amelanchier arborea (Rosaceae: Maloideae).  American Journal of Botany. (1988);  75 1275-1285
• 16 Grime J. P., Hodgson J. G., Hunt R.. Comparative plant ecology. London; Unwin Hyman (1988) 424-425 612-615
• 17 Gugerli F.. Sexual reproduction in Saxifraga oppositifolia L. and Saxifraga biflora All. (Saxifragaceae) in the Alps.  International Journal of Plant Sciences. (1997);  158 274-281
• 18 Guth C. J., Weller S. G.. Pollination, fertilization and ovule abortion in Oxalis magnifica. .  American Journal of Botany. (1986);  73 246-253
• 19 Helenurm K., Schaal B. A.. Genetic load, nutrient limitation, and seed production in Lupinus texensis (Fabaceae).  American Journal of Botany. (1996);  83 1585-1595
• 20 Herrera J.. Fecundity above the species level: Ovule number and brood size in the Genistae (Fabaceae: Papilionideae).  International Journal of Plant Sciences. (1999);  160 887-896
• 21 Hultén (ed.) E.. Vår svenska flora i färg, Band I. [in Swedish]. Stockholm; AB Svensk Litteratur (1958) 335-336 374-377
• 22 Lee T. D., Bazzaz F. A.. Regulation of fruit and seed production in an annual legume, Cassia fasciculata. .  Ecology. (1982);  63 1363-1373
• 23 Lee T. D., Bazzaz F. A.. Maternal regulation of fecundity: non-random ovule abortion in Cassia fasciculata .  Michx. Oecologia (Berlin). (1986);  68 459-465
• 24 Lord E. M.. Cleistogamy: a tool for the study of floral morphogenesis, function and evolution.  The Botanical Review. (1981);  47 421-449
• 25 Mattila T., Salonen V.. Reproduction of Viola mirabilis in relation to light and nutrient availability.  Canadian Journal of Botany. (1995);  73 1917-1924
• 26 Medan D.. Breeding system and maternal success of a perennial hermaphrodite, Discaria americana (Rhamnaceae).  New Zealand Journal of Botany. (1993);  31 175-184
• 27 Mitchell-Olds T., Waller D. M.. Relative performance of selfed and outcrossed progeny in Impatiens capensis. .  Evolution. (1985);  39 533-544
• 28 Nakamura R. R., Stanton M. L.. Cryptic seed abortion and the estimation of ovule fertilization.  Canadian Journal of Botany. (1987);  65 2463-2465
• 29 Packham J. R.. Biological flora of the British Isles: Oxalis acetosella .  L. Journal of Ecology. (1978);  66 669-693
• 30 Plitmann U.. Distribution of dimorphic flowers as related to other elements of the reproductive strategy.  Plant Species Biology. (1995);  10 53-60
• 31 Redbo-Torstensson P., Berg H.. Seasonal cleistogamy: a conditional strategy to provide reproductive assurance.  Acta Botanica Neerlandica. (1995);  44 247-256
• 32 Schemske D. W., Willson M. F., Melampy M. N., Miller L. J., Verner L., Schemske K. M., Best L. B.. Flowering ecology of some spring woodland herbs.  Ecology. (1978);  59 351-366
• 33 Schmitt J., Gamble S. E.. The effect of distance from the parental site on offspring performance and inbreeding depression in Impatiens capensis: a test of the local adaptation hypothesis.  Evolution. (1990);  44 2022-2030
• 34 Spira T. P., Pollak O. D.. Comparative reproductive biology of alpine biennial and perennial gentians (Gentiana: Gentianaceae) in California.  American Journal of Botany. (1986);  73 39-47
• 35 Sun M.. Cleistogamy in Scutellaria indica (Labiatae): effective mating system and population genetic structure.  Molecular Ecology. (1999);  8 1285-1295
• 36 Valdés B., Lifante Z. D.. Habitual autogamy in Linaria tursica Valdés et Cabezudo (Scrophulariaceae).  Flora. (1996);  191 329-333
• 37 von Mohl H.. Einige Beobachtungen über dimorphe Blüthen.  Botanische Zeitung. (1863);  21 309-315 321-328
• 38 Waller D. M.. Differences in fitness between seedlings derived from cleistogamous and chasmogamous flowers in Impatiens capensis. .  Evolution. (1984);  38 427-440
• 39 Weller S. G.. Fecundity in populations of Oxalis alpina in southeastern Arizona.  Evolution. (1981);  35 197-200
• 40 Wiens D.. Ovule survivorship, brood size, life history, breeding systems, and reproductive success in plants.  Oecologia (Berlin). (1984);  64 47-53
• 41 Wiens D., Calvin C. L., Wilson C. A., Davern C. I., Frank D., Seavey S. R.. Reproductive success, spontaneous embryo abortion, and genetic load in flowering plants.  Oecologia (Berlin). (1987);  71 501-509
• 42 Wilkinson L.. SYSTAT 7.0 for Windows. Chicago; SPSS Inc (1997)

Section Editor: G. Gottsberger