Morphological Adaptation of Inflorescences in Plants that Develop at Low Temperatures in Early Spring: The Convergent Evolution of “Downy Plants”

Abstract

A new category of plants that exhibit convergent evolution, namely “downy plants”, is described and discussed here on the bais of natural selection. So-called snowball plants can be represented by Saussurea gossypiphora D. Don (Compositae), which has extremely dense trichomes on well-developed bracts that are tightly packed around floral buds. Plants whose morphology is similar to that of S. gossypiphora are found at high elevations of alpine zones in the Nepalese Himalayas, where temperatures are low and precipitation is high (frequent rain) in summer. Nonetheless, we noticed that plants with a morphology similar to that of Himalaya snowball plants are commonly distributed from temperature to Arctic zones, and are even found in Alaska where precipitation is very limited. Willows (Salix spp.: Salicaceae) and deciduous magnolias (Magnoliaceae) are typical examples of such plants. Measurements of temperature inside and outside the inflorescences of Salix (pussy willow or catkin) and of Magnolia suggested that the pubescent bracts might play a role in keeping the interior of buds warm, but that the effect depends on light intensity. Our examination of such species led us to extend the concept of “snowball plants” to a larger group of plants, namely “downy plants”, that are characterized by very dense trichomes on tightly packed bracts of inflorescences. Downy plants are thereby considered to represent a convergent adaptation that allows blooming at low temperatures.

Key words

Alpine plants - convergent evolution - downy plants - environment - Himalaya - Magnolia - Salix - Saussurea - temperature

References

• 01 Brewer,  C. A., and Smith,  W. K.. (1997);  Patterns of leaf surface wetness for montane and subalpine plants.  Plant, Cell and Environment. 20 1-11
• 02 Fujikawa,  K.. 2000);  A short trip to Yak Khrka, West Nepal, in quest of Saussurea. .  Newsletter of Himalayan Botany. 26 6-7
• 03 Fujikawa,  K., and Omori,  Y.. (2000);  A field survey in Milke Danda and Jaljale Himal, East Nepal.  Newsletter of Himalayan Botany. 26 1-5
• 04 Gauslaa,  Y.. (1984);  Heat resistance and energy budget in different Scandinavian plants.  Holarctic Ecology. 7 1-78
• 05 Gauslaa,  Y., and Odasz,  A. M.. (1990);  Water relations, temperatures, and mineral nutrients in Pedicularis dasyantha (Scrophulariaceae) from Svalbard, Norway.  Holarctic Ecology. 13 112-121
• 06 Hayase,  H.,, Satake,  T.,, Nishmura,  I.,, and Ito,  N.. (1969);  Male sterility caused by cooling treatment at the mitotic stage in rice plants II. The most sensitive stage to cooling and the fertilizing ability to pistils.  Proceedings of Crop Science Society, Japan. 38 706-711
• 07 Inoue,  J.. (1976);  Climate of Khumbu Himal.  Seppyo. 38 66-73
• 08 Ishibashi,  M., and Terashima,  I.. (1995);  Effects of continuous leaf wetness on photosynthesis: adverse aspects of rainfall.  Plant, Cell and Environment. 18 431-438
• 09 Johnson,  H. B.. (1975);  Plant pubescence: An ecological perspective.  Botanical Review. 41 233-258
• 10 Joshi,  D. P.. (1982);  The climate of Namche Bazar: a bioclimate analysis.  Mount Research and Development. 2 399-403
• 11 Kikuchi,  T., and Ohba,  H.. (1988) Daytime air temperature and its lapse rate in the monsoon season in a Himalayan high mountain region. The Himalayan Plants, Vol. 1. Ohba, H. and Malla, S. B., eds. Tokyo; University Tokyo Press pp. 11-18
• 12 Körner,  C.. (1999) Alpine plant life: Functional plant ecology of high mountain ecosystems. Berlin, Heidelberg; Springer-Verlag pp. 343
• 13 Krog,  J.. (1955);  Notes on temperature measurements indicative of special organization in Arctic and subarctic plants for utilization of radiated heat from the sun.  Physiologia Plantarum. 8 836-839
• 14 Kurata,  S.. (1971 - 1976) Illustrated important forest trees of Japan. Tokyo; CHIKYUSHA (in Japanese)
• 15 Lansac,  A. R.,, Sullivan,  C. Y.,, and Johnson,  B. E.. (1996);  Accumulation of free proline in sorghum (Sorghum bicolor) pollen.  Canadian Journal of Botany. 74 40-45
• 16 Levin,  D. A.. (1973);  The role of trichomes in plant defense.  Quarterly Review of Biology. 48 3-15
• 17 Missouri Botanical Gardens . (1997) Flora of China Project. http://www.mobot.org/MOBOT/TROPICOA/China/Salix.html
• 18 Morris,  W. F., and Doak,  D. F.. (1998);  Life history of the long-lived gynodioecious cushion plant Silene acaulis (Caryophyllaceae), inferred from size-based population projection matrices.  Amer. J. Bot.. 85 785-793
• 19 Nordal,  I.,, Erilsen,  A. B.,, Laane,  M. M.,, and Solberg,  Y.. (1986);  Biogeographic and biosystematic studies in the genus Cochlearia in Northern Scandinavia.  Symbolae Botanique Upsalienses. 27 83-93
• 20 Ohba,  H.. (1988) The alpine flora of the Nepal Himalayas: an introductory note. The Himalayan Plants, Vol. 1. Ohba, H. and Malla, S. B., eds. Tokyo; University Tokyo Press pp. 19-46
• 21 Ohba,  H., and Fujikawa,  K.. (2000) Saussurea. . The Flora of Hinku and Hunku Valleys, East Nepal. Ohba, H. and Ikeda, H., eds. Tokyo; The University Museum, Univ. Tokyo, Nature and Culture, no. 6 pp. 216-225, Plates 5 - 6
• 22 Omori,  Y., and Ohba,  H.. (1996);  Pollen development of Rheum nobile Hook. f. & Thomson (Polygonaceae), with reference to its sterility induced by bract removal.  Botanical Journal of Linnean Society. 122 269-278
• 23 Rensch,  B.. (1959) Evolution above the species level. New York; Columbia Press, New York
• 24 Schuepp,  P. H.. (1993);  Leaf boundary layers.  New Phytologist. 125 477-507
• 25 Seymour,  R. S.,, Bartholomew,  G. A.,, and Barnhart,  M. C.. (1983);  Respiration and heat production by the inflorescences of Philodendron selloum Koch.  Planta. 157 336-343
• 26 Seymour,  R. S., and Schultze-Motel,  P.. (1996);  Thermoregulating lotus flowers.  Nature. 383 305
• 27 Tamura,  M.. (1989) Magnoliaceae. Wild Flowers of Japan, Woody Plants, Vol. 1. Satake, Y., Hara, H., Itari, S., and Tominari, T., eds. Tokyo; Heibon-sha (in Japanese) pp. 105-108
• 28 Terashima,  I.,, Masuzawa,  T.,, and Ohba,  H.. (1993);  Photosynthetic characteristics of a giant alpine plant, Rheum nobile Hook. f. et Thoms. and of some other alpine species measured at 4300 m, in the Eastern Himalaya, Nepal.  Oecologia. 95 194-201
• 29 The Alaskan Climate Research Center. (1997) http://climate.gi.alaska.edu/AKCityClimo/
• 30 Tsukaya,  H., and Ohba,  H.. (1999) Outline of climate in the monsoon season. A Contribution to the Flora of Ganesh Himal, Central Nepal. Ohba, H. and Ikeda, H., eds. Tokyo, Japan; The University Museum, Univ. Tokyo, Nature and Culture, no. 5 pp. 3-7
• 31 Tsukaya,  H.,, Yokoyama,  J.,, Ikeda,  H.,, Kuroiwa,  H.,, Kuroiwa,  T.,, and Iwatsuki,  K.. (1997);  Morphological, physiological and molecular genetic characterization of Arabidopsis himalaica, with reference to A. thaliana. .  Journal of Plant Research. 110 15-23
• 32 Ueda,  K.. (1986);  Taxonomical note on a little-known species, Magnolia pseudokobus Abe et Akasawa.  Journal of Phytogeogra Taxon. 14 15-19
• 33 Ueda,  K.. (1988);  Star magnolia (Magnolia tomentosa) - an indigenous Japanese plant.  Journal of the Arnold Arboretum. 69 281-288
• 34 Van Steenis,  C. G. G. J.. (1981) Rheophytes of the World. Alpen aan den Rijn; Sijthoff & Noordhoff
• 35 Walter,  H.. (1971) Ecology of tropical and subtropical vegetation. Edinburgh; Oliver & Boyd
• 36 Webber,  P. J.,, Miller,  P. C.,, Chapin,  F. S. III,, and McCown,  B. H.. (1980) The vegetation: pattern and succession. Arctic ecosystem. Brown, J., Miller, P. C., Tieszen, L., and Brunnell, F. L., eds. Pennsylvania; Dowson, Hutchington & Ross pp. 186-218
• 37 Wuenscher,  J. E.. (1970);  The effect of leaf hairs of Verbascum thapsus on leaf energy exchange.  New Phytologist. 69 65-73

Section Editor: T. Nagata