Genetic Diversity and the Reintroduction of Meadow Species

Abstract

Restoration of formerly nutrient-poor and species-rich grasslands generally leads to an increase in species diversity. However, species without a persistent seed bank and with poor dispersal ability often do not re-establish spontaneously. Here, reintroduction is an option. If existing populations are comparable in their genetic composition, any population will do. This is not the case if populations have local adaptations. Unfortunately, whether populations are adapted locally is not easily determined, in contrast to assessing differentiation using neutral genetic markers. We used AFLP to study genetic diversity of Cirsium dissectum and Succisa pratensis within and among several Junco-Molinion plant communities in the Netherlands (up to 200 km apart) that were potential source populations, and followed the reintroduction using seeds from these populations. Also, vegetative growth phase characteristics of three populations of C. dissectum were analyzed under controlled conditions. Most of the genetic variation in these cross-fertilizing species was found within populations. Small but significant genetic differences in band frequencies were found among populations (F_st 0.100 - 0.135). The first generation of reintroduced plants contained less polymorphic bands than the source populations. The genetic differences caused by reintroduction using a limited number of seeds (founder effects) were significant in all except one case (F_st 0.012 - 0.101 between source and corresponding reintroduced population), but the magnitude was smaller than the source population differentiation. In assignment tests, reintroduced populations resembled their source population more than any other population, but all populations contained sizeable proportions of plants that were assigned to most similar plants from other populations, indicating that the populations are only marginally distinct. Calculations show that reintroduction from more than one source population introduces significantly more polymorphic bands into the new population, capitalizing on the existence of band frequency differences among populations.

Key words

AFLP - Cirsium dissectum - genetic diversity - Succisa pratensis - restoration ecology

References

• 01 Arens,  P.,, Coops,  H.,, Jansen,  J.,, and Vosman,  B.. (1998);  Molecular genetic analysis of Black poplar (Populus nigra L.) along Dutch rivers.  Molecular Ecology. 7 11-18
• 02 Berendse,  F.,, Oomes,  M. J. M.,, Altena,  H. J.,, and De Visser,  W.. (1994);  A comparative study of nitrogen flows in two similar meadows affected by different groundwater levels.  Journal of Applied Ecology. 31 40-48
• 03 Booy,  G.,, Hendriks,  R. J. J.,, Smulders,  M. J. M.,, Van Groenendael,  J. M.,, and Vosman,  B.. (2000);  Genetic diversity and the survival of populations.  Plant biol.. 2 379-395
• 04 Fulton,  T. M.,, Chunwongse,  J.,, and Tanksley,  S. D.. (1995);  Microprep protocol for extraction of DNA from tomato and other herbaceous species.  Plant Molecular Biology Reporter. 13 207-209
• 05 Geerts,  R. H. E. M.,, Ketelaars,  J. J. M. H.,, Oomes,  M. J. M.,, Korevaar,  H.,, and van der Werf,  A. K.. (1996) Reintroduction of grassland species. Annual Report 1995. Wageningen; Research Institute for Agrobiology and Soil Fertility (AB-DLO) pp. 65-68
• 06 Gordon,  D. R., and Rice,  K. J.. (1998);  Patterns of differentiation in wiregrass (Aristida beyrichiana): implications for restoration efforts.  Restoration Ecology. 6 166-174
• 07 Grashof-Bokdam,  C. J.,, Jansen,  J.,, and Smulders,  M. J. M.. (1998);  Dispersal patterns of Lonicera periclymenum determined by genetic analysis.  Molecular Ecology. 7 165-174
• 08 Grime,  J. P., and Hunt,  R.. (1975);  Relative-growth-rate: Its range and adaptive significance in a local flora.  Journal of Ecology. 63 393-422
• 09 van Groenendael,  J. M.,, Ouborg,  N. J.,, and Hendriks,  R. J. J.. (1998);  Criteria for the reintroduction of plant species.  Acta Botanica Neerlandica. 47 3-13
• 10 Jones,  A. T., and Hayes,  M. J.. (1999);  Increasing floristic diversity in grasslands: the effects of management regime and provenance on species introduction.  Biological Conservation. 87 381-390
• 11 Hamilton,  M. B.. (1997);  Genetic fingerprint-inferred population subdivision and spatial genetic tests for isolation by distance and adaptation in the coastal plant Limonium carolinianum. .  Evolution. 51 1457-1468
• 12 Helenurm,  K.. (1998);  Outplanting and differential source population success in Lupinus guadalupensis. .  Conservation Biology. 12 118-127
• 13 Hunt,  R.. (1982) Plant Growth Curves. The Functional Approach to Plant Growth Analysis. London; E. Arnold
• 14 Lambers,  H.,, Poorter,  H.,, and van Vuuren,  M. M. I.. (1998) Inherent Variation in Plant Growth. Physiological mechanisms and Ecological Consequences. Leiden; Backhuys Publishers
• 15 Lynch,  M., and Milligan,  B. G.. (1994);  Analysis of population genetic structure with RAPD markers.  Molecular Ecology. 3 91-99
• 16 Nagy,  E. S.. (1997);  Selection for native characters in hybrids between two locally adapted plant subspecies.  Evolution. 51 1469-1480
• 17 Oomes,  M. J. M.,, Olff,  H.,, and Altena,  H. J.. (1996);  Effects of vegetation management and raising the water table on nutrient dynamics and vegetation change in a wet grassland.  Journal of Applied Ecology. 33 576-588
• 18 Poorter,  H., and Van der Werf,  A.. (1998) Is inherent variation in RGR determined by LAR at low irradiance and by NAR at high irradiance? A review of herbaceous species. Inherent Variation in Plant Growth. Physiological mechanisms and Ecological Consequences. Lambers, H., Poorter, H., and Van Vuuren, M. M. I., eds Leiden; Backhuys Publishers pp. 309-336
• 19 Prins,  A. H.,, Dijkstra,  G. A.,, and Bekker,  R. M.. (1998);  Feasibility of target communities in a Dutch brook valley system.  Acta Botanica Neerlandica. 47 71-88
• 20 Pywell,  R.,, Peel,  S.,, Hopkins,  A.,, and Bullock,  J.. (1997) Multi-site experiments on the restoration of botanically diverse grasslands in ESAS. Grassland management in the “Environmentally Sensitive Areas”. Occasional Symposium,Vol. 32. Sheldrick, B. D., ed. British Grassland Society pp. 160-165
• 21 Reynolds,  J.,, Weir,  B. S.,, and Cockerham,  C. C.. (1983);  Estimation of the coancestry coefficient: basis for a short-term genetic distance.  Genetics. 105 767-779
• 22 Smulders,  M. J. M.,, van de Wiel,  C.,, Arens,  P.,, and Vosman,  B.. (2000) The use of molecular markers for the characterisation of biodiversity and the study of ecological processes. Focus on Biotechnology in press
• 23 van der Werf,  A.,, van Nuenen,  M.,, Visser,  A. J.,, and Lambers,  H.. (1993);  Contribution of physiological and morphological plant traits to a species' competitive ability at high and low nitrogen supply: a hypothesis for inherently fast- and slow-growing monocotyledonous species.  Oecologia. 94 434-440
• 24 van der Werf,  A.,, Geerts,  R. H. E. M.,, Jacobs,  F. H. H.,, Korevaar,  H.,, Oomes,  M. J. M.,, and de Visser,  W.. (1998) The importance of relative growth rate and associated traits for competition between species during vegetation succession. Inherent Variation in Plant Growth. Physiological mechanisms and Ecological Consequences. Lambers, H., Poorter, H., and van Vuuren, M. M. I., eds. Leiden; Backhuys Publishers pp. 489-502
• 25 Vos,  P.,, Hogers,  R.,, Bleeker,  M.,, Reijans,  M.,, van de Lee,  T.,, Hornes,  M.,, Frijters,  A.,, Pot,  J.,, Peleman,  J.,, Kuiper,  M.,, and Zabeau,  M.. (1995);  AFLP: A new technique for DNA fingerprinting.  Nucleic Acids Research. 23 4407-4414

Section Editor: R. Aerts