Consequence Evaluation in Decision Analytic Models of Medical Screening, Diagnosis, and Treatment

J. C. Hershey

doi:10.1055/s-0038-1636157

Methods of Information in Medicine, Table of Contents

Methods Inf Med 1974; 13(04): 197-203
DOI: 10.1055/s-0038-1636157

Original Article

Schattauer GmbH

Consequence Evaluation in Decision Analytic Models of Medical Screening, Diagnosis, and Treatment

Bewertung der Folgen in Analytischen Entscheidungsmodellen FÜr Medizinisches Screening, Diagnose und Behandlung

Authors

J. C. Hershey

¹From the Health Services Administration Program. Department of Community and Preventive Medicine, Stanford University School of Medicine

Abstract

This paper examines the problem of assigning values, or utilities, to separate consequences in decision analytic models of medical screening, diagnosis, and treatment. Several important issues related to this problem are studied, and a number of methodologies proposed for various applications are reviewed in relation to these issues. Finally, suggestions for future research in this area are proposed.

In dieser Arbeit wird das Problem der Zuordnung von Werten oder Nutzen untersucht, um die Folgen in analytischen Entscheidmigsmodellen für medizinisches Screening, Diagnose und Behandlung zu unterscheiden. Mehrere wichtige auf dieses Problem bezogene Fragestellungen werden mitersucht, und eine Anzahl von für verschiedene Anwendungsgebiete vorgeschlagene Methoden werden in bezug auf diese Fragestellungen besprochen. Letztlich werden Vorschläge für die zukünftige Forschung auf diesem Sektor unterbreitet.

Key-Words

Medical Screening - Diagnosis - Therapy - Decision Analysis - Utility Theory

Schlüssel-Wörter

Reihenuntersuchungen - Diagnostik - Therapie - Entscheidungsmodelle - Nutzen-Theorie

Full Text

References

References
1 Betaque N. E, Gobey G. A. Automating Judgmental Decision Making for a Serious Medical Problem. Management So 17 1971; 421-434.
2 Bickner R. E. Measurements and Indices of Health. Conference Series, Outcome Conference I and II, Methodology of Identifying, Measuring and Evaluating Outcomes of Health Service Programs, Systems and Subsystems. (California Center for Health Services Research and National Center for Health Services Research and Development 1969).
3 Blumbebg M. S. Evaluating Health Screening Procedures. Operations Res 05 1957; 351-360.
4 Carlson J. AV. Valuation of Life Saving. (Unpublished Ph. D. Dissertation, Harvard University 1963).
5 Collen M. F, Rubin L, Neyman J. et al. Automated Multiphasic Screening and Diagnosis. Amer. J. publ. Hlth 54 1964; 741-750.
6 Fanshel S, Bush J. W. A Health-Status Index and Its Application to Health-Services Outcomes. Operations Res 18 1970; 1021-1066.
7 Fishbtjrn P. C. Independence in Utility Theory with Whole Product Sets. Operations Res 13 1965; 28-45.
8 Fishburn P. C. Utility Theory. Management Sc 14 1968; 335-378.
9 Flagle Ch. D. Decision Theoretical Comparison of Three Procedures of Screening for a Single Disease. In LeCam L. J, Neyman J. (Eds.): Proceed Fifth Berkeley Symp. Math. Statist. Probab. Vol. IV. 887-901 Berkeley and Los Angeles: Univ. of California Press; 1967
10 Flagle Ch. D. Automated Multiphasic Health Testing and Services. Total Systems Analysis and Design. Meth. Inform. Med 10 1971; 201-206.
11 Flagle Ch. D. A Threshold Method for Utility Estimation and Resolution of Conflict. In: Lawrence J. R. (Edit.): Operational Research and the Social Sciences. 399-408 London: Tavistock Publications; 1966
12 Flagle Ch. D, Lechat M. F. Statistical Decision Theory and the Selection of Diagnostic and Therapeutic Procedures in Public Health. Actes 3. Conf. Internat. Recherche Operationelle. London: English Universities Press; 1964
13 Gorby G. A, Barnett G. O. Experience with a Model of Sequential Diagnosis. Comput. biomed. Res 01 1968; 490-507.
14 Gorby G. A, Babnett G. O. Sequential Diagnosis by Computer. J. Amer. med. Ass 205 1968; 141-146.
15 Ginsberg A. S. Decision Analysis in Clinical Patient Management with an Application to the Pleural-EPfusion Problem. Rand Report R-751-RC/NLM. (The Rand Corporation, July 1971).
16 Ginsbebg A. S, Offensend F. L. An Application of Decision Theory to a Medical Diagnosis-Treatment Problem. IEEE Trans. Syst. Sc. Cybernet d 1968; 355-362.
17 Gustafson D. H, Edwabds W, Philipps L. D. et al. Subjective Probabilities in Medical Diagnosis. IEEE Trans. Man-Machine Sys 10 1969; 61-65.
18 Henschke U. K, Fleeinger B. J. Decision Theory in Cancer Therapy. Cancer 20 1967; 1819-1826.
19 Hebshey J. C. A Decision Theoretic Analysis of Medical Screening Procedures. (Unpublished Ph. D. Dissertation, Stanford University 1970).
20 Hobvath W. J. Operations Research in Medical and Hospital Practice. In Morse J. R. P. M. (Edit.): Operations Research for Public Systems. 127-157 Cambridge, Mass: The M. I. T. Press; 1967
21 Lechat M. F, Flagle Ch. D. Allocation of Medical and Associated Resources to the Control of Leprosy. In Barish N, Verhulst M. (Eds): Management Sciences in the Emerging Countries. London: Pergamon Press; 1965
22 Ledley R. S, Lusted L. B. Mathematical Models in Medical Diagnosis. J. med. Educat 35 1960; 214-222.
23 Ledley R. S, Lusted L. B. Reasoning Foundation of Medical Diagnosis. Science 130 1959; 9-21.
24 Ledley R. S, Lusted L. B. The Use of Electronic Computers in Medical Data Processing. IRE Trans, med. Electron 07 1960; 31-47.
25 Lodwick G. S. Computer Aided Diagnosis in Radiology: A Research Plan. Investigat. Radiol 01 1966; 72-80.
26 Lodwicic G. S. A Probabilistic Approach to the Diagnosis of Bone Tumors. Radiol. Clin. North America 03 1965; 487-497.
27 Lodwick G. S, Turner A. H, Lusted L. B. et al. Computer Aided Analysis of Radiographic Images. J. chron. Dis 19 1966; 485-496.
28 Lusted L. B. Introduction to Medical Decision Making. Springfield, III: Charles C. Thomas; 1965
29 Lusted L. B. Logical Analysis in Medical Diagnosis. In LeCam L. M, Neyman J. (Eds): Proceed. Fifth Berkeley Symp. Math. Statist. Probab. Vol. IV. 903-923 Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press; 1967
30 Overall J. E, Williams C. E. Conditional Probability Program for Diagnosis of Thyroid Function. J. Amer. med. Ass 1S3 1963; 307-313.
31 Raiffa H. Decision Analysis: Introductory Lectures on Choices under Uncertainty. (Reading, Menlo Park, London, and Don Mills: Addison-Wesley 1968).
32 Raiffa H. Preferences for Multi-Attributed Alternatives. Rand Report RM-5868-D0T/RC. (The Rand Corporation, April 1969).
33 Reale A, Maccacaro G. A, Rocca E. et al. Computer Diagnosis of Congenital Heart Disease. Comput. biomed. Res 01 1968; 533-549.
34 Rubel R. A. Decision Analysis in Medical Diagnosis and Treatment. (Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation, Harvard University 1967).
35 Rubin L, Collen M. F, Goldman G. E. Frequency Decision Theoretical Approach to Automated Medical Diagnosis. In LeCam L. M, Neyman J. (Eds): Proceed. Fifth Berkeley Symp. Math. Statist. Probab. Vol. IV. 867-886 Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press; 1967
36 Sasuly R, Ward PD. Two Approaches to Health Planning: The Ideal vs. the Pragmatic. Med. Care 07 1969; 235-241.
37 Scheff T. J. Decision Rules, Types of Errors, and Their Consequences in Medical Diagnosis. Behav. Sc 05 1933; 97-107.
38 Schelling T. C. The Life You Save May Be Your Own. In Chase BSamuel. (Edit.): Problems in Public Expenditure Analysis. 127-176 Washington, D. C: Brookings Institution; 1938
39 Stirison D. H. Utility Measurement in Public Health Decision Making. Management Sc 16 1969; 17-30.
40 Toronto A. F, Warner H. et al. Evaluation of a Computer Program for Diagnosis of Congenital Heart Disease. Progr. cardiovas. Dis 05 1963; 362-377.
41 U. S. Department of Health, Education and Welfare, PHS, National Center for Health Statistics: Conceptual Problems in Developing an Index of Health, Vital and Health Statistics, PHS Publ. No. 1000, Series 2, No. 17. Washington, D. C: Government Printing Office; 1966
42 Warner H. R, Toronto A. F, Veasey L. G. et al. Experience with Bayes’ Theorem for Computer Diagnosis of Congenital Heart Disease. Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sc 115 1964; 55S-567.
43 Warner H. R, Toronto A. F, Veasey L. G. et al. A Mathematical Approach to Medical Diagnosis. J. Amer. med. Ass 177 1901; 177-1S3.