Is a Picture Worth a Thousand Medical Words? A Randomized Trial of Reporting Formats for Medical Research Data

Abstract

Monitoring data that vary over time is an essential component of medical practice. This is doubly true in clinical trials in which the overall safety and efficacy of investigational treatments in populations must be monitored in addition to the status of the individual patients who receive them. We report the results of a randomized trial of four reporting methods for time-dependent information derived from clinical trials; narrative text, table, pie chart and icon. Multivariate analysis of variance with a repeated measures design was used to analyze the efficiency of subjects’ (physicians, research nurses and laboratory personnel) assimilation of information. Icons were found to be superior to the other reporting formats tested in both speed (p <0.0001) and accuracy (p = 0.02). The differences were most pronounced in subjects’ first exposure to the data, suggesting that icons reduce the time needed for training. We conclude that icons are a valuable method for presentation of time-dependent information in medical settings.

Key-Words

Medical Monitoring - Clinical Trials - Icon - Graphical Displays

• REFERENCES

• 1 Cole WG. Quick and accurate monitoring via metaphor graphics. In: Proceedings 14th Symposium on Computer Applications in Medical Care. Washington DC: IEE Computer Society Press; 1990: 425-9.
• 2 Guastello S, Traut M, Korienek G. Verbal versus pictorial representations of objects in a human-computer interface. Int J Man-Machine Studies 1989; 31: 99-120.
• 3 Tullis T. An evaluation of alphanumeric, graphic, and color information displays. Hum Fact 1981; 23: 541-50.
• 4 Gittins D, Winder R, Bez H. An icon-driven end-user interface to UNIX. Int J Man-Machine Studies 1984; 21: 451-61.
• 5 Bewley W, Roberts T, Schroit D, Verplank W. Human factors testing in the design of Xerox’s 8010 “Star” office workstation. In: CHI’83 Proceedings, December. 1983: 72-7.
• 6 De Zegher-Geets I, Freeman A, Walker M, Blum R, Wiederhold G. Summarization and display of on-line medical records. MD Comput 1988; 05: 8-45.
• 7 Moses F, Maisaino R, Bersh P. Natural associations between symbols and military information. In: Easterby R, Zwaga H. eds. Proceedings of a NATO Conference on Visual Presentation of Information. Sussex: Wiley and Sons; 1980: 229-41.
• 8 Spurlock M. Control operator overload during emergency situations. In: Proceedings of the American Petroleum Institute Operating Practices Committee Executive Session. Seattle WA: October; 1987: 1-38.
• 9 Legge G, Yuanchao G, Luebker A. Efficiency of graphical perception. Perception & Psychophysics 1989; 46: 365-74.
• 10 Schwartz D, Howell W. Optional stopping performance under graphic and numeric CRT formatting. Human Factors 1985; 27: 433-44.
• 11 Hemenway K. Psychological issues in the use of icons in command menus. In: Proceedings of the Human Factors in Computer Systems Conference. Washington DC: March 1982: 20-4.
• 12 Cole BL, MacDonald WA. Defective colour vision can impede information acquisition from redundantly colour-coded video displays. Ophthal Physiol Opt 1988; 08: 198-210.
• 13 Murch G. Physiological principles for the effective use of color. IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications, November 1984; 49-54.
• 14 Elting L, Lynn A, Bodey GP. Human-computer interfaces: A randomized trial of data entry and editing formats. In: Proceedings 12th Symposium on Computer Applications in Medical Case. Washington DC: IEEE Computer Society Press; 1988: 459-62.
• 15 Gittins D. Icon-based human-computer interaction. Int J Man-Machine Studies 1986; 54: 519-43.
• 16 Chernoff H. The use of faces to represent points in K-dimensional space graphically. J Am Stat Assoc 1983; 69: 361-8.