Ethics in Egg Donation: Past, Present, and Future

ABSTRACT

Since the advent of clinical human egg donation just over 25 years ago, ethical considerations have been central to its successful application and popular acceptance. Early in its history, “essentialist” arguments questioning the moral validity of the practice altogether were commonplace. More recently, most academic discussion has been focused on “consequentialist” issues relating to practical approaches to egg donation that minimize ethically troublesome consequences. Three issues that have attracted a bulk of the attention in this regard are compensation, postmenopausal pregnancy, and egg sharing. Although much consensus has been reached on some very controversial issues, the enormous potential of increasingly successful oocyte cryopreservation, as well as emerging stem cell technologies, is very likely to provide abundant fuel for the continued debate of provocative and contentious ethical issues in human egg donation.

KEYWORDS

Ethics - egg donation - IVF - compensation - postmenopausal - egg sharing

REFERENCES

• 1 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention .Assisted reproductive technology. Available at: http://www.cdc.gov/art/ Accessed May 25, 2010
• 2 Heape W. Preliminary note on transplantation and growth of mammalian ova within a uterine foster-mother.  Proc R Soc Lond. 1890;  48 457-458
• 3 Willet E L, Black W G, Casida L E et al. Successful transplantation of fertilized bovine ovum.  Science. 1951;  113 247
• 4 Buster J. The first live birth donation.  Sexuality, Reproduction, and Menopause. 2008;  6 23-28
• 5 Buster J E, Bustillo M, Thorneycroft I H et al. Non-surgical transfer of in vivo fertilised donated ova to five infertile women: report of two pregnancies.  Lancet. 1983;  2(8343) 223-224
• 6 Trounson A, Leeton J, Besanko M, Wood C, Conti A. Pregnancy established in an infertile patient after transfer of a donated embryo fertilised in vitro.  Br Med J (Clin Res Ed). 1983;  286(6368) 835-838
• 7 Bustillo M, Buster J E, Cohen S W et al. Delivery of a healthy infant following nonsurgical ovum transfer.  , [letter] JAMA. 1984;  251(7) 889
• 8 Lutjen P, Trounson A, Leeton J, Findlay J, Wood C, Renou P. The establishment and maintenance of pregnancy using in vitro fertilization and embryo donation in a patient with primary ovarian failure.  Nature. 1984;  307(5947) 174-175
• 9 National Advisory Board on Ethics and Reproduction .Report and recommendations on oocyte donation. In: Cohen C New Ways of Making Babies: The Case of Egg Donation. Bloomington, IN; Indiana University Press 1996: 233-285
• 10 Steinbock B. Payment for egg donation and surrogacy.  Mt Sinai J Med. 2004;  71(4) 255-265
• 11 Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith .Instruction on respect for human life in its origin and on the dignity of procreation. 1987. Available at: http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_19870222_respect-for-human-life_en.html Accessed May 25, 2010
• 12 Callahan D. Bioethics and fatherhood.  Utah Law Rev. 1992;  1992(3) 735-746
• 13 Benatar D. The unbearable lightness of bringing into being.  J Appl Philos. 1999;  16(2) 173-180
• 14 Sauer M V. Defining the incidence of serious complications experienced by oocyte donors: a review of 1000 cases.  Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2001;  184(3) 277-278
• 15 Maxwell K N, Cholst I N, Rosenwaks Z. The incidence of both serious and minor complications in young women undergoing oocyte donation.  Fertil Steril. 2008;  90(6) 2165-2171
• 16 The Ethics Committee Of The American Society For Reproductive Medicine . Financial compensation of oocyte donors.  Fertil Steril. 2007;  88(2) 305-309
• 17 Fox D. Paying for particulars in people-to-be: commercialisation, commodification and commensurability in human reproduction.  J Med Ethics. 2008;  34(3) 162-166
• 18 Holland S. Contested commodities at both ends of life: buying and selling gametes, embryos, and body tissues.  Kennedy Inst Ethics J. 2001;  11(3) 263-284
• 19 Macklin R. What is wrong with commodification?. In: Cohen C New Ways of Making Babies: The Case of Egg Donation. Bloomington, IN; Indiana University Press 1996: 106-121
• 20 Murray T. New reproductive technologies and the family. In: Cohen C New Ways of Making Babies: The Case of Egg Donation. Bloomington, IN; Indiana University Press 1996: 52-69
• 21 Sauer M V, Paulson R J, Lobo R A. Pregnancy after age 50: application of oocyte donation to women after natural menopause.  Lancet. 1993;  341(8841) 321-323
• 22 Sauer M V. Indecent proposal: $5,000 is not “reasonable compensation” for oocyte donors.  Fertil Steril. 1999;  71(1) 7-8
• 23 Bergh P. Indecent proposal: $5,000 is not “reasonable compensation” for oocyte donors—a reply.  Fertil Steril. 1999;  71 9-10
• 24 Covington S N, Gibbons W E. Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology . What is happening to the price of eggs?.  Fertil Steril. 2007;  87(5) 1001-1004
• 25 Sauer M V, Paulson R J, Lobo R A. Pregnancy in women 50 or more years of age: outcomes of 22 consecutively established pregnancies from oocyte donation.  Fertil Steril. 1995;  64(1) 111-115
• 26 Paulson R J, Boostanfar R, Saadat P et al. Pregnancy in the sixth decade of life: obstetric outcomes in women of advanced reproductive age.  JAMA. 2002;  288(18) 2320-2323
• 27 Paulson R J, Sauer M V. Pregnancies in post-menopausal women. Oocyte donation to women of advanced reproductive age: “how old is too old?”.  Hum Reprod. 1994;  9(4) 571-572
• 28 United Nations .Declaration of the rights of the child. Adopted by UN General Assembly Resolution 1386 (XIV) of 10 December. 1959. Available at: http://www.un.org/cyberschoolbus/humanrights/resources/child.asp Accessed May 25, 2010
• 29 Mori T. Egg donation should be limited to women below 60 years of age.  J Assist Reprod Genet. 1995;  12(4) 229-230
• 30 ASRM Ethics Committee Report . Oocyte donation to postmenopausal women.  Fertil Steril. 2004;  82(Suppl 1) 254-255
• 31 Smajdor A. The ethics of egg donation in the over fifties.  Menopause Int. 2008;  14(4) 173-177
• 32 Ahuja K K, Simons E G, Fiamanya W et al. Egg-sharing in assisted conception: ethical and practical considerations.  Hum Reprod. 1996;  11(5) 1126-1131
• 33 Pennings G, Devroey P. Subsidized in-vitro fertilization treatment and the effect on the number of egg sharers.  Reprod Biomed Online. 2006;  13(1) 8-10
• 34 Thum M Y, Gafar A, Wren M et al. Does egg-sharing compromise the chance of donors or recipients achieving a live birth?.  Hum Reprod. 2003;  18(11) 2363-2367
• 35 Pearson H. Health effects of egg donation may take decades to emerge.  Nature. 2006;  442(7103) 607-608
• 36 Ahuja K K, Simons E G, Mostyn B J, Bowen-Simpkins P. An assessment of the motives and morals of egg share donors: policy of “payments” to egg donors requires a fair review.  Hum Reprod. 1998;  13(1O) 2671-2678