Minimal Hearing Loss in Children: Minimal But Not Inconsequential

ABSTRACT

It has been ~25 years since Bess published his first work on unilateral hearing loss in children. Those early articles triggered considerable interest in the audiology and medical communities and represented an expansion of our focus at that time on children with severe to profound degrees of hearing loss to include those with lesser degrees of hearing loss. Before Bess' work, professionals were of the opinion that minimal degrees of hearing loss were of little consequence to a child's development. However, these early studies demonstrated that children with minimal degrees of permanent hearing loss were, in fact, at considerable risk for academic and behavioral problems. Today those problems persist, and we are still wrestling with which children with minimal degrees of hearing loss require intervention, what type(s) of intervention is most effective, and whether preventive measures exist to avoid the commonly reported problems known to plague some of these children. This article reviews the early studies conducted by Bess and his colleagues documenting the psychoeducational, audiological, and behavioral difficulties experienced by children with permanent unilateral and minimal bilateral hearing loss. In addition, contemporary studies are reported along with a summary of current thinking on the appropriate management of these populations.

KEYWORDS

Minimal hearing loss - unilateral hearing loss

REFERENCES

• 1 Humes L E, Allen S K, Bess F H. Horizontal sound localization skills of unilaterally hearing-impaired children.  Audiology. 1980;  19 508-518
• 2 Humes L E, Schwartz D M, Bess F H. Two experiments on subtle mid-frequency hearing loss and its influence on word discrimination in noise-exposed listeners.  Audiology. 1979;  18 307-319
• 3 Gravel J S, White K R, Johnson J L et al.. A multisite study to examine the efficacy of the otoacoustic emission/automated auditory brainstem response newborn hearing screening protocol: recommendations for policy, practice, and research.  Am J Audiol. 2005;  14 S217-S228
• 4 Northern J, Downs M. Hearing in Children. 2nd ed. Baltimore, MD; Williams and Wilkins 1978: 143
• 5 American Academy of Audiology Pediatric Hearing Aid Task Force .Pediatric amplification guidelines. http://Available at: www.audiology.org/resources/documentlibrary/documents Accessed March 13, 2009
• 6 Joint Committee on Infant Hearing . Year 2007 position statement: principles and guidelines for early hearing detection and intervention programs.  Pediatrics. 2007;  120(4) 898-921
• 7 Bess F H, Dodd-Murphy J D, Parker R A. Children with minimal sensorineural hearing loss: prevalence, educational performance, and functional status.  Ear Hear. 1998;  19 339-354
• 8 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention .National workshop on mild and unilateral hearing loss: 2005 workshop proceedings. http://Available at: www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/ehdi Accessed January 14, 2008
• 9 Tharpe A M. Minimal hearing loss in children: the facts and the fiction. Sound Foundation Through Early Amplification 2007: Proceedings of the 4th International Conference United Kingdom; Cambrian Printers 2007
• 10 Bess F H. Children with minimal sensorineural hearing loss. Paper presented at: Children with Hearing Loss workshop 2004 Casper, WY;
• 11 Humes L E, Allen S K, Bess F H. Horizontal sound localization skills of unilaterally hearing-impaired children.  Audiology. 1980;  19 508-518
• 12 Bess F H, Tharpe A M. Case history data on unilaterally hearing-impaired children.  Ear Hear. 1986;  7 14-19
• 13 Bess F H, Tharpe A M, Gibler A M. Auditory performance of children with unilateral hearing loss.  Ear Hear. 1986;  7 20-26
• 14 Culbertson J L, Gilbert L E. Children with unilateral sensorineural hearing loss.  Ear Hear. 1986;  7(1) 38-42
• 15 Klee T M, Davis-Dansky E. A comparison of unilaterally hearing-impaired children and normal-hearing children on a battery of standardized language tests.  Ear Hear. 1986;  7(1) 27-37
• 16 Bess F H, Tharpe A M. Unilateral hearing impairment in children.  Pediatrics. 1984;  74(2) 206-216
• 17 Oyler R F, Oyler A L, Matkin N D. Unilateral hearing loss: demographics and educational impact.  Lang Speech Hear Serv Sch. 1988;  19 201-210
• 18 Bovo R, Martini A, Agnoletto M et al.. Auditory and academic performance of children with unilateral hearing loss.  Scand Audiol Suppl. 1988;  30 71-74
• 19 Hartvig Jensen J, Børre S, Johansen P A. Unilateral sensorineural hearing loss in children: cognitive abilities with respect to right/left differences.  Br J Audiol. 1989;  23 215-220
• 20 Watier-Launey C, Soin C, Manceau A, Ployet M J. Necessity of auditory and academic supervision in patients with unilateral hearing disorder: retrospective study of 175 children.  Ann Otolaryngol Chir Cervicofac. 1998;  115 149-155
• 21 Colletti V, Fiorino F G, Carner M, Rizzi R. Investigation of the long-term effects of unilateral hearing loss in adults.  Br J Audiol. 1988;  22 113-118
• 22 Hallmo P, Møller P, Lind O, Tonning F M. Unilateral sensorineural hearing loss in children less than 15 years of age.  Scand Audiol. 1986;  15 131-137
• 23 Brookhouser P E, Worthington D W, Kelly W J. Unilateral hearing loss in children.  Laryngoscope. 1991;  101(12, pt 1) 1264-1272
• 24 Sedey A, Stredler-Brown A, Carpenter K. Language outcomes in young children with unilateral hearing loss. Paper presented at: National Workshop on Mild and Unilateral Hearing Loss 2005 Breckenridge, CO;
• 25 Ruscetta M N, Arjmand E M, Pratt S R. Speech recognition abilities in noise for children with severe-to-profound unilateral hearing impairment.  Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol. 2005;  69(6) 771-779
• 26 Tieri L, Masi R, Ducci M, Marsella P. Unilateral sensorineural hearing loss in children.  Scand Audiol Suppl. 1988;  30 33-36
• 27 Kiese-Himmel C. Unilateral sensorineural hearing impairment in childhood: analysis of 31 consecutive cases.  Int J Audiol. 2002;  41 57-63
• 28 Yoshinaga-Itano C, Johnson C D, Carpenter K, Brown A S. Outcomes of children with mild bilateral hearing loss and unilateral hearing loss.  Semin Hear. 2008;  29 196-211
• 29 Bess F H, Sinclair S, Riggs D. Group amplification in schools for the hearing-impaired.  Ear Hear. 1984;  5 138-144
• 30 Knecht H A, Nelson P, Whitelaw G, Feth L. Background noise levels and reverberation times in unoccupied classrooms: predictions and measurements.  Am J Audiol. 2002;  11 65-71
• 31 McCroskey F, Devens J. Acoustic Characteristics of Public School Classrooms Constructed Between 1890 and 1960. NOISEXPO Proceedings 1975: 101-103
• 32 Picard M, Bradley J. Revisiting speech interference in classrooms.  Audiology. 2001;  40 221-244
• 33 Crandell C, Bess F H. Developmental changes in speech recognition in noise and reverberation. Presented at: American Speech-Language-Hearing Association annual convention November 1987 New Orleans, LA;
• 34 Elliott L L. Performance of children aged 9 to 17 years on a test of speech intelligibility in noise using sentence material with controlled word predictability.  J Acoust Soc Am. 1979;  66 651-653
• 35 Elliott L L, Connors S, Kille E, Levin S, Ball K, Katz D. Children's understanding of monosyllabic nouns in quiet and noise.  J Acoust Soc Am. 1979;  66 12-21
• 36 Elliott L. Effects of noise on perception of speech by children and certain handicapped individuals.  Sound Vibration. 1982;  16 9-14
• 37 Johnson C E. Children's phoneme identification in reverberation and noise.  J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2000;  43 144-157
• 38 Nabelek A K, Robinson P. Monaural and binaural speech perception in reverberation for listeners of various ages.  J Acoust Soc Am. 1982;  71 1242-1248
• 39 Stuart A. Development of auditory temporal resolution in school-age children by word recognition in continuous and interrupted noise.  Ear Hear. 2005;  26 78-88
• 40 Boney S, Bess F. Noise and reverberation effects in minimal bilateral sensorineural hearing loss. Paper presented at: American Speech-Language-Hearing Association annual convention November 1984 San Francisco, CA;
• 41 Crandell C C. Speech recognition in noise by children with minimal degrees of sensorineural hearing loss.  Ear Hear. 1993;  14 210-216
• 42 Finitzo-Hieber T, Tillman T. Room acoustics effects on monosyllabic word discrimination ability for normal-hearing and hearing-impaired children.  J Speech Hear Res. 1978;  21 440-458
• 43 Hawkins D B, Yacullo W. Signal-to-noise ratio advantage of binaural hearing aids and directional microphones under different levels of reverberation.  J Speech Hear Disord. 1984;  49 409-418
• 44 Blair J C. Effects of amplification, speechreading, and classroom environments on reception of speech.  Volta Review. 1977;  79 443-449
• 45 Markides A, Huntington A, Kettlety C. Comparative speech discrimination abilities of hearing-impaired children achieved through infra-red, radio, and conventional hearing aids.  J Brit Assoc Teachers of the Deaf. 1980;  1 5-14
• 46 Bess F H. The minimally hearing-impaired child.  Ear Hear. 1985;  6 43-47
• 47 Clark J G. Uses and abuses of hearing loss classification.  ASHA. 1981;  23 493-500
• 48 Diefendorf A, Gravel J. Behavioral observation and visual reinforcement audiometry. In: Gerber S The Handbook of Pediatric Audiology. Washington, DC; Gallaudet University Press 1996
• 49 Ross M, Giolas T. Effects of three classroom listening conditions on speech intelligibility.  Am Ann Deaf. 1971;  116 580-584
• 50 Ross M, Giolas T, Carver P. Effects of classroom listening conditions on speech intelligibility.  Lang Speech Hear Sch. 1973;  4 72-76
• 51 Bench J, Bamford J. Speech-Hearing Tests and the Spoken Language of Hearing-Impaired Children. London, United Kingdom; Academic Press 1979
• 52 Johnson C, Stein R, Broadway A, Markwalter T. Minimal high-frequency hearing loss and school-age children: speech recognition in a classroom.  Lang Speech Hear Sch. 1997;  28 77-85
• 53 Edgerton B, Danhauer J. Clinical Implications of Speech Discrimination Using Nonsense Syllables. Baltimore, MD; University Park Press 1979
• 54 Crandell C, Bess F H. Speech recognition of children in a “typical” classroom setting.  ASHA. 1987;  29 87
• 55 Crandell C, Bess F H. Sound field amplification in the classroom setting. Paper presented at: American Speech Language Hearing Association annual convention November 1987 New Orleans, LA;
• 56 Crandell C, Siebein G, Gold M et al.. Pilot studies of speech communication in elementary school classrooms: literature review and methods. Paper presented at: National Conference on Noise Control Engineering June 1997 State College, PA;
• 57 Anderson K L. S.I.F.T.E.R.: Screening Identification for Targeting Educational Risk. Tampa, FL; Educational Audiology Association 1989
• 58 Macmillan/McGraw-Hill .Comprehensive Test of Basic Skills—Technical Report. 4th ed. Monterey, CA; Macmillan/McGraw-Hill 1993
• 59 Blair J C, Peterson M E, Viehweg S H. The effects of mild sensorineural hearing loss on academic performance of young school-age children.  Volta Review. 1985;  87 87-93
• 60 Ross D S, Visser S, Holstrum J, Kenneson A. Minimal hearing loss and cognitive performance in children: brief update. In: National Workshop on Mild and Unilateral Hearing Loss—Workshop Proceedings Breckenridge, CO; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; 2005 http://Available at: www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/ehdi/unilateralhi.htm Accessed July 21, 2008
• 61 Reed S, Antia S, Kreimeyer K. Academic status of deaf and hard-of-hearing students in public schools: student, home and service facilitators and detractors.  J Deaf Stud Deaf Educ. 2008;  13(4) 485-502
• 62 Wake M, Hughes E K, Poulakis Z, Collins C, Rickards F W. Outcomes of children with mild-profound congenital hearing loss at 7 to 8 years: a population study.  Ear Hear. 2004;  25 1-8
• 63 Most T. The effects of degree and type of hearing loss on children's performance in class.  Deafness Educ Int. 2004;  6(3) 154-166
• 64 Tharpe A M, Ricketts T, Sladen D P. FM systems for children with minimal to mild hearing loss. In: Fabry D, Johnson CD Access Conference Proceedings. United Kingdom; Cambrian Printers 2004
• 65 Dodd-Murphy J, Murphy W. Educational risk and perception of hearing difficulty in schoolchildren. Poster presented at: American Speech-Language-Hearing Association national convention November 2007 Boston, MA;
• 66 Blake P E, Bess F H. The use of functional health assessments with hearing impaired adolescents. Poster presented at: Florida Language Speech and Hearing Association annual convention 1992 Tarpon Springs, FL;
• 67 Cappelli M, Daniels T, Durieux-Smith A, McGrath P J, Neuss D. Social development of children with hearing impairments who are integrated into general education classrooms.  Volta Review. 1995;  97 197-208
• 68 Pudlas K A. Self-esteem and self-concept: special education as experienced by deaf, hard of hearing and hearing students.  BC J Spec Educ. 1998;  20(1) 23-39
• 69 Nelson E, Wasson J, Kirk J et al.. Assessment of function in routine clinical practice: description of the COOP Chart method and preliminary findings.  J Chronic Dis. 1987;  40(suppl 1) 55S-69S
• 70 Dodd-Murphy J D, Bess F H, Parker R A. Social and emotional correlates of minimal sensorineural hearing loss. Paper presented at: American Speech-Language-Hearing Association annual meeting November 1997 Boston, MA;
• 71 Davis A, Reeve K, Hind S, Bamford J. Children with mild and unilateral hearing impairment. In: A Sound Foundation Through Early Amplification 2001—Proceedings of the Second International Conference—Section V United Kingdom; St. Edmundsbury Press 2001: 179-86
• 72 Wake M, Tobin S, Cone-Wesson B et al.. Slight/mild sensorineural hearing loss in children.  Pediatrics. 2006;  118 1842-1851
• 73 Brunnberg E, Bostrom M L, Berglund M. Self-rated mental health, school adjustment, and substance abuse in hard-of-hearing adolescents.  J Deaf Stud Deaf Educ. 2008;  13(3) 324-335
• 74 Hick C B, Tharpe A M. Listening effort and fatigue in school-age children with and without hearing loss.  J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2002;  45 573-584
• 75 Newman C W, Jacobson G P, Hug G A, Sandridge S A. Perceived handicap of patients with unilateral or mild hearing loss.  Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 1997;  106 210-214
• 76 Kopun J G, Stelmachowicz P G. Perceived communication difficulties of children with hearing loss.  Am J Audiol. 1998;  7(1) 30-38
• 77 Anderson K L, Smaldino J J. Listening Inventory For Education: a classroom measurement tool.  Hear J. 1999;  52 74-76
• 78 Stelmachowicz P G, Lewis D E, Choi S, Hoover B. Effect of stimulus bandwidth on auditory skills in normal-hearing and hearing-impaired children.  Ear Hear. 2007;  28(4) 483-494
• 79 McFadden B, Pittman A. Effect of minimal hearing loss on children's ability to multitask in quiet and in noise.  Lang Speech Hear Serv Sch. 2008;  39 342-351
• 80 Dalzell L, Orlando M, MacDonald M et al.. The New York State Universal Newborn Hearing Screening Demonstration Project: ages of hearing loss identification, hearing aid fitting, and enrollment in early intervention.  Ear Hear. 2000;  21(2) 118-130
• 81 Harrison M, Roush J. Age of suspicion, identification, and intervention for infants and young children with hearing loss: a national study.  Ear Hear. 1996;  17(1) 55-62
• 82 Johnson J L, White K R, Widen J E et al.. A multicenter evaluation of how many infants with permanent hearing loss pass a two-stage otoacoustic emissions/automated auditory brainstem response newborn hearing screening protocol.  Pediatrics. 2005;  116 663-672
• 83 McKay S, Gravel J S, Tharpe A M. Amplification considerations for children with minimal or mild bilateral hearing loss and unilateral hearing loss.  Trends Amplif. 2008;  12(1) 43-54
• 84 Jerger J, Silman S, Lew H L, Chmiel R. Case studies in binaural interference: converging evidence from behavioral and electrophysiologic measures.  J Am Acad Audiol. 1993;  4 122-131
• 85 Litovsky R Y, Johnstone P M, Godar S P. Benefits of bilateral cochlear implants and/or hearing aids in children.  Int J Audiol. 2006;  45(Suppl) S78-S91
• 86 Gelfand S A, Silman S. Apparent auditory deprivation in children: implications of monaural versus binaural amplification.  J Am Acad Audiol. 1993;  4 313-318
• 87 Grimault N, Garnier S, Collet L. Relationship between amplification fitting age and speech perception performance in school age children. In: Seewald RC Sound Foundation Through Early Amplification. Nashville, TN; Bill Wilkerson Center Press 1998: 191-198
• 88 Reeve K, Davis A C, Hind S. Mild and unilateral hearing impairments: what the clinicians think. Poster presented at: A Sound Foundation Through Early Amplification Conference October 2001 Chicago, IL;
• 89 McKay S. To aid or not to aid: children with unilateral hearing loss. Health Hear 2002. Available at: http://www.healthyhearing.com/library/article_content.asp?article_id=163 Accessed July 16, 2008
• 90 Reeve K. Amplification and family factors for children with mild and unilateral hearing impairment. In: National Workshop on Mild and Unilateral Hearing Loss—Workshop Proceedings Breckenridge, CO; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; 2005 http://Available at: www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/ehdi/unilateralhi.htm Accessed July 21, 2008
• 91 Valente M. Fitting options for adults with unilateral hearing loss.  Hear J. 2007;  60(8) 10-18
• 92 Kenworthy O T, Klee T, Tharpe A M. Speech recognition ability of children with unilateral sensorineural hearing loss as a function of amplification, speech stimuli and listening condition.  Ear Hear. 1990;  11 264-270
• 93 Updike C D. Comparison of FM auditory trainers, CROS aids and personal amplification in unilaterally hearing impaired children.  J Am Acad Audiol. 1994;  5 204-209
• 94 Chartrand M S. Transcranial or internal CROS fittings: evaluation and validation protocol.  Hear J. 1991;  44 26-28
• 95 Valente M, Potts L H, Valente M, Goebel J. Wireless CROS versus transcranial CROS for unilateral hearing loss.  Am J Audiol. 1995;  4 52-59
• 96 Tjellström A, Lindstrom O, Hallen T, Branemark P I. Osseointegrated titanium implants in the temporal bone: a clinical study on bone-anchored hearing aids.  Am J Otol. 1981;  2(4) 304-310
• 97 Priwin C, Jonsson R, Magnusson L, Hultcarantz M, Granstrom G. Audiological evaluation and self-assessed hearing problems in subjects with single-sided congenital external ear malformation and associated conductive hearing loss.  Int J Audiol. 2007;  46 162-171
• 98 Wazen J J, Ghossani S N, Kacker A, Zschommler A. Results of bone-anchored hearing aid in unilateral hearing loss.  Laryngoscope. 2001;  111 955-958
• 99 Wazen J J, Spitzer J B, Ghossani S N et al.. Transcranial contralateral cochlear stimulation in unilateral deafness.  Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2003;  129 248-254
• 100 Wazen J J, Ghossani S N, Spitzer J B, Kuller M. Localization by unilateral BAHA users.  Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2005;  132 928-932
• 101 American Academy of Audiology . Pediatric amplification protocol.  Audiology Today. 2004;  16 46-53
• 102 Seewald R C, Scollie S D. An approach for ensuring accuracy in pediatric hearing instrument fitting.  Trends Amplif. 2003;  7 29-40
• 103 Agnew J. Perception of internally generated noise in hearing amplification.  J Am Acad Audiol. 1996;  7 296-303
• 104 Davis A C, Reeve C, Hind S, Bamford J. (2001). Children with mild and unilateral hearing impairment. In: Seewald RC, Gravel JS A Sound Foundation Through Early Amplification. Proceedings of the Second International Conference. United Kingdom; Cambrian Printers 2001: 179-184
• 105 Nance W. Marion Downs lecture: How can newborn hearing screening be improved? Paper presented at: Audiology Now Conference. April 2007 Denver, CO;
• 106 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention .2005 National Workshop on Mild and Unilateral Hearing Loss. http://Available at: www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/ehdi/unilateralhi.htm Accessed August 1, 2008