Posterior Cruciate Ligament Preservation versus Posterior Cruciate Ligament Sacrifice: Comparing Patient Outcomes in Medial Congruent Total Knee Arthroplasty

Abstract

This study aimed to compare outcomes and complication rates between posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) retention and excision utilizing a medial congruent (MC) polyethylene insert in total knee arthroplasty (TKA) in a specialized ambulatory surgery center (ASC) dedicated to hip and knee arthroplasty. A retrospective review was performed between May 2023 and October 2023 analyzing 398 patients who underwent primary MC TKA by high-volume joint arthroplasty surgeons (n = 9) with either PCL preservation (n = 264) or sacrifice (n = 134) in a single free-standing ASC. Patients were matched chronologically on a 2:1 basis. Demographics, baseline function, 90-day complications, and patient-reported outcomes were recorded for each patient. There were no differences in preoperative baseline function or patient-reported outcome measures, Charlson Comorbidity Index, or American Society of Anesthesiologists class among patient groups. The PCL-preserve and PCL-sacrifice cohorts showed significant variation in 12-week postoperative Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome, Junior (KOOS, JR.) scores. Specifically, the number of patients who achieved the minimal clinically important difference (MCID) in KOOS, JR. scores was higher in the PCL-sacrifice group (p < 0.05). Yet, no complications within the 90-day period were associated with PCL status and other patient-reported outcomes. This study comparing outcomes between MC TKAs with PCL retention and sacrifice suggests that both techniques are viable options with similar functional outcomes, pain scores, and complication rates, which may have benefits in an ASC setting. The PCL-sacrifice group exhibited a statistically significant increase in patients who achieved the MCID in KOOS, JR. score compared with the PCL-preserving at early follow-up. Future research should employ prospective, randomized designs to further validate these findings and explore long-term implications.

Keywords

medial congruent polyethylene - posterior cruciate ligament - ambulatory surgery center - total knee arthroplasty

Publication History

Received: 12 March 2024

Accepted: 30 July 2024

Accepted Manuscript online:
05 August 2024

Article published online:
18 September 2024

• References

• 1 Rajgopal A, Kumar S, Singh MK, Aggarwal K. PCL retention demonstrates better functional scores and gait patterns in total knee arthroplasty using a medial congruent insert-a prospective study. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 2023; 31 (11) 4741-4746
• 2 Dall'Oca C, Ricci M, Vecchini E. et al. Evolution of TKA design. Acta Biomed 2017; 88 (2S, Suppl 2) 17-31
• 3 Heckmann ND, Steck T, Sporer SM, Meneghini RM. Conforming polyethylene inserts in total knee arthroplasty: beyond the posterior-stabilized and cruciate-retaining debate. J Am Acad Orthop Surg 2021; 29 (22) e1097-e1104
• 4 Putame G, Terzini M, Rivera F, Kebbach M, Bader R, Bignardi C. Kinematics and kinetics comparison of ultra-congruent versus medial-pivot designs for total knee arthroplasty by multibody analysis. Sci Rep 2022; 12 (01) 3052
• 5 Youm YS, Cho SD, Lee SH, Cho HY. Total knee arthroplasty using a posterior cruciate ligament sacrificing medial pivot knee: minimum 5-year follow-up results. Knee Surg Relat Res 2014; 26 (03) 135-140
• 6 Jones CW, Jacobs H, Shumborski S. et al. Sagittal stability and implant design affect patient reported outcomes after total knee arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty 2020; 35 (03) 747-751
• 7 Petersen ET, Rytter S, Koppens D. et al. Medial congruent polyethylene design show different tibiofemoral kinematics and enhanced congruency compared to a standard symmetrical cruciate retaining design for total knee arthroplasty-an in vivo randomized controlled study of gait using dynamic radiostereometry. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 2023; 31 (03) 933-945
• 8 Shi W, Jiang Y, Wang Y, Zhao X, Yu T, Li T. Medial pivot prosthesis has a better functional score and lower complication rate than posterior-stabilized prosthesis: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Orthop Surg Res 2022; 17 (01) 395
• 9 Cacciola G, De Martino I, De Meo F. Does the medial pivot knee improve the clinical and radiographic outcome of total knee arthroplasty? A single centre study on two hundred and ninety seven patients. Int Orthop 2020; 44 (02) 291-299
• 10 Sun X, Gao X, Sun X, Su Z. Comparison of clinical and radiographic results between total knee arthroplasties using medial pivot and posterior-stabilized prosthesis: a meta-analysis. Medicine (Baltimore) 2021; 100 (04) e23809
• 11 Konno T, Onodera T, Nishio Y, Kasahara Y, Iwasaki N, Majima T. Correlation between knee kinematics and patellofemoral contact pressure in total knee arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty 2014; 29 (12) 2305-2308
• 12 Wang Z, Zhang YQ, Ding CR, Wang YZ, Xu H. Early patellofemoral function of medial pivot prostheses compared with posterior-stabilized prostheses for unilateral total knee arthroplasty. Orthop Surg 2021; 13 (02) 417-425
• 13 Kato M, Warashina H, Mitamura S, Kataoka A. Medial pivot-based total knee arthroplasty achieves better clinical outcomes than posterior-stabilised total knee arthroplasty. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 2023; 31 (03) 998-1010
• 14 Nishio Y, Onodera T, Kasahara Y, Takahashi D, Iwasaki N, Majima T. Intraoperative medial pivot affects deep knee flexion angle and patient-reported outcomes after total knee arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty 2014; 29 (04) 702-706
• 15 Batra S, Malhotra R. Medial ball and socket total knee arthroplasty in Indian population: 5-year clinical results. Clin Orthop Surg 2022; 14 (01) 90-95
• 16 Kayani B, Konan S, Horriat S, Ibrahim MS, Haddad FS. Posterior cruciate ligament resection in total knee arthroplasty: the effect on flexion-extension gaps, mediolateral laxity, and fixed flexion deformity. Bone Joint J 2019; 101-B (10) 1230-1237
• 17 Lyman S, Lee YY, McLawhorn AS, Islam W, MacLean CH. What are the minimal and substantial improvements in the HOOS and KOOS and JR versions after total joint replacement?. Clin Orthop Relat Res 2018; 476 (12) 2432-2441