Density-Induced Plant Size Reduction and Size Inequalities in Ethylene-Sensing and Ethylene-Insensitive Tobacco

Abstract

Plant competition for light is a commonly occurring phenomenon in natural and agricultural vegetations. It is typically size-asymmetric, meaning that slightly larger individuals receive a disproportionate share of the light, leaving a limited amount of light for the initially smaller individuals. As a result, size inequalities of such stands increase with competition intensity. A plant's ability to respond morphologically to the presence of neighbour plants with enhanced shoot elongation, the so-called shade avoidance response, acts against the development of size inequalities. This has been shown experimentally with transgenic plants that cannot sense neighbours and, therefore, show no shade avoidance responses. Stands of such transgenic plants showed a much stronger development of size inequalities at high plant densities than did wild type (WT) stands. However, the transgenic plants used in these experiments displayed severely hampered growth rates and virtually no response to neighbours. In order to more precisely study the impact of this phenotypic plasticity on size inequality development, experiments required plants that have normal growth rates and reduced, but not absent, shade avoidance responses. We made use of an ethylene-insensitive, transgenic tobacco genotype (Tetr) that has wild type growth rates and moderately reduced shade avoidance responses to neighbours. Here, we show that the development of size inequalities in monocultures of these plants is not affected unambiguously different from wild type monocultures. Plots of Tetr plants developed higher inequalities for stem length than did WT, but monocultures of the two genotypes had identical CV (Coefficient of Variance) values for shoot biomass that increased with plant density. Therefore, even though reduced shade avoidance capacities led to the expected higher size inequalities for stem length, this does not necessarily lead to increased size inequalities for shoot biomass.

Competition - growth - ethylene perception - plasticity - shade avoidance.

References

• 1 Aphalo P. J., Ballaré C. L., Scopel A. L.. Plant-plant signalling, the shade avoidance response and competition.  Journal of Experimental Botany. (1999);  50 1629-1634
• 2 Ballaré C. L.. Keeping up with the neighbours: phytochrome sensing and other signalling mechanisms.  Trends in Plant Science. (1999);  4 97-102
• 3 Ballaré C. L., Scopel A. L., Jordan E. T., Vierstra R. D.. Signaling among neighboring plants and the development of size inequalities in plant populations.  Proceedings of the National Academy of Science USA. (1994);  91 10094-10098
• 4 Black J. N., Wilkinson G. N.. The role of the time of emergence in determining the growth of individual plants in swards of subterranean clover (Trifolium subterraneum L.).  Australian Journal of Agricultural Research. (1963);  14 628-638
• 5 Callaway R. M., Pennings S. C., Richards C. L.. Phenotypic plasticity and interactions among plants.  Ecology. (2003);  84 1115-1128
• 6 Dudley S. A., Schmitt J.. Testing the adaptive plasticity hypothesis: density-dependent selection on manipulated stem length in Impatiens capensis. .  The American Naturalist. (1996);  147 445-465
• 7 Geber M. A.. Interplay of morphology and development on size inequality: a Polygonum greenhouse study.  Ecological Monographs. (1989);  59 267-288
• 8 Grbic V., Bleecker A. B.. Ethylene regulates the timing of leaf senescence in Arabidopsis. .  The Plant Journal. (1995);  8 595-602
• 9 Knoester M., Van Loon L. C., Van den Heuvel J., Hennig J., Bol J. F., Linthorst H. J. M.. Ethylene-insensitive tobacco lacks nonhost resistance against soil-borne fungi.  Proceedings of the National Academy of Science USA. (1998);  95 1933-1937
• 10 Maloof J. N., Borevitz J., Weigel D., Chory J.. Natural variation in phytochrome signaling.  Seminars in Cell and Developmental Biology. (2000);  11 523-530
• 11 Miller T. E., Weiner J.. Local density variation may mimic effects of asymmetric competition on plant size variability.  Ecology. (1989);  70 1188-1191
• 12 Pierik R., Visser E. J. W., de Kroon H., Voesenek L. A. C. J.. Ethylene is required in tobacco to successfully compete with proximate neighbours.  Plant, Cell and Environment. (2003);  26 1229-1234
• 13 Schmitt J., McCormac A. C., Smith H.. A test of the adaptive plasticity hypothesis using transgenic and mutant plants disabled in phytochrome-mediated elongation responses to neighbors.  The American Naturalist. (1995);  146 937-953
• 14 Schmitt J., Wulff R. D.. Light spectral quality, phytochrome and plant competition.  Trends in Ecology and Evolution. (1993);  8 47-51
• 15 Schwinning S., Weiner J.. Mechanisms determining the degree of size asymmetry in competition among plants.  Oecologia. (1998);  113 447-455
• 16 Smith H., Whitelam G. C.. The shade avoidance syndrome: multiple responses mediated by multiple phytochromes.  Plant, Cell and Environment. (1997);  20 840-844
• 25 Tholen D., Voesenek L. A. C. J., Poorter H.. Ethylene insensitivity does not increase leaf area or relative growth rate in Arabidopsis thaliana, Nicotiana tabacum and Petunia × hybrida. .  Plant Physiology. (2004);  in press
• 17 Turner M. D., Rabinowitz D.. Factors affecting frequency distributions of plant mass: the absence of dominance and suppression in competing monocultures of Festuca paradoxa. .  Ecology. (1983);  64 469-475
• 18 Weiner J.. Size hierarchies in experimental populations of annual plants.  Ecology. (1985);  66 743-752
• 19 Weiner J.. Asymmetric competition in plant populations.  Trends in Ecology and Evolution. (1990);  5 360-364
• 20 Weiner J., Fishman L.. Competition and allometry in Kochia scoparia. .  Annals of Botany. (1994);  73 263-271
• 21 Weiner J., Mallory E. B., Kennedy C.. Growth and variability in crowded and uncrowded populations of dwarf marigolds (Tagetes patula). .  Annals of Botany. (1990);  65 513-524
• 22 Weiner J., Stoll P., Muller-Landau H., Jasentuliyana A.. The effects of density, spatial patter, and competitive symmetry on size variation in simulated plant populations.  The American Naturalist. (2001);  158 438-450
• 23 Weiner J., Thomas S. C.. Competition and allometry in three species of annual plants.  Ecology. (1992);  73 648-656
• 24 Weinig C.. Differing selection in alternative competitive environments: shade-avoidance responses and germination timing.  Evolution. (2000);  54 124-136

Section Editor: K. Clay