Positive and Negative Interactions among Individuals of a Root Hemiparasite

Abstract

I studied the effects of a wide range of densities on establishment, survival, growth and reproduction of the annual root hemiparasite Rhinanthus alectorolophus in a field experiment. Seeds of the parasite were sown with those of a mixture of grassland plants as potential hosts. In most plants, seedling survival is strongly reduced by self-thinning at high densities, but in R. alectorolophus the proportion of seeds producing a young plant increased linearly with sowing density, indicating positive interactions among seedlings. Because survival to maturity was not influenced by density, the number of flowering plants per seed sown also increased with density. In contrast, mean plant size and reproduction were strongly reduced at high densities. It is suggested that resource sharing among parasites connected by haustoria is the most likely mechanism responsible for the reduced mortality of seedlings at high densities. The results indicate that facilitation among cohorts of conspecific root hemiparasites can increase the recruitment of young plants. The number of seeds produced per seed sown (a multiplicative fitness measure) was, however, independent of density in Rhinanthus because the early positive effects of density on recruitment were compensated later by the negative effects of crowding on growth and reproduction. Increased survival of seedlings could, however, indirectly increase fitness because it will increase the genetic diversity of offspring and may thus, for instance, reduce the impact of pathogens.

Competition - facilitation - parasitism - root hemiparasites

References

• 01 Antonovics,  J., and Levin,  D. A.. (1980);  The ecological and genetical consequences of density-dependent regulation in plants.  Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics. 11 411-452
• 02 Atsatt,  P. R.. (1970) Biochemical bridges between vascular plants. Biochemical evolution: Proceedings of the 29th Annual Biology Colloquium. Chambers, K. L., ed. Eugene, Oregon; Oregon State University Press pp. 53-68
• 03 Bergelson,  J. R., and Perry,  R.. (1989);  Interspecific competition between seed: relative planting data and density affect seedling emergence.  Ecology. 70 1639-1644
• 04 Bertness,  M. D., and Callaway,  R. M.. (1994);  Positive interactions in communities.  Trends in Ecology and Evolution. 9 191-193
• 05 Bertness,  M. D., and Hacker,  S. D.. (1994);  Physical stress and positive interactions among marsh plants.  American Naturalist. 144 363-372
• 06 Bertness,  M. D., and Shumway,  S. W.. (1993);  Competition and facilitation in marsh plants.  American Naturalist. 142 718-724
• 07 Bertness,  M. D., and Yeh,  S. M.. (1994);  Cooperative and competitive interactions in the recruitment of marsh elders.  Ecology. 75 2416-2429
• 08 Booy,  G.,, Hendriks,  R. J. J.,, Smulders,  M. J. M.,, Van Groenendael,  J. M.,, and Vosman,  B.. (2000);  Genetic diversity and the survival of populations.  Plant Biology. 2 379-395
• 09 Burdon,  J. J.. (1987) Diseases and plant population biology. Cambridge, UK; Cambridge University Press
• 10 Callaway,  R. M.. (1994);  Facilitative and interfering effects of Arthrocnemum subterminale on winter annuals in a California salt marsh.  Ecology. 75 681-686
• 11 Callaway,  R. M.. (1995);  Positive interactions among plants.  Botanical Review. 61 306-349
• 12 Callaway,  R. M., and Walker,  L. R.. (1997);  Competition and facilitation: a synthetic to interactions in plant communities.  Ecology. 78 1567-1578
• 13 Cantlon,  J. E.,, Curtis,  E. J. C.,, and Malcolm,  W. M.. (1963);  Studies on Melampyrum lineare. .  Ecology. 44 466-474
• 14 Damon,  R. A., and Harvey,  W. R.. (1987) Experimental design, ANOVA, and regression. New York; Harper and Row
• 15 Day,  R. W., and Quinn,  G. P.. (1989);  Comparison of treatments after an analysis of variance in ecology.  Ecological Monographs. 59 433-463
• 16 Fineran,  B. A.. (1965);  Parasitism in Exocarpus bidwillii Hook, f. VI. Haustorial attachment to non-living objects and the phenomenon of self-parasitism.  Phytomorphology. 15 387-399
• 17 Gibson,  C. C., and Watkinson,  A. R.. (1991);  Host selectivity and the mediation of competition by the root hemiparasite Rhinanthus minor. .  Oecologia. 86 81-87
• 18 Grace,  J. B.,, Wetzel,  R.,, and Tilman,  D.. (1990) Perspectives on plant competition. New York; Academic Press
• 19 Greenlee,  J. T., and Callaway,  R. M.. (1996);  Abiotic stress and the relative importance of interference and facilitation in montane communities in Western Montana.  American Naturalist. 148 386-396
• 20 Harper,  J. L.. (1977) Population biology of plants. London, New York, San Francisco; Academic Press
• 21 Hartl,  D.. (1974) Rhinanthus. . Illustrierte Flora von Mitteleuropa, Vol. 6. 2nd edn. Hamburg, Berlin; Paul Parey pp. 374-403
• 22 Heinricher,  E.. (1898);  Die grünen Halbschmarotzer. II. Euphrasia, Alectorolophus und Odontites. .  Jahrbücher für wissenschaftliche Botanik.. 32 389-452
• 23 Heinricher,  E.. (1909);  Die grünen Halbschmarotzer. V. Melampyrum. .  Jahrbücher für wissenschaftliche Botanik. 46 273-376
• 24 Heckard,  L. R.. (1962);  Root parasitism in Castilleja. .  Botanical Gazette. 124 21-29
• 25 Huenneke,  L. F.. (1991) Ecological implications of genetic variation in plant populations. Genetics and conservation of rare plants. Falk, D. A. and Holsinger, K. E., eds. New York; Oxford University Press, USA pp. 31-44
• 26 Hutchings,  M. J.. (1979);  Weight-density relationships in ramet populations of clonal perennial herbs, with special reference to the 3/2 power law.  Journal of Ecology. 67 31-34
• 27 Joshi,  J.,, Matthies,  D.,, and Schmid,  B.. (2000);  Root hemiparasites and plant diversity in experimental grassland communities.  Journal of Ecology. 88 634-644
• 28 Koch,  L.. (1889);  Zur Entwickelungsgeschichte der Rhinanthaceen. Rhinanthus minor Ehrh.  Jahrbücher für wissenschaftliche Botanik. 20 1-37
• 29 Linhart,  Y. B.. (1976);  Density-dependent seed germination strategies in colonizing versus non-colonizing plant species.  Journal of Ecology. 64 375-380
• 30 Matthies,  D.. (1991) Die Populationsbiologie der annuellen Hemiparasiten Melampyrum arvense, Melampyrum cristatum und Melampyrum nemorosum (Scrophulariaceae). University of Bochum, Germany; PhD-thesis
• 31 Matthies,  D.. (1995 a);  Parasitic and competitive interactions between the hemiparasites Rhinanthus serotinus and Odontites rubra and their host Medicago sativa. .  Journal of Ecology. 83 245-251
• 32 Matthies,  D.. (1995 b);  Host-parasite relations in the root parasite Melampyrum arvense. .  Flora. 190 383-394
• 33 Matthies,  D.. (1997);  Host-parasite interactions in Castilleja and Orthocarpus. .  Canadian Journal of Botany. 75 1252-1260
• 34 Matthies,  D., and Egli,  P.. (1999);  Response of a root hemiparasite to elevated CO₂ depends on host type and soil nutrients.  Oecologia. 120 156-161
• 35 Musselman,  L. J., and Dickison,  W. C.. (1975);  The structure and development of the haustorium in parasitic Scrophulariaceae.  Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society. 70 183-212
• 36 Nwoke,  F. I. D., and Okonkwo,  S. N. C.. (1974);  Facultative hemiparasitism in Buchnera hispida Buch.-Ham ex. D.Don.  Annals of Botany. 38 993-1002
• 37 Parker,  M. A.. (1982);  Association with mature plants protects seedlings from predation in an arid grassland shrub, Gutierrezia microcephala. .  Oecologia. 53 276-280
• 38 Prati,  D.,, Matthies,  D.,, and Schmid,  B.. (1997);  Reciprocal parasitization in Rhinanthus serotinus: a model system of physiological integration in clonal plants.  Oikos. 78 221-229
• 39 Press,  M. C.,, Graves,  J. D.,, and Stewart,  G. R.. (1990);  Physiology of the interaction of angiosperm parasites and their higher plant hosts.  Plant Cell and Environment. 13 91-104
• 40 Sans,  F. X.,, Escarre,  J.,, Gorse,  V.,, and Lepart,  J.. (1998);  Persistence of Picris hieracoides populations in old fields: An example of facilitation.  Oikos. 83 283-292
• 41 Schmid,  B.. (1994);  Effects of genetic diversity in experimental stands of Solidago altissima - evidence for the potential role of pathogens as selective agents in plant populations.  Journal of Ecology. 82 165-175
• 42 Snogerup,  B.. (1982);  Host influence on north west European taxa of Odontites (Scrophulariaceae).  Annales Botanicae Fennici. 19 17-30
• 43 Steenberg,  W. F., and Lowe,  C. H.. (1969);  Critical factors during the first year of life of the saguaro (Cereus giganteus) at Saguaro National Monument.  Ecology. 50 825-834
• 44 Van Hulst,  R. B.,, Shipley,  B.,, and Theriault,  A.. (1987);  Why is Rhinanthus minor such a good invader?.  Canadian Journal of Botany. 65 2373-2379
• 45 Waite,  S., and Hutchings,  M. J.. (1978);  The effects of sowing density, salinity and substrate upon the germination of seeds of Plantago coronopus L.  New Phytologist. 81 341-348
• 46 Weber,  H. C.. (1976);  Über Wirtspflanzen und Parasitismus einiger mitteleuropäischer Rhinanthoideae (Scrophulariaceae).  Plant Systematics and Evolution. 125 97-107
• 47 Weltzin,  J. F., and McPherson,  G. R.. (1998);  Facilitation of conspecific seedling recruitment and shifts in temperate savanna ecotones.  Ecological Monographs. 69 513-534
• 48 Wied,  A., and Galen,  C.. (1998);  Plant parental care: conspecific nurse effects in Frasera speciosa and Cirsium scopulorum. .  Ecology. 79 1657-1668
• 49 Yeo,  P. F.. (1964);  The growth of Euphrasia in cultivation.  Watsonia. 6 1-24
• 50 Yoda,  K.,, Kira,  T.,, Ogawa,  H.,, and Hozumi,  K.. (1963);  Self-thinning in overcrowded pure stands under cultivated and natural conditions.  Journal of Biology Osaka City University. 14 107-129

Section Editor: G. Gottsberger