Tropos or Atropos? That is the Question!

Abstract

While non-racemic catalysts can generate non-racemic products with or without the non-linear relationship in enantiomeric excesses between catalysts and products, racemic catalysts inherently give only a racemic mixture of chiral products. Racemic catalysts can be enantioselectively evolved into highly activated catalysts by association with chiral activators. Asymmetric activation strategy can produce greater enantiomeric excess in the products, even when using a catalytic amount of chiral activator per chiral or racemic catalysts bearing atropisomeric (atropos: from Greek a meaning not, and tropos meaning turn) ligands, than the enantioselectivity attained by the enantiomerically pure catalyst on its own. Some recent applications of the asymmetric activation catalysis that employ not only atropos and racemic ligands but also tropos ligands without enantiomeric resolution are herein reported. The great success of the asymmetric catalysts with tropos ligands clearly illustrate that chirally rigid atropos ligands can be replaced by chirally flexible tropos ligands to give preferentially the thermodynamically favorable diastereomer of catalysts with higher chiral efficiency than does the minor isomer. The asymmetric activation concept now progress toward the use of racemic but tropos ligands rather than the use of atropos ones.

1 Prologue: Tropos or Atropos? That is the Question!

2 Asymmetric Activation of Atropos and Racemic
Catalysts

2.1 Carbon-Carbon Bond Forming (Ene, Aldol, and
Diels-Alder) Reactions

2.2 Hydrogenation

3 Asymmetric Activation of Racemic but Tropos Catalysts

3.1 Biphenol (BIPOL)

3.2 Biphenylphosphine (BIPHEP)

3.3 Bis(diphenylphosphino)ferrocene (DPPF)

3.4 Hydrogenation

3.5 Carbon-Carbon Bond Forming (Diels-Alder and Ene)
Reactions

3.6 Tropos vs. Atropos Nature of BIPHEP-Metal Catalysts

4 Epilogue: Tropos rather than Atropos! That is an Answer!

asymmetric catalysis - asymmetric activation - atropos - tropos - biphenylphosphine

References

<A NAME="RA30302ST-1A">1a</A> Gawley RE. Aube J. Principles of Asymmetric Synthesis   Pergamon; London: 1996. 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-1B">1b</A> Advances in Catalytic Processes   Vol. 1:  Doyle MP. JAI Press; London: 1995. 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-1C">1c</A> Noyori R. Asymmetric Catalysis in Organic Synthesis   Wiley; New York: 1994. 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-1D">1d</A> Brunner H. Zettlmeier W. Handbook of Enantioselective Catalysis   VCH; Weinheim: 1993. 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-1E">1e</A> Catalytic Asymmetric Synthesis   Ojima I. VCH; New York: 1993. 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-1F">1f</A> Kagan HB. Comprehensive Organic Chemistry   Vol. 8:  Pergamon; Oxford: 1992. 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-1G">1g</A> Asymmetric Catalysis   Bosnich B. Martinus Nijhoff Publishers; Dordrecht: 1986. 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-2">2</A> Kuhn R. Molekulare Asymmetrie in Stereochemie   Freuberg H. Franz, Deutike; Leipzig-Wien: 1933.  p.803 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-3">3</A> Haworth WH. The Constitution of the Sugars   Edward Arnold & C.; London: 1929.  p.90 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-4A">4a</A> Kemp JD. Pitzer KS. J. Chem. Phys.  1936,  4:  749 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-4B">4b</A> Kemp JD. Pitzer KS. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1937,  59:  276 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-5">5</A> Christie GH. Kenner J. J. Chem. Soc.  1922,  121:  614 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-6A">6a</A> Oki M. Yamamoto G. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn.  1971,  44:  266 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-6B">6b</A> Oki M. Top. Stereochem.  1983,  14:  1 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-7A">7a</A> Pople JA. Schneider WG. Bernstein HJ. High Resolution Nuclear Magnetic Resonance   McGraw-Hill; New York: 1959.  p.218 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-7B">7b</A> Binsch G. Band-Shape Analysis in Dynamic Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy   Jackman LM. Cotton FA. Academic Press; New York: 1975.  p.45-81 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-7C">7c</A> Binsch G. Top Stereochem.  1968,  3:  97 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-8">8</A> Eliel EL. Wilen SH. Stereochemistry of Organic Compounds   Chap.14-15:  Wiley; New York: 1994. 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-9">9</A> Ahmed SR. Hall DM. J. Chem. Soc.  1959,  3383 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-10">10</A> Iffland DC. Siegel H. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1958,  80:  1947 

Reviews:

<A NAME="RA30302ST-11A">11a</A> Berrisford DJ. Bolm C. Sharpless KB. Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl.  1995,  34:  1059 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-11B">11b</A> Jacobsen EN. Marko I. France MB. Svendsen JS. Sharpless KB. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1989,  111:  737 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-11C">11c</A> Jacobsen EN. Marko I. France MB. Svendsen JS. Sharpless KB. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1988,  110:  1968 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-12">12</A> Review: Mikami K. Terada M. Korenaga T. Matsumoto Y. Ueki M. Angelaud R. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed.  2000,  39:  3532 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-13A">13a</A> Blaser H.-U. Müller M. Enantioselective Catalysis by Chiral Solids: Approaches and Results, In Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals II   Guisnet M. Barrault J. Bouchoule C. Duprez D. Perot G. Maurel M. Montassier C. Elsevier; Amsterdam: 1991. 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-13B">13b</A> Blaser H.-U. Tetrahedron: Asymmetry  1991,  2:  843 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-13C">13c</A> Garland M. Blaser HU. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1990,  112:  7048 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-13D">13d</A> Margitfalvi JL. Marti P. Baiker A. Botz L. Sticher O. Catal. Lett.  1990,  6:  281 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-14A">14a</A> Alcock NW. Brown JM. Maddox PJ. J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun.  1986,  1532 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-14B">14b</A> Brown JM. Maddox PJ. Chirality  1991,  3:  345 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-14C">14c</A> Maruoka K. Yamamoto H. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1989,  111:  789 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-14D">14d</A> Faller JW. Parr J. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1993,  115:  804 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-14E">14e</A> Faller JW. Tokunaga M. Tetrahedron Lett.  1993,  34:  7359 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-14F">14f</A> Faller JW. Liu Sams X. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1996,  118:  1217 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-14G">14g</A> Sablong R. Osborn JA. Faller JW. J. Organomet. Chem.  1997,  527:  65 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-15">15</A> Mikami K. Matsukawa S. Nature (London)  1997,  385:  613 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-16">16</A> Matsukawa S. Mikami K. Tetrahedron: Asymmetry  1997,  8:  815 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-17">17</A> Matsukawa S. Mikami K. Enantiomer  1996,  1:  69 

Reviews:

<A NAME="RA30302ST-18A">18a</A> Mikami K. Nakai T. Catalytic Asymmetric Synthesis   2nd Ed.:  Ojima I. Wiley-VCH; Weinheim: 2000.  p.543 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-18B">18b</A> Mikami K. Terada M. Comprehensive Asymmetric Catalysis   Jacobsen EN. Pfaltz A. Yamamoto H. Springer; Heidelberg: 1999.  p.1143 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-18C">18c</A> Mikami K. Shimizu M. Chem. Rev.  1992,  92:  1021 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-18D">18d</A> Mikami K. Terada M. Shimizu M. Nakai T. J. Symp. Org. Chem. Jpn.  1990,  48:  292 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-19A">19a</A> Ohkuma T. Ooka H. Hashiguchi S. Ikariya T. Noyori R. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1995,  117:  2675 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-19B">19b</A> Ohkuma T. Ooka H. Ikariya T. Noyori R. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1995,  117:  10417 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-19C">19c</A> Ohkuma T. Ooka H. Yamakawa M. Ikariya T. Noyori R. J. Org. Chem.  1996,  61:  4872 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-19D">19d</A> Ohkuma T. Ikehira H. Ikariya T. Noyori R. Synlett  1997,  467 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-19E">19e</A> Doucet H. Ohkuma T. Murata K. Yokozawa T. Kozawa M. Katayama E. England AF. Ikariya T. Noyori R. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed.  1998,  37:  1703 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-20A">20a</A> Ohkuma T. Doucet H. Pham T. Mikami K. Korenaga T. Terada M. Noyori R. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1998,  120:  1086 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-20B">20b</A> Mikami K. Korenaga T. Matsumoto Y. Ueki M. Terada M. Matsukawa S. Pure Appl. Chem.  2001,  73:  255 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-21">21</A>

See ref. [14] Amounts of chiral poisons: 2.0 equiv for Al, 1.4 equiv for Rh, 20 equiv for Ru, 3.0 equiv for Ti, and 2.0 equiv for Ir.

<A NAME="RA30302ST-22">22</A>

Mikami, K.; Yusa, Y.; Korenaga, T. Org. Lett. in press.

<A NAME="RA30302ST-23">23</A> Noyori R. Ohkuma T. Kitamura M. Takaya H. Sayo N. Kumobayashi H. Akutagawa S. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1987,  109:  5856 

The real catalyst has been suggested to be a mono- or dihydride species (X = H or Cl):

<A NAME="RA30302ST-24A">24a</A> Chowdhury RL. Bäckvall J.-E. J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun.  1991,  1063 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-24B">24b</A> Haack K.-J. Hashiguchi S. Fujii A. Ikariya T. Noyori R. Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl.  1997,  36:  285 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-24C">24c</A> Noyori R. Hashiguchi S. Acc. Chem. Res.  1997,  30:  97 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-24D">24d</A> Abdur-Rashid K. Lough AJ. Morris RH. Organometallics  2000,  19:  2655 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-24E">24e</A> Abdur-Rashid K. Faatz M. Lough AJ. Morris RH. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  2001,  123:  7473 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-24F">24f</A> Hartmann R. Chen P. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed.  2001,  40:  3581 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-25">25</A> Mikami K. Korenaga T. Ohkuma T. Noyori R. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed.  2000,  39:  3707 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-26">26</A> Mikami K. Matsukawa S. Volk T. Terada M. Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl.  1997,  36:  2768 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-27">27</A> Chavarot M. Byrne JJ. Chavant PY. Pardillos-Guindet J. Vallee Y. Tetrahedron: Asymmetry  1998,  9:  3889 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-28">28</A> Ueki M. Matsumoto Y. Jodry JJ. Mikami K. Synlett  2001,  1889 

BIPHEP [(2,2′-bis(diphenylphosphino)-1,1′-biphenyl]: This ligand was also named BPBP, but contrarily to what was claimed in the publication, it was unsuccessfully synthesized to give instead the monophosphine derivative:

<A NAME="RA30302ST-29A">29a</A> Uehara A. Bailar JC. J. Organomet. Chem.  1982,  239:  1 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-29B">29b</A> Bennett MA. Bhargava SK. Griffiths KD. Robertson GB. Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl.  1987,  26:  260 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-29C">29c</A> Desponds O. Schlosser M. J. Organomet. Chem.  1996,  507:  257 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-29D">29d</A> Desponds O. Schlosser M. Tetrahedron Lett.  1996,  37:  47 

For more details see:

<A NAME="RA30302ST-30A">30a</A> ‘BIPHEMP’ (2,2′-bis(diphenylphosphanyl)-6,6′-dimethyl- 1,1′-biphenyl): Svensson G. Albertsson J. Frejd T. Klingstedt T. Acta Crystallogr., Sect. C  1986,  42:  1324 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-30B">30b</A> See also: Schmid R. Cereghetti M. Heiser B. Schonholzer P. Hansen H.-J. Helv. Chim. Acta  1988,  71:  897 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-30C">30c</A> ‘BICHEPs’[2,2′-bis(dicyclohexylphosphanyl)-6,6′-dimethyl-1,1′-biphenyl]: Chiba T. Miyashita A. Nohira H. Tetrahedron Lett.  1991,  32:  4745 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-30D">30d</A> ‘MeO-BIPHEP’ [2,2′-bis(diphenyl-phosphanyl)-6,6′-dimethoxy-1,1′-biphenyl]: Schmid R. Foricher J. Cereghetti M. Schönholzer P. Helv. Chim. Acta  1991,  74:  370 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-30E">30e</A> See also: Schmid R. Broger EA. Cereghetti M. Crameri Y. Foricher J. Lalonde M. Müller RK. Scalone M. Schoettel G. Zutter U. Pure Appl. Chem.  1996,  68:  131 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-30F">30f</A> See further: Trabesinger G. Albinati A. Feiken N. Kunz RW. Pregosin PS. Tschoerner M. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1997,  119:  6315 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-30G">30g</A> 2,2′-bis(diphenylphosphanyl)-6,6′-difluoro-1,1′-biphenyl: Jendralla H. Li C.-H. Paulus E. Tetrahedron: Asymmetry  1994,  5:  1297 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-31">31</A> Mikami K. Korenaga T. Terada M. Ohkuma T. Pham T. Noyori R. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed.  1999,  38:  495 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-32">32</A> Mikami K. Aikawa K. Yusa Y. Org. Lett.  2002,  4:  95 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-33">33</A> Mikami K. Aikawa K. Yusa Y. Hatano M. Org. Lett.  2002,  4:  91 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-34A">34a</A> Ferrocenes   Togni A. Hayashi T. VCH; Weinheim: 1995. 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-34B">34b</A> Richards CJ. Locke AJ. Tetrahedron: Asymmetry  1998,  9:  2377 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-35">35</A> Hayashi T. Ohno A. Lu S. Matsumoto Y. Fukuyo E. Yanagi K. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1994,  116:  4421 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-36">36</A> Kanemasa S. Oderanotoshi Y. Sakaguchi S. Yamamoto H. Tanaka J. Wada E. Curran DP. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1998,  120:  3074 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-37">37</A>

Configuration of the dppf chirality is denoted by using the descriptors of chirality: (P), plus, clockwise and (M), minus, anticlockwise.

<A NAME="RA30302ST-38">38</A> Mikami K. Aikawa K. Org. Lett.  2002,  4:  99 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-39A">39a</A> Johannsen M. Jørgensen KA. J. Org. Chem.  1995,  60:  5757 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-39B">39b</A> Johannsen M. Jørgensen KA. Tetrahedron  1996,  52:  7321 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-39C">39c</A> Oi S. Kashiwagi K. Terada E. Ohuchi K. Inoue Y. Tetrahedron Lett.  1996,  37:  6351 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-39D">39d</A> Oi S. Terada E. Ohuchi K. Kato T. Tachibana Y. Inoue Y. J. Org. Chem.  1999,  64:  8660 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-40A">40a</A> Maseras F. Morokuma K. J. Comp. Chem.  1995,  16:  1170 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-40B">40b</A> Svensson M. Humbel S. Froese RDJ. Matsubara T. Sieber S. Morokuma K. J. Phys. Chem.  1996,  100:  19357 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-40C">40c</A> Dapprich S. Komaromi I. Byun KS. Morokuma K. Frisch MJ. J. Mol. Struct. (THEOCHEM)  1999,  461-462:  1 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-40D">40d</A> Vreven T. Morokuma K. J. Comput. Chem.  2000,  21:  1419 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-41">41</A>

Geometry optimization was performed with Gaussian 98. Computational details, see: Yamanaka, M.; Mikami, K. submitted.

<A NAME="RA30302ST-42">42</A> Korenaga T. Aikawa K. Terada M. Kawauchi S. Mikami K. Adv. Synth. Catal.  2001,  343:  284 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-43">43</A> Desponds O. Schlosser M. Tetrahedron Lett.  1996,  37:  47 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-44">44</A>

Epimerisation of (R)-RuCl₂(XylBIPHEP)/(S,S)-DPEN to (S)-RuCl₂(XylBIPHEP)/(S,S)-DPEN was very slow at room temperature in CD₂Cl₂, but accelerated in 2-propanol to give a 3:1 ratio of diastereomeric complexes within 2-3 hours (see ref. [28] ).

<A NAME="RA30302ST-45A">45a</A> Bott G. Field LD. Sternhell S. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1980,  102:  5618 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-45B">45b</A> Rousel C. Liden A. Chanon M. Metzger J. Sandstrom J. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1976,  98:  2847 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-45C">45c</A> Nilsson B. Martinson P. Olsson K. Carter RE. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1974,  96:  3190 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-46A">46a</A> Morokuma K. Acc. Chem. Res.  1977,  10:  294 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-46B">46b</A> Kitaura K. Morokuma K. Int. J. Quantum Chem.  1976,  10:  325 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-47">47</A> Reed AE. Curtiss LA. Weinhold F. Chem. Rev.  1988,  88:  899 

Tropos catalysts with biphenyl chirality, see:

<A NAME="RA30302ST-48A">48a</A> Ringwald M. Sturmer R. Brintzinger HH. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1999,  121:  1524 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-48B">48b</A> Chen W. Xiao J. Tetrahedron Lett.  2001,  42:  8737 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-48C">48c</A> Becker JJ. White PS. Gagne MR. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  2001,  123:  9478 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-48D">48d</A> Hashihara T. Ito Y. Katsuki T. Synlett  1996,  1079 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-48E">48e</A> Hashihara T. Ito Y. Katsuki T. Tetrahedron  1997,  53:  9541 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-48F">48f</A> Miura K. Katsuki T. Synlett  1999,  783 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-48G">48g</A> Pritchett S. Walsh PJ. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  1998,  120:  6423 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-48H">48h</A> Balsells J. Walsch PJ. J. Am. Chem. Soc.  2000,  122:  1802 

<A NAME="RA30302ST-48I">48i</A> Balsells J. Betancort JM. Walsch PJ. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed.  2000,  39:  3428