Genome Size and Pollen Viability as Taxonomic Criteria: Application to the Genus Hosta

Abstract

Genome size (C values) and pollen viability staining were applied as new criteria to investigate the taxonomy of the genus Hosta Tratt. (Hostaceae). Nearly all species of the genus Hosta have the same basic chromosome number (2n = 2x = 60). However, the nuclear DNA contents, as measured by flow cytometry with propidium iodide, could be demonstrated to range between 17.2 to 26.6 pg. This implies that the largest genome contains roughly 10¹⁰ more base pairs than the smallest. Therefore, nuclear DNA content is a very relevant taxonomic trait that can be measured simply by flow cytometry. In addition, differences in overall DNA composition were demonstrated by comparing to DAPI fluorescence. In general, genome size data confirmed the division into three subgenera. The geographical distribution of genome sizes indicates the migration pattern of Hosta throughout East Asia. The species belonging to the mainly Korean subgenus Bryocles, with a low nuclear DNA content (17.2 - 19.3 pg), can now largely be distinguished from the mainly Japanese species of the subgenus Giboshi (21.3 - 26.5 pg). The exception is H. longissima, that with only 19.6 pg provides a nice example of a decrease in DNA content. On the mainland, as well as on Honshu, species with increased and decreased DNA content have evolved independently. The usefulness of pollen viability to detect hybrids in Hosta was demonstrated in a large series of artificial crosses between bona fide species. Consequently, pollen viability was measured in all available Hosta described as species. Several had low pollen viability and were concluded to be hybrids. Morphology and DNA content confirmed this in most cases. The resulting 23 species approximate the number of Hosta species that follows from the combined studies by Fujita (1976[18]) on the Japanese species and Chung (1991 a[11]) on the Korean species.

Key words

Hosta - DNA content - flow cytometry - pollen viability staining

References

• 01 Araki,  Y.. (1942);  The new Hostas of Japan.  Acta Phytotaxonomica Geobotanica (Reprinted in: The American Hosta Society Bulletin [1970] 2, 45 - 51). 11 322-328
• 02 Bailey,  L. H.. (1930);  Hosta, the plantain lilies.  Gentes Herbarum. 2 - 3 117-142
• 03 Bennett,  M. D.. (1972);  Nuclear DNA content and minimum generation time in herbaceous plants.  Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. 181 109-135
• 04 Bennett,  M. D., and Leitch,  I. J.. (1995);  Nuclear DNA amounts in Angiosperms.  Annals of Botany. 76 113-176
• 05 Bennett,  M. D., and Leitch,  I. J.. (1997);  Nuclear DNA amounts in Angiosperms - 583 new estimates.  Annals of Botany. 80 169-196
• 06 Bennetzen,  J. L., and Kellog,  E. A.. (1997);  Do plants have a one way ticket to genomic obesity?.  The Plant Cell. 9 1509-1514
• 07 Bharathan,  G.,, Lambert,  G.,, and Galbraith,  D. W.. (1994);  Nuclear DNA content of monocotyledons and related taxa.  American Journal of Botany. 81 381-386
• 08 Bogler,  D. J., and Simpson,  B. B.. (1996);  Phylogeny of Agavaceae based on its rDNA sequence variation.  American Journal of Botany. 83 1225-1235
• 09 Buitendijk,  J. H.,, Boon,  E. J.,, and Ramanna,  M. S.. (1997);  Nuclear DNA content in twelve species of Alstroemeria L. and some of their hybrids.  Annals of Botany. 79 343-353
• 10 Cavallini,  A.,, Natali,  L.,, Ciononi,  G.,, and Castorena-Sanchez,  I.. (1996);  Cytophotometric and biochemical analyses of DNA in pentaploid and diploid Agave species.  Genome. 36 266-271
• 11 Chung,  M. G.. (1991 a);  Note on the phylogenetic relationships among species of the Korean Hosta based on DNA restriction sites.  Plant Species Biology. 6 71-74
• 12 Chung,  M. G.,, Hamrick,  J. L.,, Jones,  S. B.,, and Derda,  G. S.. (1991 b);  Isozyme variation within and among populations of Hosta (Liliaceae) in Korea.  Systematic Botany. 16 667-684
• 13 Chung,  M. G., and Jones,  S. B.. (1989);  Pollen morphology of Hosta Tratt. and related genera.  Bulletin of the Torrey Botanical Club. 116 31-44
• 14 Chung,  M. G.,, Jones,  S. B.,, Hamrick,  J. L.,, and Chung,  H. G.. (1991 c);  Morphometric and Isozyme analysis of the genus Hosta in Korea.  Plant Species Biology. 6 55-69
• 15 Chung,  M. G., and Kim,  J. W.. (1991 d);  The genus Hosta Tratt. (Liliaceae) in Korea.  Sida. 14 411-420
• 16 de Laat,  A. N. M.,, Göhde,  W.,, and Vogelzang,  M. J. D.. (1987);  Determination of ploidy of single plants and plant populations by flow cytometry.  Plant Breeding. 99 303-307
• 17 Dolezel,  J.,, Greilhuber,  J.,, Lucretti,  S.,, Meister,  A.,, Lysak,  M. A.,, Nardi,  L.,, and Obermayer,  R.. (1998);  Plant genome size estimation by flow cytometry: inter-laboratory comparison.  Annals of Botany. 82 (Suppl. A) 17-26
• 18 Fujita,  N.. (1976);  The genus Hosta in Japan.  Acta Phytotaxonomica Geobotanica (Translated in: The American Hosta Society Bulletin [1979] 10, 14 - 43). 28 3-4 66-96
• 19 Greilhuber,  J.. (1998);  Intraspecific variation in genome size: a critical reassessment.  Annals of Botany. 82 27-35
• 20 Grime,  J. P., and Mowforth,  M. A.. (1982);  Variation in genome size - an ecological interpretation.  Nature. 299 151-153
• 21 Hensen,  K. J. W.. (1985);  A study of the taxonomy of cultivated Hostas. .  The Plantsman. 7 1-36
• 22 Hylander,  N.. (1954);  The genus Hosta in Swedish gardens.  Acta Horti Bergiani. 16 332-416
• 23 Johnston,  J. S.,, Bennett,  M. D.,, Rayburn,  A. L.,, Galbraith,  D. W.,, and Price,  H. J.. (1999);  Reference standards for determination of DNA content of plant nuclei.  American Journal of Botany. 86 (5) 609-613
• 24 Kaneko,  K.. (1968);  Cytological studies on some species of Hosta. III. Karyotypes of H. clausa, H. clausa var. normalis and H. ventricosa. .  Botanical Magazine (Tokyo). 81 396-403
• 25 Kaneko,  K.. (1970);  Cytological studies on some species of Hosta. VI. Karyotypes of H. undulata, H. tardiva and H. sacra. .  Botanical Magazine (Tokyo). 83 27-35
• 26 Leitch,  I. J.,, Chase,  M. W.,, and Bennett,  M. D.. (1998);  Phylogenetic analysis of DNA C-values provides evidence for a small ancestral genome size in flowering plants.  Annals of Botany. 82 (Suppl. A) 85-94
• 27 Maekawa,  F.. (1940);  The genus Hosta. Journal of the Faculty of Science. Imperial University Tokyo, Section 3 (Reprinted in: The American Hosta Society Bulletin [1972] 4, 12 - 64 and [1973] 5, 12 - 59).  Botany. 5 317-425
• 28 Maekawa,  F.. (1969) Hosta Trattinnick, Vol. 3. The encyclopedia of Horticulture. Tokyo; Seibundoshinkosha pp. 1104-1109
• 29 Mathew,  B.. (1988);  Hostaceae a new name for the invalid Funkiaceae. .  Kew Bulletin. 43 (2) 302
• 30 Ohri,  D.. (1998);  Genome size variation and plant systematics.  Annals of Botany. 82 (Suppl. A) 750-812
• 31 Sanmiguel,  P., and Bennetzen,  J.. (1998);  Evidence that a recent increase in maize genome size was caused by the massive amplification of intergene retrotransposons.  Annals of Botany. 82 (Suppl. A) 37-44
• 32 Schmid,  G. H.. (1991) The genus Hosta. . Portland, Oregon; Timber Press
• 33 Stearn,  W. T.. (1951) Hosta rectifolia. . Curtis's Botanical Magazine, NS 168, tab. 138
• 34 Sugita,  H.. (1994);  Wild Hostas and little known H. alismifolia in Aichi prefecture and the surrounding areas.  The American Hosta Society Bulletin. 25 (2) 50-59
• 35 Tiersch,  T. R.,, Chandler,  R. W.,, Wachtel,  S. S. M.,, and Ellias,  S.. (1989);  Reference standards for flow cytometry and application in comparative studies of nuclear DNA content.  Cytometry. 10 706-710
• 36 Wang,  D. Q.. (1989);  A new species of Hosta from Anhui.  Guihaia. 9 (4) 297-298
• 37 Zilis,  M. R.. (2000) The Hosta handbook. Rochelle, Il., USA; Published by Q & Z Inc.
• 38 Zonneveld,  B. J. M.. (1997);  Cultivar and Cultivar-group definitions applied to Hosta. .  The American Hosta Society Bulletin. 28 (1) 37-41
• 39 Zonneveld,  B. J. M.. (1998 a);  Hosta “Crispula” is not an “Undulata”.  British Hosta and Hemerocallis Bulletin. 4-4 64-65
• 40 Zonneveld,  B. J. M.. (1998 b) Hosta sports from species and cultivars. Published by the author pp. 1-53
• 41 Zonneveld,  B. J. M., and Chamberlain,  S.. (1999 a);  How often do flowers form seedpods in Hosta species and cultivars?.  The American Hosta Society Bulletin. 30 (1) 43-51
• 42 Zonneveld,  B. J. M.. (1999 b);  The DNA content of Hosta “Francee” , “Minuteman”, and two different varieties called “Patriot”.  The American Hosta Society Bulletin. 30 (2) 28-29
• 43 Zonneveld,  B. J. M., and Van Iren,  F.. (2000);  Flow cytometric measurement of DNA content in Hosta reveals ploidy chimeras.  Euphytica. 111 105-110

Section Editor: M. Hasebe