The silica hypothesis for homeopathy: physical chemistry
Received22 February 2007
accepted27 July 2007
13 December 2017 (online)
The ‘silica hypothesis’ is one of several frameworks that have been put forward to explain how homeopathic remedies, which often are diluted beyond the point where any of the original substance remains, might still be clinically effective. We describe here what the silica hypothesis says. From a physical chemistry viewpoint, we explore three challenges that the hypothesis would have to meet in order to explain homeopathy: thermodynamic stability of a large number of distinct structures, pattern initiation at low potencies, and pattern maintenance or gradual evolution at higher potencies. We juxtapose current knowledge about silicates with some of the conventional wisdom about homeopathic remedies, to see how well the latter might be a consequence of the former. We explore variants of the hypothesis including some speculations about mechanisms. We outline laboratory experiments that could help to decide it.
- 1 Milgrom L.R., King K.R., Lee J., Pinkus A.S. On the investigation of homeopathic potencies using low resolution NMR T2 relaxation times: an experimental and critical survey of the work of Roland Conte et al . Br Hom J 2001; 90 (01) 5-13.
- 2 Demangeat J.-L., Gries P., Poitevin B. et al. Low-field NMR water proton longitudinal relaxation in ultrahighly diluted aqueous solutions of silica-lactose prepared in glass material for pharmaceutical use. Appl Magn Reson 2004; 26: 465-481.
- 3 Walach H., Jonas W.B., Ives J. et al. Research on homeopathy: state of the art. J. Altern. Compl. Med. 2005; 11 (05) 813-829.
- 4 Witt C.M., Ludtke R., Weisshuhn T.E. et al. The role of trace elements in homeopathic preparations and the influence of container material, storage duration, and potentisation. Forsch Komplementarmed 2006; 13: 15-21.
- 5 Roy R., Tiller W.A., Bell I., Hoover M.R. The structure of liquid water; novel insights from materials research; potential relevance to homeopathy. Mat Res Innovat, 2005; 9–4: 93-124.
- 6 Alexander G.B., Heston W.M., Iler R.K. The solubility of amorphous silica in water. J Phys Chem 1954; 58: 453.
- 7 Iler RK, ed., The Chemistry of Silica, ch. 1 & 2 (pp. 3–171), Wiley, New York (1979).
- 8 Harris R.K., Knight C.T.G., Hull W.E. Nature of species present in an aqueous solution of potassium silicate. J Amer Chem Soc 1981; 103: 1577-1578.
- 9 Source: http://www.iza-structure.org/databases/
- 10 Busey R.H., Mesmer R.E. Ionization equilibria of silicic acid and polysilicate formation in aqueous sodium chloride solutions to 300 °C. Inorg Chem 1977; 16 (10) 2444.
- 11 Manning CE. Polymeric silicate complexing in aqueous fluids at high pressure and temperature. In: Wanty RB, (ed.). Water–Rock Interaction I, Taylor & Francis, 2004; pp. 45–52.
- 12 Zotov N., Keppler H. Silica speciation in aqueous fluids at high pressures and high temperatures. Chem Geol 2002; 184: 71-82.
- 13 Hendricks W.M., Bell A.T., Radke C.J. Effects of organic and alkali metal cations on the distribution of silicate anions in aqueous solutions. J Phys Chem 1991; 95: 9513-9518.
- 14 Kinradet S.D., Swaddle T.W. Silicon-29 NMR studies of aqueous silicate solutions. 1. Chemical shifts and equilibria. Inorg Chem 1988; 27: 4253-4259.
- 15 Xue X., Stebbins J.F., Kanzaki M., McMillan P.F., Poe B. Pressure-induced silicon coordination and tetrahedral structural changes in alkali oxide-silica melts up to 12 GPa: NMR, Raman, and infrared spectroscopy. Amer Mineral 1991; 76: 8-26.
- 16 Ennis R.D., Pritchard R., Nakamura C. et al. Glass vials for small volume parenterals: influence of drug and manufacturing processes on glass delamination. Pharm Dev Technol 2001; 6 (03) 393-405.
- 17 Jal P.K., Sudarshan M., Saha A. et al. Synthesis and characterization of nanosilica prepared by precipitation method. Colloids Surf A: Physicochem Eng Aspects 2004; 240: 173-178.
- 18 Corma A., Davis M.E. Issues in the synthesis of crystalline molecular sieves: towards the crystallization of low framework-density structures. Chemphyschem 2004; 5 (03) 305-313.
- 19 Kinradet S.D., Pole D.L. Effect of alkali-metal cations on the chemistry of aqueous silicate solutions. Inorg Chem 1992; 31: 4558-4563.
- 20 Tossell JA, Calculation of 19F and 29Si NMR shifts and stabilities of F− encapsulating silsesquioxanes, preprint.
- 21 Mortlock R.F., Bell A.T., Radke C.J. Incorporation of aluminum into silicate anions in aqueous and methanoic solutions of TMA silicates. J Phys Chem 1991; 95: 7847-7851.
- 22 Burkett S.L., Davis M.E. Mechanism of structure direction in the synthesis of Si-ZSM-5: an investigation by intermolecular 1H-29Si CP MAS NMR. J Phys Chem B 1994; 98: 4647.
- 23 Burkett SL, Davis ME, Mechanisms of structure direction in the synthesis of pure-silica zeolites. 1. Synthesis of TPNSJ-ZSM-5, 2. hydrophobic hydration and structural specificity. Chem Mater 1995; 7: 920-928, 1453-1463.
- 24 Houssin C.J.Y., Kirschhock C.E.A., Magusin P.C.M.M. et al. Combined in situ 29Si NMR and small-angle X-ray scattering study of precursors in MFI zeolite formation from silicic acid in TPAOH solutions. Phys Chem Chem Phys 2003; 5: 3518-3524.
- 25 Poulsen N., Sumper M., Kröger N. Biosilica formation in diatoms: characterization of native silaffin-2 and its role in silica morphogenesis. Proc Nat Acad Sci 2003; 100: 12075-12080.
- 26 Poulsen N., Kröger N. Silica morphogenesis by alternative processing of silaffins in the diatom thalassiosira pseudonana. J. Biol Chem 2004; 279 (41) 42993-42999.
- 27 Belton D.J., Patwardhan S.V., Perry C.C. Spermine, spermidine and their analogues generate tailored silicas. J Mater Chem 2005; 15: 4629-4638.
- 28 Belton D.J., Paine G., Patwardhan S.V., Perry C.C. Towards an understanding of (bio)silicification: the role of amino acids and lysine oligomers in silicification. J Mater Chem 2004; 14: 2231-2241.
- 29 Zeng H., Wilson L.D., Walker V.K., Ripmeester J.A. Effect of antifreeze proteins on the nucleation, growth, and the memory effect during tetrahydrofuran clathrate hydrate formation. J Am Chem Soc 2006; 128: 2844-2850.
- 30 Buchanan P., Soper A.K., Thompson J. et al. Search for memory effects in methane hydrate: Structure of water before hydrate formation and after hydrate decomposition. J Chem Phys 2005; 123: 164507.
- 31 Asay D.B., Kim S.H. Evolution of the adsorbed water layer structure on silicon oxide at room temperature. J Phys Chem B 2005; 109: 16760-16763.