Securing aesthetic outcomes for composite grafts to alar margin and columellar defects: A long term experience

ABSTRACT

Introduction: Composite grafts for nasal reconstruction have been around for over a century but the opinion on its virtues and failings keeps vacillating with a huge difference on the safe size of the graft for transfer. Alar margin and columellar defects are more distinct than dorsal nasal defects in greater difficulty in ensuring a good aesthetic outcome. We report our series of 19 consecutive patients in whom a composite graft was used to reconstruct a defect of alar margin (8 patients), alar base (7 patients) or columella (4 patients). Patients and Methods: Patient ages ranged from 3-35 years with 5 males and 14 females. The grafts to alar margin and base ranged 0.6-1 cm in width, while grafts to columella were 0.7-1.2 cm. The maximum dimension of the graft in this series was 0.9 mm × 10 mm. Composite grafts were sculpted to be two layered (skin + cartilage), three layered wedges (skin + cartilage + skin) or their combination (two layered in a portion and three layered in another portion). All grafts were cooled in postoperative period for three days by applying an indigenous ice pack of surgical glove. The follow up ranged from 3-9 months with an average of 4.5 months. Results: All of our 19 composite grafts survived completely but they all shrank by a small percentage of their bulk. Eleven patients rated the outcome between 90-95% improvement. We noticed that composite grafts tended to show varied pigmentation in our patients, akin to split skin grafts. Conclusion: In our opinion, most critical to graft survival is its size and the ratio of the marginal raw area to the graft bulk. We recommend that graft width should not exceed 1 cm to ensure complete survival even though larger sized grafts have been reported to survive. We recommend cooling of the graft and justify it on the analogy of ‘warm ischemia time’ for a replantation, especially in warmer climes like ours in India. We have outlined several considerations in the technique, with an analysis of differing opinions that should facilitate a surgeon in making an informed choice.

KEY WORDS

Alar defect - columellar defect - composite grafts - nose defects

• REFERENCES

• 1 Konig F. ZurDeckung von Defekten der Nasenfugel. Klin Wochenschr 1902; 7: 137-8 Quoted by Symonds FC, Crikelair GF. Auricular composite grafts in nasal reconstruction: A report of 36 cases. Plast Reconstr Surg 1966;37:433-7.
• 2 Joseph J. Nasenplastik. Leipzig: Curt Kabitzsch; 1931. p. 383. Quoted by McLaughlin CR. Composite ear grafts and their blood supply. Br J Plast Surg 1954 7. 274-8
• 3 Limberg AA. Rhinoplasty using free transplant from concha. Sov Khir 1935; 9: 70 Quoted by Symonds FC, Crikelair GF. Auricular composite grafts in nasal reconstruction: A report of 36 cases. Plast Reconstr Surg 1966;37:433-7.
• 4 Brown JB, Cannon B. Composite free grafts of two surfaces of skin and cartilage from the Ear. Ann Surg 1946; 124: 1101-7
• 5 Brown JB, Cannon B. Further reports on the use of composite free grafts of skin and cartilage from the ear. Plast Reconstr Surg (1946) 1946; 1: 130-4
• 6 Szlazak J. Repair of nasal defects with free auricular grafts; report of four cases. Br J Plast Surg 1948; 1: 176-80
• 7 Converse JM. Reconstruction of the naso-labial area by composite graft from the concha. Plast Reconstr Surg 1950; 5: 247-51
• 8 Farina R. Loss of substance from the nasal alae and tip: Repairing with free chondro-cutaneous graft from the auricular pavilion. Plast Reconstruct Surg 1952; 9: 52-4
• 9 McLaughlin CR. Composite ear grafts and their blood supply. Br J Plast Surg 1954; 7: 274-8
• 10 Meade RJ. Composite ear grafts for construction of columella; composite ear grafts for the correction of nasal deformities associated with cleft lip and other congenital and post-traumatic deficiencies of the columella. Plast Reconstr Surg Transplant Bull 1959; 23: 134-47
• 11 Conley JJ, Vonfraenkel PH. The principle of cooling as applied to the composite graft in the nose. Plast Reconstr Surg (1946) 1956; 17: 444-51
• 12 Argamaso RV. An ideal donor site for the auricular composite graft. Br J Plast Surg 1975; 28: 219-21
• 13 Peach AH, Stretch JR. Improved selection and management of the auricular composite graft donor site. Br J Plast Surg 2004; 57: 797-9
• 14 Singh DJ, Bartlett SP. Aesthetic management of the ear as a donor site. Plast Reconstr Surg 2007; 120: 899-908
• 15 Haug MD, Rieger UM, Witt P, Gubisch W. Managing the ear as a donor site for composite graft in nasal reconstruction: Update on technical refinements and donor site morbidity in 110 cases. Ann Plast Surg 2009; 63: 171-5
• 16 Parkhouse N, Evans D. Reconstruction of the ala of the nose using a composite free flap from the pinna. Br J Plast Surg 1985; 38: 306-13
• 17 Lehman Jr JA, Garrett Jr WS, Musgrave RH. Earlobe composite grafts for the correction of nasal defects. Plast Reconstr Surg 1971; 47: 12-6
• 18 Haas AF, Glogau RG. A variation of composite grafting for reconstruction of full-thickness nasal alar defects. Arch Dermatol 1994; 130: 978-80
• 19 Burget GC. Aesthetic reconstruction of the nose. In: Mathes SJ. editor Plastic Surgery. The Head and Neck. 2 nd ed. Vol. 2. Philadelphia: Elsevier; 2006: p. 573-648
• 20 Son D, Kwak M, Yun S, Yeo H, Kim J, Han K. Large auricular chondrocutaneous composite graft for nasal alar and columellar reconstruction. Arch Plast Surg 2012; 39: 323-8
• 21 Pilanci Ö, Saçak B, Kuvat SV, Sen E, Arslan H, Aygit AC. Use of outsized composite chondrocutaneous grafts in conjunction with dermal turnover flaps for reconstruction of full-thickness alar defects. J Craniofac Surg 2011; 22: 864-7
• 22 Cheon YW, Park BY. Long-term evaluation of elongating columella using conchal composite graft in bilateral secondary cleft lip and nose deformity. Plast Reconstr Surg 2010; 126: 543-53
• 23 Ruch MK. Utilization of composite free grafts. J Int Coll Surg 1958; 30: 274-5
• 24 Zilinsky I, Farber N, Haik J, Weissman O, Israeli H, Winkler E. Nasal ala reconstruction with a crus helix composite graft: A stepladder approach. J Drugs Dermatol 2012; 11: 376-81
• 25 Symonds FC, Crikelair GF. Auricular composite grafts in nasal reconstruction: A report of 36 cases. Plast Reconstr Surg 1966; 37: 433-7