Foundations for an Electronic Medical Record

Abstract

Given the many efforts currently under way to develop standards for electronic medical records, it is important to step back and reexamine the fundamental principles which should underlie a model of the electronic medical record. This paper presents an analysis based on the experience in developing the PEN & PAD prototype clinical workstation. The fundamental contention is that the requirements for a medical record must be grounded in its use for patient care. The basic requirement is that it be a faithful record of what clinicians have heard, seen, thought, and done. The other requirements for a medical record, e.g., that it be attributable and permanent, follow naturally from this view. We use the criteria developed to re-examine Weed’s Problem Oriented Medical Record and also relate the criteria to secondary uses of the medical record for population data, communications and decision support.

Key-Words

Medical Record - Information Models - Standards - Problem-Oriented Medical Record

• REFERENCES

• 1 Howkins TJ, Kay S, Rector AL, Goble CA, Horan B, Nowlan WA, Wilson A. An overview of the PEN & PAD project. In: O’Moore R, Bengtsson S, Bryant JR, Bryden JS. eds. MIE 90, Lecture Notes in Medical Informatics no. 40. Berlin: Sprin-ger-Verlag; 1990: 73-8.
• 2 Horan B, Rector AL, Sneath EL, Goble CA, Howkins TJ, Kay S, Nowlan WA, Wilson A. Supporting a humanly impossible task: the clinical human-computer environment. In: Diaper D. ed. Proceedings of Interact 90. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Publ; 1990: 247-52.
• 3 Rector AL, Goble CA, Horan B, Howkins TJ, Kay S, Nowlan WA, Wilson A. Shedding light on patient’s problems: integrating knowledge-based systems into medical practice. In: Aiello L. ed. Proceedings of the Ninth European Conference on Artificial Intelligence, ECAI 90. Pitman Publ. 1990: 531-4.
• 4 Kay S. SKRAM: Semantics & Knowledge Representation of the Medical Record. Subcommittee of IEEE P1157 (MEDIX). 1989
• 5 National Academy of Sciences. Institute of Medicine. Medical Record Project (Proposal March 21st 1988). Final Report (to appear).
• 6 European Workshop for Open Systems (EWOS PT007 Medical Informatics). Study and Investigation of Problems Related to Standardisation and the Relevance of Open Systems Standards in Medical Informatics. Final report (Second Draft v3.12).
• 7 Commission of the European Communities, Directorate General Telecommunications, Information Industries and Innovation. Operation 1992: Investigation of Requirements and Options in the Field of Advanced Informatics in Medicine: Consolidation of Results (Ref XIII/F/GE0392). Brussels: EEC DG XIII; 1990
• 8 Engelbrecht R, Fitter M, Newton P, Rector AL, Robinson D, Sneath L. PRECISE: Prospects for an Extra Mural and Clinical Information System Environment (AIM Project A1043, Subproject CRS: Requirements for Consulting Room Systems). Report on User Workshop. 1990
• 9 SESAME. Standardization in Europe on Semantical Aspects of Medicine (AIM Project A1031, Deliverable 9, Structure for Classifications on Primary Health Care). 1990
• 10 Harrison J, Kain B, Harvey F. Framework Model: Level 2 AIM Eurodiabeta Project (Deliverable 2, Eurodiabeta). London: Department of Chemical Pathology, St. Thomas’s Hospital; 1990
• 11 Read JD. Computerising medical language. In: De Glanville H, Roberts J. eds. Current Perspectives in Health Computing HC90. Brit J Healthcare Computing. 1990: 203-8.
• 12 Evans DA, Miller RA. Unified Medical Language System (UMLS) Project. Initial phase in developing representations for mapping medical knowledge: INTER-NEST- I/QMR, HELP and MeSH (Technical Report No. CMU-LCL-87-1). Pittsburgh, PA: Laboratory for Computational Linguistics, Carnegie Mellon University; 1987
• 13 Rector AL, Nowlan WA, Kay S. Unifying medical information using an architecture based on descriptions. In: Miller RA. ed. Proceedings of the Symposium on Computer Applications in Medical Care, SCAMC 90. Washington, 1990: 190-4.
• 14 Rector AL, Kay S. Descriptive models for medical records and data interchange. In: Barber B, Cao D, Qin D, Wagner G. eds. MEDINFO 89. Amsterdam: North-Holland Publ Comp; 1989: 230-4.
• 15 Clancey W. The epistemology of a rule-based expert system: a framework for explanation. Artif Intell 1983; 20: 215-51.
• 16 Steels L. Second generation expert systems. In: Bramer MA. ed. Research and Development in Expert Systems III. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1986: 175-83.
• 17 Barber B, Jensen OA, Lamberts H, Roger-France R, De Schouwer P, Zollner H. The six safety first principles of health information systems: A programme of implementation, Part 1: Safety and Security. In: O’Moore R, Bengtsson S, Bryant JR, Bryden JS. eds. MIE 90. Lecture Notes in Medical Informatics no. 40. Berlin: Springer-Verlag; 1990: 608-13.
• 18 Barber B, Jensen OA, Lamberts H, Roger-France R, De Schouwer P, Zollner H. The six safety first principles of health information systems: A programme of implementation. Part 2: Convenience and Legal Issues. In: O’Moore R, Bengtsson S, Bryant JR, Bryden JS. eds. MIE 90. Lecture Notes in Medical Informatics no. 40. Berlin: Springer-Verlag; 1990: 614-9.
• 19 Gale J, Marsden P. Diagnosis: Process not Product. In: Sheldon MG, Brooke JB, Rector AL. eds. Decision Making in General Practice. London: MacMillan Press Ltd; 1985: 59-61.
• 20 Patel VL, Groen GJ. Knowledge-based solution strategies in medical reasoning. Cognitive Science 1986; 10: 91-116.
• 21 Weed LL. The Problem-Oriented Record as a basic tool in medical education, patient care and clinical research. Ann Clin Res 1971; 03: 131-4.
• 22 Fries JF. Time-oriented patient records and a computer data bank. Amer Med Ass 1972; 222: 1536-42.
• 23 Van der Lei J, Westerman RF, Mosseveld BMTh. Critiquing based on automated medical records: An evaluation of HYPER-CRITIC. In: O’Moore R, Bengtsson S, Bryant JR, Bryden JS. eds. MIE 90. Lecture Notes in Medical Informatics no. 40. Berlin: Springer-Verlag; 1990: 369-74.
• 24 Gordon C, Fox J, Glowinski A, O’Neill M. The design of the Oxford System of Medicine: An overview. In: O’Moore R, Bengtsson S, Bryant JR, Bryden JS. eds. MIE 90. Lecture Notes in Medical Informa-tics no. 40. Berlin: Springer-Verlag; 1990: 225-70.
• 25 O’Neill M, Glowinski A, Fox J. A symbolic theory of decision-making applied to several medical tasks. In: Hunter J, Cookson J, Wyatt J. eds. AIME 89. Lecture Notes in Medical Informatics No. 38. Berlin: Sprin-ger-Verlag; 1989: 62-71.
• 26 Miller RA, Masarie FE. Quick Medical Reference (QMR): A microcomputer-based diagnostic decision-support system for general internal medicine. In: Miller RA. ed. Washington DC: IEEE Computer Society Press; 1990: 986-8.
• 27 Gell G. AURA: Experience and future. In: Scherrer JR, Cote RA, Mandil SH. eds. Computerized Natural Medical Language Processing for Knowledge Representation. Proceedings of the IFIP-IMIA WG6 International Working Conference on Computerized Natural Medical Language Processing for Knowledge Representation. Amsterdam: North-Holland Publ Comp; 1988: 253-61.
• 28 Scherrer J-R, Baud RH, Hochstrasser D. Osman R. An integrated hospital informa tion system in general. MD Computing 1990; 07: 81-9.
• 29 Nowlan WA, Rector AL. Predictive data entry: A new paradigm for medical knowledge representation. In: Proceedings of AIME-91. Berlin: Springer-Verlag; (in press).
• 30 Nowlan WA, Rector AL, Kay S, Horan B, Wilson A. A patient care workstation based on user-centred design and a formal theory of medical terminology: PEN & PAD and the SMK formalism (submitted to SCAMC 91).