Comparative efficacy of homeopathic and allopathic systems of medicine in the management of clinical mastitis of Indian dairy cows

Abstract

Mastitis is the major problem of dairy animals despite a number of preventive and therapeutic approaches. Treatment is costly and out of reach of farmers of developing countries like India. The treatment cost of bovine mastitis with conventional treatment has been calculated. Good results have been claimed with homeopathic treatment however, treatment costs are not available. This article reports the treatment economics of homeopathic drugs conventional drugs for the management of bovine mastitis.

Ninety-six mastitic quarters (non-fibrosed 67 and fibrosed 29) were treated with a homeopathic combination medicine. Another 96 quarters with acute mastitis (non-fibrosed) treated with different antibiotics were included in the study. The animals were selected from dairy farm of the Indian Veterinary Research Institute and from private dairy farms. The overall effectiveness of homeopathic combination medicine in the treatment of acute non-fibrosed mastitis was 86.6% with a mean recovery period of 7.7 days (range 3–28), and total cost of therapy as Indian Rupees 21.4 (€0.39, US$0.47). The corresponding cure rate for the antibiotic group was 59.2% with a mean recovery period of 4.5 days (range 2–15) and an average treatment cost of Rs.149.20 (€2.69, US$3.28). We conclude that the combination of Phytolacca, Calcarea fluorica., Silica, Belladonna, Bryonia, Arnica, Conium and Ipecacuanha (Healwell VT-6) was effective and economical in the management of mastitis in lactating dairy cows.

Keywords

antibiotics - bovine - comparative efficacy - homeopathy - mastitis - treatment cost

• References

• 1 Dua K. Incidence, etiology and estimated economic losses due to mastitis in Punjab and India. An update. Indian dairyman 2001; 53: 41-48.
• 2 Hoeben D., Burvenich C., Heyneman R. Influence of antimicrobial agent on bactericidal activity of bovine milk polymorphonuclera leukocytes. Vet Immunol Immunopathol 1997; 56: 271-282.
• 3 Radostits O.M., Blood D.C., Gay C.C. Veterinary Medicine. London, UK: Bailliere Tindall; 1994
• 4 Day C. Veterinary homeopathy. principal and practices. Schoen A.M., Wyne S.G. Complementary and Alternative Veterinary Medicine. Principles and Practices. 1999. St. Luis: Mushy; 485-513
• 5 Merck C.C., Sonnenwald B., Rallwage H. Untersuchungen iiber oen Einsatz homoopathischer Arznciittel Zur Behandlung akutas mastitiden beim Rind. Berlin Muenchen tiermed Wascher 1989; 102: 266-272.
• 6 Searcy R., Reyes O., Guajardo G. Control of subclinical bovine mastitis. Utilization of a homeopathic combination. Br Hom J 1995; 84: 67-70.
• 7 Upadhyay A.K., Sharma S.P. Management of bovine mastitis by homeopathy. Indian Vet Med J 1999; 23: 71-72.
• 8 Varshney JP, Naresh R. Management of udder affections of Indian buffaloes (Bubalis bubalis) with a homeopathic combination remedy. Fourth Asian Buffalo Congress, New Delhi, February 25–28, 2003.
• 9 Day C, Day C. Healthy dairy herds through homeopathy. Rearing husbandry and treatment. Gesunde-Rinderbstande-durch-Homeopathie-Sufzucht, Haltung-und-Bchanlung, 2001, p. 175.
• 10 Hovi M, Roderick S, Alfoldei T. Proceedings of the 13th International IFOAM Scientific congress, Besel, Switzerland, August 28–31, 2000.
• 11 Kromker V., Hamann J. Non-antibiotic mastitis therapy—a critical evaluation. Praktische Tiererzt 1999; 80: 48-51.
• 12 Anderson R., Morcillo L.L., Sommes H. Treatment and prophylaxis of subclinical mastitis with homeopathic drugs. Tierarztliche Umscheau 1997; 52: 407-412.
• 13 Reilly D. Is homeopathy a placebo response? Controlled trial of homeopathic potency with pollen in hay fever as model. Lancet 1986; 2: 881-883.
• 14 Zell J. Behendlang von Akuten Spring-gsten Ksdiosotrionen; Doppelblind studie zum Wirks-ameitsnachwise lines. Hom Schenpraparats Frstschr Med 1988; 106: 96-98.
• 15 Naresh R, Varshney JP. Management of udder affections with homeopathic drugs. Xth International Congress of AAAP (Asian-Australasian Animal Production Societies), New Delhi, India, September 23–27, 2002.
• 16 Varshney, JP. Evaluation of a homeopathic combination remedy in the management of canine viral gastroenteritis simulating to parvo. National Symposium on Focusing on Need to Develop New Diagnostic Therapeutic and Preventive Approaches to Deal with Diseases of Farm and Companion Animals. Gujarat, India; Anand, February 7–9, 2003.
• 17 Kumar, H. Srivastava, SK, Yadav MC, Varshney JP. Management of post partum anestrus in dairy animals with a homeopathic combination remedy. National Symposium on Challenges and Strategies for Sustainable Animal Production in Mountains, Palampur (H.P.), India, April 14–15, 2003.
• 18 Naresh R, Varshney, JP. Management of nonspecific diarrhoea syndrome in calves with a homeopathic combination remedy. Indian J Vet Med 2003, accepted.
• 19 Boericke W. Pocket Manual of Homeopathic Materia Medica. Karolbagh Road, New Delhi, India: Indian Books and Periodicals Publishers; 2001