Key-words:
Cardiovascular - endocrine - literature - metabolism - nutrition - patients' perceptions
- physiology - pregnancy - professional - Ramadan - renal - research - sports medicine
Introduction
The impact on health and disease results from the direct biological effects of the
fasting itself and the associated social changes. Recently, health-care providers
have shown increased interest regarding possible health-related risks due to Ramadan
fasting (RF) practiced by adult Muslims. It includes that the individuals abstain
from eating and drinking from dawn to sunset.
The medical profession and religious scholars got closer to patients' advice based
on objective risk assessment in common conditions.[[1]] Although Muslim patients with acute or chronic medical conditions may be exempted
from fasting, many observe the fast, even against the physicians' advice. This may
adversely affect their health if not appropriately addressed by implementing evidence-based
recommendations.[[2]],[[3]]
Keeping up with developments in RF research may prove difficult, and hence, a narrative
overview under a single cover may help present a digest of the research and expert
opinion published in the year. The literature published in 2017–2019 has been reviewed
previously.[[4]],[[5]],[[6]] The present article aims to provide a thematic overview of the global research
work in 2020. For practical reasons, the narrations of the diabetes-related literature
of 2019 and 2020 were published separately.[[7]],[[8]] The present review aims allow researchers to catch up with the year's aims to allow
researchers directions and highlight the evidence base that may direct practice for
clinicians.
Materials and Methods
This is a narrative, nonsystematic review of the literature retrieved from two online
databases over a full calendar year (2020). The search term “Ramadan fasting” was
used to identify the relevant records from PubMed. Due to the extensive number, articles
on diabetes were submitted separately elsewhere and were excluded from the present
manuscript.[[6]] The selected articles were reviewed and narrated thematically to provide reasonably
concise but adequate representative reading material. Only full-text research articles
and systematic reviews-meta analyses in English were included.
Results
Physiology and nutrition
Five original studies and two systematic reviews addressed various physiological and
nutritional issues during Ramadan.[[9]],[[10]],[[11]],[[12]],[[13]],[[14]],[[15]] Zouhal et al.[[9]] studied the effects of RF on gut hormones in thirty sedentary males randomly allocated
to either an experimental or a control group. The experimental group completed their
RF rituals. There were significant pre-to-post improvements for leptin, GLP-1, peptide
YY, and cholecystokinin in the experimental group with no interaction effect for ghrelin.
No significant changes occurred in plasma volume variations after RF in either groups.
Based on these findings, the authors concluded that RF may be an effective strategy
to modify appetite-regulating hormones, leading to improved body composition (BC)
indices and reduced obesity. Nugraha et al.[[10]] determined the effect of RF on fatigue in young individuals. Sleepiness, mood-related
symptoms (MRS), and BC were determined as well. Thirty-four young males and females
were assessed before, during, and after Ramadan. This study illustrates how prolonged
fasting, like RF, benefits the youth, particularly by decreasing fatigue, improving
MRS, and positively impacting BC. Miladi et al.[[11]] compared the 6-min walk test (6MWT) data of a group of 22 healthy fasting boys
with an age-matched nonfasting group. The 6MWTs were performed during three experimental
conditions: pre-Ramadan (PR), mid-Ramadan, and post-Ramadan. The findings suggest
that, in boys, RF does not impact the 6MW distance, heart rate, or oxygen saturation
but has minimal impact on the blood pressure (BP). Akın et al.[[12]] estimated the physiological effects of RF on muscle function and muscle mass in
older people. A random sample was recruited from healthy older Muslim people aged
60 years and older who intended to fast for 30 days during Ramadan. Dietary data of
the patients during Ramadan were obtained by a 43-item Food Frequency Questionnaire.
The mean age of the older people was 66.7 years of age, and 50% were females. There
were no significant changes in body weight, muscle function, and muscle mass before
and after RF. They consumed adequate milk and yogurt before and after RF. Restriction
in meal timing has emerged as a promising dietary approach for managing obesity and
dysmetabolic diseases. Levels of cortisol, melatonin, ghrelin, and leptin are highly
correlated with circadian rhythmicity. The levels of these hormones are affected by
sleep, feeding, and general behaviors and fluctuate with light and dark cycles. Al-Rawi
et al.[[13]] examined the effect of RF on daytime levels of ghrelin, leptin, melatonin, and
cortisol in a group of overweight and obese subjects, to determine how anthropometric,
dietary, and lifestyle changes during Ramadan correlate with these hormonal changes.
Fifty-seven overweight and obese male and female subjects were enrolled. At the end
of Ramadan, serum levels of ghrelin, melatonin, and leptin significantly decreased,
while salivary cortisol did not change compared to the levels assessed in the prefasting
state. Thus, RF significantly altered serum levels of ghrelin, melatonin, and serum
leptin. Further, male sex and anthropometric variables were the most impacting factors
on the tested four hormones.
A systematic review and meta-analysis by Pellegrini et al.[[14]] summarized the evidence on the effect of time-restricted feeding (TRF) on weight-loss
and cardiometabolic variables compared to unrestricted-time regimens. Studies involving
TRF regimen were systematically searched up to January 2019. A total of 11 studies,
5 randomized controlled trials and 6 observational, were included. All studies had
a control group without time restriction; hours of fasting ranged from 12 h to 20
h and study duration from 4 to 8 weeks. Most studies involved RF. TRF determined a
greater weight loss than control regimens. The subgroup analysis showed an inverse
association between TRF and fat-free mass in observational studies. An overall significant
reduction in fasting glucose concentrations was observed with TRF regimens. No between-group
differences in the other variables were found. TRF regimens achieved a superior effect
in promoting weight loss and reducing fasting glucose compared to free time in meal
consumption. However, long-term and well-designed trials are needed to draw definitive
conclusions. In another systematic review and meta-analysis, Jahrami et al.[[15]] estimated the effect size of body weight changes in healthy, nonathletic practicing
RF, Several databases were searched and 85 studies conducted in 25 countries were
identified. Fasting may confer a significant slight reduction in body weight in nonathletic
healthy people aged 16 years and above, directly associated with fasting time and
variably correlated with the season and country.
Kidneys
Impact of Ramadan fasting on renal function in chronic kidney disease
There is no clear information about whether there is an obstacle to fasting in patients
with chronic kidney diseases (CKD). Baloglu et al.[[16]] investigated the effects of RF on the kidney and the factors affecting this relationship
in patients with CKD. They involved 117 patients (36 females, mean age 60 years) with
stage 2–3 CKD observing RF. Patients were evaluated for acute kidney injury (AKI)
during Ramadan. Of that cohort, 27 patients developed AKI. While patients without
AKI fasted for more days, urea levels, and frequency of hypertension were higher in
the group with AKI. They found a significant relationship between hypertension, the
number of fasting days, and AKI. Patients with chronic kidney damage and hypertension
should be evaluated more carefully, informed about the importance of hydration after
fasting, and should be followed frequently for AKI. Studies investigating the health
effects of prolonged intermittent fasting during Ramadan among patients on hemodialysis
(HD) are limited and report heterogeneous findings. Adanan et al.[[17]] evaluated the effects of RF patients' nutritional and functional status on maintenance
HD in a 12-week, multicenter, prospective observational study. Nutritional and functional
status assessments were carried out 2 weeks before, at the 4th week of Ramadan, and
4 weeks after Ramadan. Nutritional status parameters included anthropometry (body
mass index [BMI], interdialytic weight gain, and waist circumference), body composition
(mid-arm circumference, triceps skinfold, and body fat percentage), blood biochemistry
(albumin, renal profile, lipid profile, and inflammatory markers), BP, dietary intake,
and handgrip strength. A total of 87 patients completed the study, with 68 patients
(78.2%) reporting fasting for ≥20 days. RF led to significant reductions in BMI, interdialytic
weight gain, waist circumference, mid-arm circumference, fat tissue mass, and body
fat percentage, but these were not accompanied by any significant change in lean tissue
mass. Significant improvement was observed in serum phosphate levels, but serum albumin,
urea, and creatinine (Cr) were reduced significantly during Ramadan. There were no
significant changes in lipid profile and inflammatory markers. Interestingly, energy
and protein intake remained unchanged during Ramadan. Eldeeb et al.[[18]] evaluated the effect of RF on arterial stiffness parameters, augmentation index
(AIx), and pulse wave velocity (PWV) in hypertensive patients with and without CKD.
The cohort included 71 patients including 34 with CKD. All patients had hypertension,
and 25 patients had diabetes mellitus. In patients without CKD, brachial systolic
pressure (BSP). brachial diastolic pressure (BDP), central systolic pressure (CSP),
and central diastolic pressure (CDP) significantly decreased. In patients with CKD,
BSP and CSP significantly decreased, whereas BDP and CDP decreased, but the change
was not significant. AIx significantly decreased in patients without CKD but did not
significantly change in patients with CKD. PWV decreased in both groups, but the change
was not significant. Serum Cr significantly increased, but estimated glomerular filtration
rate (eGFR) did not significantly decrease in patients without CKD. Serum Cr significantly
decreased, and eGFR significantly increased in patients with CKD.
Clinical practice and patients' advocacy
Alsughayer et al.[[19]] explored nephrologists' concerns and recommendations when counseling patients with
advanced CKD on RF. An electronic survey was completed by 48 nephrologists practicing
in Saudi Arabia. Most respondents were senior nephrologists (75%), practicing for
over 10 years (68.8%). The majority of responding nephrologists (85.4%) were concerned
about eGFR, diabetes (68.8%), patient age (64.6%), use of diuretics (62.5%), body
fluid volume (60.4%), and BP (60.4%). This research in another study, El-Kannishy
et al.[[20]] investigated patients' and medical professionals' opinions toward fasting in four
HD centers in Egypt and the impact of physicians' attitude on patient behavior. Patients
and physicians were interviewed and asked about their opinion toward fasting in HD
patients and any experienced complications during fasting. Eighty-one (50.3%) of the
studied HD patients practiced fasting in Ramadan. No significant difference was observed
between fasting and nonfasting groups regarding age, sex, and HD duration. Eighty
percent of patients reported no complications. Fifteen (65.2%) physicians support
the opinion that HD patients are capable of fasting with precautions. There was a
significant variation in fasting frequency among HD patients in the studied centers,
with a significantly low fasting frequency observed in one center (10.5%). Most physicians
from this center adopted that HD patients should not fast. HD patients were keen to
practice fasting in Ramadan and were to a considerable extent capable of doing so.
Also, the patient's decision seems to be affected by the physician's opinion. Arabi
et al.[[21]] studied what nephrologists would advise transplant recipients on lifestyles and
religious duties. Fifty-eight nephrologists responded, of whom, 77% routinely follow-up
posttransplant patients; Fifty-four percent of the respondents would let patients
with stable graft function fast during Ramadan, whereas 20% would not recommend fasting
at any time following transplantation. This response did not change much if the patient
had diabetes, although in these patients, not recommending fasting at any time increased
to 32%. For kidney donors, fasting would be allowed by 58% of the respondents once
the kidney function stabilizes. Finally, The same group[[22]] presented evidence-based education materials for medical providers (in the English
language) and patients and donors (in the Arabic language). These educational materials
were prepared to be easy to print or adopt by patients, providers, and centers.
Renal stone formation
There is a concern that RF may be a risk factor for the development of renal stones.
Two systematic reviews addressed the question of the association of RF with renal
stone formation. Amjadi et al.[[23]] evaluated the available comparative information through a systematic review. They
included all studies comparing fasting and nonfasting conditions, studies evaluating
stone formation, and clinical manifestations of kidney stone disease. All the English
studies published from January 1980 to the end of 2019 were included. They excluded
studies that had fasting out of Ramadan, noncomparative studies, animal studies, patients
with bladder stones, and studies evaluating conditions that are only indirectly related
to the stone formation or clinical manifestations. Only five studies remained after
exclusion. Meta-analysis was not applicable due to the diversity in methods and evaluated
population. Kirubarajan et al.[[24]] conducted a systematic review. Ten observational studies with a total of 9906 participants
were included. Nine of the studies were conducted in the context of Islamic fasting
during Ramadan, with the majority (7/9) finding that renal colic incidence was unaffected
by the month of fasting. In contrast, two studies noted an increased incidence among
fasting populations. Two other studies noted that urine metabolites and density were
altered with fasting but did not translate into clinical outcomes. The primary trend
of the included studies is toward showing no difference between fasting and nonfasting
conditions in terms of renal stone formation.
Cardiovascular Disease
Cardiac function and risk factors
Hammoud et al.[[25]] evaluated the effect of RF on the heart rate variation (HRV), an indirect measure
of cardiac sympathetic stress in 80 healthy Lebanese females. They were monitored
for 24 h when following a normal routine; 38 and 42 females were enrolled before and
during Ramadan, respectively. The results reveal no effect of fasting on HRV; there
was an insignificant change in HRV between the first and last weeks of Ramadan. Morning
fasting was significantly the least stressful period, with lower HR compared with
nonfasting day. Therefore, RF does not alter the autonomic nervous activity of the
heart nor HRV levels. This may imply that RF is a risk-free practice, which does not
interfere with healthy individuals' cardiac autonomic nervous system function. Furthermore,
Aslan et al.[[26]] examined the effect of long RF on BP with ambulatory BP monitoring in hypertensive
patients using diuretics. In a prospective observational study involving 129 hypertensive
patients (73 in the diuretic group, and 56 in the nondiuretic group. Twenty-four-hour
ambulatory BP monitoring was performed during and after Ramadan. In the diuretic group,
24-h systolic BP (SBP) and diastolic BP (DBP) decreased significantly during Ramadan
by 8.9 and 4.1 units, respectively. On the other hand, SBP and DBP were lower but
insignificantly in the nondiuretic group. The reduction in SBP was significantly higher
in the diuretic group. Thiazide-like diuretics tended to lower BP more, thus suggesting
that RF might cause significant reductions in mean SBP and DBP measurements in patients
using diuretics. Despite decreasing BP, diuretics are generally well tolerated and
can be safe in well-controlled hypertensive patients during RF. Furthermore, Bener
et al.[[27]] investigated the effect of RF on BP, fatigue, sleeping, and physical activity among
hypertensive patients in a cross-sectional study conducted in 2019. Out of 1118 subjects,
47.6% were males. There were statistically significant differences for the biochemistry
parameters regarding Vitamin D, blood glucose, hemoglobin A1c level, Cr, bilirubin,
albumin, total cholesterol (TC), triglycerides (TG), high-density lipoprotein cholesterol
(HDL-C), low-density lipoprotein (LDL)-cholesterol, uric acid, and SBP for both males
and females after Ramadan compared to before Ramadan (BR). Furthermore, BMI was significantly
lower during and after the month of Ramadan as compared to BR. Fewer hours of sleeping,
SBP, DBP, family size, obesity BMI, fatigue, and smoking cigarettes were significant
predictors of hypertensive patients with RF contributing to higher risk. Khorshid
et al.[[28]] assessed the effect of RF on biochemical and exercise parameters among patients
undergoing a 12-week exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation (CR) program. Fifty-three
patients joining the CR program in a university hospital were included in the study.
There were 32 fasting patients and 21 nonfasting patients. All patients underwent
supervised exercise-based CR during the month of Ramadan. The two groups were similar
in baseline characteristics. After the program, both groups showed significant improvement
in ejection fraction, TC, LDL, and HDL levels. Furthermore, an improvement in exercise
duration reached and achieved metabolic equivalents before and after the CR program
in both groups. An important observation was that fasting did not significantly influence
plasma osmolality in either group. Therefore appears to be safe to undergo exercise-based
CR during Ramadan, even in the summer season. Farag et al.[[29]] assessed the effects of RF among a representative sample of hypertensive patients
(both sex, aged 25–50 years, on common antihypertensive drugs), during Ramadan of
2020. A total of 120 hypertensive patients were included in the study, with a mean
age of 37.5 years. There was a significant decrease in BP, body weight, BMI, and waist
circumference after RF. However, lipid profile changes were not statistically significant
except for TG which decreased after RF.
Acute coronary syndrome in Ramadan
Patients with acute coronary syndrome (ACS) may face several health issues during
Ramadan. Raffee et al.[[30]] investigated the influence of fasting during Ramadan on ACS occurrence. It was
a retrospective observational stufy of 226 patients aged between 20 and 80 years with
a principal diagnosis of ACS. The study's findings indicated that RF was not significantly
related to ACS occurrence since no difference was found in the incidence of hypertension,
diabetes, unstable angina, and coronary artery disease findings during and after Ramadan.
Similar findings were obtained for patients' final diagnosis, which had normal kidney
function tests, platelets, and ejection fraction. Furthermore, no significant difference
was found in patients' smoking status, hospital stay, and discharge rate.
Furthermore, Amin and Alaarag[[31]] assessed the safety of RF following Percutaneous Coronary Intervention (PCI) in
303 patients who had successful PCI before the 1st day of Ramadan. Although patients
were advised that recent PCI could be a valid excuse for not fulfilling RF, many patients
insisted on fasting, and they were included in the fasting group. The controls are
patients who decided not to fast. All the patients were followed up during and for
6 months after Ramadan. The fasting group (n = 153) showed a significant difference
in the incidence of Major Adverse Cardiac Events (MACE) compared to Group II with
a P (0.005). MACE's in Group I occurred mainly during RF, with 19 patients having
MACE's during Ramadan and four patients during the remainder of the follow-up period.
The Receiver Operating Characteristic curve analysis showed the decline of the incidence
of MACEs after 90 days from PCI till the start of RF with sensitivity and specificity
(90% and 65%), respectively. The authors suggested that low-risk patients with a normal
systolic function who underwent PCI may safely fast. Nonetheless, RF during the first
3 months following the PCI may not be safe.
On a different note, AlSheef et al.[[32]] identified the epidemiologic profile of cerebral vein thrombosis (CVT) among fasting
women using oral contraceptive pills (OCPs) during Ramadan in a retrospective study
conducted on all patients diagnosed with CVT. The study participants were categorized
into two groups RF group and a nonfasting group). Out of 108 female patients with
CVT, 36.1% were secondary to OCP, of whom 41% participants were fasting. The most
affected site was the transverse sinus. Dehydration among the fasting and protein
S deficiency in the nonfasting group was identified as the two prominent risk factors.
This study suggests that the adverse effects of OCPs use might outweigh its benefits;
thus, it should be prescribed with caution, more so in fasting patients.
Endocrinology
Thyroid
Or Koca et al.[[33]] compared the thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) values of hypothyroid patients,
before and after Ramadan. Ninety-seven patients, ranging from 18 to 65 years old,
diagnosed with hypothyroidism, who fasted during Ramadan, and who had no change of
LT4 dose for at least 6 months were included. The median serum TSH level of patients
before fasting was 2.19 mIU/L and after fasting was 2.73 mIU/L (P = 0.004). The study
demonstrated no significant change in serum free thyroxine (fT4) levels. It may be
appropriate to take precautions by making a small increase in LT4 dose BR in some
hypothyroid patients wishing to fast. Dellal et al.[[34]] compared late evening and pre-dawn use of levothyroxine in patients with hypothyroidism
in a cross-sectional study in Turkey during 2018. Patients who were on levothyroxine
treatment and having normal thyroid functions were recruited for the study last week
BR. Patients were offered to take levothyroxine at 10.30–11.00 p.m. before sleep or
between 01:30 and 03:00 a.m. at least 30 min pre-sohour. There were 53 (85.5%) females.
Basal TSH was 2.02 μIU/mL and insignificantly increased at the end of Ramadan (2.18
μIU/mL). Free triiodothyronine (fT3) decreased while free thyroxine (fT4) increased
(P < 0.001 for both). Eighteen patients preferred to take levothyroxine in the late
evening, and 44 preferred to take it before dawm. There were insignificant increases
in TSH in both groups. At the end of Ramadan, TSH increased in 63.9%, decreased in
36.1% of the participants, Zaboon et al.[[35]] determined the best time of L-thyroxine intake during Ramadan. Fifty patients taking
L-thyroxine treatment for primary hypothyroidism were involved in a prospective study
for 3 months including the fasting and prefasting months. The patients were divided
into three groups with different times of L-thyroxine intake. In the first group (pre-iftar),
the patients were asked to take L-thyroxine at the time of iftar (the sunset meal)
and delay any oral intake for at least 30 min. In the second group (post-iftar), the
patients were asked to take L-thyroxine 2 h after iftar. The patients in the last
group (pre-dawn) were asked not to eat in the last 2 h before suhoor (the predawn
meal) and take L-thyroxine tablets 1 h before suhoor. There were no significant differences
neither within each group nor among all the study groups. Moreover, the frequencies
of the TSH control after Ramadan showed no significant differences within each of
the study groups). Similarly, comparison among the study groups showed no significant
differences regardless of whether the patients had controlled or uncontrolled TSH
BR. In the patients with controlled TSH BR, 8/10 (presuhoor), 8/12 (preiftar), and
4/6 (postiftar) maintained control after Ramadan. While in the patients with uncontrolled
TSH BR, 7/10 (presuhoor), 6/8 (preiftar), and 2/4 (postiftar) achieved controlled
TSH after Ramadan.
Adrenals
The risks of RF on BP in patients with adrenal insufficiency are unknown. This study
aimed to evaluate the levels of BP and particularly the risk for hypotension during
a fasting day compared with a nonfasting day in patients with corticotrope deficiency.
Chihaoui et al.[[36]] reported a prospective case-crossover study on 28 patients with known and treated
adrenal deficiency who were fasting the month of Ramadan. Clinical and paraclinical
data were collected. Patients had a 24 h ambulatory BP monitoring during an RF day
then again during a nonfasting day. The data of 25 patients were analyzed; 20 women,
median age: 40 years, median duration of the disease: 6 years. The prevalence of hypotension
did not differ between the fasting day and the nonfasting day. Hour-by-hour BP levels
comparison showed that both systolic and diastolic BP were significantly lower at
2.00 p.m. during fasting. BP variability was significantly lower during the fasting
period compared with the same period during the nonfasting day. The same groupm Chihaoui
et al.[[37]] compared hydrocortisone and prednisolone as treatments. In a randomized, double-blind
crossover clinical trial conducted during Ramadan 2018 on 53 patients with known adrenal
inefficiency treated with hydrocortisone 20 mg/day and who wished to fast during Ramadan.
Patients were randomized into two groups; AB received hydrocortisone twice daily for
14 days, then prednisolone once daily with a placebo for 14 days, and BA received
the two treatments in the reverse order. Patients had to complete a daily follow-up
sheet about their eating and sleeping habits, the occurrence of complications, and
blood glucose monitoring and also to respond to the AddiQoL questionnaire at the end
of each treatment period. Fifty patients' data were analyzed; 29 men, mean age: 42.4
years, mean duration of the disease: 8.1 years. The frequency of complications, mean
blood glucose levels, and the quality of life did not differ on hydrocortisone compared
to prednisolone after adjusting the treatment sequence. Chihaoui et al.[[38]] assessed the daily cortisol profile in hydrocortisone-treated patients with secondary
adrenal insufficiency (SAI) and healthy controls during a fasting day. A cross-sectional
matched case–control study on fifty hydrocortisone-treated SAI patients and 69 controls
who are used to fasting. Clinical and therapeutic data were collected. Five salivary
samples for cortisol measurement were collected throughout a fasting day of the 3rd
week of Ramadan 2019.
Salivary cortisol levels were significantly higher on awakening, at midnight, and
before the predawn meal in patients compared with controls. The circadian cortisol
rhythm was disrupted in patients. The area under the salivary cortisol level versus
time curve was lower than the 2.5th percentile of the controls in one patient (2.5%)
and higher than the 97.5th percentile in 23 patients (59%) who were considered overtreated.
Age ≥35 was independently associated with overtreatment. Seven patients broke their
fasting for a complication compared with no one of the controls. No factor was associated
with this risk.
Hussain et al.[[39]] guided health-care professionals to educate, discuss, and manage patients with
artificial intelligence (AI) during RF. Risk stratification for patients with AI and
optimal strategies for management, including steroid dosing, are detailed. Before
the commencement of Ramadan, all patients must receive up-to-date education on sick
day rules, instructions on when to terminate their fast or abstain from fasting, carry
steroid warning information, and must have a valid intramuscular HC pack and know
how to administer this. Switching AI patients desiring to fast from multiple daily
HC replacement to prednisolone 5 mg once daily at dawn is recommended. Patients on
fludrocortisone for AI should be advised to take their total dose at dawn. Beshyah
et al.[[40]] surveyed 145 physicians, two-thirds of whom were adult endocrinologists. Respondents
recognized RF as having potential consequences in AI patients. Almost half of the
respondents thought that RF has some probable or definite impact on glucocorticoid
therapy that certainly warrants specific concern and possible action. The survey revealed
a remarkable variation in the physicians' perceptions and practices regarding AI management
during Ramadan.
Lipids
Akhtar et al.[[41]] included 100 healthy adult male volunteers from different mosques in and around
Jammu. The study showed a reduction in TC and TG and a rise in HDL-C levels, which
had beneficial effects on lipid profile post-RF period in healthy volunteers.
Bariatric surgery
In many practices, bariatric surgery is delayed until after Ramadan in order to avoid
postoperative complications. However, there are no studies that have evaluated this
practice. Tat et al.[[42]] evaluated the perioperative outcomes between bariatric surgeries performed before/during
Ramadan and at times distant to Ramadan. All patients who underwent primary bariatric
surgery at Cleveland Clinic Abu Dhabi between September 2015 and July 2019 were retrospectively
reviewed. The PR cohort included patients that underwent surgery during the month
of Ramadan and up to 3 months BR. The non-Ramadan (NR) cohort included patients from
the remaining 8 months. The study included 542 patients: 185 patients in the PR cohort
and 357 patients in the NR cohort. Baseline characteristics were similar. There were
no statistically significant differences in perioperative outcomes including emergency
department (ED) visits, readmission rates, reoperation, and complications within 30
days. Based on these data, there does not appear to be an increased risk of performing
bariatric surgery before or during Ramadan in a comprehensive, multi-disciplinary
program.
Neurology
Ismail et al.[[43]] examined the association of RF with clinical outcomes in 131 patients with myasthenia
gravis (MG) and used clinical characteristics to estimate outcome risk in a prospective
cohort study conducted in a tertiary neurology center in Kuwait (Ramadan 2019). Patients
with MG who were willing to fast were evaluated through three clinical visits before,
during, and after Ramadan. Disease severity was classified from Class I to Class V.
Outcomes were classified as stable, worsened, or improved. The outcomes were stable
disease in 91 patients (80.5%) and worsened disease in 17 patients (15.0%) including
two patients who developed severe weakness of limb and axial muscles; five patients
(4.4%) had improved disease. Of the patients whose conditions worsened during Ramadan,
15 (94.1%) returned to PR status during the follow-up period. Therefore, RF appears
to be safe and well tolerated for most patients with MG in this cohort. Only 15.0%
showed worsening of their symptoms; however, no patient developed respiratory involvement
or myasthenic crisis, and only two patients developed severe weakness of limb and
axial muscles. A favorable outcome was observed in patients with ocular MG, those
with generalized MG of class IIb or lower BR, those taking pyridostigmine with a dose
of 240 mg or less per day at a frequency of 3 times or less per day, those taking
prednisolone, and those who needed only one immunosuppressant to control their symptoms.
Moreover, most patients whose conditions worsened during Ramadan returned to PR status
during the follow-up period. The ability of patients with MG to observe a total or
partial fasting during Ramadan can be attributed to the diurnal variation of weakness,
which is a characteristic feature of MG. Other possible reasons might be decreased
physical exertion, reversed sleep patterns, and shortened working hours during Ramadan.
Transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) is a neuromodulation tool used to modify
cognitive function in subjects. There is a paucity of data on tDCS' effect on cognitive
function during RF. AlSultan et al.[[44]] assessed the effect of tDCS on three brain areas including the right dorsolateral
prefrontal cortex (DLPFC), posterior parietal cortex (PPC), and cerebellum on cognitive
function and obtained safety data in healthy adults during RF. Forty-two healthy,
right-handed participants were randomly assigned to one of the six stimulation groups.
An improvement in performance time in attention tasks was observed; however, it did
not reach a significant level after anodal stimulation of the DLPFC, PPC, and cerebellum.
Overall, there were no statistically significant differences between the active and
sham tDCS groups in cognitive function. There were no significant side effects of
tDCS during fasting for any group.
RF represents a challenge for both patients with epilepsy (MPWE) and their treating
neurologists who aim to minimize the risk of fasting-related seizures. Several factors
may contribute to the risk of fasting-related seizures, such as the half-life of antiepileptic
drugs (AEDs), seizure control BR, and sleep fragmentation. Magdy et al.[[45]] investigated these factors. A prospective observational study included all MPWE
who completed RF in 2019, about 16 h per day for 30 days. They were assessed regarding
seizure control, AEDs, and sleep alterations using The Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index.
The study included 430 MPWE. The majority of patients (75.58%) completed RF without
breakthrough seizures. Patients who achieved successful RF were significantly younger,
had shorter disease duration, extended periods of seizure freedom BR, more efficient
and longer sleep hours. There was no significant difference between patients receiving
monotherapy regimens with short versus intermediate long t½. Maximum seizure freedom
BR and sleep hours were identified as independent predictors of successful RF, using
multivariate analysis. Every extra week of being seizure-free BR and every extra hour
of sleep was associated with an increase in the probability of successful RF by 10%
and 30%, respectively. Neurologists should guide MPWE who wish to fast Ramadan about
the risks and precautions. Proper seizure control and ensuring adequate sleep duration
can increase the probability of a successful RF. Fasting is the basis for the ketogenic
diet, and intermittent fasting is emerging as a treatment for epilepsy. There is no
available data about the role of Islamic fasting on seizure control. The same group
assessed the effect of RF on the frequency of different seizure types.[[46]] A prospective observational study on Muslim patients with active epilepsy intending
to fast during Ramadan of 2019, with an average of 16 fasting hours per day. Seizure
frequency for each seizure type was followed over 3 months, 1 month before (Shaaban),
during Ramadan, and 1 month after (Shawwal), after ensuring drug compliance. Three
hundred and twenty-one Muslim patients with active epilepsy with a median age of 33
years were included (some patients had more than one type of seizure). In Ramadan,
86 out of 224 patients with focal seizures, 17 out of 38 patients with myoclonic seizures,
and 6 out of 10 patients with absence seizures showed ≥ a 50% reduction. In Shawaal,
such improvement continued to include 83, 13, and 4 patients with focal, myoclonic,
and absence seizures. Focal and myoclonic seizures were significantly improved in
the months of Ramadan and Shawaal compared to Shaaban. However, absence seizures were
significantly improved only in Ramadan compared with Shaaban. The frequency of generalized
tonic–clonic seizures did not significantly differ between the 3 months. The authors
concluded that RF might indeed have an improving effect, as well as a postfasting
effect, on active focal, myoclonic, and absence seizures.
Alqadi et al.[[47]] aimed to investigate the effect of fasting during Ramadan on seizure control and
quality of life in adult patients with epilepsy. A prospective observational study
over 3 months (1 month before fasting, the fasting month, and 1 month after fasting).
They recruited adult patients with active epilepsy who were able to fast during the
month of Ramadan. The primary outcome measures were as follows: (1) seizure control
and (2) quality of life score using the Arabic version of the Ferrans and Powers Quality
of Life Index (QLI). Changes in anticonvulsant medications were not allowed during
the study period. They used a seizure log provided to participants to record the number
of seizures during the 3 months. Quality of life was scored at the end of each month
of the study period. Thirty-seven patients were studied (59% males). The mean age
was 30 years, and the mean age at epilepsy onset was 13 years. On average, patients
were on three antiepileptic medications at baseline. A total of 1576 seizures were
reported during the 3-month follow-up, where seizures before fasting represented 35.5%
of all seizures. Multilinear regression analysis revealed a significant decline of
seizures by 21% during the fasting month compared with baseline and by 29% during
post fasting compared with baseline. No significant change was found in the QLI scores
calculated during the 3 months of the study period.
Effects of fasting on stress responses, mood, and withdrawal symptoms among khat users
have not been examined. Nakajima and al'Absi[[48]] enrolled eighty individuals to complete an ambulatory monitoring period and a laboratory
assessment session. Results indicated that withdrawal symptoms were lower during evening
hours in the fasting group than in the nonfasting group. Stress-related changes were
flattened in the fasting group relative to the nonfasting group. Khat users reported
reduced BP responses relative to nonusers. These preliminary results demonstrate that
fasting is associated with reduced adverse effects and withdrawal symptoms in khat
users.
Blood and Coagulation
The changes in the therapeutic effect of warfarin during RF are controversial. Hence,
Sridharan et al.[[49]] carried out a study to assess any alterations in the anticoagulation response to
warfarin and identify the associated risk factors. Patients receiving warfarin for
at least 1 year were included. Demographic details, warfarin doses, prothrombin time-international
normalized ratio (PT-INR) values, and concomitant diseases/drugs were retrieved. Ramadan
periods for the calendar years were obtained, and these periods were considered as
Ramadan periods. One month before the start dates of Ramadan was considered as PR,
and 1 month later than the last dates was considered as post-Ramadan periods. Warfarin
sensitivity index (WSI), PT-INR category, and time spent in therapeutic range (TTR)
were assessed. National Institute of Clinical Health Excellence (NICE) criteria for
anticoagulation status were adhered to where TTR (%) <65 was considered as insufficient
anticoagulation. One hundred and eighty-three patients were recruited. No significant
differences were observed in warfarin doses between the study participants between
PR, Ramadan, and post-Ramadan. Significantly more numbers of PT-INR tests were carried
out during Ramadan compared with pre-and post-Ramadan periods. A higher WSI was akin
to PT-INR, and lower intra-individual variability was observed in middle-aged and
older adults in the post-Ramadan period. Significantly fewer patients had our PT-INR
in the therapeutic range and more in the subtherapeutic range during Ramadan. A greater
proportion of patients had PT-INR in the supratherapeutic range during the post-Ramadan
periods, particularly the elderly. Although 38.3% had poor anticoagulation status
overall, 92.4% met the NICE criteria for poor anticoagulation during the 3 months
(PR, Ramadan, and post-Ramadan periods). RF influences warfarin's therapeutic effect
in lowered TTR (%), reduced proportion of patients achieving therapeutic PT-INR, and
increased risk of poor anticoagulation control. Greater caution is required during
the post-Ramadan period, particularly in the elderly category, as they are more prone
to over-anticoagulation and consequently the risk of bleeding. Batarfi et al.[[50]] determined patient-guided modifications of OAC medication regimen during Ramadan
and to evaluate its consequences. Through a multicenter cross-sectional study conducted
in Saudi Arabia. Data were collected shortly after Ramadan 2019. Participants were
patients who fasted Ramadan and who were on long-term anticoagulation. Patient-guided
medication changes during Ramadan in comparison to the regular intake schedule BR
were recorded. Modification behavior was compared between twice daily (BID) and once
daily (QD) treatment regimens. Rates of hospital admission during Ramadan were determined.
They included 808 patients. During Ramadan, 53.1% modified our intake schedule (31.1%
adjusted intake time, 13.2% skipped intakes, and 2.2% took double dosing). A higher
frequency of patient-guided modification was observed in patients on the BID regimen
than in the QD regimen. During Ramadan, 11.3% of patients were admitted to the hospital.
The patient-guided modification was a strong predictor for the hospital admission.
Patient-guided modification of OAC intake during Ramadan is common, particularly in
patients on BID regimen. It increases the risk of hospital admission during Ramadan.
Planning of OAC intake during Ramadan and patient education on the risk of low adherence
is advisable.
Chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) is a myeloproliferative neoplasm classically described
as a triphasic disease: chronic, accelerated, and blast crisis. There are many unmet
needs and unanswered questions about CML. Intermittent fasting in patients with CML
on tyrosine kinase inhibitors is among these unmet needs. Al-Dubai et al.[[51]] report on the effects of intermittent fasting on response to nilotinib in a 49-year-old
female Muslim who fasted during Ramadan and took her medication once instead of twice
daily and remained in major molecular response. This is, however, a single case report
and therefore cannot be generalized to all patients with CML. Individualization of
risk and close follow-up are mandatory for those who choose to fast.
Skeletal Medicine
Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a common inflammatory disorder affected by various factors
including fasting. Siddique et al.[[52]] the effect of RF on DAS 28 in RA patients in an observational cohort study. Two
hundred and forty participants (74 males) were recruited and then divided into fasting
(n = 120) and nonfasting cohorts (n = 120) based on their own choice. Mean DAS-28
scores before and after Ramadan were compared in both cohorts with appropriate statistical
analyses. The baseline DAS of the fasting group was significantly low as compared
to the nonfasting group. Statistically significant improvement in fasting and nonfasting
groups in total and in both sexes was evident. Mean improvement in DAS was numerically
more remarkable and statistically significant in the nonfasting group than fasting
ones. Post-Ramadan DAS was, however, significantly low in the fasting group versus
the nonfasting group. RA patients with moderate disease activity who want to observe
fasting can do so without any fear of disease worsening.
Ben Nessib et al.[[53]] reviewed data that assessed the relationship of RF with rheumatic diseases. Recent
evidence indicates that RF may attenuate the inflammatory state by suppressing pro-inflammatory
cytokine expression and reducing the body fat and the circulating levels of leukocytes.
Therefore, it may be a promising nonpharmacological approach for managing the course
of rheumatic inflammatory diseases. Despite differences between studies in daily fasting
duration and dietary norms, there appears to be a consensus that most patients with
RA or spondyloarthritis (SpA) who fasted Ramadan experienced relief of their symptoms.
Nevertheless, further clinical trials are required to assess the effect of RF on other
musculoskeletal and bone disorders. In addition, the authors evaluated the impact
of RF on chronic medication intake. Although a few studies on this issue are available,
the primary outcomes indicate that RF does not significantly impair compliance or
tolerance to chronic medications. These findings may give some reassurance to patients
with a specific fear of drug intake during this month. The critical points generated
from the observations include (a) RF can modulate the inflammatory status through
the downregulation of metabolic syndrome, the reduction of pro-inflammatory cytokines,
and the reduction of circulating levels of leukocytes; (b) RF can effectively improve
the activity of rheumatic inflammatory diseases; (c) although further studies are
still required, there seems no harm for patients with gout to participate in RF; and
(d) primary outcomes indicate that RF may be a promising nonpharmacological intervention
for managing patients with osteoarthritis and osteoporosis.
Ben Nessib et al.[[54]] specifically assessed the impact of RF on RA and SpA activity and assessed its
impact on chronic medication intake in patients with rheumatic diseases. In a prospective
study that included patients with RA or SpA who fasted during Ramadan of 2019. The
disease activity and the management of chronic medications were assessed and compared
between two visits: the first one six months before starting RF and the second after
fasting at least 7 days. Fifty-six patients were included: 36 with RA and 20 with
SpA. Fasting did not significantly affect either compliance with chronic medications
or tolerance. Fasting can be a possible way to induce the rapid improvement of rheumatic
disease activity. In addition, patients with a specific fear of drug intake during
this period can be reassured, which will enhance treatment adherence. In this set
of patients, beneficial effects of intermittent fasting were demonstrated on RA activity
but were less evident in patients with SpA despite a general trend towards improvement.
Pehlivan et al.[[55]] identified rheumatology patients' attitudes toward RF in a descriptive, cross-sectional
study involving 374 patients. Using a questionnaire form, It was determined that 56.1%
fasted during Ramadan. When asked about the effect of fasting on the disease, 88.4%
of those who fasted answered “it did not affect,” and 80.1% of those that did not
fast said “it affected negatively.” They observed that more than half of the rheumatology
patients fasted, the majority of patients thought it would not affect their disease,
and the rate of request for information from the doctor was low. The authors conclude
that a drug program could be helpful for individuals who are willing to fast, in which
drugs are taken between the İftar and Suhoor times, to help patients fast safely without
any additional risk of worsening disease.
Eyes
Beyoğlu et al.[[56]] evaluated the effect of fasting on anterior chamber depth (ACD), anterior chamber
volume (ACV), and corneal and lens density (LD) by Scheimpflug technology and measured
intraocular pressure (IOP) changes. Fifty healthy fasting individuals in Ramadan (study
group) and 50 healthy nonfasting subjects (control group) were included. Central corneal
thickness (CCT), ACD, ACV, corneal density (CD), and LD were evaluated. Although there
was a statistically significant difference between the ACV, CD, and IOP values on
the left side, no statistical significance was found for the ACV value on the left
side. While fasting did not lead to any change in LD and CCT, the results demonstrated
that it caused a slight decrease in ACD and ACV and a significant decrease in CD and
IOP values. Gokmen and Ozgur[[57]] investigated the effect of religious fasting and dehydration during Ramadan on
the choroidal thickness and vessel density in the superficial and deep vascular plexuses
with optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA) of 70 eyes of 35 healthy subjects
with a mean age of 43 years. The measured choroidal thickness, superficial vessel
density index, and deep vessel density index were 288.89 μm, 40.6%, and 41.4%, respectively,
compared to 284.62 μm, 40.41%, and 41.41%, respectively when measured in the nonfasting
period. The choroidal thickness under the fovea center was significantly higher in
the fasting period than in the nonfasting period. The mean total choroidal thickness
was reduced in the nonfasting period, although not to a statistically significant
degree. An analysis of the mean total superficial and deep vascular plexuses revealed
no statistically significant difference. Although a significant increase was noted
in central choroidal thickness in the fasting period, no significant change due to
fasting was observed in the superficial and deep capillary plexuses. The choroidal
layer may vary in thickness due to fasting-related metabolic factors, while retinal
vessels are more stable against such effects.
Demirtaş et al.[[58]] investigated the effects of RF on diurnal superficial-deep parafoveal vessel density
(pfVD) and nerve head (NH)-radial peripapillary capillary (RPC) peripapillary vessel
density (ppVD) using OCTA, as well as other related ocular dynamic and hemodynamic
parameters and compared these findings with those in the nonfasting period in healthy
individuals. A total of 105 healthy individuals, 42 women and 63 men were included
in this prospective study. OCTA was used to examine the superficial-deep pfVD and
NH-RPC ppVD. In the 3rd week of Ramadan, OCTA readings were obtained twice daily at
08:00 and 16:00 h under fasting conditions and compared with nonfasting values 2 weeks
after Ramadan. Compared with the 08:00 h values, the 16:00 h IOPs, superficial-deep
pfVDs, and RPC ppVDs were substantially reduced during fasting and nonfasting periods.
No differences were found in the diurnal change of superficial-deep pfVDs, NH-RPC
ppVDs, IOPs, and mean ocular perfusion pressures between fasting and nonfasting periods
same was not true for mean arterial BPs. The authors concluded that the parafoveal
and peripapillary VDs (except for NHpp-VD) and IOPs were found to have decreased significantly
throughout the day, both in fasting and nonfasting periods.
Nilforushan et al.[[59]] investigated the effects of fasting on IOP, CCT, RPC density, and retinal nerve
fiber layer (RNFL) thickness during the Islamic fasting month of Ramadan. Twenty-seven
healthy fasting volunteers were enrolled. All subjects underwent complete ophthalmic
examination and OCTA of both eyes. All measurements were recorded first in the morning
and then in the evening. The first visit was performed during the 2nd and 3rd week
of Ramadan and then 2 months later on a nonfasting routine day. The mean age of participants
was 40.07 years. A significant decrease was found for evening IOP 11.17 mmHg) in comparison
with morning IOP (12.00) only on fasting days. A decrease was observed for CCT both
on fasting (6 μm) and nonfasting days (3 μm) in the evening. There was a significant
increase in whole and peripapillary RPC density (%) on fasting days (48.79 mornings,
49.72 evenings for whole and 50.57 mornings, and 51.64 evenings for peripapillary).
Average RNFL thickness was decreased from morning to evening both on fasting days
(0.80 μm) and nonfasting days (1.25 μm). Optic NH (ONH) vertical cup/disc (C/D) ratio
was greater on fasting days (0.30 morning and 0.31 evening) in comparison with nonfasting
days (0.27 morning and 0.28 evening). Fasting decreases the IOP and CCT in healthy
subjects. OCTA revealed significant differences in RPC vessel density, RNFL thickness,
and ONH vertical C/D ratio during fasting hours compared to nonfasting days.
Maternal and Fetal Health
Maternal and Fetal Health
Long-term impact on fetal exposure to Ramadan fasting
Although pregnant women are exempt, many prefer to fast. Savitri et al.[[60]] investigated the effects of RF during pregnancy among Muslims in the Netherlands.
Data from the Perinatal Registry of the Netherlands on all births between 2000 and
2010 to mothers recorded as the Mediterranean (i.e., Turkish/Moroccan descent, a proxy
for Muslim) or ethnically Dutch were used. Ramadan during pregnancy among Muslims
was not associated with altered birth weight, gestational length, newborn's sex, perinatal
mortality, low Apgar, or mild congenital anomalies. Odds for severe congenital anomalies
were higher among the exposed (odds ratio: 1.17), but this association became nonsignificant
when adjusting for multiple testing. Therefore, there seems to be little or no relation
between exposure to Ramadan during pregnancy and birth outcomes. Parveen et al.[[61]] determined maternal and perinatal outcomes after RF during pregnancy. In a cross-sectional
study. A total of 226 women attending the labor room, aged 18–35 years, at 15–40 weeks
of gestation were included. Women who fasted for more than 15 days were compared with
those who did not fast or fasted for <15 days in Ramadan. Out of 226 women, 25.7%
were included in the fasting group, whereas the remaining 74.3% were in the nonfasting
group. There was no difference between groups concerning demographic characteristics
except significantly fewer women employed in the fasting group (P = 0.0246). Fasting
women were not found to have poor maternal and fetal outcomes when compared to nonfasting
women. Karimi et al.[[62]] examined the impact of the in utero exposure to RF by trimester on the height of
0–18 in children from Tehran, Iran. RF in the second trimester of gestation was associated
with 0.091 age-adjusted SDs decrease in children's height at the age of 10 years or
older. The negative association was largest in male children and was approximately
1 cm at age 12 years or older among male children. Therefore, maternal exposure to
in the second trimester, the critical period for long bone development, was associated
with decreased height.
Ramadan fasting and breastfeeding
There are guidelines on lactation following maternal analog-sedative exposure, but
these do not consider the effect of maternal fasting or fluid abstention on human
milk macronutrient composition. Allegaert and Smits[[63]] performed a structured search on the link between fasting and human mild composition
resulting six papers and one abstract related to religious fasting (n = 129) and observational
studies in lactating women (n = 23). These data reflect two different “fasting” patterns:
an acute (18–25 h) model in 71 (healthy volunteers, Yom Kippur/Ninth of Av) women
and chronic repetitive fasting (Ramadan) model in 81 women. They concluded that neither
short-term fasting nor fluid abstention (18–25 h) affects human milk macronutrient
composition so that women can be reassured when this topic was raised during consulting.
Al-Qahtani et al.[[64]] assess the knowledge, practice, and attitude of breastfeeding among women in the
Najran area, Saudi Arabia, during Ramadan using a descriptive cross-sectional study
employing a self-administrated questionnaire. A total of 169 breastfeeding women visiting
a gynecology clinic were randomly recruited. Nearly 89.9% showed that they used to
practice breastfeeding while fasting during the day in Ramadan. The study revealed
that 85.8% of the participants thought that fasting does not alter the nutritional
composition of breast milk. Around 80.5% stated that fasting has no adverse effect
on the volume of breast milk and the growth of the infants during Ramadan.
Medical Emergencies
The impact of Ramadan on emergency services was reported from two studies.[[65]],[[66]],[[67]] Faruqi et al.[[65]] analyzed the emergency department (ED) patients' flow during Ramadan and compared
it to NR days in a retrospective study from Abu Dhabi, UAE. It was conducted at a
tertiary hospital (2014–2016). A total of 45,116 ED patient visits were analyzed over
the mentioned study period. There was a difference in the total volume of Ramadan
and NR patients between the years 2014 and 2016. The highest percentage of visits
was during the NR days, and this had a slight fluctuation from 53% in 2014 to 52%
in 2016. It was observed from the collected data that 53% of the patients were present
in the hospital during the fasting hours, whereas 47% were present during the nonfasting
hours.
Moreover, the authors observed a difference in the patient arrival pattern between
the Ramadan and NR days and the predominant categorization of chief patient complaints.
Sawaya et al.[[66]] investigated the impact of Ramadan on patient characteristics, diagnoses, and metrics
in the pediatric ED (PED). In a retrospective cross-sectional study, all pediatric
patients attending the PED of a tertiary care center in Lebanon were included during
Ramadan (June 2016 and 2017) versus the months before and after Ramadan (NR). They
included 5711 patients with a mean age of 6.1 years and 55.4% males. The number of
daily visits was 28.3 during Ramadan versus 31.5 during NR (P = 0.004). The peak time
of visits ranged from 18:00 to 22:00 during NR versus from 22:00 to 02:00 during Ramadan.
During Ramadan, there were significantly more gastrointestinal and trauma-related
complaints. The Ramadan group had faster work efficiency measures such as times to
order tests and to collect samples. These findings could help EDs structure their
staffing to optimize resource allocation during Ramadan. Finally, Joachim et al.[[67]] examined the frequency of sialadenitis among a Muslim population during Ramadan
by comparing it to other months of the year in a retrospective study using the medical
records of 120 Muslim patients admitted to the ED and diagnosed with acute sialadenitis
over 5 years. During Ramadan, the diagnosis of acute sialadenitis was more than double
that during the other months of the year. In addition, they found that Ramadan sialadenitis
patients had significantly higher leukocyte numbers at admission and importantly,
a significantly higher level of dehydration than NR sialadenitis patients.
GUT and Liver
Ebrahimi et al.[[68]] investigated the effects of RF on liver function, Visceral Adiposity Index (VAI),
and Atherogenic Indexes of Plasma (AIP) in nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD)
patients. Eighty-three NAFLD patients (57 males), forty-two patients practiced RF
(2015), and 41 patients in nonfasting groups. Mean decreases in anthropometric indices
were significantly different between groups. Similarly, the mean decrease in the TC
values in the fasting group was remarkably greater than in the control group (P =
0.02). The values of AIP and VAI decreased at the end of the study in both groups,
and the mean of changes showed no differences between groups. The changes in the concentrations
of liver enzymes and the severity of hepatic steatosis showed remarkable differences
between groups. RF improved liver steatosis in NAFLD patients and might be helpful
in the management of NAFLD.
Ozkul et al.[[69]] hypothesized that RF might lead to changes in gut microbial composition and diversity.
A total of nine adult subjects were included in the study. Stool samples were collected
before (baseline) and at the end of the RF (after 29 days). Microbial richness was
significantly increased after Ramadan, according to observed results. The analysis
also revealed that Butyricicoccus, Bacteroides, Faecalibacterium, Roseburia, Allobaculum,
Eubacterium, Dialister, and Erysipelotrichi were significantly enriched genera after
the end of RF. According to random forest analysis, the bacterial species most affected
by the RF was Butyricicoccus pullicaecorum. Despite this being a pilot study with
a limited sample size, the results revealed that RF, which represents an intermittent
fasting regime, leads to compositional changes in the gut microbiota.
Montasser et al.[[70]] assessed the effect of RF on liver transplantation recipients' renal and liver
functions and propose a protocol for adapting an immunosuppression regimen and follow-up
schedule for patients wishing to fast after liver transplantation. A prospective study
was conducted on 45 recipients who wished to fast Ramadan (2018) in Cairo, Egypt.
The mean age of the patients was 55.5 years, and 84.4% were males; the meantime from
liver transplantation was 51.6 months. Thirty-seven patients (82.2%) completed RF,
three patients (6.6%) had interrupted fasting, and five patients (11.1%) had to stop
fasting because of an unacceptable rise in renal function. There was a statistically
significant difference between the pre- and post-fasting states in terms of the serum
Cr level. However, the serum Cr did not exceed the upper normal value in the patients
who completed fasting. Although a small study, these findings seem promising for RF
with an adapted immunosuppression protocol and regular follow-up for recipients wishing
to fast. Further multicenter studies on a larger number of patients are warranted.
Sleep Medicine
A couple of studies evaluated sleep physiology during Ramadan in healthy subjects
and athletes. Faris et al.[[71]] estimated the effect size of RF on sleep duration and daytime sleepiness. The sleep
quality measures analyzed were excessive daytime sleepiness measured by the Epworth
sleepiness scale (ESS) and total sleep time (TST). They identified 24 studies (involving
646 participants, median age 23.7 years, 73% men) conducted in 12 countries from 2001
to 2019. The results revealed that TST decreased from 7.2 h per night BR to 6.4 h
during Ramadan, whereas the ESS score increased slightly from 6.1 BR to 7.0 during
Ramadan. During Ramadan, there is approximately a 1 h reduction in TST and nearly
a 1 point increase in the ESS score. Trabelsi et al.[[72]] evaluated the effect of observing Ramadan on athletes' sleep patterns. Studies
assessing sleep quantity, quality, daytime sleepiness, and/or daily naps based on
objective or subjective methods were deemed eligible. Eleven studies evaluated TST;
this decreased during Ramadan in four studies, increased in 1, and remained unchanged
in 6. Meta-regressions showed no study year, age, sample size, type of sport, or competition
level, but the country's effects (with France and Tunisia being the most affected
countries and Turkey the least affected) and study design. One study of sleep architecture
reported more frequent waking and more light sleep during Ramadan. Daily nap duration
was increased in two studies, but daytime sleepiness remained unchanged in four studies.
When athletes continue to train at least two times/week while observing Ramadan, TST
is decreased compared with athletes' baseline levels.
Sports Medicine
Graja et al.[[73]] assessed the effect of RF on cognitive and physical performance and biochemical
responses to specific exercises in elite young female handball players. Twelve athletes
participated in three experimental sessions: 1 week BR, during the first week of Ramadan,
and the last week of Ramadan (LWR), in Tunisia 2013. During each session, a battery
of tests was performed as follow: Hooper index, vigilance test, ESS, five jump test
(5-JT), modified agility t-test, maximal standing ball-throw velocity test (MSBVT),
and Running-based Anaerobic Sprint (RAST) test. Rating of perceived exertion (RPE)
was recorded immediately after the RAST. Blood samples were collected before and after
exercises during each session. The results showed that ESS scores were higher during
LWR than BR. Moreover, MSBVT time decreased during LWR; therefore, performance enhanced.
The power of three final sprints from the RAST decreased significantly during LWR
than BR. RAST fatigue index (FI) and RPE scores were higher during LWR more than BR.
The results also showed that hematological measures, plasma osmolarity, and energetic
markers were unaffected by RF. Biomarkers of muscle damage were higher after the RAST
only during LWR compared to BR. In conclusion, RF increased ESS and decreased RAST
performances are associated with greater muscle damage and fatigue, especially at
LWR. These alterations could be attributed to disturbances of sleep and circadian
rhythms rather than nutritional deficiency or dehydration. Hsouna et al.[[74]] investigated the effects of a 25 min nap opportunity on physical performance during
the 5-m shuttle run test (5mSRT), feelings, attention, and the perception of fatigue
during Ramadan observance. Twelve physically active men voluntarily participated in
five test sessions: 15 days BR, the first 10 days of Ramadan (FR), the last 10 days
of Ramadan (ER), 10 days after Ramadan (10AR), and 20 days after Ramadan (20AR). The
total distance (TD) covered during the 5mSRT did not differ significantly before,
during, or after Ramadan but was significantly greater after N25 than N0 at 10AR and
20AR. The attention scores were higher after N25 in comparison with N0 at 10A. RPE
scores were not significantly different between N25 and N0 conditions. Feelings scores
were higher after N25 compared to N0 during both FR and 20AR. A significant deterioration
of sleep quality was recorded during Ramadan. A 25 min nap opportunity was beneficial
for physical and cognitive performance after Ramadan observance; however, any effect
is insufficient to show significant beneficial impacts during Ramadan. The same group
Hsouna et al.[[75]] investigated the effects of a 35-min nap opportunity on physical performance during
the 5mSRT; attention; feelings; mood states; and perceptual measures of stress, fatigue,
and muscle soreness during Ramadan observance. Fourteen physically active men were
tested after a no-nap condition (N0), N35 15 days BR, the last 10 days of Ramadan
(DR), and 20 days after Ramadan (AR). After a 5 min standard warm-up, participants
performed the 5mSRT (6 × 30 s with 35 s in between; best distance [BD], TD, and FI
were recorded), along with the RPE after each test repetition. After the 5mSRT test,
participants responded to the feeling scale. The results showed that TD and FI during
the 5mSRT were not affected by Ramadan observance. However, BD was significantly lower
in DR compared to AR after N0. After N0, attention decreased significantly at DR in
comparison with BR and AR. BD and TD improved after N35 compared to N0 at BR, DR,
and AR. A significant increase in attendance was observed after N35 in comparison
with N0 at DR and AR. However, no changes were found to perceive mood states, stress,
sleep, muscle soreness, or the FI during the 5mSRT. Furthermore, N35 was better than
N0 for RPE at DR, feelings at AR, and fatigue estimation at AR. A 35-min nap opportunity
may have beneficial effects on physical and cognitive performances before, during,
and after Ramadan.
Fekih et al.[[76]] explored whether a training program incorporating motor imagery could affect physical
performance outcomes in terms of agility, speed, and reaction time in a sample of
tennis athletes who fasted during the month of Ramadan 2016. Recruited subjects were
27 young male tennis players, randomly allocated to two groups: the imaging training
group (n = 13) and a control group (n = 14). The study was designed as a randomized,
controlled experimental study. The control group was engaged in watching videos concerning
the Olympic Games history, whereas the motor imagery group followed a motor imagery-based
training program. Physical performance outcomes were assessed during four sessions
(one BR and three during Ramadan) utilizing field tests. Results revealed a drop in
all performance outcomes measured in the middle and at the end of Ramadan for both
groups. This drop in performance was greater for the control group than the motor
imagery group in the middle and at the end of Ramadan. This study showed that fasting
during Ramadan reduced agility, speed, and reaction time performance for tennis players.
A motor imagery-based training program could be an effective approach to reduce the
effect of fasting during Ramadan and stabilize physical performance outcomes in terms
of agility, speed, and reaction time for male tennis players. Furthermore, the same
group[[77]] analyzed the effects of motor mental imagery training on tennis service performance
among tennis athletes who fast during Ramadan 2017. Thirty-eight young male tennis
players were randomly divided into imaging training (IMG, n = 18) and control groups
(CG, n = 20). The CG watched videos on the Olympic Games history, while IMG followed
a training program in motor imagery. The performance of the tennis service was obtained
by the product between accuracy and average speed of all shots (km/h). The effect
of group/time interaction was identified for all performance indicators (accuracy,
running speed, and performance [speed × precision]), with improvement only in IMG.
The results showed that motor imagery training could be an effective strategy for
mitigating/counteracting the negative effects of Ramadan on the tennis service performance.
A systematic review by Correia et al.[[78]] summarized the effects of RF on performance outcomes. Twenty-eight articles met
the eligibility criteria. Findings indicated that maximum oxygen uptake is significantly
enhanced with TRF protocols but reduced with RF. Nonsignificant effects were observed
for muscle strength and anaerobic capacity. While Ramadan IF may lead to impairments
in aerobic capacity, TRF may be effective for improving it. More research is needed
to move the field forward. Another systematic review and meta-analysis determind the
effects of fasting on physical performance during the month of Ramadan.[[79]] Results revealed that RF had a deleterious effect on mean power and peak power
during a Wingate and a repeated sprint test. In the morning, sprint performance was
negatively affected by RF. Aerobic performance, strength, jump height, FI, and total
work were not affected by the intermittent fasting during Ramadan. Athletes appear
able to participate in the competition in a fasted state with little impact on physical
performance.
Professional Perspectives
Professional Perspectives
Amin and Abdelmageed[[80]] proposed a communication tool, RAMCOM, which aims to assist clinicians in communicating
with Muslim patients considering fasting during Ramadan. They explored clinicians'
perspectives on factors affecting care provided to Muslim patients who decide to fast
during Ramadan. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with a purposeful sample
of clinicians in Egypt (11) and the USA (10). Data were mapped into clinician's belief
inability to care for those patients, belief in group's ability to provide care, anticipated
consequences of providing such care, knowledge, learning by observing other clinicians,
cultural norms and perceived acceptability and prevalence of care provision, environmental
barriers and opportunities, and communication approach.
It is unclear how many Muslim patients receive adequate counseling on fasting. As
such, Hamodat et al.[[81]] explored the knowledge, perception, and comfort level of primary care physicians
(PCPs) at a University's Department of Family Medicine (Nova Scotia, Canada) in managing
patients' choosing to fast during Ramadan. Many PCPs perceived the importance of understanding
RF and its relevance to our patient's health. However, they did not have adequate
knowledge about the matter. The majority of PCPs felt they received inadequate training
in this area and did not feel comfortable counseling and managing the health of these
patients. Dabaja et al.[[82]] reported an anonymous, digital, bilingual pediatric fasting survey of 918 Muslim
parents or guardians of children between 7 and 18. Approximately 80% identified as
Arab American and 57% as immigrants to the US. Over 63% of participants reported that
their child's health-care provider was unaware that our children fasted during Ramadan.
In addition, 75% of participants indicated that their child's health-care provider
did not offer them any medical advice regarding fasting. However, 69% of participants
reported being comfortable discussing fasting practices with their child's doctor.
Furthermore, 80% of participants reported that our children's doctor had a good or
an advanced understanding of fasting. The findings of these studies have outlined
a knowledge gap that exists within our PCP community. They should also help elucidate
beliefs and practices about Muslim fasting. In addition, they will help inform and
prioritize educational needs and direct efforts to ensure safe patient management
during Ramadan. Furthermore, they highlight a stark contrast between parents' perceptions
and the current clinical practice of our physicians.
Conclusions
RF continues to offer interested researchers fertile ground for assessing risks and
health-associated outcomes in different disease states. The nature of RF, abstinence
from food and drink, and the cultural norms may lead to both favorable and adverse
outcomes in different patient populations and healthy individuals. Challenges remain
in identifying patients who can fast safely despite medical conditions and the measures
required to optimize their fasting experience.
Authors' contribution
All authors contributed to the conception of the study. SAB performed the initial
literature searches and produced the initial draft. All authors developed their assigned
sections, reviewed the whole manuscript for intellectual content, and approved its
final version.
Compliance with ethical principles
No ethical approval is required for review articles.
Reviewers:
Not applicable (invited Review)
Editors:
Elmahdi A Elkhammas (Columbus OH, USA)
Issam M Hajjaji (Tripoli, Libya)
