Arquivos Internacionais de Otorrinolaringologia 2011; 15(03): 346-349
DOI: 10.1590/S1809-48722011000300013
Original Article
Thieme Publicações Ltda Rio de Janeiro, Brazil

Evaluation of the ultrasound reproducibility as a method to measure the subcutaneous tissue of the nasal tip

Avaliação da reprodutibilidade ultrassonográfica como método para medida do tecido subcutâneo da ponta nasal
Marcell de Melo Naves
1  Doctor. Otorhinolaryngology Department of the Federal University of Uberlândia's Medical School.
,
Rogério Costa Sousa
1  Doctor. Otorhinolaryngology Department of the Federal University of Uberlândia's Medical School.
,
Raphael Alves Ferreira Tomé
2  Doctor. Radiology Deparment of the Federal University of Uberlândia's Medical School.
,
Nicholas Godoy Canazza Damian
2  Doctor. Radiology Deparment of the Federal University of Uberlândia's Medical School.
,
Angélica Lemos Debs Diniz
3  Professor Doctor. Radiology Deparment of the Federal University of Uberlândia's Medical School.
,
Lucas Gomes Patrocinio
4  Professor Doctor. Head of the Deparment of Junior Doctors in Otorhinolaryngology of the Federal University of Uberlândia's Medical School.
› Author Affiliations
Further Information

Address for correspondence

Lucas Gomes Patrocinio
Rua Artur Bernardes 555, 1° Andar - Uberlândia / MG - Brazil - ZIP Code: 3840-368 - Telephone: (+55 34) 3215-1143

Publication History

28 April 2011

25 June 2011

Publication Date:
12 February 2014 (online)

 

Summary

Introduction: The previous evaluation of the patient's anatomy is crucial to achieve a sharp nasal tip in a rhinoplasty. The thickness of the subcutaneous tissue is indispensable for the esthetical harmony of the area. Techniques to measure such structures on the patient 'in vivo' are not found in literature.

Objective: Evaluate the inter-observer inconsistency of the ultrasound method to measure the thickness of the subcutaneous tissue of the nasal tip by way of an ultrasound.

Method: 47 volunteers were submitted to a nasal tip ultrasound performed by two radiology specialists, who used the same exam technique with a linear electronic transducer at a frequency between 5 and 9 MHz. The thickness of the subcutaneous tissue was evaluated by measuring the point with the highest protrusion of the largest alar cartilage dome towards skin. Prospective study.

Results: The measurement averages of the subcutaneous tissue of the nasal tip achieved by the examiners did not show statistically significant differences (p = 0.5303). When analyzing the reproducibility between examiners, an interclass 'r'correlation coefficient (Pearson) 0.9333, i.e., an excellent inter-observer reproducibility was found.

Conclusion: The ultrasound proved to be reproducible and examiners satisfactorily agree about evaluating the thickness of the subcutaneous tissue of the skin, thus helping the surgeon perform the pre-surgical analysis and find the best surgical technique for each case.


#

Resumo

Introdução: A prévia avaliação da anatomia do paciente é fundamental para atingir uma ponta nasal bem definida em rinoplastia. A espessura do tecido subcutâneo é essencial para a harmonia estética dessa região. Técnicas de mensuração dessas estruturas no paciente “in vivo” não estão padronizadas na literatura.

Objetivo: Avaliar a variabilidade interobservador do método ultrassonográfico para medida da espessura do tecido subcutâneo da ponta nasal por de ultrasonografia.

Método: 47 voluntários submeteram-se a ultrasonografia da ponta nasal por dois especialistas em radiologia que utilizaram a mesma técnica de exame com transdutor eletrônico linear na frequência de 5 a 9 MHz. Avaliou-se a espessura do tecido subcutâneo através da medida do ponto de maior projeção do domo da cartilagem alar maior até a pele. Estudo prospectivo.

Resultados: As médias das medidas do tecido subcutâneo da ponta nasal obtidas pelos examinadores não apresentaram diferenças estatisticamente significante (p = 0.5303). Na análise da reprodutibilidade entre examinadores encontrou-se coeficiente de correlação interclasse r (Pearson) 0,9333, isto é, uma excelente reprodutibilidade interobservadores.

Conclusão: A ultrassonografia demonstrou-se reprodutível e excelente concordância entre os examinadores para avaliação da espessura do tecido subcutâneo da pele, auxiliando o cirurgião na análise pré-operatória do paciente e na escolha da melhor técnica cirúrgica para cada caso.


#

Introduction

The pre-surgical evaluation based on the patient's anatomy is extremely important for rhinoplasty to be successful[1] [2]. The type of skin, thickness of the subcutaneous tissue, support of the tip and the size, form and position of the biggest alar cartilages are extremely important when choosing the available techniques to reach a proper sharpness of the nasal tip[2] [3] [4] [5].

The thickness of the nasal subcutaneous tissue is extremely changeable. A same noise is usually thicker in both the tip and the nasal root. It equally varies with race, and it is thicker in afro-descending patients than white patients.

The intra-domal space is regarded as the space between the highest protrusion of the biggest alar cartilages, and it is normally occupied by adipose tissue[7]. The shape of the biggest alar cartilages, especially the dome (cupola) is wide and it can contribute for the width of the tip complex[6]. The 30o angle of interdomal divergence and the domal arch equal to or smaller than 4 mm are considered normal.

Anatomic studies in corpses showed that barely defined box-like bulbous nasal tips show a thicker subcutaneous nasal tissue[8]. However, measurement techniques of the thickness of the subcutaneous tissue in 'in vivo' patients is not standardized in literature.

The objective of this study is to evaluate the inter-observer changeability of the ultrasound method to measure the thickness of the subcutaneous tissue of the nasal tip by using a standardized technique.


#

Method

47 volunteers were submitted to a nasal tip ultrasound. The inclusion criteria were: age between 18 and 70. The exclusion criteria were: previous nasal surgery, scar in the nasal tip, previous nasal trauma and presence of any disease changing the anatomy of skin, subcutaneous tissue and nasal tip cartilages.

The ultrasound exams were performed by two radiologist specialists, who used the same previously standardized exam technique. Each patient was evaluated on the same day; however, the observers could not access the results of the previously obtained measurements in order to prevent samples from being contaminated.

The equipment used to perform the ultrasound was a Medison® Sonoace 8000 SE with an electronic linear transducer at a frequency between 5 and 9 MHz. All the patients were evaluated in a dorsal decubitus position. The transducer was positioned on the nasal tip without putting any pressure on it not to underestimate affection. The thickness of the subcutaneous tissue was evaluated by measuring the point with the highest protrusion of the largest alar cartilage dome towards skin, in millimeters.

Statistical Analysis

The descriptive statistical analysis was used for a socio-demographic characterization and to calculate the averages and standard deviations of the measures achieved by the two observers. When performing Lilliefors test, the data normality was checked. Student's t test was used to compare the measures achieved by the two observers. The intraclass correlation coefficient and the respective confidence interval were used to determine the reproducibility of the measures achieved by the two observers. Bland-Altman graphic was equally used to evaluate the compliance between the measures. The level of statistical significance was defined as p < 0,05.


#
#

Results

The study group was comprised of 47 patients - 16 were male and 31 were aged between 18 and 70 (average of 35 ± 14).

The ultrasound measurement of the subcutaneous tissue of the nasal tip was performed in an average of 1.2 minutes (0.9-2 minutes). The achieved measurement averages of the subcutaneous tissue of the nasal tip and their respective standard deviations were: 4.352 mm ± 0.6222 for the first examiner and 4.330 mm ± 0.674 for the second examiner.

The measurement comparisons achieved by the examiners one and two did not show statistically significant differences (p = 0.5303), implying that the examiners do not disagree with each other regarding the measurements ([Graphic 1]). The good similarity can be confirmed by referring to the graphic of the averages. The average of differences was very low, i.e., 0.02234 mm and a standard deviation of 0.24 mm, proving the examiners excellently agree with each other.

Zoom Image
Figure 1. Ultrasound image of the nasal tip clearly showing the thickness measure of the subcutaneous tissue of the nasal tip (biggest protrusion of the largest alar cartilage dome towards skin).
Zoom Image
Graphic 1. Averages and standard deviation of the measures obtained by examiners 1 and 2. No significant different were observed among the averages of the three measures obtained by the examiners.

When analyzing the reproducibility between examiners, an interclass 'r' correlation coefficient (Pearson) 0,9333 (confidence interval [IC] 95 = 0.88-0.96 p < 0.0001), i.e., an excellent inter-observer reproducibility was found.


#

Discussion

The nasal tip surgery is an extremely complex part of rhinoplasty[1]. Likewise, it is influenced by factors such as type of skin, thickness of the subcutaneous tissue, tip support and size, shape and position of the biggest alar cartilages. Therefore, a detailed anatomic knowledge of this area helps surgeon plan the surgery and decide about the technique to be used, hence directly impacting the final aesthetic result[2] [3] [4].

Additionally, the thickness of the skin and subcutaneous tissue is an extremely important factor to choose the technique to be used, with a view to achieving a better sharpness of the nasal tip[5]. Thus, the ultrasound analysis of the nasal tip simultaneously performed with the pre-surgical analysis can help surgeon decide abut the technique to be used for each patient.

Ultrasound exam to evaluate the nasal tip was firstly introduced by Tasman and Helbig in 2000, for purposes of evaluating the changes occurred on the nasal tip as a result of rhinoplasty[9]. In 2004, Copcu et al. used the ultrasound to show the presence of interdomal adipose tissue as an independent structure taking the interdomal space on the nasal tip[8]. Coskun et al., in 2008, published the tridimensional ultrasound analysis of the interdomal adipose tissue by way of vertical, transverse and longitudinal measures of this structure, which was confirmed by dissection[10]. However, no study was performed to accredit the method to evaluate the thickness of the subcutaneous tissue of the nasal tip.

The sharpness of the nasal tip can be achieved by several methods, including techniques of suture, resections and exertions[11] [12]. Choosing the technique to be used on each patient is totally dependent on the skin and the subcutaneous tissue. The suture techniques are applied to patients with thin and normal and intended to correct abnormalities of the nasal tip cartilages in those patients with box-like nasal tips[5] [13] [14] [15]. Patients with bigger abnormalities of the nasal tip and thick skin are not satisfactorily approached by suture techniques. They need exertions to attain proper sharpness and enhancement of the nasal tip[16]. Dome-dividing techniques can equally be necessary for patients with extremely thick skin[17] [18].

Several authors agree that the best sharpness of the nasal tip must be founded on the most conservative techniques for more discreet alterations in individuals with thin skins and subcutaneous tissues, and more aggressive techniques for bigger abnormalities in patients with thick skins and subcutaneous tissues[5].

The ultrasound evaluation of the nasal tip is an objective method to identify the anatomy of this region and proved to be effective to evaluate the skin and the subcutaneous tissue of the nasal tip. The results achieved proved that there is a good reproducibility without a statistically significant difference in the measurements obtained by the examiners, making this method reliable as one more tool for the surgeon in the pre-surgical analysis and subsequently in the surgical plan.


#

Conclusion

Using ultrasound exam to evaluate the thickness of the subcutaneous tissue proved to be reproducible and examiners satisfactorily agree. It is a non-invasive, low-cost and safe method that can help surgeon both evaluate the patient's skin and the subcutaneous tissue and choose the best surgical technique for each case.


#
#

Address for correspondence

Lucas Gomes Patrocinio
Rua Artur Bernardes 555, 1° Andar - Uberlândia / MG - Brazil - ZIP Code: 3840-368 - Telephone: (+55 34) 3215-1143


Zoom Image
Figure 1. Ultrasound image of the nasal tip clearly showing the thickness measure of the subcutaneous tissue of the nasal tip (biggest protrusion of the largest alar cartilage dome towards skin).
Zoom Image
Graphic 1. Averages and standard deviation of the measures obtained by examiners 1 and 2. No significant different were observed among the averages of the three measures obtained by the examiners.