Keywords: spinocerebellar ataxias - quality of life - surveys and questionnaires
Palavras-chave: ataxia espinocerebelar - qualidade de vida - inquéritos e questionários
Spinocerebellar ataxia type 10 (SCA10) is a neurodegenerative disease with autosomal
dominant inheritance[1 ]. Atrophy of the cerebellum and its afferent and efferent connections[2 ] is caused by a pentanucleotide (ATTCT) repeat expansion ranging from 800 to 4,500
repeats in intron 9 of the ATXN10 gene[3 ].
The characteristic symptoms are gait ataxia, dysarthria, dysphagia, nystagmus and,
in some cases, epileptic seizures, reduced cognitive ability and depression[4 ],[5 ]. In addition, reduced ability to perform activities of daily living (ADL) impairs
quality of life (QoL) in individuals with ataxia[6 ].
The World Health Organization defines QoL as the individual's perception of their
position in society and in relation to their goals, expectations and concerns[7 ]. A QoL assessment through generic or specific instruments is an important measure
of the impact of treatments on health indicators[8 ]. Health is not merely the absence of disease[9 ] and, therefore, should be measured based on QoL[10 ]. This study aimed to assess the self-perception of QoL and its association with
disease duration, severity of ataxia, balance and functional independence.
METHODS
Participants
The study population comprised 15 individuals (eight females, seven males) with a
diagnosis of SCA10 who were treated in the Ataxia Outpatient Unit. Inclusion criteria
were: a) having a positive molecular genetic test for SCA10; b) in the absence of
molecular results, having neurological signs characteristic of SCA10 and a family
member with a positive genetic test for SCA10; c) absence of dementia; and d) having
signed a voluntary informed-consent form.
The study was a prospective, descriptive, cross-sectional study. All the participants
were told about the procedures and signed the voluntary informed-consent form. The
study was approved by the Committee for Ethics in Research at the Hospital de Clínicas,
Federal University of Paraná (HC-UFPR) (CAAE:57853816.0.0000.0096, ref. no.: 1.674.669).
Assessment instruments
The following instruments, validated in Portuguese, were used: the Medical Outcomes
Study 36-Item Short-Form Health Survey Version 2 (SF-36)[11 ] to assess QoL; the Functional Independence Measure (FIM)[12 ] for ADL and the Lawton Instrumental Activities of Daily Living (IADL) scale[13 ]; the Berg Balance Scale[14 ] for balance and fall risk; and the Scale for the Assessment and Rating of Ataxia
(SARA)[15 ] to rate the severity of the ataxia.
SF-36: This comprises 36 questions. One measures health transition and the others cover
eight domains. Scores from 0-100 are assigned to each answer, 0 corresponding to the
worst health state and 100 to the best[11 ]. In our study, we defined a cutoff at 50 points. Scores above this value were classified
as “high quality of life”, and those below as “low quality of life”.
FIM: This instrument provides an objective assessment of an individual's independence
in terms of motor and cognitive function. It covers 18 items, and the overall score
can vary from 18-126; the lower the final score, the greater the dependence[12 ].
Lawton IADL Scale: This assesses an individual's ability to live independently and participate in the
community. The scale comprises seven items, and the total score can vary from 7-21.
The global score is interpreted as follows: ≤ 5 – totally dependent; > 5 and < 21
– partially dependent; 21 – independent[13 ].
Berg Balance Scale: The Berg Balance Scale assesses static and dynamic balance during 14 tasks. A score
from 0-4 is assigned to each task, and the maximum score is 56. Individuals with scores
from 41-56 can walk independently (low fall risk), those with scores from 21-40 are
able to walk with assistance (medium fall risk) and those with scores from 0-20 require
a wheelchair (high fall risk)[14 ].
SARA: This is an eight-item scale for assessing and rating ataxia. The total score ranges
from 0 (no ataxia) to 40 (severe ataxia)[15 ].
Data collection procedures
The collection period was from August 2016 to June 2017, during the individual's multidisciplinary
routine check-up at the Ataxia Outpatient Unit. The physiotherapy assessment in this
outpatient unit included demographic, clinical and laboratory data (age, disease duration,
duration of symptoms, number of ATTCT pentanucleotide repeats) and functional data
(SARA, Berg, FIM and Lawton IADL scores). After this evaluation, the individuals were
invited to participate in the study and were then assessed by one of the researchers
using the SF-36 v.2.
Data analysis
The data were analyzed using Microsoft Office Excel 2013® .
To identify the SF-36 domains with the greatest impairment, hypothesis tests were
run, in which the mean score in each SF-36 domain was compared with the cutoff (50
points). A 5% significance level was used. T-tests for equal means with unequal variances
were used to confirm the hypotheses.
To confirm the hypothesis that the variables disease duration, Berg, SARA, FIM and
Lawton IADL influenced the magnitude of any increase or decrease in QoL in each SF-36
domain, the correlation between each pair of variables was analyzed with ANOVA at
a 5% significance level. When a statistically significant result was obtained, the
linear regression equation was determined and the regression line drawn on the scatter
plot. The line was fitted using the least squares method, and the linear relationship
was identified as either positive or negative. Pearson's correlation coefficient was
also calculated for all the SF-36 domains so that the correlation between the variables
could be classified as weak, moderate or strong. Descriptive statistics including
mean, standard deviation and variance were also calculated.
To analyze the SARA results (which were not obtained for one individual), the technique
of replacing the median was used to preserve part of the sample variability and interfere
as little as possible with the variable analyzed.
RESULTS
The mean age of the 15 individuals with SCA10 in the study was 43.8 (± 8.3) years,
mean age of symptom onset 33.1 (± 9.0) years and mean disease duration 9.8 (± 11.2)
years. The mean score on the Berg Balance Scale was 47.2 (± 12), and four individuals
were considered dependent and needed a mobility aid when walking. Of these, three
used a walking aid, and one refused to use an aid. The mean SARA score (n = 14) was
11.5 (± 7.3). The mean Lawton IADL score was 20.4 (± 1.8); six individuals were independent,
three dependent for one item, and six dependent in two to four items. The items for
which the most individuals were dependent were “housekeeping”, “shopping” and “mode
of transportation”.
The mean FIM score was 120.3 (± 5.4); seven individuals were independent, five were
dependent for one area and three were dependent for two to three areas. The areas
with the most dependent individuals were “expression”, “social interaction” and “stairs”.
Considering the means of the scores, most of the study population was independent
in ADL and partially dependent in IADL, had a low fall risk (independent balance)
and mild ataxia. Demographic, clinical, laboratory and functional data for each individual
are shown in [Table 1 ].
Table 1
Demographic, clinical, laboratory and functional data (SARA, Berg, FIM and Lawton
IADL scores) for each individual.
Individual
Gender
Age
Profession
ATTCT expansion
Age of onset of symptoms
Disease duration
Walking aid
Berg score
SARA score
Lawton IADL score
FIM score
1
M
53
N
1960
38
15
Walker
13
25.5
16
113
2
M
31
Retired
*
28
3
No
55
**
19
117
3
F
39
Retired
*
30
9
No
52
12
20
118
4
M
38
Retired
*
36
2
No
49
7
18
120
5
F
42
Disability benefit
2120
37
5
No
56
9
20
122
6
F
46
N
2060
44
2
No
56
4
21
124
7
F
31
N
1900
27
4
No
56
3.5
21
124
8
M
55
Disability benefit
1980
23
32
Wheelchair
32
25.5
15
117
9
F
50
N
2160
46
4
No
53
12
19
124
10
F
52
Pensioner
2000
48
4
No
47
7
21
125
11
M
34
Driver
2560
29
5
No
56
3
21
126
12
F
51
N
1800
36
15
Walking stick
47
16
20
108
13
M
53
Disability benefit
1980
14
39
No
35
18
19
113
14
F
39
Administrative assistant
2304
31
8
No
53
11
21
115
15
M
43
N
1508
30
13
No
49
8.5
21
124
M: Male; F: Female; N: not working; ATTCT expansion: ATTCT pentanucleotide repeat
expansion;
*awaiting genetic test; Berg: Berg Balance Scale; SARA: Scale for the Assessment and
Rating of Ataxia;
**Individual could not be assessed with SARA scale; Lawton IADL: Instrumental Activities
of Daily Living (IADL) Scale; FIM: Functional Independence Measure (ADL).
[Table 2 ] shows the final scores for each of the eight SF-36 domains for each individual with
SCA-10. The scores were calculated according to the formulae in the SF-36 questionnaire.
The mean, standard deviation and variance for each domain are also given. Mean scores
for the domains “physical functioning”, “role-physical”, “role-emotional and “vitality”
were below 50, corresponding to poor quality of life. However, to test the significance
of these means, the t-test for equal means with unequal variances was used. This revealed
that the only domain for which the difference was statistically significant was “role-physical”,
highlighting the reduced quality of life in this domain in individuals with SCA-10.
Table 2
Final SF-36 scores for individuals (1 to 15) with SCA10 and mean, standard deviation,
variance and p value.
SF-36
Domain
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
M
SD
V
p-value
PC
Physical functioning
29
39
29
14
84
64
89
9
84
64
99
19
14
24
49
47.3
31.0
959.5
0.372
Role-physical
55
0
30
0
30
5
30
55
80
55
80
0
0
80
30
35.3
30.7
941.0
* 0.043
Bodily pain
99
99
50
21
63
41
40
99
99
61
99
31
30
99
41
64.8
30.8
948.2
0.042
General health
46
46
56
51
61
51
31
24
51
91
46
84
31
39
66
51.6
18.5
341.5
0.371
MC
Role-emotional
80
0
47
47
0
0
0
80
80
80
80
0
0
0
0
32.9
37.9
1439.2
0.052
Vitality
74
29
49
19
19
19
39
19
69
79
69
84
54
29
49
46.7
23.9
571.0
0.299
Social functioning
86
24
74
99
49
11
49
99
99
99
99
74
11
11
24
60.5
36.6
1336.1
0.142
Mental health
63
51
51
39
27
47
63
91
99
71
67
71
67
39
43
59.3
19.7
387.4
0.045
SF-36: The Medical Outcomes Study 36- Item Short-Form Health Survey Version 2; PC:
Physical Component; MC: Mental Component; M: Mean; SD: Standard Deviation; V: Variance;
P value in relation to a mean of 50 - T-tests for equal means with unequal variances.
*Significant; SCA10: Spinocerebellar Ataxia type 10.
When ANOVA was used, and the linear regression model was fitted using least squares,
statistically significant relationships at the 5% level were found between the variables
of disease duration, Berg, SARA, FIM, Lawton IADL and the SF-36 domain “physical functioning”.
The coefficients of the straight lines identified in the linear regression in the
[Figure ] indicate whether the relationship between the variables is one of direct proportionality
(rising line) or inverse proportionality (falling line).
Linear regression between “physical functioning” and “disease duration” (A) and between
“physical functioning” and the SARA score (C) at the 5% significance level resulted
in fitted regression functions y = -1.6266x + 64.683 and y = -2.867x + 80.208 ([Figure ]). These indicate an inversely proportional correlation, i.e., an increase in the
SARA score and an increase in disease duration are associated with a lower score in
the “physical functioning” domain. A one-point increase in the SARA score and a one-year
increase in disease duration can be expected to correspond, respectively, to 2.86-point
and 1.62-point decreases in the score in the “physical functioning” domain ([Table 3 ]).
Figure Correlation between the “physical functioning” domain and (A) disease duration, (B)
balance (Berg), (C) severity of ataxia (SARA), (D) dependence in instrumental activities
of daily living (Lawton) and (E) dependence in basic activities of daily living.SARA:
Scale for the Assessment and Rating of Ataxia; Berg: Berg Balance Scale; Lawton: Lawton
Instrumental Activities of Daily Living (IADL) Scale; FIM: Functional Independence
Measure (ADL); r: Pearson's coefficient correlation; p: p-values for correlation shown.
Statistical findings: Test Anova; Linear regression with least squares method; Pearson's
correlation.
Table 3
SCA10 – Interpretation of the results of the linear regression analysis with least
squares method.
Variable
Interpretation
Disease duration vs. Physical functioning
A 1.62-point* decrease in Physical functioning score can be expected for a one-year increase in
disease duration.
SARA vs. Physical functioning
A 2.86-point* decrease in Physical functioning score can be expected for a 1-point increase in
the SARA score.
Berg vs. Physical functioning
A 1.37-point* decrease in Physical functioning score can be expected for a 1-point decrease in
the Berg score.
Lawton vs. Physical functioning
An 8.88-point* decrease in Physical functioning score can be expected for a 1-point decrease in
the Lawton score.
FIM vs. Physical functioning
A 4.49-point* decrease in Physical functioning score can be expected for a 1-point decrease in
the FIM score.
SARA: Scale for the Assessment and Rating of Ataxia; Berg: Berg Balance Scale; Lawton:
Lawton Instrumental Activities of Daily Living (IADL) Scale; FIM: Functional Independence
Measure (ADL).
*Scores present in the equations of the scatter plots of the Figure; SCA10: Spinocerebellar
Ataxia type 10.
Reduced quality of life in the “physical functioning” domain can be expected as disease
duration (A) and severity of ataxia (C) increase. The p values used are shown in the
[Figure ].
Linear regression between “physical functioning” and the “Berg” (B), “FIM” (E) and
“Lawton” (D) scores at the 5% significance level resulted in regression functions
y = 1.3767x - 17.738, y = 8.8807x - 125.54 and y = 4.4935x - 488.89 ([Figure ]). These indicate a positive correlation and that the variables are directly proportional,
i.e., a decrease in the Berg, FIM and Lawton IADL score will lead to a lower score
in the “physical functioning” domain. Decreases of 1.37, 8.88 and 4.49 in the “physical
functioning” score can be expected for one-point decreases in the Berg, Lawton IADL
and FIM scores, respectively ([Table 3 ]).
A reduction in QoL in the domain “physical functioning” is expected as a fall risk
(B), functional dependence for ADL (E) and dependence for IADL (D) increase. The p
values used are shown in the [Figure ].
The correlation coefficient (r) varies between 1 and −1. The closer r is to these
values, the stronger the correlation between the variables: r = 0.10 to 0.30 corresponds
to a weak correlation, r = 0.40 to 0.60 to a moderate correlation and r = 0.70 to
1 to a strong correlation. The same classification is used for negative values[16 ]. Pearson's correlation revealed statistically significant results at the 5% level.
Moderate correlations were identified between “physical functioning” and the disease
duration, SARA score, Berg score and Lawton IADL score and a strong correlation between
“physical functioning” and the FIM. The r values are shown in the [Figure ].
DISCUSSION
This study assessed the QoL of individuals with SCA10 and identified impairment in
the “role-physical” and “physical functioning” domains. Impairment in the latter was
associated with longer disease duration, functional dependence, ataxia severity and
fall risk. Although an understanding of how disease affects QoL is important for clinical
management, few authors have investigated this relationship in individuals with spinocerebellar
ataxias[17 ],[18 ],[19 ]. The concept of QoL covers physical and psychological health, level of independence,
social relationships, environment and beliefs[20 ]. According to Azevedo et al.[21 ], individuals with chronic nervous system diseases have a lower self-perception of
QoL than those with diseases in other systems.
Castilhos et al.[5 ] showed that Brazil has a considerable number of families with spinocerebellar ataxias
and included 359 in a study, most of them in southern Brazil. The present study assessed
individuals with SCA10 in southern Brazil, where this type of SCA is the second most
prevalent after SCA3.
The mean age of symptom onset in the study sample was 33 years, corroborating the
literature, in which a mean of 33–35 years has been reported[5 ],[22 ], and the individuals were young when they began to gradually lose their autonomy.
Two of them had had the disease for over 30 years. The different series of SCA10 patients
in the literature show that the mean disease duration is very variable, with a mean
survival of 13–20 years[5 ],[22 ],[23 ].
Although it is a generic instrument, the SF-36 is highly reliable, providing valid
data covering the patient's physical and mental health[24 ]. It has also been used by other authors for individuals with ataxia[19 ],[25 ]. The “role-physical” domain focuses on how difficulties in performing tasks at work
(reflected in, for example, fewer hours spent working) and ADL affect the QoL[26 ]. The “physical functioning” domain considers the limitations on performing physical
activities of different intensities[26 ].
The lower scores in the “role-physical” and “physical functioning” domains in this
sample corroborate the findings of Sánchez-López et al.[19 ]. Unlike the present study, which assessed individuals with SCA10, the study by Sánchez-López
et al.[19 ] assessed individuals with different types of ataxias, allowing the authors to observe
the impact of the disease in the “general health”, “vitality”, “bodily pain” and “social
functioning” domains. Tai et al.[23 ] observed a reduction in the QoL of individuals with Friedreich's ataxia in all domains
of the SF-36. The lower scores in the “role-physical” domain in the present study
may be related to the fact that most of the participants were not working, as only
two individuals kept their jobs. Work is one of the main activities carried out by
adults and, in addition to providing an income, it is associated with satisfaction,
social interaction, coexistence and personal fulfilment[27 ].
The lower scores in the “physical functioning” domain in the present study were related
to longer disease duration, corroborating the findings of Tai et al.[23 ]. As the symptoms of ataxia progress, the need for help from others increases. In
this sample, this was evidenced by the FIM scale for stairs, expression and social
interaction. No relationship was observed between the FIM cognitive aspects and the
SF-36 mental component, probably because of the sample size, as both the ability to
interact socially and to express oneself are considered in the “social role” domain
of the SF-36 and are important skills for the individual's well-being.
Dependence in more complex activities of daily living is associated with a lower QoL,
considering the “physical functioning” domain. The individuals in this sample were
independent for a single item on the Lawton IADL scale (responsibility for their own
medications), while activities such as housekeeping, shopping and traveling required
help from others. Moreira et al.[25 ], when assessing the QoL of individuals with Parkinson's disease, associated dependence
on others for ADL with a worse QoL.
In the present study, a greater severity of ataxia was associated with worse QoL in
the “physical functioning “ domain, corroborating the findings of Graves et al.[4 ]. These authors assessed individuals with episodic ataxia type 1 and observed that
those who had persistent ataxia also had worse ataxia severity and a longer disease
duration, as well as difficulties in performing ADL and an increase in falls. In addition,
all the SF-36 domains were below normal, particularly the “role-emotional”, although
the QoL was generally lower in the physical component.
In our study, there was a trend toward a correlation between QoL and the “role-emotional”
domain. Ten individuals had a final score below the average of 50 in the “role-emotional”
domain, indicating a low QoL, which may have been a result of the mild mood disorder
(depression) observed in individuals with SCA10 [28 ]. The fact that the other five patients had scores of 80 in this domain may explain
the lack of correlation with QoL in this sample.
The mean score on the Berg Balance Scale indicated a low fall risk in this sample.
Nevertheless, this score was associated with a worse QoL in the “physical functioning”
domain. A study by Filippin et al.[17 ] assessed balance in individuals with SCA3 and the relationship to all SF-36 domains.
They observed that a worse QoL in the “physical functioning” domain was associated
with a worse static and dynamic balance and even with a mean Berg score of 41.85,
showed a correlation with fall risk. According to Aizawa et al.[18 ], signs and symptoms other than ataxia (such as ataxia severity and greater functional
impairment) can influence static and dynamic balance.
In a study of 16 individuals with SCA2, Amarante et al.[29 ] described how balance, fall risk and ataxia severity evolved over one year of disease.
In our study, we found that for every year of disease there was a 1.62-point decrease
in the “physical functioning” score, reflecting an increase in disease severity, functional
dependence and fall risk.
The small population sample in this study prevented us separating the groups by age,
gender, disease duration, age of onset of symptoms, employment status and presence
of a caregiver, which may have enabled us to identify significant changes in other
SF-36 domains. Further studies with larger population samples are therefore required
to confirm our findings.
In conclusion, reduced QoL in individuals with SCA10 in this cohort was associated
with the “role-physical” and “physical functioning” domains. Self-perception of QoL
was influenced by disease severity, disease duration, balance impairment and level
of dependence on others for ADL and IADL.