The Ears of the Deaf Unstopped: Changes Associated with Cochlear Implantation

The Center for Applied Research on Childhood Deafness at Central Institute for the Deaf (St. Louis, MO) has been collecting data on the speech perception, speech production, language level, and reading skills of profoundly deaf children for over 30 years. A recent study examined children from across the United States and Canada who used cochlear implants. When these results are compared with those obtained in past studies with similar children who used hearing aids, the following trends are apparent: (1) Auditory speech perception ability has improved; (2) there is a stronger relation between auditory speech perception ability and oral communication; (3) there is a closer approximation to the language of hearing age-mates; (4) there is an increased use of speech by children in total communication programs; and (5) the acquisition of reading is accelerated. As Ira Hirsh predicted, even limited auditory skills play an important role in language development. This role is evidenced in the improved speech perception, spoken language and reading scores of profoundly deaf children who used cochlear implants compared to similarly impaired children who used hearing aids before implants were available.

KEYWORDS

Childhood deafness - cochlear implants - speech perception - language development

REFERENCES

• 1 Hirsh I J. The ears of the deaf unstopped.  Volta Rev. 1966;  68 623-633
• 2 Hirsh I J. Psychological aspects of early auditory education.  J R Soc Med. 1980;  73 611-616
• 3 Ling D. Advances underlying spoken language development.  Volta Rev. 1990;  92 8-20
• 4 Jordan I, Gustason G, Rosen R. An update on communication trends in programs for the deaf.  Am Ann Deaf. 1979;  125 350-357
• 5 Niparko JK, Kirk KI, Mellon NK, Robbins AM, Tucci DL, Wilson BS Cochlear Implants, Principles & Practices. Philadelphia, PA; Lippincott, Williams & Wilkins 2000
• 6 Kirk K I. Challenges in the clinical investigation of cochlear implant outcomes. In: Niparko JK, Kirk KI, Mellon NK, Robbins AM, Tucci DL, Wilson BS Cochlear Implants, Principles & Practices. Philadelphia, PA; Lippincott, Williams & Wilkins 2000: 225-259
• 7 Geers A, Brenner C. Speech perception results: audition and lipreading enhancement.  Volta Rev. 1994;  96 97-108
• 8 Geers A E, Moog J S. Effectiveness of cochlear implants and tactile aids for deaf children: the sensory aids study at Central Institute for the Deaf.  Volta Rev. 1994;  96
• 9 Geers A E, Brenner C. Background and educational characteristics of prelingually deaf children implanted by five years of age.  Ear Hear. 2003;  24(suppl) 2-14
• 10 Geers A, Spehar B, Sedey A. Use of speech and sign by children with cochlear implants educated in total communication programs.  Am J Speech Lang Pathol. 2002;  11 50-58
• 11 Geers A E, Moog J S. Speech perception and production skills of students with impaired hearing from oral and total communication education settings.  J Speech Hear Res. 1992;  35 1384-1393
• 12 Geers A E, Moog J S. Syntactic maturity of spontaneous speech and elicited imitations of hearing-impaired children.  J Speech Hear Dis. 1978;  43 380-391
• 13 Boothroyd A, Geers A, Moog J. Practical implications of cochlear implants in children.  Ear Hear. 1991;  12(suppl) 81-89
• 14 Geers A E, Moog J S, Schick B. Acquisition of spoken and signed English by profoundly deaf children.  J Speech Hear Dis. 1984;  49 378-388
• 15 Erber N P, Alencewicz C. Audiologic evaluation of deaf children.  J Speech Hear Dis. 1976;  41 256-267
• 16 Geers A E, Brenner C, Davidson L. Factors associated with development of speech perception skills in children implanted by age five.  Ear Hear. 2003;  24(suppl) 24-35
• 17 Moog J S, Geers A E. Early Speech Perception Test for Profoundly Deaf Children. St. Louis; Central Institute for the Deaf 1990
• 18 Owens E, Kessler D, Teleen E, Schubert E. Minimal Auditory Capabilities Battery, revised ed. St. Louis, MO; Auditec 1985
• 19 Tye-Murray N, Geers A. Childrens Audio-Visual Enhancement Test. St. Louis, MO; Central Institute for the Deaf 2001
• 20 Johnson R, Colonomos B, Futrell M, Eastman G, Knight D. Sign Language Use and Evaluation (faculty report). Washington, DC; Gallaudet College 1983
• 21 Moores D F, Sweet C. Factors predictive of school achievement. In: Moores DF, Meadow-Orlans KP Educational Developmental Aspects of Deafness. Washington, DC; Gallaudet University Press 1990: 154-201
• 22 Tye-Murray N. Conversational fluency of children who use cochlear implants.  Ear Hear. 2003;  24(suppl) 82-89
• 23 Erber N, Weiner F. Dyalog Communication Analysis Plus. West Bloomfield, MI; Parrot Software 1997
• 24 Lee L L. Developmental Sentence Analysis. Evanston, IL; Northwestern University Press 1974
• 25 Geers A, Nicholas J, Sedey A. Language skills of children with early cochlear implantation.  Ear Hear. 2003;  24(suppl) 46-58
• 26 Dunn L M, Dunn L M. Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test. Circle Pines, MN; American Guidance 1981
• 27 Carrow E. Test for Auditory Comprehension of Language-Revised. Allen, TX; DLM Teaching Resources 1985
• 28 Moog J S, Geers A E. Grammatical Analysis of Elicited Language-Simple Sentence Level. St. Louis, MO; Central Institute for the Deaf 1985
• 29 Traxler C B. The Stanford Achievement Test, 9th edition: National norming and performance standards for deaf and hard-of-hearing students.  J Deaf Stud Deaf Educ. 2000;  5 337-348
• 30 Moores D F, Sweet C. Factors predictive of school achievement. In: Moores DF, Meadow-Orlans KP Educational and Developmental Aspects of Deafness. Washington, DC; Gallaudet University Press 1990: 154-201
• 31 Lane H S, Baker D. Reading achievement of the deaf: another look.  Volta Rev. 1974;  76 489-499
• 32 Geers A E, Moog J S. Factors predictive of the development of literacy in profoundly hearing-impaired adolescents.  Volta Rev. 1989;  91 69-86
• 33 Moog J S, Geers A. EPIC: a program to accelerate academic progress in profoundly hearing-impaired children.  Volta Rev. 1985;  87 259-277
• 34 Geers A E. Predictors of reading skill development in children with early cochlear implantation.  Ear Hear. 2003;  24(suppl) 59-68