ASSESSMENT OF LANGUAGE STRUCTURE: FROM SYNTAX TO EVENT-BASED ANALYSIS

ABSTRACT

The last 70 years have seen much research and clinical attention devoted to the descriptions and assessment of children's developing language structures. From these efforts have evolved a number of ways to describe the kinds of structures children evidence at different stages of development, and thus the means to make comparisons across children or across time periods. This article reviews major trends that have emerged in syntactic descriptions and approaches to language habilitation, culminating in contemporary approaches that view syntactic structure in real life events rather than in artificial tasks or with arbitrary checklists. These new approaches allow us to determine the communication goals that are not being met rather than cataloging the syntactic structures that have not yet been mastered and provide us with the contexts for helping the children develop structures that will lead to clearer expression of meanings and fewer breakdowns in communication.

KEYWORD

analysis - language sampling - history of language assessment - communication functions - syntax

REFERENCES

• 1 McCarthy D. The language development of the preschool child. University of Minnesota Institute of Child Welfare Monograph 4 Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press; 1929
• 2 Murchison C, Langer S. Tiedmann's observations on the development of the mental faculties of children.  Pedagog Semin J Genet Psychol . 1927;  34 205-230
• 3 Gale M C, Gale H. Children's vocabularies.  Pop Sci Mthly . 1901;  61 45-51
• 4 Gale M C, Gale H. Vocabularies of three children of one family to two-and-one-half years of age.  Psychol Stud . 1906;  1 70-117
• 5 Bateman W G. A child's progress in speech.  J Ed Psychol . 1914;  5 307-320
• 6 Brandenburg G C, Brandenburg J. Language development during the fourth year.  Pedagog Semin . 1916;  23 14-29
• 7 Nice M. Length of sentences as a criterion of a child's progress in speech.  J Ed Psychol . 1925;  16 370-379
• 8 Smith M E. An investigation of the development of the sentence and extent of vocabulary in young children.  Univ Iowa Stud Child Welfare . 1926;  3
• 9 Piaget J. Language and thought of the child.  New York: Harcourt Brace; 1926
• 10 Davis E A. The development of linguistic skill in twins, singletons with siblings, and only children from age five to ten years. University of Minnesota Institute of Child Welfare Monograph 14 Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press; 1937
• 11 Templin M C. Certain language skills in children: Their development and interrelations. University of Minnesota Institute of Child Welfare Monograph 26 Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press; 1957
• 12 Williams H M. An analytical study of language achievement in preschool children.  Univ Iowa Stud Child Welfare . 1937;  13 9-18
• 13 Brain M DS. The ontogeny of English phrase structure: The first phrase.  Language . 1963;  39 1-13
• 14 Brown R, Bellugi U. Three processes in the child's acquisition of syntax.  Harvard Educational Review . 1964;  34 133-151
• 15 Miller W, Ervin S. The development of grammar in child language. In: Bellugi U, Brown R, eds. The acquisition of language. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development 1964: 92
• 16 Bloom L. Language development: Form and function of emerging grammars. Cambridge: MIT Press 1970
• 17 Chomsky N. Aspects of theory of syntax. Cambridge: MIT Press 1965
• 18 Bates E, MacWhinney B. A functionalist approach to the acquisition of gramar. In: Ochs E, Schieffelin BB, eds. Developmental pragmatics San Diego: Academic Press 1979: 167-211
• 19 Lee L. Northwestern Syntax Screening Test.  Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press; 1971
• 20 Menyuk P. Comparison of grammar of children with functionally deviant and normal speech.  J Speech Hear Res . 1969;  7 112-113
• 21 Carrow E. Carrow elicited language inventory.  Austin, TX: Learning Concepts; 1974
• 22 Brown R. A first language: The early stages.  Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press; 1973
• 23 MacWhinney, B. Grammatical devices for sharing points. In: Schiefelbusch R, Pickar J, eds. The acquisition of communicative competence Austin, TX: Pro-Ed 1984: 323-374
• 24 Duchan J F, Lund N J. Situated pragmatics. American Speech-Language-Hearing Association Convention, Boston 1997