Open Access
CC BY 4.0 · Indian Journal of Neurosurgery
DOI: 10.1055/s-0044-1793945
Case Report

Squamous Cell Carcinoma Arising in an Epidermoid Cyst of Cavernous Sinus: A Rare Occurrence

Ashvini Kolhe
1   Department of Pathology, Seth G S Medical College and KEM Hospital, Parel, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India
,
Tanvi Gaitonde
1   Department of Pathology, Seth G S Medical College and KEM Hospital, Parel, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India
,
Ayushi Dubey
1   Department of Pathology, Seth G S Medical College and KEM Hospital, Parel, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India
,
Asha Shenoy
1   Department of Pathology, Seth G S Medical College and KEM Hospital, Parel, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India
› Author Affiliations
 

Abstract

Epidermoid cysts (ECs) account for 0.2 to 1.8% of all intracranial tumors and are even rarer in the cavernous sinus. They are benign with a favorable prognosis following surgical resection, but rarely can undergo malignant transformation to squamous cell carcinoma (SCC). We hereby report the first case of SCC arising in an EC of the cavernous sinus. A 40-year-old woman presented with recurrent cyst in the left cavernous sinus. Thirteen years ago, she underwent a surgery for EC at the same site. Histopathology of the recent resection showed features of a primary SCC arising from the EC, fulfilling the Garcia criteria for malignant transformation. SCCs usually involve the brain as a manifestation of metastases from a primary located elsewhere in the body or as a result of direct local spread from a head and neck primary. Primary intracranial SCCs are rare and usually arise from malignant transformation of benign epithelial cysts. It may present itself at the initial clinical presentation or may develop following a variable lag period (3 months to 33 years) after resection of a previous benign cyst and has a dismal prognosis. Clinically, rapid deterioration, recurrence, or failure to recover following surgery for a benign cyst along with contrast-enhanced computed tomography or magnetic resonance imaging findings on the lesion should raise suspicion for malignant transformation.


Introduction

An epidermoid cyst (EC) is slow-growing lesion of developmental origin, accounting for 0.2 to 1.8% of all the intracranial tumors. It arises from the aberrant inclusions of the ectodermal remnants that fail to regress between the third and fifth weeks of intrauterine life after completion of neural embryogenesis.[1] The most frequent locations of their occurrence are the cerebellopontine angle (CPA), parasellar region, middle cranial fossa, and prepontine cistern, and are extremely rare in the cavernous sinus.[2] They are benign but rarely can undergo malignant transformation to squamous cell carcinoma (SCC). This transformation has not yet been reported in the cavernous sinus. By far, intracranial SCC manifests as metastases from a primary, located outside the central nervous system or as a result of direct local spread from a head and neck primary.[3] Herein, we report a case of SCC occurring in the cavernous sinus, 13 years after complete excision of an EC at the same site, after ruling out known primary anywhere else in the body.


Case History

A 40-year-old woman presented with left-sided headache, diplopia, and drooping of the left eye for the past 15 days and was found to have oculomotor nerve palsy. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the brain revealed a 15 × 14 × 11 mm mass with diffusion restriction in the left cavernous sinus suggestive of an EC with a 25 × 25 × 24 mm nonenhancing solid component ([Fig. 1]). She had a history of similar complaints 13 years ago when she was diagnosed with EC at the same site. She underwent complete excision and its histopathology confirmed an EC, showing benign stratified squamous epithelial lining, abundant lamellated keratin, and foreign body giant cells. The present excision revealed an SCC composed of atypical squamous epithelial cells arranged in trabeculae and papillae ([Fig. 2A]). Cells showed abundant cytoplasmic keratinization ([Fig. 2B]) with hyperchromatic and pleomorphic nuclei. Mitoses were brisk ([Fig. 2C]). The foci of necrosis were noted ([Fig. 2D]). There was no other primary on clinical examination and imaging. The patient was then referred for radiotherapy but did not take the same and expired 1 year after the operation.

Zoom
Fig. 1 A 40-year-old woman with squamous cell carcinoma in the cavernous sinus presented with headache, diplopia, and drooping of the left eye. Axial T2 and diffusion weighted magnetic resonance imaging showed a mass lesion measuring 15 × 14 × 11 mm with diffusion restriction (red arrow).
Zoom
Fig. 2 (A) Atypical squamous cells arranged in trabeculae and papillae (×40, hematoxylin and eosin [H&E] stain). (B) Cells showing abundant cytoplasmic keratinization (×400, H&E). (C) Cells showing pleomorphic nuclei, prominent nucleoli, and brisk mitosis (×400, H&E). (D) Tumor with necrosis (×100, H&E).

Discussion

ECs are benign, lined by stratified squamous epithelium and contain abundant keratin with variable amount of chronic inflammation. Among intracranial locations, the cavernous sinus is a rare site. In 2018, Zhou et al published the largest case series of 31 cases of ECs of the cavernous sinus. According the study, most of them were located in the parasellar region in the middle cranial fossa with a mean age of occurrence at 46 years.[2]

Malignant transformation of benign cyst was predominant in males.[4] ECs in the cavernous sinus generally present with facial numbness, absent corneal reflex, temporal muscle atrophy, and trigeminal neuralgia followed by abducens or oculomotor nerve deficits such as diplopia.[2] Our case had a similar presentation.

Malignant transformation of EC was first described by Ernst in 1912[5] at the CPA. The largest review of literature was published in 2012 by Nagasawa et al,[1] who reviewed a total of 58 cases of malignant transformation in intracranial EC. The most frequently involved site was the CPA, but no case was seen in the cavernous sinus.[1] To date, 85 cases of SCC occurring in the EC have been reported ([Table 1]).

Table 1

Literature review of SCCs arising in intracranial ECs from 1912 to date

Sl. no.

Year

Study

Age (y)

Sex

Location

Time to progression

1

1912

Ernst et al[5]

52

M

CPA

2

1942

Hug et al[8]

42

M

CPA

3

1951

Henkel et al[9]

49

M

CPA

4

1955

Yamanaka et al[10]

57

M

Base of brain

4 mo

5

1960

Davidson and Small et al[11]

46

M

Frontal

3 mo

6

1960

Landers and Danielski et al[12]

73

F

Frontal

1 mo

7

1964

Komjatszegi et al

45

F

CPA

8

1965

Fox et al[13]

43

M

Temporal

7 y

9

1965

Toglia et al[14]

54

M

Base of brain

1 y

10

1977

Koempf and Menges et al[15]

57

F

Parapontine

11

1981

Dubois et al[16]

53

M

Fourth ventricle

4 mo

12

1982

Takado et al[17]

53

F

Parapontine

13

1983

Lewis et al[18]

53

F

Parasellar

3 y

14

1984

Bondeson and Falt et al[19]

56

F

CPA

15

1984

Giangaspero et al[20]

45

M

Parieto-occipital

16

1986

Maffazzoni et al[21]

45

M

Fronto-basal

17

1986

Kubokura et al[22]

60

F

Temporal

18

1987

Salazar et al[23]

49

M

CPA

19

1987

Matsuno et al[24]

43

M

CPA

1 y

20

1987

Goldman and Gandy[25]

59

F

Intraventricular

33 y

21

1988

Ishimatsu et al[26]

40

M

CPA

22

1989

Nishiura et al[27]

38

M

CPA

23

1989

Michenet et al[28]

40

M

Latero-peduncular

24

1989

Abramson et al[29]

37

M

CPA

25

1990

Gi et al[30]

39

M

CPA

1 y

26

1991

Knorr et al[31]

74

M

CPA

31 y

27

1991

Tognetti et al[32]

67

F

Temporal lobe

31 y

28

1992

Delangre et al[33]

71

F

CPA

29

1993

Acciarri et al[34]

62

M

Parasellar

30

1994

Radhakrishnan et al[35]

53

M

Frontal

31 y

31

1995

Fuse et al[36]

74

F

CPA

32

1995

Nishio et al[37]

57

M

CPA

1 y

33

1995

Uchino et al[38]

57

M

CPA

1.5 y

34

1995

Mori et al[39]

42

M

CPA

3 mo

35

1996

Bayindir et al[40]

67

F

Intraventricular

8 mo

36

1996

Mohanty et al[41]

20

M

Posterior fossa

37

1999

Murase et al[42]

50

F

CPA

12 y

38

2000

Ishikawa et al[43]

65

M

CPA

39

2000

Sawan et al[44]

66

M

Prepontine

40

2001

Asahi et al[45]

55

F

CPA

13 y

41

2001

Khan et al[46]

53

M

Prepontine

6 mo

42

2001

Nawashiro et al[47]

46

M

Temporal lobe

43

2002

Link et al[48]

57

F

CPA

11 y

44

2002

Hatem et al[49]

40

M

Frontotemporal

45

2003

Akar et al[50]

F

CPA

1.5 y

46

2003

Monaco et al[51]

36

M

Cisterna magna

6 mo

47

2003

Hamlat et al[4]

54

F

Temporal lobe

3 y

48

2003

Shirabe et al[52]

49

F

Ventral pons

1.5 y

49

2004

Guan et al[53]

42

F

Temporal

17 y

50

2005

Michael et al[54]

45

M

Prepontine

1 mo

51

2006

Kodama et al[55]

67

M

CPA

8 y

52

2006

Tamura et al[6]

56

F

CPA

13 y

53

2006

Ge et al[56]

50

M

Temporal

6 y

54

2007

Pagni et al[57]

65

F

Pineal region

1 mo

55

2007

Agarwal et al[58]

45

M

Posterior fossa

1 mo

56

2008

Kim et al[59]

72

F

CPA

57

2008

Hao et al[60]

61

F

CPA

6 y

58

2009

Ge et al[61]

44

M

Right temporal lobe

6 y

59

2010

Nakao et al[62]

74

F

CPA

20 y

60

2010

Kano et al[63]

64

F

Parapontine

16 y

61

2010

Hao et al[64]

61

F

Right CPA

6 y

62

2011

Lakhdar et al[65]

52

M

CPA

6 y

63

2012

Chon et al[66]

43

M

CPA

27 y

64

2014

Vellutini et al[67]

43

F

CPA

24 y

65

2016

Solanki et al[68]

47

F

CPA

36 y

66

2016

Pikis et al[69]

77

M

CPA

12 y

67

2017

Ozutemiz et al[70]

64

M

Lat ventricle

23 y

68

2017

Mascarenhas et al[71]

35

F

CPA

5 y

69

2018

Kwon et al[72]

35

M

Left CPA

70

2019

Cuoco et al[3]

71

M

CPA

40 y

71

2019

Demuth et al[73]

67

F

CPA

72

2019

Fereydonyan et al[74]

30

M

CPA

5 y

73

2019

Gerges et al[75]

65

F

Pineal

74

2020

Romesberg et al

52

M

Left CPA

6 mo

75

2021

Zuo et al[76]

39

M

CPA

76

54

F

Suprasellar

77

43

M

CPA

78

44

M

CPA

3 y

79

51

M

CPA

80

48

M

CPA

15 y

81

61

M

CPA

28 y

82

61

M

CPA

83

60

M

CPA

5 y

84

2021

Sakamoto et al[77]

59

F

Right CPA

6 y

85

2023

Zhang et al[78]

58

M

Right frontoparietal lobe

Abbreviations: CPA, cerebellopontine angle; EC, epidermoid cyst; F, female; M, male; SCC, squamous cell carcinoma.


No case of malignant transformation in EC has been reported in the cavernous sinus, thus making this the first report of such transformation.

The mechanism of malignant transformation has not been well known, but certain hypotheses suggest that subtotal resection of the cyst wall or chronic inflammation from ruptured cyst contents or introduction of foreign material intraoperatively leads to metaplasia and carcinoma.[1] [4] Malignant transformation may present itself at the initial presentation or may develop following a variable lag period of 3months to 33 years after resection of the previous benign cyst.[6]

Garcia's criteria for malignant transformation state that the tumor must be restricted to the intracranial, intradural compartment without extension beyond the dura or cranial bones and there should not be any invasion or extension through intracranial orifices. There should be no communication with the middle ear, air sinuses, sella turcica, and no evidence of nasopharyngeal tumor. Hamlat et al proposed additional criteria of the presence of benign squamous epithelium within the malignant tumor and the need for ruling out metastases.[7]

ECs are totally resected by an extradural/interdural approach as it causes less chances of brain or cranial nerve injury, but often, complete capsule removal cannot be achieved and postoperative complications such as chemical meningitis and seizures due to chemical irritation are known to occur. For intracranial SCCs, adjuvant radiotherapy and chemotherapy have proven to improve survival.[1] [2]

Our patient underwent a left temporal craniotomy and total excision. Radiotherapy was advised, but she did not take the same and expired 1 year after the operation.


Conclusion

Malignant transformation of an EC is a rare event with dismal prognosis. This is the first case of an EC of the cavernous sinus to undergo malignant transformation to SCC after 13 years of primary resection. Clinically, rapid deterioration postexcision without hydrocephalus, recurrence, or failure to recover following surgery for a benign cyst along with contrast-enhanced computed tomography or MRI findings of the lesion should raise the suspicion for malignant transformation.



Conflict of Interest

None declared.


Address for correspondence

Asha Shenoy, MD
Department of Pathology, Seth G S Medical College and KEM Hospital
Mumbai, Parel, Mumbai, Maharashtra
India   

Publication History

Article published online:
10 June 2025

© 2025. The Author(s). This is an open access article published by Thieme under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, permitting unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction so long as the original work is properly cited. (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/)

Thieme Medical and Scientific Publishers Pvt. Ltd.
A-12, 2nd Floor, Sector 2, Noida-201301 UP, India


Zoom
Fig. 1 A 40-year-old woman with squamous cell carcinoma in the cavernous sinus presented with headache, diplopia, and drooping of the left eye. Axial T2 and diffusion weighted magnetic resonance imaging showed a mass lesion measuring 15 × 14 × 11 mm with diffusion restriction (red arrow).
Zoom
Fig. 2 (A) Atypical squamous cells arranged in trabeculae and papillae (×40, hematoxylin and eosin [H&E] stain). (B) Cells showing abundant cytoplasmic keratinization (×400, H&E). (C) Cells showing pleomorphic nuclei, prominent nucleoli, and brisk mitosis (×400, H&E). (D) Tumor with necrosis (×100, H&E).