Keywords endodontically treated teeth - custom post core - finite element analysis
Introduction
In endodontically treated teeth, whose clinical crown is weakened or completely missing,
where except function, we must ensure complex aesthetic requirements, the therapeutic
choice is the fabrication of a custom post core as a foundation for prosthetic crowns.[1 ]
[2 ]
[3 ]
[4 ] The custom post core will ensure safe and long-term retention of fixed-prosthetic
work and enable the proper transfer of occlusal load on the entire root and surrounding
supporting tissues.[3 ]
[4 ] Today's possibilities include two therapeutic options: the use of custom post core
or a prefabricated post. The amount of remaining ferrule and tooth structure is a
determining factor in this choice. In a case of a greater or complete failure of a
clinical crown, the choice of therapy is custom cast post core,[5 ] which enables close contact with the dentin walls, following its morphology, and
evenly transmits occlusal forces to the remaining part of the root and the supporting
tissues.[6 ]
[7 ] The remaining supragingival tooth structure at a height of 1 to 2 mm increases stability
and resistance to fracture due to better load distribution.[8 ]
[9 ]
[10 ] The vertical axial tooth structure that will be covered by the artificial crown
is called metal ring or “Ferrule effect.”[9 ]
[11 ] Sorensen and Engelman define the “Ferrule effect” as a 360 degrees metal ring or
collar of the artificial crown surrounding the parallel dentine walls in the cervical
part of the crown.[12 ] It is considered better to have even a partial ferrule effect rather than a complete
lack.[13 ]
[14 ] Custom cast post cores can be made of different alloys; they have a high resistance
to fracture but also significantly higher modulus of elasticity than dentin. Due to
the large difference between the modulus of elasticity of metal alloys compared with
dentin, their use can cause stress on the root structures that can result in tooth
root fracture.[15 ]
[16 ] Opposite of that some studies confirmed that the increased modulus of elasticity
of the post reduces the stress in the dentin.[11 ]
[17 ] These facts are supported by studies with a follow-up period of 19.5 and 25 years,
which indicate the longevity of teeth restored with custom cast post core.[18 ]
[19 ] Some authors presented those materials with a lower modulus of elasticity, such
as fiber-reinforced composite posts (FRC posts), which lead to lower stress on the
root structures and reduce the risk of root fracture, but have limited application
in case of greater tooth destruction and lower resistance to fracture than custom
cast post core.[5 ]
[20 ]
[21 ] If there is not enough coronary tooth structure or the ferrule effect is insufficient,
the use of FRC posts is not indicated. In that case, they present quite high stresses
in the cervical region due to their flexibility and the presence of a less stiff core
material.[15 ]
[22 ] To achieve long-term therapy success, new materials were introduced as an option
for the custom post core. One of these materials is polyether ether ketone (PEEK),
a high-performance biocompatible polymer presented as a new dental material. Due to
its good resistance to fracture and ability to absorb dynamic masticatory forces,
it is considered an alternative to metal.[23 ]
[24 ]
[25 ] PEEK has a low modulus of elasticity (4–6 GPa) and enables the absorption of functional
stresses by transmitting the forces to the tooth-supporting tissue, which is why some
authors recommend them for making endo-crowns in significantly weakened teeth and
to patients with parafunctions.[26 ]
[27 ]
[28 ] Its advantage is also the possibility of combining with other materials such as
carbon fibers or glass fiber that greatly improve mechanical properties especially
modulus of elasticity.[27 ]
[28 ]
[29 ] PEEK composites reinforced with carbon fibers (CFR-PEEK) have elastic modulus 18 GPa
and PEEK composites reinforced with glass fiber (GFR-PEEK) have approximately 12GPa.[27 ]
[28 ]
[29 ]
Today, they are used in dentistry for healing caps, temporary abutments, implant-supported
prostheses, other dental restorations, and computer-aided design/computer-aided manufacturing
framework fabrication. Considering the biocompatibility, good mechanical characteristics,
and the possibility of fabrication processing including milling and pressing, this
makes this material attractive to produce individual custom posts.[24 ]
[25 ]
[28 ]
[29 ]
[30 ]
[31 ]
However, there is a small number of studies on this new high-performance PEEK polymer
as a custom post core material, which will be analyzed in this research.
Aim of Study
The aim of this study is, by using the finite element analysis (FEA), to evaluate
the biomechanical behavior of custom post core made of six different materials, on
mandibular first premolar with and without the ferrule effect, under different masticatory
loads.
Materials and Methods
The mandibular first premolar was scanned by micro-computed tomography scanner (SkyScan
1076 Kontich, Belgium). Three-dimensional modeling was performed using Siemens NX
and Dassault System Catia software packages. The resulting model consisted of enamel,
dentin, pulp, periodontal ligament, and reconstructed segment of alveolar bone. Using
the AnsysWorkbench program package, a mesh of a complex model was formed, by dividing
the tooth model into finite elements: for volumetric bodies mesh type Solid 187, for
contact areas mesh type Targe 170 and Conta 174, and for boundary conditions and the
area of force action network type Surf 154. When creating the model, the size of the
basic element was 0.2 [mm], so the model consisted of 254.781 nodes or 143.664 elements
([Fig. 1 ]). Two types of models were made: teeth with custom post core, with and without ferrule.
To compare the stress distribution in different custom post core, six different materials
were chosen: zirconia, Ni-Cr alloy, gold alloy, GFR-PEEK, PEEK, and CFR-PEEK. A zirconia
fully-anatomical crown of the mandibular first premolar was modeled. A layer of glass
ionomer cement with a thickness of 0.1 mm was also modeled, which was located between
the custom post and the root dentin as well as the extra coronal part of custom post
and the zirconia crown. The materials used in this research are linearly elastic,
homogeneous, and isotropic. Since the intensity of occlusal force and teeth contact
surface is extremely variable, two occlusal contact types were chosen. The stress
of the simulated axial and oblique load was 200 N[32 ]
[33 ]
[34 ]
[35 ] ([Fig. 2A ] and [B ]). The values of the measured stress are shown by von Mises criteria that are a formula
for combining the three principal stresses into an equivalent stress. Properties of
the tooth tissues and used materials are given in [Table 1 ].[17 ]
[23 ]
[30 ]
[36 ]
[37 ]
[38 ]
[39 ]
[40 ]
[41 ]
[42 ]
[43 ] The results obtained by the FEA represent the stress distribution values measured
on dental tissues and custom post core. All research results are presented graphically
with numerical stress values (on the left side of the image) and in tables. Standard
statistical tests do not apply to this type of research.
Table 1
Properties of the tooth tissues and used materials in 3D model
Material
Young's modulus of elasticity (GPa)
Poisson's coefficient
Reference
Dentin
18.6
0.31
[36 ]
Periodontal ligament
0.05
0.49
[37 ]
Alveolar bone
13.7
0.30
[38 ]
Glass ionomer cement
4
0.35
[39 ]
Zirconia
210
0.32
[40 ]
[41 ]
Ni-Cr alloy
203
0.30
[42 ]
Gold alloy
95
0.33
[17 ]
GFR-PEEK
12
0.40
[23 ]
[30 ]
PEEK
5.1
0.30
[30 ]
[43 ]
CFR-PEEK
18
0.39
[23 ]
[30 ]
Abbreviations: 3D, three-dimensional; CFR-PEEK, carbon fiber-polyether ether ketone;
GFR-PEEK, glass fiber-polyether ether ketone; PEEK, polyether ether ketone.
Fig. 1 Finite element mesh.
Fig. 2 (A ) Axial tooth load and (B ) oblique tooth load. CFR-PEEK, carbon fiber-polyether ether ketone.
Results
Von Mises stress values obtained in MPa are presented in tables and figures (images)
with numeric values (on the left side of the image). The highest concentration of
stress under axial load was measured in a zirconia post of 61.8 MPa in teeth with
a ferrule and 62.8 MPa in teeth without a ferrule ([Tables 2 ] and [4 ]). Under oblique load, measured stress values in a zirconia post were 191.7 MPa in
teeth with ferrule and 192.5 MPa in teeth without ferrule ([Tables 3 ] and [5 ], [Fig. 3A ]–D). Under an axial load, the measured stress of the Ni-Cr alloy was 60.6 MPa in
teeth with the ferrule and 62.1 MPa without ferrule ([Tables 2 ] and [4 ]). Under oblique load, the stress in the Ni-Cr alloy post was 187.3 MPa in teeth
with ferrule and 188.1 MPa in teeth without ferrule ([Tables 3 ] and [5 ]).
Fig. 3 (A –D ) Stress distribution in the custom post core and dentin without ferrule under two
types of loading.
Table 2
Stress values under axial load in the cast post core and dentin with ferrule
Von Mises stress
CFR-PEEK
Zirconia
Cr-Ni alloy
GFR-PEEK
PEEK
Gold alloy
Post (MPa)
9.4992
61.768
60.565
6.7665
3.5429
36.291
Dentin (MPa)
28.665
29.590
29.577
28.601
29.898
29.234
Abbreviations: CFR-PEEK, carbon fiber-polyether ether ketone; GFR-PEEK, glass fiber-polyether
ether ketone; PEEK, polyether ether ketone.
Table 3
Stress values under oblique load in the cast post core and dentin with ferrule
Von Mises stress
CFR-PEEK
Zirconia
Cr-Ni alloy
GFR-PEEK
PEEK
Gold alloy
Post (MPa)
28.420
191.650
187.34
22.577
14.330
101.29
Dentin (MPa)
55.93
48.315
48.301
59.416
69.424
49.200
Abbreviations: CFR-PEEK, carbon fiber-polyether ether ketone; GFR-PEEK, glass fiber-polyether
ether ketone; PEEK, polyether ether ketone.
Table 4
Stress values under axial load in the cast post core and dentin without ferrule
Von Mises stress
CFR-PEEK
Zirconia
Cr-Ni alloy
GFR-PEEK
PEEK
Gold alloy
Post (MPa)
9.7457
62.794
62.137
7.7526
5.1363
37.816
Dentin (MPa)
31.661
32.905
32.890
31.548
31.458
32.459
Abbreviations: CFR-PEEK, carbon fiber-polyether ether ketone; GFR-PEEK, glass fiber-polyether
ether ketone; PEEK, polyether ether ketone.
Table 5
Stress values under oblique load in the cast post core and dentin without ferrule
Von Mises stress
CFR-PEEK
Zirconia
Cr Ni alloy
GFR-PEEK
PEEK
Gold alloy
Post (MPa)
29.523
192.49
188.17
22.764
13.999
101.58
Dentin (MPa)
57.359
51.071
51.059
60.232
70.699
51.148
Abbreviations: CFR-PEEK, carbon fiber-polyether ether ketone; GFR-PEEK, glass fiber-polyether
ether ketone; PEEK, polyether ether ketone.
Stresses measured in the dentin of teeth with a ferrule effect under oblique loading
with a zirconium and CR-Ni alloy post were equal (48.3 MPa). Stress in dentin with
a gold post was 49 MPa, which is approximately 1.6 times higher compared with the
stress of dentin under axial force ([Table 3 ]). Slightly higher stress was measured in dentin under paraxial load in CFR-PEEK
post of 56 MPa, and GFR of 59.4 MPa, which is approximately two times higher compared
with axial force. The highest stress values were measured in dentin with a PEEK post
of 69.4 MPa, which is 2.3 times higher than the stress obtained under axial force
([Table 3 ], [Fig. 4A ]–[D ]). Posts with a higher modulus of elasticity in teeth with a ferrule effect under
paraxial loading produced lower stress values in the dentin. In gold alloy post, whose
modulus of elasticity is twice as low compared with zirconia and Ni-Cr alloy, the
stress of 36.3 MPa was measured in teeth with ferrule and 37.8 MPa without ferrule
([Tables 2 ] and [4 ]). Under oblique load, the measured stress in the gold alloy post was 101.3 MPa for
teeth with ferrule and 101.6 Mpa without the ferrule ([Tables 3 ] and [5 ]). Posts made from PEEK, CFR-PEEK, GFR PEEK, and PEEK showed the lowest measured
stress values under axial load, 3.5 MPa for teeth with a ferrule, and 5.1 MPa without
ferrule ([Tables 2 ] and [4 ]). Under oblique load, the measured stress in a PEEK post was 14.3 MPa in teeth with
ferrule and 14 MPa without ferrule. The measured stress in posts under oblique load
was approximately three times higher compared with axial load ([Tables 3 ] and [5 ], [Fig. 4A ]–[D ]). Stress measured in dentin in teeth with ferrule effect under axial load was equal
in teeth with zirconia post and Ni-Cr alloy post of 29.6MPa, followed by stress in
teeth with gold alloy post of 29.2 MPa. CFR-PEEK and GFR-PEEK posts had slightly lower
stress in dentin, 28.7 MPa, while the PEEK post caused a slightly higher dentin stress
of 30 MPa ([Table 2 ]). Differences in obtained stress values in dentin in teeth with a ferrule effect
after application of different types of custom post core under axial load did not
prove to be significant, considering that the difference in stress values was only
1 to 2 Mpa ([Fig. 5A ]–[F ]).
Fig. 4 (A –D ). Stress distribution in the custom post core and dentin with ferrule under two types
of loading. PEEK, polyether ether ketone.
Fig. 5 Total stress distribution in the tooth under oblique load with six tested materials:
(A ) CFR-PEEK, (B ) zirconium, (C ) Cr-Ni, (D ) GFR-PEEK, (E ) PEEK, and (F ) gold alloy. CFR-PEEK, carbon fiber-polyether ether ketone; GFR-PEEK, glass fiber-polyether
ether ketone; PEEK, polyether ether ketone.
The measured stress values in the cement layer are five times higher under paraxial
loading. Differences in stress values measured in cement when using different post
core systems are considered insignificant.
Total stress distribution in the tooth under oblique load with six tested materials
(CFR-PEEK, zirconium, Cr-Ni, GFR-PEEK, PEEK, gold alloy) was shown in [Table 6 ].
Table 6
Total stress in the tooth under oblique load with 6 tested cast post cores (MPa)
CFR-PEEK
Zirconia
Cr-Ni alloy
GFR-PEEK
PEEK
Gold alloy
114.4
192.49
188.17
157.7
130.09
101.58
Abbreviations: CFR-PEEK, carbon fiber-polyether ether ketone; GFR-PEEK, glass fiber-polyether
ether ketone; PEEK, polyether ether ketone.
Discussion
During the restoration of endodontically treated teeth with an appropriate post that
differs from the natural dental tissues, there is a change in stress distribution
within the dental structures.
The mandibular first premolar is a specific tooth in form and function. It could be
considered as a transitional form between the lower canine and the mandibular second
premolar because it has some characteristics of both. Due to the lingual inclination
of its crown, its occlusal surface does not lie perpendicular to the long axis of
the root. Having in mind the prominent crown inclination of the first mandibular premolar
and its specific contact area, it is easy to pose the question on their contribution
to the mechanism of the distribution of occlusal forces.[44 ]
The anatomy of premolars and the location of the masticatory load may increase the
fracture likelihood of restorations.[45 ]
Posts have different rigidity and modulus of elasticity from dental tissues, which
could be the reason for stress concentration within the tooth root structure.[30 ]
[46 ]
[47 ]
[48 ]
[49 ] The FEA indicates maximum stress locations and identifies areas that could lead
to failure of restorations. von Mises stress shows how stress is transferred within
a body structure, without specifying its compressive or tensile nature.[50 ] In this research, the obtained stress in the custom post core is proportional to
the increase in the modulus of elasticity of the material, while the stress in the
dentin is inversely proportional to the modulus of elasticity. Similar results are
presented by de Andrade et al who concluded that the stress values in the post increase
with the increase in the elastic modulus of the material.[51 ] The results of Nahar et al. are similar to our results, where the CFR-PEEK post
had stress values of 6.7 MPa, GFR-PEEK of 4.5 MPa, and PEEK of 2.2 MPa. With CFR-PEEK,
due to its higher modulus of elasticity, dentin stress values of 20.2 Mpa were recorded,
which is slightly less (0.2 Mpa) than the stress obtained on teeth with other custom
post cores. The values of the occlusal load by Nahar et al were 100N, while in our
study the values were 200 N.[30 ] In the study by Jafari et al, similar stress values were measured in the root dentin
of Ni-Cr alloy posts and zirconia posts. The use of FRC posts in teeth without ferrule
results in lower stress values along the post, but higher stress in the simulated
region of the tooth, which supports the conclusion that their use is not indicated
in teeth without a ferrule.[5 ]
[11 ]
[22 ] Durmuş and Oyar state that the highest stress values in the weakened root were measured
in the tooth with carbon fiber post, while the Ni-Cr alloy posts showed the lowest
stress values in the weakened root. The authors conclude that materials with a high
modulus of elasticity cause less stress in the weakened root, but greater stress in
the post itself.[52 ] Dejak and Młotkowski, Nishioka et al, Eskitaşcioǧlu et al, and Asmussen et al reported
that increased modulus of elasticity of the post reduces stress in dentin. FRC post
produced higher stress transmitted to the surrounding dentin compared with the Ni-Cr
post. The authors state that teeth restored with cast post cores have a higher fracture
resistance than teeth restored with FRC posts.[17 ]
[40 ]
[53 ]
[54 ] In endodontically treated teeth laboratory strength tests show that a statistically
higher force is required to cause tooth fracture restored with individual cast posts
compared with FRC posts.[55 ]
[56 ] The results of Badami et al showed that custom post cores made of different materials
lead to lower stresses compared with prefabricated posts.[57 ] In our study, the stress measured in the dentin of teeth without ferrule effect
under axial load was slightly higher in all tested materials compared with teeth with
ferrule. The measured stress in dentin for the zirconium and the Ni-Cr alloy post
was 33 MPa, gold alloy post 32.5 MPa, CFR-PEEK, and GFR-PEEK posts 31.6 MPa, and PEEK
posts 31.5 MPa, respectively ([Table 4 ]). Obtained stress values in dentin under oblique load in teeth without a ferrule
with zirconia, Cr-Ni, and gold alloy post were 51 MPa, CFR PEEK 57.3 MPa, GFR-PEEK
60 MPa, while the highest stress recorded in the dentin was with the PEEK post 70.6
MPa ([Table 5 ]). Posts with a higher modulus of elasticity (zirconium, Cr-Ni, and gold) caused
approximately 7 to 10 MPa less stress in the dentin than the CFR and GPR posts, and
for approximately 20 MPa less stress than PEEK post under paraxial load in teeth without
ferrule effect ([Table 5 ]). The results of our research are in accordance with Sarkis-Onofre et al who proved
that posts with a high modulus of elasticity show better performance in teeth that
do not have a ferrule effect.[58 ] Teeth without ferrule effect have slightly higher measured stress values for all
types of custom post core, which confirms their use in case of greater loss of tooth
tissue, considering that they evenly transfer the load to the root and the supporting
structures.[6 ]
[7 ] The better adaptability of the custom cast post helps in resistance to torsional
stress and rotational forces.[59 ] Teeth with ferrule and cast metal posts are the most resistant to fracture.[60 ] Due to its composition, zirconium posts cannot be etched with hydrofluoric acid,
nor can it be silanized due to its resistance to acids and the lack of silicon dioxide
content,[61 ]
[62 ] so they do not achieve a micromechanical bond with the composite types of cement.
In recent years, various surface treatments have been proposed, such as airborne particle
abrasion with alumina particles, tribochemical silica coating tribochemical silica
coating, laser irradiation, or chemical etching, which lead to an increase in the
surface roughness of zirconium oxide, improving the micromechanical bond between cement
and zirconia.[63 ]
[64 ]
[65 ]
[66 ]
[67 ]
[68 ] However, various studies have reported possible damage to the surface of zirconia
caused by air-abrasion methods.[66 ]
[67 ]
[69 ] To overcome this problem, alternative methods are introduced such as chemical promoters
and zirconium-specific organophosphate/carboxylic acid monomer resin cements, which
are considered chemical surface treatments.[67 ]
[70 ] However, hydrolytic degradation is still problematic, as is the bond of zirconia
to composite cement.[67 ] Zirconia custom post core and peek custom post core can be made with CAD/CAM technology
using “additive” or “subtractive” manufacturing methods.[59 ] CAD/CAM technology reduces the number of patient visits to the office and allows
faster production of dental restorations with higher mechanical strength compared
with hand-made ceramic restorations.[71 ] Due to the weak connection and adaptation of zirconia custom post core with composite
types of cement, there is a possibility of the zirconia post falling out of the root
canal, which gives an advantage to custom cast metal post cores. Custom cast metal
post cores can be made with conventional technology and CAD/CAM technology as well.
Studies by Chen et al and Hendi et al reported that CAD/CAM post core required less
time to manufacture than custom cast post core, but custom cast post core had better
adaptation in the root canal.[72 ]
[73 ] The use of CAD/CAM technology in the production of custom post core represents alternatives
to conventional techniques, but there is not enough data on their clinical success,
so long-term clinical studies are necessary to confirm their success.[59 ] PEEK has only recently been introduced as an alternative treatment option to many
conventional methods. PEEK custom post core, which had the lowest modulus of elasticity,
but due to the highest values of the measured stress in the dentin, is not recommended
for use in the restoration of endodontically treated teeth. PEEK material reinforced
with carbon and glass fibers has proven to be a better choice in the therapy of endodontically
treated teeth, due to better mechanical properties and lower stress within the dentin.
It is possible to consider their application in frontal teeth with ceramic crowns
in situations where the aesthetic factor is dominant. However, there is still little
data on their application. The total stress in the tooth supplied with the custom
post core was the lowest with gold alloy, followed by PEEK materials, then Ni-Cr,
while the highest total stress was measured in the tooth with zirconia post ([Table 6 ], [Fig. 5A ]–[D ]).
Conclusion
The stress in the custom post core under axial load is proportional to the increase
in the modulus of elasticity of the material. The highest stress was measured in the
zirconia post and the lowest in the PEEK post under both types of loads in teeth with
and without the ferrule effect. The measured stress in the custom post core under
oblique load is approximately three times higher compared with axial load. Custom
post cores with a higher modulus of elasticity produced less stress in the dentin
under oblique loading. The lowest stress in the dentin under paraxial load was produced
by the zirconia and post made of Cr-Ni alloy and the highest by the PEEK posts. In
teeth without the ferrule effect, slightly higher stress values were measured both
in the custom post core and in the dentine for both types of loading. The use of custom
cast post cores made of different alloys is recommended in restoration of endodontically
treated teeth, with extensive loss of tooth structure especially in teeth without
ferrule effect. Randomized controlled studies must be conducted to obtain data on
the clinical behavior of PEEK and fiber-reinforced PEEK materials and their use in
endodontically treated teeth.
Limitations of the Study
The structures and materials used in this research are considered to be linearly elastic,
homogeneous, and isotropic, which is different from the natural structure of teeth
and supporting tissues. In this research, a static load was applied, while in real
clinical situations, there is always a dynamic loading, which leads to fatigue of
the material and eventual fracture of the root.