Keywords
SARS-CoV-2 spike gp - molecular mimicry - peptide sharing - cross-reactivity - immunologic
imprinting - autoimmune - infantile diseases
Introduction
Recently, researchers and clinicians called attention on the issue of vaccinating
newborns and children against severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2)
to protect from coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19). Pros and cons have been examined
and discussed in light of the following data:
-
Children account only for 1.7 to 2% of the diagnosed cases of COVID-19.[1]
-
COVID-19 in children shows a milder disease course and better prognosis than adults.
Mortality is extremely low.[2]
-
COVID-19 is deadlier for aged people than for other age groups.[3]
-
Severe manifestations of COVID-19 in adults comprehend dyspnea, respiratory failure,
pneumonitis, thromboembolic events, cardiogenic shock, renal injury, ischemic strokes,
encephalitis, and cutaneous eruptions.[4]
-
In contrast, severe manifestations of COVID-19 in children appear to be associated
only with an uncommon, somewhat serious but tractable inflammatory disorder, that
is, the so-called multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (MIS-C). MIS-C is
rarest and rarely is fatal. Indeed, Ergenc et al[5] reported that among 1,340 patients aged between 0 and 216 months and diagnosed with
COVID-19, only 6 patients had MIS-C, which corresponds to a MIS-C incidence of 0.4%.
None of the patients died. In parallel, Payne et al[6] reported that MIS-C incidence per 1,000,000 SARS-CoV-2 infections was 316.
-
Moreover, and crucially, an analysis of the potential risk of autoimmune cross-reactivity[7]
[8]
[9]
[10]
[11]
[12]
[13]
[14]
[15]
[16]
[17] lacks while it should be compulsorily included in the benefit–risk assessment of
SARS-CoV-2 vaccination in children.
Then, the present study aims at exploring (or excluding) the possibility that molecular
mimicry and the consequent potential cross-reactivity may exist between SARS-CoV-2
and human proteins that are linked, when altered, to infantile diseases, so that targeting
the viral antigen via vaccination might equate to hit human proteins linked to childhood
pathologies.
Materials and Methods
Peptide sharing between SARS-CoV-2 spike glycoprotein (gp) (NCBI, GenBank Protein
Accession Id = QHD43416.1) from SARS-CoV-2 and human proteins related to childhood
diseases was analyzed as previously detailed[9]
[10] using the pentapeptide as minimal immune determinant unit. Pentapeptides were used
as sequence probes since a peptide grouping composed of five amino acid (aa) residues
defines a minimal immune unit that can (1) induce highly specific antibodies and (2)
determine antigen–antibody-specific interaction.[18]
[19] A library of 372 human proteins linked—when altered—to pediatric diseases was obtained
from UniProt database (www.uniprot.org)[20] using the keyword “infantile.” The 372 proteins are listed in [Supplementary Table S1] (online only).
CoV controls were as follows, with NCBI:txid number in parentheses: Middle East respiratory
syndrome (MERS)-CoV (1335626); human (H) CoV-229E (11137); HCoV-NL63 (277944).
Methodologically, the SARS-CoV-2 spike gp primary aa sequence was dissected into pentapeptides
offset each other by one residue (i.e., MFVFL, FVFLV, VFLVL, FLVLL, and so forth)
and the resulting viral pentapeptides were analyzed for occurrences within the human
proteins related to infantile diseases. Peptide Match and Peptide Search programs
available at www.uniprot.org20
were used.
The immunologic potential of the peptides shared between SARS-CoV-2 spike gp and proteins
related to childhood diseases was analyzed by searching the Immune Epitope Database
(IEDB, www.iedb.org/)21
for immunoreactive SARS-CoV-2 spike gp-derived epitopes hosting the shared pentapeptides.
Finally, pentapeptides common to SARS-CoV-2 spike gp–derived epitopes and human proteins
related to infantile diseases were additionally controlled for occurrences in the
following bacterial pathogens listed with NCBI:txid number in parentheses: Bordetella pertussis (257313), Corynebacterium diphtheriae (257309), Clostridium tetani (212717), Haemophilus influenzae (71421), and Neisseria meningitides (122586).
Results and Discussion
Molecular Mimicry between SARS-CoV-2 Spike gp and Human Proteins Related to Infantile
Diseases
[Table 1] shows that SARS-CoV-2 spike gp shares a high number of minimal immune determinants
(namely, 54) with 43 human proteins that associate with infantile disorders when altered,
mutated, or, however, improperly functioning. The following points emerge from [Table 1]:
Table 1
Peptide sharing between SARS-CoV-2 spike gp and human proteins related to infantile
diseases
Peptides[a]
|
Human proteins, pathologies, and references[b]
|
TECSN
|
ANTR2. Anthrax toxin receptor 2
Juvenile hyaline fibromatosis and infantile systemic hyalinosis[22]
|
GAGAAA
|
ARX. Homeobox protein ARX
Lissencephaly associated with abnormal genitalia[23]
|
DIAAR
|
AT1A2. Sodium/potassium-transporting ATPase subunit α-2
Alternating hemiplegia of childhood. Epilepsy[24]
[25]
|
SFELL
|
CLN6. Ceroid-lipofuscinosis neuronal protein 6
Seizures, dementia, visual loss, and/or cerebral atrophy[26]
|
NSVAY
|
CO1A1. Collagen α-1(I) chain
Osteogenesis imperfecta/Ehlers–Danlos' syndrome[27]
|
TLLAL
|
COX15. Cytochrome c oxidase assembly protein homolog
Microcephaly, encephalopathy, hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, lactic acidosis, respiratory
distress, hypotonia and seizures[28]
|
FLLKY
|
CTNS. Cystinosin
Late-onset juvenile or adolescent nephropathic cystinosis[29]
|
NLLLQ, VPVAI, AGTIT
|
DPOG1. DNA polymerase subunit gamma-1
Juvenile-onset Alpers' syndrome and status epilepticus[30]
|
SEPVL
|
FRMD7. FERM domain-containing protein 7
Infantile nystagmus syndrome[31]
|
EDLLF, LQELGK
|
GLSK. Glutaminase kidney isoform, mitochondrial
Neonatal epileptic encephalopathy[32]
|
SSVLN
|
HCN1. Potassium/sodium hyperpolarization-activated cyclic nucleotide-gated channel
1
Infantile epileptic encephalopathy[33]
|
YLQPR
|
MTU1. Mitochondrial tRNA-specific 2-thiouridylase 1
Mitochondrial infantile liver disease[34]
|
SLLIV
|
NALCN. Sodium leak channel nonselective protein
Hypotonia, speech impairment, intellectual disability, pyramidal signs, and chronic
constipation[35]
|
IAGLI, VDCAL, LLQYG
|
NBAS. Neuroblastoma-amplified sequence
Growth retardation, senile face, and optic atrophy[36]
|
GVVFL
|
NEUR1. Sialidase-1
Sialidosis: cherry red macular spots in childhood, progressive debilitating myoclonus,
insidious visual loss[37]
|
VCGPK, NASVV
|
NPC1. NPC intracellular cholesterol transporter 1
Infantile Niemann–Pick type C disease[38]
|
LVLLPL
|
NPT2A. Sodium-dependent phosphate transport protein 2A
Hypercalcemia, failure to thrive, vomiting, nephrocalcinosis[39]
|
GGFNF, AGAAA
|
NUP62. Nuclear pore glycoprotein p62
Infantile bilateral striatal necrosis[40]
|
EMIAQ, LVDLP
|
OPA1. Dynamin-like 120 kDa protein, mitochondrial
Lethal encephalopathy, cardiomyopathy optic atrophy[41]
|
KSFTV
|
PCD19. Protocadherin-19
Seizure, cognitive impairment, and delayed development of variable severity. Mainly
affects females[42]
|
EVRQI, KVTLA
|
PEX1. Peroxisome biogenesis factor 1
The peroxisome biogenesis disorders include: Zellweger's syndrome, neonatal adrenoleukodystrophy,
infantile Refsum's disease, and rhizomelic chondrodysplasia punctata[43]
|
SASFS, FLVLLP
|
PEX12. Peroxisome assembly protein 12
See above[43]
|
VLLPL
|
PEX26. Peroxisome assembly protein 26
See above[43]
|
LHSTQD
|
PEX6. Peroxisome assembly factor 2
See above[43]
|
LIAIV
|
PIGP. Phosphatidylinositol N-acetylglucosaminyltransferase subunit P
Developmental and epileptic encephalopathy[44]
|
LQPEL
|
PRRT2. Proline-rich transmembrane protein 2
Recurrent and brief attacks of abnormal involuntary movements, triggered by sudden
voluntary movement[45]
|
QIAPG
|
PTH2. Peptidyl-tRNA hydrolase 2, mitochondrial
Global developmental delay, hypotonia, hearing loss, ataxia, hyporeflexia, hypothyroidism,
and pancreatic insufficiency[46]
|
DLFLP
|
RMND1. Required for meiotic nuclear division protein 1
Neonatal hypotonia and lactic acidosis. Affected individuals may have respiratory
insufficiency, seizures[47]
|
KRVDF
|
RPB1. DNA-directed RNA polymerase II subunit RPB1
Hypotonia and intellectual and behavioral abnormalities[48]
|
PGDSS
|
SC6A3. Sodium-dependent dopamine transporter
Infantile parkinsonism-dystonia[49]
|
NLAAT
|
SCN1A. Sodium channel protein type 1 subunit α
Generalized epilepsy with febrile seizures persisting beyond the age of 6 y and/or
a variety of afebrile seizure types[50]
|
NLAAT
|
SCN2A. Sodium channel protein type 2 subunit α
Benign infantile epilepsy[51]
|
NLAAT
|
SCN3A. Sodium channel protein type 3 subunit α
Epilepsy with focal seizures arising from temporal, frontal, parietal, occipital lobes[52]
|
NLAAT, DPLSE
|
SCN8A. Sodium channel protein type 8 subunit α
Delayed cognitive and motor development, attention deficit disorder, and cerebellar
ataxia[53]
|
VVLSF, NLDSK
|
SIAT6. CMP-N-acetylneuraminate-β-1,4-galactoside α-2,3-sialyltransferase
Significantly below average general intellectual functioning associated with impairments
in adaptive behavior[54]
|
LQPRT
|
SIAT9. Lactosylceramide α-2,3-sialyltransferase
Salt and pepper syndrome with seizures, psychomotor delay, cortical blindness. Patches
of skin hypo- or hyperpigmentation[55]
|
QSLLI
|
SLF2. SMC5-SMC6 complex localization factor protein 2
Infantile-onset spinocerebellar ataxia[56]
|
GRLQS
|
SPTN2. Spectrin β chain, nonerythrocytic 2
Spinocerebellar ataxia[57]
|
SASFST
|
STXB1. Syntaxin-binding protein 1
Developmental and epileptic encephalopathy[58]
|
FIAGL
|
SUCA. Succinate-CoA ligase subunit α, mitochondrial
Infantile onset of hypotonia, lactic acidosis, severe psychomotor retardation, progressive
neurologic deterioration[59]
|
LADAG
|
SYLC. Leucine–tRNA ligase, cytoplasmic
Infantile liver failure syndrome[60]
|
LPLVS
|
SZT2. KICSTOR complex protein SZT2
Developmental and epileptic encephalopathy[61]
|
DSLSS
|
TPP1. Tripeptidyl-peptidase 1
Spinocerebellar ataxia[62]
|
Abbreviations: gp, glycoprotein; SARS-CoV-2, severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus
2.
a Hexapeptides derived from overlapping pentapeptides are given in bold.
b Human proteins given by UniProt entry and name are in italic. Further details and
references on related pathologies are available in PubMed, OMIM, and UniProt databases.
-
The unexpectedly high molecular mimicry described in [Table 1] and the consequent potential cross-reactivity support the hypothesis that several
diseases might occur in children following exposure to the SARS-CoV-2 antigen.
-
Mathematically, the vastness of the common molecular platform stands out when one
considers that the probability for 2 proteins to share 1 pentapeptide on the basis
of the 20 aa and neglecting the relative aa abundance is equal to 1 out of 20 raised
to 5. That is, it is equal to 0.0000003125.
-
Such unexpected massive peptide commonality between SARS-CoV-2 antigen gp and the
human proteome indicates and confirms a strict phenetic relationship between viruses
and the origin of eukaryotic cells according to the endosymbiotic theory.[63]
-
Pathologically, the diseasome that might occur via cross-reactivity includes severe
disorders such as nephropathies, seizures, cardiomyopathies, parkinsonism-dystonia,
global developmental delay, hypotonia, hearing loss, ataxia, hyporeflexia, hypothyroidism,
pancreatic insufficiency, and lethal encephalopathy, inter alia.
Immunologic Potential of the Peptide Sharing between SARS-CoV-2 Spike gp and Human
Proteins Related to Infantile Diseases
The cross-reactivity potential of the peptide sharing described in [Table 1] appears to be supported by inspection of IEDB (www.iedb.org).[21] Indeed, all the 54 minimal immune determinants common to SARS-CoV-2 spike gp and
human proteins related to infantile diseases occur and repeatedly recur in 839 SARS-CoV-2
spike gp–derived epitopes, of which [Table 2] displays only a synopsis in the interest of brevity. In essence, [Table 2] validates, likely enough, the cross-reactivity hypothesis at the basis of the present
study.
Table 2
Immunoreactive SARS-CoV-2 spike gp-derived epitopes containing pentapeptides shared
between SARS-CoV-2 spike gp and human proteins linked to infantile diseases: a synopsis
IEDB ID[a]
|
Epitope sequence[b]
|
IEDB ID[a]
|
Epitope sequence[b]
|
3589
|
aphGVVFLhv
|
1325536
|
tLADAGfik
|
4321
|
asaNLAATk
|
1327418
|
vydpLQPELdsf
|
16156
|
FIAGLIAIV
|
1327824
|
wtAGAAAyy
|
23200
|
GVVFLhvty
|
1327836
|
wtfGAGAAl
|
36724
|
litGRLQSl
|
1329248
|
dEMIAQytsal
|
37289
|
llfnKVTLA
|
1330227
|
tqDLFLPff
|
37724
|
LLQYGsfct
|
1330420
|
aphGVVFL
|
50166
|
pyrvVVLSF
|
1330526
|
lynSASFSTf
|
51999
|
qpyrvVVLSF
|
1331519
|
EDLLFn
|
57592
|
SEPVLkgvkl
|
1332003
|
fvFLVLLPL
|
57792
|
sfiEDLLFnk
|
1332424
|
itGRLQSlqty
|
59161
|
slidLQELGK
|
1332664
|
lltdEMIAQy
|
71996
|
vydpLQPEL
|
1332702
|
LQELGKyeqy
|
1074967
|
lepLVDLPi
|
1332727
|
ltdEMIAQyt
|
1075065
|
stqDLFLPff
|
1332785
|
mfvFLVLLPLVSs
|
1309147
|
YLQPRTfll
|
1333450
|
SASFSTfkcy
|
1310623
|
ltdEMIAQy
|
1333520
|
SFELLhapatv
|
1311673
|
EVRQIAPGqt
|
1333523
|
sfiEDLLF
|
1311846
|
SFELL
|
1333568
|
sKRVDFcgkgy
|
1313244
|
nSASFSTfk
|
1333801
|
sTECSNLLLQy
|
1314425
|
alDPLSEtk
|
1333812
|
stqDLFLPf
|
1315940
|
epLVDLPi
|
1333921
|
tdEMIAQy
|
1316323
|
fdeddSEPVL
|
1334182
|
vgYLQPRTf
|
1317916
|
gYLQPRTfll
|
1390229
|
VDCALDPLSEtkctlks
|
1320443
|
lgaeNSVAY
|
1541124
|
KRVDFcgk
|
1321078
|
LPLVSsqcv
|
1546420
|
fiEDLLFnk
|
1322298
|
NASVVniqk
|
1547648
|
gYLQPRTfl
|
1323200
|
QELGKyeqy
|
1593850
|
YLQPRifll
|
1323249
|
QIAPGqtgk
|
1597683
|
fiEDLLFnkv
|
1323750
|
rasaNLAATk
|
1625440
|
ssvLHSTQ
|
1325401
|
TECSNLLLQy
|
1659240
|
fvFLVLLPLv
|
Abbreviations: gp, glycoprotein; IEDB, Immune Epitope Database; SARS-CoV-2, severe
acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2.
a Epitopes listed according to the IEDB ID number. Details and references for each
epitope are available at www.iedb.org/.21
b Shared peptides are given capitalized.
Specificity of the Peptide Sharing between SARS-CoV-2 Spike gp and Human Proteins
Linked to Infantile Diseases
To control the specificity of the peptide sharing between SARS-CoV-2 spike gp and
human proteins linked to childhood diseases ([Table 1]), the 54 shared pentapeptides were analyzed for occurrences in other coronaviruses
not associated with particular pediatric complications, that is, MERS-CoV, HCoV-OC43,
and HCoV-229E. Results are shown in [Table 3] that provides evidence that the intense peptide overlap between SARS-CoV-2 spike
gp and human proteins related to childhood diseases is highly specific. De facto, almost all the 54 shared pentapeptides are absent in the CoV controls, that is,
in the pathogenic MERS-CoV[64] as well as in the scarcely pathogenic HCoV-OC43 and HCoV-229E that cause only mild
symptoms.[65]
Table 3
Quantitation of the pentapeptide sharing between CoVs spike gps and human proteins
linked to childhood diseases
Spike gp from:
|
Number of shared pentapeptides
|
SARS-CoV-2
|
54
|
MERS-CoV
|
−
|
hCoV-229E
|
−
|
hCoV-NL63
|
2
|
Abbreviations: CoV, coronavirus; gp, glycoprotein; h, human; MERS, Middle East respiratory
syndrome; SARS-CoV-2, severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2.
Occurrence in Bacteria of Peptides Common to SARS-CoV-2 Spike gp and Proteins Linked
to Infantile Diseases
To further control the specificity of the peptide sharing between SARS-CoV-2 spike
gp and human proteins linked to childhood diseases, comparative sequence analyses
were extended to the bacterial pathogens B. pertussis, C. diphtheriae, C. tetani, H. influenzae, and N. meningitides—that is, bacteria to which children may be exposed also following current vaccinal
routes—were analyzed. Results are displayed in [Table 4].
Table 4
Occurrences in bacterial pathogens of pentapeptides shared between SARS-CoV-2 spike
gp and human proteins linked to infantile diseases
Organism
|
Shared pentapeptides
|
B. pertussis
|
AGAAA, AGTIT, DIAAR, DSLSS, FIAGL, FLVLL, GAGAA, GVVFL, KVTLA, LADAG, LIAIV, LPLVS,
LQELG, LVDLP, NASVV, NLAAT, QELGK, SLLIV, VLLPL
|
C. diphtheriae
|
AGAAA, AGTIT, GAGAA, LADAG, VPVAI
|
C. tetani
|
AGAAA, AGTIT, DLFLP, EVRQI, FIAGL, LLQYG, LQELG, NASVV, SSVLN
|
H. influenzae
|
AGAAA, AGTIT, DIAAR, EVRQI, GAGAA, GGFNF, GVVFL, IAGLI, KRVDF, LADAG, LIAIV, LPLVS,
LQELG, LVDLP, LVLLP, NASVV, NLAAT, NLDSK, NLLLQ, NSVAY, QELGK, QIAPG, QSLLI, SFELL,
SLLIV, SSVLN, TLLAL, VLLPL, VPVAI, VVLSF
|
N. meningitidis
|
AGAAA, ASFST, EVRQI, FIAGL, FLVLL, GAGAA, KRVDF, LADAG, LQELG, LQPEL, NLDSK, QELGK,
TLLAL, VLLPL, VVLSF
|
Abbreviations: gp, glycoprotein; SARS-CoV-2, severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus
2.
It can be seen that many of the 54 peptides shared between SARS-CoV-2 spike gp and
human proteins linked to infantile diseases also occur in the analyzed microbial organisms,
thus highlighting that, contrary to expectations, while practically no phenetic similarity
exists between SARS-CoV-2 spike gp and the control CoVs ([Table 3]), a high level of similarity exists between SARS-CoV-2 spike gp and bacterial pathogens
to which children have been exposed via passive/active infection and by which the
immune system has already been imprinted ([Table 4]).
Then, as highlighted in the literature,[66]
[67]
[68]
[69]
[70]
[71]
[72] the interpathogen peptide commonality can add a further potential burden to the
molecular mimicry phenomenon described in [Table 1]. Indeed, a fundamental property of the immune system is the memory for immune determinants
previously encountered so that, as a rule, the immune system reacts by recalling memory
of the responses toward past infections rather than producing ex novo responses toward the recent ones.
Consequently, in the case under study here, the following sequence of events may unfold:
-
A primary response to SARS-CoV-2 can actually occur as a secondary (or even tertiary)
response against pathogens previously encountered and memorized by the immune system.
That is, anamnestic secondary antibacterial responses can occur after exposure to
SARS-CoV-2. Such anamnestic secondary antibacterial responses will be of considerable
proportions given the extent of the viral versus bacterial peptide overlap described
in [Table 4].
-
SARS-CoV-2 antigen will not be affected in that the immunologic memory deflects the
immune response toward the already encountered peptides, that is, the bacterial peptide
platform detailed in [Table 4].
-
However, also the attack against the early sensitizing bacterial pathogens can fail
by being the early sensitizing bacterial pathogens no more present in the organism.
-
Then, the ultimate result might be that the anamnestic, high affinity, high avidity,
and extremely potent secondary immune response elicited by the lastly encountered
pathogen—that is, SARS-CoV-2—can hit the only available targets, that is, the common
immune determinants that in this instance are present in the human proteins related
to infantile diseases ([Table 1]).
According to this sequence of events, molecular mimicry and immunologic memory might
explain also the different pathological outcomes of the autoimmune responses—from
mild symptoms to even lethal pathologies—that may follow exposure to SARS-CoV-2. In
practice, the history of infections/immunization of each child is the main factor
dictating the onset and the severity of the pathologies outlined in [Table 1].
Conclusion
The present study investigates the possible adverse events that might occur in newborns
and children following exposure to SARS-CoV-2. Based on the extensive peptide sharing
between SARS-CoV-2 gp antigen and human proteins related to infantile diseases, supported
by epitopic data that confer a high immunoreactivity to the peptide sharing, and given
the possibility of immunologic imprinting phenomena, this study leads to predict that
exposing newborns and children to SARS-CoV-2 might associate with infantile severe
diseases such as growth retardation, abnormal genitalia, epilepsy, seizures, cardiomyopathies,
hypotonia, visual loss, hypercalcemia, ataxia, infantile parkinsonism-dystonia, below
average general intellectual functioning, encephalopathies, and inter alia. Then,
the present data suggest that extreme caution be exercised in planning and implementing
a mass anti-SARS-CoV-2 vaccination of infants and children.