Introduction
The new guidelines of the German Stroke Society (Deutsche Schlaganfallgesellschaft,
DSG) for the treatment of acute stroke and the revision of the Stroke OPS 8-981 and
8-98b, in which neurological ultrasound diagnostics is no longer an obligatory diagnostic
procedure if CT or MR angiography is available during treatment in the stroke unit
will have a significant impact on standard of care. This article will describe the
specific diagnostic potential of neurovascular ultrasound in the early phase of the
cerebral infarction and will present this procedure as an indicator of high quality
and competence in neurovascular treatment.
Since five large randomized trials have demonstrated the efficacy of thrombectomy
in patients with occlusions of the distal internal carotid artery and the proximal
middle cerebral artery, there is a need to rethink stroke treatment in stroke units
and neurovascular centers and to organize in stroke networks. While in the past intravenous
IV thrombolysis required only a simple clinical neurological score, an appropriate
time window, preclusion of contraindications including computed tomography to rule
out cerebral hemorrhage, now vascular diagnosis with detection of intracranial vessel
occlusion has become a central issue in the diagnosis of acute cases. The revitalized
interest in the neurovascular status is advantageous not only for the approx. 5% thrombectomy
candidates, but also benefits all stroke patients, including the approximately 20%
patients with so-called “stroke mimics” diagnosed and treated on our stroke units.
With good reason, the 24/7 availability of neurovascular ultrasound diagnosis is deemed
“mandatory” by the German Stroke Society for stroke unit certication and was found
to be “absolutely” necessary by a majority of international stroke researchers according
to a recent survey [1]
[2].
Basic Parameters of Stroke Diagnostics
Basic Parameters of Stroke Diagnostics
When it comes to treatment of acute stroke, neurovascular sonography is the only diagnostic
instrument in the hands of the treating neurologist. Otherwise, the indication for
CT and MRI examination can only be formally provided by radiologists or neuroradiologists
and relevant specialists. This also applies in particular to the prioritization of
examinations in the face of limited capacity. Stroke registry data show that ultrasound
diagnostics together with native CT are by far the most common means of diagnosis
in routine care. Ultrasound is widely available around the clock at all levels of
care, with no additional technical assistance required to maintain 24-hour readiness.
Administration of contrast agent such as required for CT or MR angiography (CTA or
MRA) with attendant risks (allergic reaction, renal failure, hyperthyroidism) can
generally be dispensed with, which makes the procedure safer, and the examination
can be performed at the patient’s bedside. High-quality color duplex sonography equipment
is now available for most neurologists, thus providing highly reliable and accurate
diagnosis.
Neurosonography, CT or MR angiography?
Neurosonography, CT or MR angiography?
In many cases, CTA, MRA and ultrasound are regarded as competing methods in stroke
care. In truth, however, these are complementary procedures that produce images representing
blood vessels, brain perfusion and blood flow based on very different physical principles.
One method or another is indicated, depending on the specific clinical issue. Likewise,
24-hour availability, therapeutic consistency and the ability of the patient to cooperate
also play a role. It is up to the clinically responsible neurologist to make the right
choice with respect to the therapeutic consequences.
Morphological imaging using ultrasound is based on the pulse-reflection behavior of
tissue. The measurement of flow velocity is based on the Doppler principle, according
to which moving objects in a sonic field cause a frequency shift. Color duplex sonography
combines both physical principles. It can be deduced from this that morphological
features of tissue and blood flow reflect a specific image that is fundamentally different
from other imaging methods.
The advantages of imaging methods are clearly shown in the rendering of vessel wall
diseases of the brain supplying arteries. Arteriosclerotic plaques, mobile thrombi
( Video 1), inflammation in Takayasu or giant cell arteritis can be displayed with ultrasound
in incomparably high spatial and temporal resolution. It is therefore useful to combine
different imaging methods to obtain precise information on the pathogenicity of vascular
disease or the dynamics of an occlusion process (see below).
Female patient with a transient ischemic attack. Thrombus in the lumen of the internal
carotid artery with ligulate fluttering distal tail. Above the round-oval depiction
of the jugular vein.
Reliability of Neurosonography
Reliability of Neurosonography
Transcranial color duplex sonography (TCCS) can identify occlusions of the large intracerebral
arteries of the circle of Willis with very high sensitivity and excellent specificity
[3]
[4]. Occlusion of the main stem of the middle cerebral artery should be assumed, if
the ipsi- and contralateral anterior cerebral artery or contralateral middle cerebral
artery but not the ipsilateral middle cerebral artery can be displayed. In the absence
of a temporal bone window and/or in order facilitate a rapid and valid diagnosis echo
enhancers may be employed [5]. As with any other sophisticated method, ultrasound diagnosis is also examiner-dependent.
This also applies to other angiographic procedures, ranging from the experience of
the medical technical radiological assistants (MTRA) in the positioning of the patient
and the measuring fields, timing of the contrast media bolus, selection of suitable
sequences through to assessment of the images by a radiologist who has completed a
multi-year specialty fellowship.
“Fast-Track” Examination
Diagnosis during the acute phase of cerebral infarction takes place under strict time
pressure. If vascular imaging using CT or even MRI is not initially possible, a rapid
ultrasound examination can determine the further procedure, e. g., whether an examination
is necessary with sedation or whether contrast medium should be administered despite
renal disease. Concretely, “fast-track” means that
-
the examination is focused on the symptomatic vascular territory,
-
relevant clinical competence is necessary for planning the steps of the examination,
-
the examination might be performed even after the start of therapy in order to ensure
the earliest possible initiation of treatment
-
despite time pressure, emergency diagnostics have to be performed both extra- and
intracranially,
-
color duplex sonography is used, which allows an anatomical overview and, in particular,
significantly simplifies and speeds up the diagnosis of vessel occlusions. In addition,
clear documentation of findings is possible at the push of a button.
-
agitated, confused or aphasic patients can be examined with a little patience.
Ultrasound Findings during the Acute Phase of the Cerebral Infarction
Ultrasound Findings during the Acute Phase of the Cerebral Infarction
Each cerebral infarction results from the occlusion of a cerebral vessel. Apart from
lacunary infarctions, the occlusion can be more frequently verified the earlier the
neurovascular examination is performed. Since the introduction of angiography, it
is known that intracranial vessel occlusions can be detected in up to 70% of collective
cases in the first few hours after occurrence, depending on the patient. Ultrasound
criteria that correlate with angiography with respect to distal branch occlusions
are as follows: occlusions of two or more M2-segments on the affected side and/or
if flow velocities in the proximal middle cerebral artery are reduced by more than
21% (“Zanette index”) compared to the unaffected side. It is important to note, that
the missing depiction of distal branches of the middle cerebral artery in color mode
is not a criterion for branch occlusion.
Recanalizing occlusions are typical findings in the acute phase of ischemic stroke
([Fig. 1]). In the case of distal middle cerebral artery branch occlusions, during the first
hours after symptom onset, spontaneous recanalization takes place, whereas in the
case of carotid T or middle cerebral artery main trunk occlusions only a low spontaneous
recanalization rate can be expected during this period ([Fig. 2]) [6]
[7]. This implies that highly variable hemodynamic conditions may be present in the
acute phase of a cerebral infarction. These are not clinically obvious but can be
directly detected by neurosonography. Likewise, fluctuating occlusion processes may
be immanent. The described pathophysiological mechanisms explain why ultrasound examinations
have to be carried out as soon as possible after the stroke to determine the cause
of the event and not at a later time point. Follow-up examinations at a later point
in time will then provide additional information regarding the etiology of the stroke,
such as identifying changes to the initial findings (spontaneous recanalization generally
occurs after embolic occlusions). In addition, the initial vascular examination allows
a very early prognostic statement about the further clinical course ([Fig. 3]) [8].
Fig. 1 Recanalization of a middle cerebral artery: a Occlusion of the middle cerebral artery, b Flow acceleration in the ipsilateral A1 segment of the anterior cerebral artery is
expression of activated leptomeningeal collateralization, c Four days later high-grade stenosis in the M1 segment of the middle cerebral artery,
d Image obtained using DSA (arrow), e The following day normalization of the flow in the M1 segment..
Fig. 2 Sonographic follow-up examination of 99 patients treated with IV lysis. Recanalization
rates (%) after 30 min, after 6 and 24 h. Branch occlusions (blue) recanalize more
frequently than M1 occlusions (green). A late recanalization up to 24 h was still
associated with a better mRS after 3 months compared to non-recanalized cases (better
late than never) [6].
Fig. 3 In a multicenter prospective NAIS study, 361 patients were sonographically examined
extra-and transcranially within 6 h. Of these 121 (34%) has a normal finding of the
middle cerebral artery; 176 (48%) has branch occlusions; 7 (2%) exhibited high-grade
middle cerebral artery stenosis, and 57 (16%) had an M1 occlusion. There was an almost
linear relationship with the clinical condition (mRS) after 3 months: the more branches
were closed, the lower the probability of minor disability. A reliable prognostic
statement can already be made during intake. (AI=Zanette Asymmetry Index) (modified
according to [8])
Furthermore, symptomatic carotid stenoses must be promptly identified, that is, directly
upon the patient’s admission, in order to decide upon an intervention as early as
possible when planning future treatment. The combination of B-image sonographic plaque
characterization to assess embolism risk and Doppler sonographic estimation of hemodynamic
changes (by measuring the collateral circulation) explains the pathomechanism of symptomatic
internal carotid artery stenoses and can determine early medical secondary stroke
prevention [9]
[10]
[11].
Follow-up Examinations in the Stroke Unit and “Stroke Mimics”
Follow-up Examinations in the Stroke Unit and “Stroke Mimics”
The possibility of performing the examination in real time, simple performance at
the patient’s bedside, and random repeatability as needed, enable TCCS to provide
effective monitoring of recanalization therapies and spontaneous changes in findings.
The TIBI score (Thrombolysis in Brain Ischemia) and COGIF score (Consensus on Grading
Intracranial Flow Obstruction) represent two ultrasound-based scoring methods allowing
the quantification of recanalization success as well as determination of the lack
of therapeutic success, reocclusion or hemodynamically critical situations in order
to respond to them at an early stage ([Fig. 4]) [6]
[12]
[13]. In the acute phase a partially recanalized embolus often exhibits the typical findings
of intracranial stenosis ([Fig. 1]). A decrease in the degree of stenosis, or a normalization of blood flow conditions
in subsequent days distinguishes the symptoms from atherosclerotic stenosis. In the
(not uncommon) common case of spontaneous recanalization which has already taken place
prior to the initial diagnosis, the detection of functional postischemic hyperemia
in the symptomatic vessel section can provide evidence of the underlying pathophysiology.
Fig. 4 A 44-year-old patient reported sudden visual disturbances while swimming. Shortly
thereafter a severe hemiparesis of the left side of the body occurred. During inpatient
intake approx. 1 h later he experienced severe media syndrome with hemiplegia and
neglect. a Color duplex sonography revealed occlusion of the right internal carotid artery resulting
from dissection (white arrow points to dissection membrane, top in longitudinal section,
bottom in cross-section). b Hemodynamically reduced perfusion in the right circulatory pathway region with attenuated
current pulse curve (top). Left middle cerebral artery with normal perfusion (bottom)
absent collateralization. MR tomography showed infarctions in the anterior right border
zone. c Follow-up 5 days later showed spontaneous recanalization of the right internal carotid
artery. d Postischemic hyperperfusion syndrome in the right middle cerebral artery after carotid
recanalization (top). Normal left middle cerebral artery for comparison (bottom).
Initially, a so-called “triple H” therapy was initiated after lysis due to the hemodynamically
critical situation; after extracranial recanalization. Due to hyperperfusion the therapy
was reversed.
It is commonly known that the diagnosis of “stroke” often conceals approx. 15–30%
of so-called “stroke mimics”. Emergency rooms can treat patients suffering from Todd’s
paresis after an epileptic attack, migraine attacks with auras, somatization disorders,
electrolyte and glucose imbalance or peripheral vestibular disorders. A pathological
ultrasound in the “fast track” is an important finding, which can rule out a “stroke
mimic” [14].
Mobile Thrombi and Dissection
Mobile Thrombi and Dissection
In addition to showing the exact location of an ICA occlusion – proximal vs. distal
– imaging can provide a more exact assessment of the underlying pathology. The display
of a mobile thrombus during recording ( Video 2) is relevant for further treatment planning and can justify acute intervention in
an individual case [15]
[16]
[17]. Systematic studies on the best possible treatment of free-floating thrombi are
rare because they can only be detected by means of real-time ultrasound and avoid
routine diagnosis with CT or MR angiography.
Floating lumen-occluding thrombus in the internal carotid artery (ICA) with a distal
(cranial) tale. Due to this finding and about two hours after initial IV thrombolysis
anticoagulation with IV heparin was started resulting in complete recanalization and
unmasking the ulcerated high grade ICA stenosis (approx. 90%, NASCET graduation.
In many cases, spontaneous dissection of the large extracranial, cerebral arteries
can be determined sonographically by means of unambiguous wall changes in proximal
vessel sections [14]
[18]. Dissection at the level of the cranial base, on the other hand, is difficult to
diagnose. Signs of increased peripheral flow resistance and poststenotic changes are
found intracranially with a heavy lumen obstruction. According to the current update
of the guidelines, dual imaging diagnostics using MRI with T1-weighted, fat-suppressed
axial sequences and neurovascular ultrasound is still the diagnostic approach of choice,
but the importance of CT angiography as a reliable alternative to MRI has increased
[19]. Because of the disease dynamics, the early initial examination and further sonographic
follow-ups are particularly important in the acute phase (both progression and frequently,
recanalization), since dissection of additional arteries or progressive dissections
may be detected, thus necessitating individual adaptation of the secondary prophylaxis,
blood pressure therapy and continuation of monitoring ([Fig. 4]).
Detection of a proximal dissection of the left common carotid artery (CCA) is easily
pathognomically recognized as an aortic dissection, even for a relatively inexperienced
examiner [20]. An aortic dissection extending in the common carotid artery is life-threatening,
and the patient must be transferred immediately to cardiac surgery.
Inflammatory Cerebrovascular Diseases
Inflammatory Cerebrovascular Diseases
Giant cell arteritis (GCA) is the most common primary systemic vasculitis. Since their
predilection sites are the medium-to-large arteries, especially the branches of the
external carotid artery, there have been pioneering findings in this regard. Likewise
intracranial arteries, especially the vertebral artery, may be affected. As much of
the length of the extracranial branches of the external carotid artery as possible
should be examined. Hypoechogenic vessel wall edema (halo sign) is pathognomonic with
high specificity (97%). Diagnostic sensitivity is significantly above 80%, thus if
a clear ultrasound is obtained without vascular biopsy, steroid therapy should be
initiated [21]. In addition, local stenoses (flow accelerations) can be observed, which can also
serve as a strong proof of the presence of vasculitis, even without evidence of vascular
edema, for example after the onset of a steroid treatment or in the absence of atherosclerosis.
In this context, duplex sonography is especially useful in patients with acute visual
loss because GCA often affects the posterior ciliary arteries leading to anterior
ischemic optic neuropathy (AION) and rarely occludes the central artery. Embolic central
artery occlusion as an essential differential diagnosis to (GCA) can be demonstrated
in duplex transorbital sonography as a hyperechoic central artery occlusion (so-called
spot sign) inside the proximal section of the optic nerve, and appears to be a highly-valid
prognostic factor for thrombolytic therapy [22]
[23]. Sonographic representation of the retro-orbital arteries is regarded as the sole
highly-specific finding of the method.
Ultrasound Diagnostics after Postinterventional Complications
Ultrasound Diagnostics after Postinterventional Complications
Patients with acute symptomatic carotid artery stenosis are often treated in the stroke
unit after carotid endarterectomy (CEA) or carotid angioplasty with stent implantation
(CAS). In the immediate postoperative ultrasound examination after CEA, it is necessary
to detect residual defects and complications such as microsuture ruptures, intimal
steps, dissections, pseudoaneurysms, thrombi and remaining stenoses which may require
re-intervention [24]
[25]. Examination conditions are often made more difficult by swelling or hematomas in
the area of the surgical wound.
Early complications after CAS are, in particular, an incomplete unfolding of the stent
with resulting in-stent stenosis (ISS) ([Fig. 5]) or even occlusion. In general, during follow-up monitoring, ISS is systematically
over-estimated when applying conventional criteria for carotid stenosis (especially
systolic peak velocity [PSV] but also end-diastolic velocity [EDV]) [26]
[27]
[28]. Therefore Lal and colleagues suggested modified threshold values based on the ICA/CCA
stenosis index [27]. In addition, the conventional criteria such as pre- and post-stenotic flow changes
as well as activation of collateral pathways should be taken into account [29]
[30].
Fig. 5 In-stent stenosis of the internal carotid artery. a Incomplete unfolding of the stent. b Detection of flow acceleration to 500/300 cm/s (systolic/diastolic maximum flow).
The relatively low flow disturbances with maintained systolic window and absent low-frequency
components indicate that the sole assessment of flow velocities overstate the degree
of stenosis of in-stent stenosis.
The reason for the increased flow rates in the stent-supplied ICA appears to be, in
addition to the reduction of vessel diameter after introduction of the stent, reduced
arterial compliance [26]
[31] and altered geometry of the blood vessel [32]. Longitudinal ultrasound examinations of 82 patients with stent-supplied ICA showed
that postinterventional moderately increased flow velocities in the stent (PSV 98.5±21 cm/s,
EDV 25.5±8.1 cm/s) remained stable for more than 1 year, contradicting the idea that
initial hyperperfusion after CAS causes increased flow velocities [33]. Pragmatically, an early baseline ultrasound examination is recommended in the first
days after stent implantation, which can then be used for the follow-up observations
in order to quantify later complications such as a hyperplasia of the neointima or
formation of neoartherosclerosis.
Discussion
The impetus for this article was the DSG notification that ultrasound examination
during hospitalization in the stroke unit is no longer obligatory for the deduction
of complex treatment of stroke according to the DIMDI (Deutsches Institut für Medizinische
Dokumentation und Information/German Institute for Medical Documentation and Information)
if another imaging method has been used to diagnose the blood vessels supplying the
brain. Without a doubt, the absolute need for early vascular diagnostics represents
an advance and is indispensable when deciding whether endovascular thrombendarterectomy
is required. The new OPS formulation also suggests that methods for neurovascular
imaging are interchangeable, and that ultrasound diagnostics can also be performed
at a later stage, if not entirely dispensable. The aim of the present article is therefore
to again describe the unique features of sonography, and to explain how the patient’s
individual pathophysiology can be optimally understood, and how sonography continues
to provide high value in the care of acute stroke patients. It would be an unfortunate
collateral damage if the successfull implementation of endovascular stroke treatment
would weaken the well established stroke unit concept by abandoning neurovascular
ultrasound.
After the onset of an ischemic stroke, complex, individually different, hemodynamic
transformation processes decisive for the fate of the patient are triggered in the
affected vessel segment and associated collateral pathways. Occlusions can persist,
recanalize partially or completely compensate collaterally or re-occlude after recanalization
([Fig. 2]). In the initial hours post-onset these processes can be more closely tracked using
ultrasound compared to any other method. The sooner the examination is performed,
the more revealing are the findings, the individual pathophysiological understanding
is more extensive and the benefit for therapeutic decisions is greater.
In the “one-stop-shop” strategy increasingly being used in the daily diagnostic routine
in the care of acute stroke cases, instrument-based diagnosis is delegated to neuroradiology
while medication-based secondary prophylaxis is handled by internal medicine. Neurosonology
makes a difference in this respect: it is widely accepted as a core competency of
instrument-based neurology and is considered a characteristic of high-quality stroke
treatment. Due to the enormous technological advances in neurology, excellent imaging
methods are available in stroke diagnosis which can be indicated as a function of
the clinical issue and availability, and which can be used in parallel or as a complement.
The demonstration of impressive ultrasound findings parallel to radiological findings
in the daily „radiology conference“ would be a useful step to anchor neurosonology
in the awareness of neurologists. Whereas CT and MRI diagnostics require years of
specialist education, neurologists learn this method formally within the course of
normal training. Unfortunately there is decreasing time for this, due to increasing
consolidation of subject matter in medical education.
The particular competence in treating stroke cases as claimed by neurologists is ultimately
not justified due to the fact that diagnostic requirements are met by other specialties.
The aim of this article is therefore to motivate neurologists to deal more intensively
with neurosonology in the acute phase of the stroke, and obtain an image themselves,
rather than having an image made for them. For the purpose of individualized medicine,
neurosonography provides very specific neurovascular information that neurologists
should use when discussing complex stroke patients with neuroradiologists, vascular
surgeons and cardiologists, and should remain an indispensable component of the successful
stroke unit concept.