Key words
Q fever - pneumonia - coxiella burnetii - lung infection
Introduction
Q fever is a zoonosis with a worldwide distribution that is caused by the bacterium
Coxiella burnetii [1]. 25 to 100 cases of Q fever are annually reported in Germany [2] with the highest incidence of the disease in the state of Baden-Württemberg in Southwest
Germany. The bacteria are found in feces, urine and milk of infected animals. However,
the most important route is the shedding of C. burnetii into the environment during
parturition [3]. Humans are infected by the ingestion of unpasteurized milk or milk products or
by the inhalation of contaminated dust. The clinical signs of acute infection range
from asymptomatic infections and mild flu-like symptoms to severe pneumonia and hepatitis
[4]. In 1 – 5 % of patients with acute, untreated Q fever, a chronic disease with valvular
heart disease, arterial aneurysms and osteomyelitis develops [1]. About 50 % of infected patients become symptomatic [5]. The signs and symptoms of acute illness include a flu-like syndrome with fever,
cough, myalgia and headaches [6]. The onset is usually abrupt. Q fever-related hepatitis is found in around 85 %
of patients with an elevation of liver enzymes from 2 to 10 times normal values. There
is a high regional heterogeneity in the incidence of Q fever-related hepatitis. While
hepatitis is common in Southern Europe, it is infrequent in North America. Hepatitis
is more common in younger patients, while pneumonia is more common in older patients
[7].
The diagnosis is made using an immunofluorescence assay (IFA) or an enzyme-linked
immunosorbent assay (EIA). Blood cultures are typically sterile, since C. burnetii
does not grow in routine blood cultures [8]. In very early infections the antibody level might not be detectable or may be very
low. In these cases PCR can be used to detect C. burnetii [8].
The reported radiologic findings in patients with Q fever pneumonia on chest radiographs
or CT scans vary and the available literature is sparse [9]
[10]. To our knowledge, there is no study that systematically describes the radiographic
findings of Q fever pneumonia on chest radiographs in Germany.
The purpose of this study is the characterization of patients with Q fever pneumonia
and analysis of the findings on chest radiographs in Southwest Germany.
Patients and methods
Between 2006 and 2016, the charts of all patients who were treated for Q fever pneumonia
at the Zollernalb Klinikum were retrospectively analyzed. The Zollernalb Klinikum
is located in the southern part of Baden-Württemberg, Germany and receives patients
from a rural area with approximately 250 000 inhabitants.
The diagnosis of acute Q fever pneumonia was based on both serologic and clinical
criteria. Serology was done using an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (EIA, Vireon\Sereon
GmbH, Würzburg, Germany). An acute infection was diagnosed if the titer of anti-phase
II was ≥ 110 U/ml for IgM or an at least fourfold increase in IgG titers in two consecutive
assays. In addition, two or more of the following clinical symptoms had to be present:
body temperature > 38 °C, respiratory symptoms (dyspnea, cough, chest pain), pneumonia
or hepatitis-like symptoms with a more than two-fold increase in serum levels of alanine
and aspartate aminotransferase (AST, ALT levels, respectively). Applying the above
mentioned criteria, we identified 40 patients with an acute Q fever pneumonia. We
were able to retrieve the chest radiographs of 33 patients. In three of the patients
an initial CT scan was done and therefore plain X-ray radiographs were not available
for analysis. In the remaining patients, chest radiographs were done in other radiologic
institutes before admission and we were not able to retrieve the original chest X-ray
radiographs.
The chest radiographs were done using a computed radiography (CR) system. The imaging
plate (Agfa, CR MD 4.0 cassette) contains a photostimulable phosphor imaging plate.
The read-out of the imaging plate was done using an Agfa CR 30X system.
All chest radiographs were reviewed by two experienced radiologists (A.B. and M.B.).
In the case of discrepancies, the findings were discussed and a consensus was reached.
The radiologic findings were analyzed following a standardized protocol: On the basis
of the predominant type of parenchymal abnormality, the radiographic patterns were
classified as either alveolar or reticular. The number and distribution characteristics
of the lesions were assessed. The definition of the air space lesions was as follows:
lobar, if one or more lobes were involved; segmental, if one or more segments were
affected; patchy, if subsegments of one or more segments were involved. Additional
findings like pleural effusion were also assessed.
Results
Patient characteristics are given in [Table 1]. The mean age of the patients at presentation was 44.9 years. Females (48 %) and
males (52 %) were almost equally affected. Direct and close contact to animals was
reported by none of the patients. Half of the patients (50 %) presented with dry cough.
Headache or myalgia was present in 23 % and 15 % of patients, respectively. 23 patients
(58 %) had a body temperature > 38.5 °C. 30 % of the patients complained of dyspnea.
Oxygen saturation of 94 % or below was obtained in 30 % of the patients. About half
of the patients (45 %) acquired their infection in the second quarter of the year.
The remaining patients acquired their infection almost equally distributed in the
other three quarters of the year. 25 (63 %) of the patients had Q fever-related hepatitis.
The white cell count was elevated in only 7 patients (18 %). Procalcitonin was measured
in 15 patients and was elevated in only 4 patients (27 %). In contrast, the levels
of C-reactive protein were elevated in all 40 patients. The infection had no impact
on platelet count, renal function and liver function (as determined by normal bilirubin
and INR levels).
Table 1
The table shows the clinical and laboratory data of the 40 patients with Q fever pneumonia.
For each parameter the number of patients with values outside the reference range
is given. The mean values as well as the standard deviations of these patients are
given.
Tab. 1 Die Tabelle zeigt die klinischen und laborchemischen Daten der 40 Patienten mit Q-Fieber-Pneumonie.
Für jeden Parameter wurde die Anzahl der Patienten angegeben, bei denen die Werte
außerhalb des Referenzbereich lagen. Von diesen Patienten wurden die Mittelwerte und
die Standardabweichungen bestimmt.
|
patients, n = 40
|
patients with pathologic values (n)
|
|
reference values
|
|
sex (male)
|
|
21
|
|
|
age (years)
|
|
44.9 ± 15.7
|
|
|
body temperature °C
|
31
|
38.9 ± 0.8
|
36.3 – 37.4 °C
|
|
white blood cell count (G/l)
|
7
|
14.4 ± 4.2
|
4.2 – 10.8 G/l
|
|
oxygen saturation (sO2) n = 27
|
9
|
89.1 ± 3.7
|
94 – 97 %
|
|
C-reactive protein (mg/dl)
|
40
|
20.0 ± 10.0
|
< 0.5 mg/dl
|
|
procalcitonin (ng/ml) n = 15
|
4
|
2.4 ± 2.3
|
< 0.5 ng/ml
|
|
AST (U/l)
|
16
|
109.4 ± 76.7
|
< 50 U/l
|
|
ALT (U/l)
|
14
|
144.0 ± 87.0
|
< 50 U/l
|
|
gGT (U/l)
|
17
|
115.8 ± 75.9
|
< 60 U/l
|
|
alkaline phosphatase (U/l)
|
9
|
233.9 ± 71.6
|
< 130 U/l
|
The findings in the three patients in whom initial CT scans of the thorax were performed
revealed single consolidations in the left lung in all patients. In one patient there
were patchy consolidations in the apex of the left lung, in one patient there were
patchy consolidations paracardial, and in the third patient a segmental consolidation
in the left lower lobe was seen.
Chest radiographs on admission were available in 33 of the 40 patients. Of the 33
chest radiographs, 2 were without pathological findings.
[Table 2] shows the distribution of the affected lobes. In the majority of patients, the lower
lobes were affected (70 %). The left lung was more affected than the right lung, 48 %
and 30 %, respectively. Involvement of both lungs was seen in 5 patients (15 %).
Table 2
The table shows the affected lobes in the 33 patients with Q fever pneumonia for whom
the chest radiographs were available.
Tab. 2 Die Tabelle zeigt die betroffenen Lungenlappen der 33 Patienten mit Q-Fieber-Pneumonie
bei denen eine Röntgenthoraxaufnahme vorlag.
|
affected lobe
|
n
|
%
|
|
right upper
|
8
|
24 %
|
|
right middle
|
6
|
18 %
|
|
right lower
|
8
|
24 %
|
|
left upper
|
9
|
27 %
|
|
left lower
|
15
|
45 %
|
The radiographic patterns are given in [Table 3]. Air space opacification was the predominant sign and was found in 27 of the patients
(82 %). Mass-like changes ([Fig. 1]) were found in 3 of the patients (9 %). In the majority of patients only one lobe
was affected (70 %). 2, 3, 4 and all 5 lobes were affected in 12 %, 6 %, 3 % and 3 %
of the patients, respectively. 23 of the patients had a segmental pattern ([Fig. 2], 70 %), 5 patients (15 %) had patchy changes ([Fig. 3]) and 2 patients (6 %) had a lobar infiltrate ([Fig. 4]). Micronodular as well as reticular changes were seen in none of the patients. Pleural
effusions ([Fig. 1]) were found in 4 patients (12 %).
Table 3
The table shows the radiographic pattern of 33 patients with Q fever pneumonia.
Tab. 3 Die Tabelle zeigt die radiologischen Befunde der 33 Patienten mit Q-Fieber-Pneumonie.
|
radiographic pattern
|
patients (n)
|
%
|
|
air space opacities
|
27
|
82 %
|
|
|
2
|
6 %
|
|
|
23
|
70 %
|
|
|
5
|
15 %
|
|
nodular findings
|
2
|
6 %
|
|
|
0
|
0 %
|
|
|
0
|
0 %
|
|
|
3
|
9 %
|
|
reticular findings
|
0
|
0 %
|
|
pleural effusion
|
4
|
12 %
|
Fig. 1 Posteroanterior chest radiograph of a 22-year old man presenting with a 10-day history
of fever and cough. IgM titer against C. burnetii was 306 and IgG was 207 U/ml. These
findings make an infection of more than two weeks likely. The radiograph shows a pleural
effusion that was later diagnosed as pleural emphysema and a mass-like lesion in the
right middle lobe.
Abb. 1 Posterior-anteriorer Röntgen-Thorax eines 22-jährigen Mannes der sich mit Fieber
und Husten seit 10 Tagen vorstellte. Der IgM Titer gegen C. burnetii war 306 und IgG
betrug 207 U/ml. Dies lässt auf eine Infektion die länger als zwei Wochen geht schließen.
Die Aufnahme zeigt einen Pleuraerguss, der laborchemisch einem Emphyem entsprach sowie
eine solide Läsion im rechten Mittellappen.
Fig. 2 Chest radiograph of a 64-year-old man presenting with fever and cough. IgM titer
against C. burnetii was > 500. The posteroanterior view shows a segmental opacity
in the lingula.
Abb. 2 Röntgenthorax eines 64-jährigen Mannes der sich mit Fieber und Husten vorstellte.
Der IgM Titer gegen C. burnetii war > 500. Die posterior-anteriore Ansicht zeigt eine
segmentale Verschattung in der Lingula.
Fig. 3 Chest radiograph of a 32-year-old woman presenting with fever, myalgia and headache.
IgM titer against C burnetii was > 500. The posteroanterior view shows patchy infiltrates
in all five lobes.
Abb. 3 Röntgen-Thorax einer 32-jährigen Frau, die sich mit Fieber, Myalgien und Kopfschmerzen
vorstellte. Der IgM Titer gegen C. burnetii war > 500. Die posterior-anteriore Ansicht
zeigt fleckige Infiltrate in allen fünf Lappen.
Fig. 4 Chest radiograph of a 21-year-old man presenting with fever and cough. IgM titer
against C burnetii was 394. The posteroanterior view a as well as the lateral view b show a lobar infiltrate in the middle lobe.
Abb. 4 Röntgen-Thorax eines 21-jährigen Mannes, der sich mit Fieber und Husten vorstellte.
Der IgM Titer gegen C. burnetii betrug 394. Die posterior-anteriore Ansicht a sowie das Seitbild b zeigen ein lobäres Infiltrat im Mittellappen.
Discussion
In our paper, we describe the clinical, radiologic and laboratory findings of patients
with Q fever pneumonia in Southwest Germany. Whereas three studies described a male
preponderance [11]
[12]
[13], Caron et al. [14] described a male-to-female ratio of 1:3.4. In contrast to these authors, we did
not find any gender-specific preponderance but rather a balanced female-to-male ratio.
Our laboratory findings are consistent with the data of other groups who reported
a normal white cell count in most of the patients with Q fever pneumonia [3]
[8]
[15] whereas the CRP values were markedly elevated in the patients. In contrast, the
mean procalcitonin (PCT) levels were only slightly elevated. Unfortunately, the PCT
levels were available in 16 patients only. Of these patients, two had markedly elevated
PCT levels and the remaining patients had normal or almost normal PCT levels. It remains
unclear why Q fever – in contrast to other bacterial pneumonias –is not associated
with an increase in the white cell count and PCT in most patients. Hence, we conclude
that PCT and the white cell count are not valuable markers in the diagnosis of Q fever
pneumonia. In addition, and in line with a large retrospective study from the Netherlands
[15], we did not find an abnormal platelet count nor did we find an abnormal creatinine
level. As expected, more than half of our patients had elevated liver enzymes as an
indicator of Q fever-related hepatitis. This is described by several other authors
[3]
[14]
[16]
[17]. The presence of elevated liver enzymes in patients with acute Q fever shows a regional
heterogeneity with a high percentage in southern Europe and a low percentage in North
America. Our results are strengthened by the results of the retrospective analysis
from the Netherlands [15] that compared patients with Q fever pneumonia to patients with pneumonia from other
pathogens. Even though they found elevated liver enzymes in both groups, liver enzymes
were significantly higher in the Q fever group than in the control group.
The radiographic findings in our patients were not specific for Q fever pneumonia.
Unilateral, single segmental opacities were the most common findings. The lower lobes
were more affected than the upper lobes. The mostly unilateral, segmental pattern
was also shown by other studies [9]
[18]
[19]
[20] and seems to be the typical but not unique pattern of Q fever pneumonia. Two of
the three studies [18]
[20] described the lower lobes to be more often affected than the upper lobes, which
is congruent with our findings. In contrast to the above mentioned studies, Millar
et al. [10] found multiple round opacities and linear atelectasis in 68 % and 50 % of the patients,
respectively.
Previous studies [9]
[19] described the radiographic changes in Q fever pneumonia as slowly resolving, compared
to other pneumonias. As our study was retrospective, systematic follow-up chest radiographs
of the patients were not available. Nevertheless, the available follow-up chest radiographs
of some of the patients did support these findings.
In conclusion, the radiographic findings in our study did not allow the definite differentiation
of Q fever pneumonia from other community-acquired pneumonias. Segmental and/or lobar
opacities are seen in both entities. However, in young to middle-aged patients in
an endemic area presenting with segmental opacities, clinicians should at least consider
Q fever pneumonia and initiate the appropriate diagnostic workup.
Summary
Patients with acute Q fever pneumonia usually present with cough, fever and myalgia.
Typical laboratory findings are a normal white blood count and a high CRP level. About
two-thirds of the patients have Q fever-related pneumonia. Unilobar, unilateral, segmental
opacities are the common findings of chest radiographs in Q fever pneumonia. However,
patchy and lobar infiltrates are also found in some patients. In young to middle-aged
patients with segmental opacities living in an endemic area, the differential diagnosis
should include Q fever pneumonia and the appropriate diagnostic workup should be initiated.
