Keywords
antibiotics - dentistry - resistance - prescriptions
Introduction
Antibiotics are a precious medicine for the treatment of spreading bacterial dental
infections. Nowadays, the appropriate prescription of antibiotics has become a challenge
in most health care systems because different studies have reported that antibiotics
are often irrationally overprescribed, which form the basis of antimicrobial resistance.[1] The extensive utilization of antibiotics in clinical practice has been determined
to be a leading factor for the emergence of antibiotic resistance.[2] Inefficient therapy due to resistance is associated with increasing human suffering,
loss of productivity, and often ending with death. Antibiotics misuse and a high level
of antibiotics resistance (AMR) are observed particularly in developing countries.
Kosovo, a country located in Southeast Europe with a population of 1.7 million inhabitants,
is facing some challenges regarding antimicrobial resistance such as limited financial
and human resources, over-the-counter sale of antibiotics, and scarcity of clinical
guidelines authorized by the Ministry of Health.[3] Kosovo is two to five times higher for the majority resistance of bacteria and corresponding
antibiotics groups compared with the means in European countries.[4]
To address the challenge of antimicrobial resistance, the Ministry of Health in Kosovo
adopted (2011–2015) the first National Strategy and Action Plan to Combat Antimicrobial
Resistance, which resulted in the surveillance of general antibiotics consumption.[3] Despite the high level of knowledge of health care professionals and great awareness
of antimicrobial resistance, prescribing and dispensing practices were influenced
by challenges of access to information on resistance patterns, next line antibiotics,
diagnostics, and patient records.[5] Second National Action Plan for Antimicrobial Resistance was adopted (2019–2021)
by the Ministry of Health regarding reports from various researches dealing with resistance
occurrence,[4]
[6] which was also aimed at improving the monitoring capacity and optimization of antibiotics'
use. The latest World Health Organization (WHO) data in 2018 showed that Kosovo made
progress in appointing an AMR focal point by the Ministry of Health as well as an
intersectoral coordinating mechanism to control AMR.[7] Also, in 2019, country representatives in a regional workshop held in Belgrade,
Serbia reported a significant decrease in antibiotic consumption (25%).[8] However, a fully functional AMR reference laboratory with a quality assessment system
in place is still missing.
Dental practitioners are frequently prescribing antibiotics for their patients as
outpatient care. Among the reasons for the misuse of antibiotics in dentistry are
the dentists' desire to avoid clinical complications, the fear to lose patients, and
perceived patient pressure.[9] Recent research studies advocated that dental practitioners should prescribe antibiotics/antimicrobials
only for acute orodental conditions, where drainage or debridement is impossible,
where there is a local spread of infection, or where systemic upset has occurred,[10] but not for mere inflammation.[11]
[12] Additionally, prophylactic use of antimicrobials[13] in dental treatment is strictly recommended with special guidelines for suspected
systemic infective conditions, such as infective endocarditis[14]
[15] and severely immunocompromised patients. The rational and effective prescription
of antimicrobial is imperative in dental practice, and it is necessary to implement
an antimicrobial prescription monitoring system and an antibiotic administration program.
In addition, quality indicators of antibiotic prescription are needed to be continuously
updated according to the standards recommended by WHO.
Therefore, the patterns of antibiotics prescription of dentists in Republic of Kosovo
major dental clinics are investigated by this research regarding the extent to which
and for what reasons they prescribe antibiotics. The purpose of the present study
is to investigate patterns of antibiotics prescription of dentists in Kosovo's major
dental clinics.
Materials and Methods
This study consisted of data collection regarding antibiotics use during 2015 to 2019
at major dental clinics in the Republic of Kosovo. Data collection based on Point
Prevalence Survey (PPS) study was performed in 10 regional Dental Clinics and a Tertiary
Health Center. Data collection was performed by the author of this study in collaboration
with the clinics' experienced staff after ethical approval in May 2019 by the management
board of the hospitals and University Clinical Service of Kosovo by app. no. 830/2.
Ethical approval for collaboration in research was granted by the Ethic committee
of the School of Dental Medicine University in Zagreb 05-PA-30-VII—5/2019.
Data Collection
Patients' forms were designed based on PPS methodology and contain information on
identification of the patients' number, year, age, gender, diagnosis, generic name
of the drug used, dosage, the single-dose administered in units, and duration of the
treatment. The patient form is developed by the European Antibiotics Use Surveillance[16] and Antibiotics Resistance and Description of European Children.[17]
Data were gathered and analyzed for the University Clinical Dentistry Center of Kosovo
in Prishtina; 18 Family Health Care Centers in Prishtina; and 10 Main Centers of Family
Medicine in Vushtrri, Prizren, Mitrovice, Obiliq, Ferizaj, Hani i Elezit, Gjilan,
Gjakovë, Fushë Kosovë, and Pejë. Inclusion criteria for data collection were completed
antibiotic treatment for a relevant disease in dental medicine in mentioned dental
clinics during the period from 2015 to 2019. Emergency patients which had received
immediate (short) therapy and were directed to the dentist for further treatment were
excluded because of the lack of complete documentation.
Antibiotic Utilization Data
For analysis of the antibiotic utilization data, the defined daily dose (DDD) and
the defined daily dose per 1,000 inhabitants per day (DID) formula codes were used
to calculate a standardized measure of medicine consumption at the national level.
DDD is defined as the assumed average maintenance dose per day for a drug used for
its main indication in adults, and this standard value for each drug was obtained
from the World Health Organization Collaborating Centre for Drug Statistics Methodology
website (https://www.whocc.no/atc_ddd_index/), and it has become a major assessment tool in the pharmacoepidemiologic studies
since it provides a fixed unit of measurement independent of dosage form, package
size, or price.
Statistical Analysis
Quantitative data are analyzed by statistical analysis where data are transformed
into numbers, percentages, tables, and diagrammatic representations. Data were entered
in MS Excel database according to the year, number of health care centers, most used
antibiotics, most common diagnosis, and number of patients for both of them. The empirical
analysis as the basis of this study is used to arrive at the most complete conclusions.
Results
On average, there were 181 antibiotic prescriptions issued per dentist/annually, with
an average number of 47% of antibiotic prescriptions per patient who used some kind
of service in observed dental clinics. For the analyzed period, the average antibiotic
utilization by each dentist was 6.5 DDD/1,000 patients/year, with fluctuations between
the years 2015 and 2019. The number of dentists in Kosovo in 2019 was 1,500 and the
number of dentists increased by 22% during the observed period. The number of patients
that used dental services was on average 1,265 annually with minimal fluctuations.
According to a statistical agency report on population estimation, Kosovo had 1,771,604
inhabitants in 2015 and the number increased by 0.59% in the next 5 years.[18]
[19]
All data regarding antibiotics prescription in dentistry in Kosovo are presented in
[Table 1] according to year, number of dental health care centers; number of patients in total,
most used antibiotics, number of patients who received them, and most common diagnosis
and number of patients who were diagnosed. There was a decrease in utilization observed
from 2017 to 2019 in overall antibiotics prescriptions in each of the cities. Results
from antibiotics use during the period from 2015 and 2019 are presented in [Table 2] for each city, with Gjilan having a significant descending trend of antibiotics
use and Peja having a significant rising trend. More information on the most common
diagnosis for each dental center in Kosovo in the years 2015 to 2019 is presented
in [Supplementary Tables S1]–[S5] (available in the online version only).
Table 1
Antibiotics' prescriptions in dentistry in Kosovo during years 2015 to 2019
Year
|
No. of health care centers
|
No. of patients (total)
|
Most used antibiotics
|
No. of patients
|
DDDs
|
DDD/1,000 patients/year
|
Most common diagnosis
|
No. of patients
|
2015
|
11
|
1,115
|
Cefazolin
|
235
|
1,175
|
2.88
|
KO4.7: Periapical abscess without sinus
|
139
|
Amoxicillin
|
177
|
885
|
2.17
|
KO4.5: Chronic apical periodontitis
|
87
|
Cefalexin
|
139
|
695
|
1.70
|
KO4.0: pulpitis
|
55
|
2016
|
16
|
1,373
|
Amoxicillin
|
294
|
1,470
|
2.92
|
KO4.7: Periapical abscess without sinus
|
293
|
Cefazolin
|
190
|
950
|
1.89
|
KO4.1: Necrosis of the pulp
|
70
|
Cefalexin
|
120
|
600
|
1.19
|
KO4.0: Pulpitis
|
61
|
2017
|
17
|
1,641
|
Amoxicillin
|
351
|
1,755
|
2.91
|
KO4.7: Periapical abscess without sinus
|
443
|
Cefazolin
|
255
|
1,275
|
2.11
|
KO4.1: Necrosis of the pulp
|
122
|
Amoxiclav
|
216
|
1,080
|
1.79
|
KO4.5: Chronic apical periodontitis
|
76
|
2018
|
17
|
1,336
|
Amoxiclav
|
216
|
1,080
|
2.16
|
KO4.7: Periapical abscess without sinus
|
349
|
Cefazolin
|
207
|
1,035
|
2.07
|
KO4.1: Necrosis of the pulp
|
135
|
Amoxicillin
|
74
|
370
|
0.74
|
KO4.5: Chronic apical periodontitis
|
67
|
2019
|
17
|
862
|
Amoxiclav
|
215
|
1,075
|
3.41
|
KO4.7: Periapical abscess without sinus
|
210
|
Amoxicillin
|
164
|
820
|
2.59
|
KO4.1: Necrosis of the pulp
|
109
|
Cefazolin
|
126
|
630
|
1.99
|
KO4.5: Periapical abscess without sinus
|
32
|
Abbreviation: DDD, defined daily dose.
Table 2
Most prescribed antibiotics by the region cities and each dental center in Kosovo
in 2015 and 2019
Place
|
Year
|
Most prescribed antibiotic 1
|
No.
of rx.
|
Most prescribed antibiotic 2
|
No.
of rx.
|
Most prescribed antibiotic 3
|
No.
of rx.
|
UCDCK in Prishtinë
|
2015
|
Amoxicillin + clavulanic acid
|
6
|
Amoxicillin
|
1
|
No data
|
/
|
2019
|
Amoxicillin + clavulanic acid
|
63
|
Metronidazole
|
14
|
No data
|
/
|
MCFM in Vushtrri
|
2015
|
Amoxicillin
|
68
|
Amoxicillin + clavulanic acid
|
19
|
Ceftriaxone
|
11
|
2019
|
Amoxicillin
|
26
|
Amoxicillin + clavulanic acid
|
5
|
No data
|
/
|
MCFM in Prizren
|
2015
|
Amoxicillin
|
27
|
No data
|
|
No data
|
/
|
2019
|
Amoxicillin
|
19
|
No data
|
|
No data
|
/
|
MCFM for maxille
|
2015
|
Cefazolin
|
235
|
Ampicillin
|
63
|
Cefalexin
|
54
|
2019
|
Cefazolin
|
126
|
Amoxicillin + clavulanic acid
|
30
|
Metronidazole
|
21
|
MCFM in Mitrovice
|
2015
|
Cefalexin
|
44
|
Ceftriaxone
|
16
|
Amoxicillin
|
12
|
2019
|
Cefalexin
|
26
|
Amoxicillin
|
16
|
Amoxicillin + clavulanic acid
|
13
|
MCFM in Ferizaj
|
2015
|
Amoxicillin
|
31
|
No data
|
|
No data
|
/
|
2019
|
Amoxicillin
|
19
|
No data
|
|
No data
|
/
|
MCFM in Gjilan
|
2015
|
Amoxicillin
|
79
|
Penicillin G
|
45
|
Cefalexin
|
41
|
2019
|
Amoxicillin
|
27
|
Penicillin G
|
5
|
Amoxicillin + clavulanic acid
|
8
|
MCFM in Fushë Kosovë
|
2015
|
Amoxicillin
|
22
|
Ceftriaxone
|
15
|
Amoxicillin + clavulanic acid
|
11
|
2019
|
Amoxicillin + clavulanic acid
|
26
|
Ceftriaxone
|
19
|
Amoxicillin
|
16
|
MCFM in Pejë
|
2015
|
Amoxicillin + clavulanic acid
|
19
|
Amoxicillin
|
29
|
No data
|
/
|
2019
|
Amoxicillin
|
71
|
Amoxicillin + clavulanic acid
|
27
|
No data
|
/
|
Abbreviations: MFMC, Main Family Medicine Center; UCDCK, University Clinical Dentistry
Centre of Kosovo.
Among antibacterials, amoxicillin was the most prescribed, averaging 36% of all antibiotic
prescriptions, which followed by cefazolin (34%), amoxicillin with clavulanic (26%),
and cefalexin (9%). A trend of high increase in the use of amoxicillin with clavulanic
acid was observed from 1.79 DDD/1,000 patients/year to 3.41 DDD/patient/year over
5 years.
Discussion
The aims of this study were to perform a descriptive analysis and quality assurance
of antibiotic prescriptions at major dental clinics in the Republic of Kosovo during
2015 to 2019. The most prescribed antibiotics by results of this study in secondary/tertiary
dental health care in Kosovo were amoxicillin (16.7%), cefazolin (16%), amoxiclav
(10.2%), and cefalexin (4.09%). Amoxicillin, as most prescribed, was the first choice
in dental infection treatment as is recommended by guidelines.[10]
[11]
[12] However, authors must warn of the observed trend of a dramatic increase in amoxicillin
with clavulanic acid prescription which is occurring in the past 2 years, increasing
from 1.16 DID to 3.86 DID. If this trend is to be continued, then the wider spectrum
antibiotic will prevail as the first choice leading to new problems regarding microbial
resistance. A similar trend in increasing usage of amoxicillin with clavulanic acid
was observed in the latest research from Croatia and Turkey. In Croatia, the most
used antibiotics are amoxicillin with clavulanic acid, amoxicillin, and clindamycin,
respectively, according to studies by national health insurance data and cross-sectional
self-reported study.[20]
[21] Amoxicillin is part of the penicillin group of antibiotics, but is effective against
a broader range of organisms and recommendations for antibiotic treatments in dentistry
are to start with a narrower one (amoxicillin), so the broader one could be effective
when needed. Observing these differences in results, with a great increase in amoxicillin
with clavulanic acid, we may suggest that a shift has occurred in the first-choice
antibiotic. It could be because of the differences in diagnosis and indications for
antibiotic treatment. According to our study, the highest number of patients in health
care dental clinics in 2015 to 2019 received antibiotics for maxilla-related health
conditions, and the lowest number of them for oncologic ones. But further studies
need to be done to confirm this observation.
The data in our research are based on the data of patients from secondary and tertiary
health care facilities, with complex diagnoses, who are most often referred for treatment
from primary health care institutions. Kosovo still has not implemented systemic monitoring
of antibiotics utilization in primary dental health care, which presents a big problem
in rationalizing antibiotics utilization in dental practice. The trends in antibiotics
utilization in primary dental practice were partially illuminated by the Hailiti et
al[22] research, which required manually retrieving the data of each patient in 12 ordinations
of primary dental practice. In primary dental offices where the study was conducted
during March to June 2012, the most commonly prescribed antibiotic was amoxicillin
with clavulanic acid (43.45%), which followed by metronidazole (2.31 DDD) and amoxicillin
(1.25 DDD).[22] By comparing results, it is obvious that the rationalization in antibiotics utilization
is more present in secondary/tertiary facilities than in primary health care. This
can be primarily be seen from lower DDD values but secondarily from the first-choice
antibiotic, amoxicillin against amoxicillin with clavulanic acid. The higher level
of rationalization in tertiary care can possibly be explained by research, where dentists
working in a university/hospital setting are more secure in making decisions regarding
treatments and following protocols and accurate guidelines.[23]
Regarding the dosage and duration of antibiotic therapy, the most prescribed antibiotic
was 500 mg of amoxicillin administered 3 × 1 for 5 days. The dosage and number of
days are prescribed according to the clinical characteristics of patients. For cefazolin,
the prescriptions were 3 g per os for 5 days, for cefalexin 1.5 g per os for 5 days,
and for amoxiclav 1.5 g per os for 5 days as well. A similarity with the Croatian
study was in the most common indication for antibiotics prescription, in Kosovo for
KO4.7 (periapical abscess) without sinus and in Croatia for periapical or periodontal
abscess,[21] a fact which is similar also with findings of Palmer et al.[24] This pattern of antibiotic prescribing is found to be accurate with the actual recommendations.
But this result has to be confirmed with a further study determining prescription
patterns for primary private dental health care, which are not part of clinics.
Although on a national level, a positive trend in rational prescription is observed,
when analyzing each city separately, the case is different for each one. Regarding
the scale of the rational use of antibiotics, in the case of Vushtrri, antibiotics
were frequently prescribed for KO4.4 (acute apical periodontitis of pulpal origin),
even though the clinical relevance of bacteria being present in the tissues is still
not clearly defined in these infections.[25] Regarding antibiotics prescriptions for KO4.1 (necrosis of the pulp) in FHCC V “Dardani,”
Prishtinë, these drugs cannot achieve an adequate therapeutic concentration within
the necrotic pulp[26] as well as are not needed in periapical infections because of meticulous endodontic
technique use.[27] In the Family Health Care Center IX “Vneshta,” Prishtinë, antibiotics were frequently
prescribed for KO4.2 (pulp degeneration) and some other studies have mentioned overprescription
of these drugs in this case (irreversible pulpitis).[28] In the Family Health Care Center 1, Prishtinë, the most common dental health condition
for antibiotics prescription was also KO3.6 (deposits on teeth), which requires plaque
removal and hygiene measures. In the Main Center of Family Medicine in Obiliq, the
second most common dental condition for antibiotics' prescription was ZO1.2 (dental
examination) even though antibiotics are not needed for simple dental examinations
without defining a proper diagnosis. In the Main Center of Family Medicine in Hani
i Elezit, KO4.0 (pulpitis) was the most frequent condition for antibiotics prescription
by dentists, even though pulpitis is a clinical case, on which antibiotics are not
needed.[29] The treatment of pulpitis, as well as periapical periodontitis, requires only operative
measures.[30] Also, in Gjilan, KO4.5 was the most common dental condition treated with antibiotics,
even though the routine use of systemic antibiotics in the treatment of chronic periodontitis
is not justified in normal healthy patients because of the related risks.[31] In these cases, the removal of the calculus and infected tissue by scaling and root
planing procedure with irrigation removes the infectious foci and resolves the inflammation.[25]
There is currently a culture of antibiotic overuse in Kosovo, including attitudes
and behaviors, and hence also experiences of patients, pharmacists, and physicians,
which is possibly underlying the high consumption of antibiotics in the country.[5]
[32] However, a level of awareness exists of the current problematic situation among
practitioners and policy makers.[5] In a study conducted in 2011 in Kosovo, antimicrobial use in 2011 was 26.3% DDD
per 1,000 inhabitants per day and 56.8% of inpatients were using at least one antibiotic
with ceftriaxone, as the most prescribed antibiotic,[33] while data on antibiotic usage in dentistry to the date are unavailable. Previous
studies have shown a high prescription rate of antibiotics in dental care in Kosovo.[34]
[35] Most of the antibiotics prescriptions are empirical and use broad-spectrum antibiotics
compared with narrow-spectrum ones. Although there are recommendations about antibiotic
therapy in dentistry, there are no surveillance measures or research done to corroborate
if dentists follow national policy measures and recommendations.
The limitation of the study is the lack of information on the prescription pattern
from general and private dentistry practice, which would provide better insight into
general antibiotic utilization from overall dentistry practice. The problem seems
to be structural in nature; since the data collection method differs for each region
and type of practice, many of them still uncategorized.
Based on the above findings, although there is an observed decreasing trend of antibiotic
use in Kosovo on a national level in the years 2015 to 2019, many separate and smaller
cities and places need improvement in antibiotic utilization. The decreasing trend
is a positive result of the national antibiotic awareness program and should be continued
and adjusted for observed differences. In the end, it can be stated, in light of the
global dental health care standards, the irrational use of antibiotics in Kosovo remains
a problem, which needs to be monitored and further addressed.
Conclusion
The results demonstrated that the patterns of antibiotics prescriptions by dental
practitioners in Kosovo during the years 2015 to 2019 have an improving trend because
fewer antibiotics have been used in secondary/tertiary dental clinics. Amoxicillin
was the first-choice antibiotic as recommended, but co-amoxiclav utilization has shown
a rapidly increasing trend which is a sign for alert and closer surveillance of antibiotic
utilization in dentistry. Compared with the global health care standards, the irrational
use of antibiotics in dental health care clinics in Kosovo still exist, and this issue
should be further addressed by respective actors. There has been great inconsistency
in prescribing patterns for different regions of Kosovo, which needs to be addressed
in further investigations. Rational use of antibiotics in dental health care is imperative
not only for dentists but also for pharmacists and patients. Kosovo and other Western
Balkan countries need to review and/or fully align their national legal framework
to enable effective implementation of EU legislation relating to AMR and EU standards;
to set specific and measurable targets as a basis for national strategies and action
plans and to have regular information updates on AMR and antimicrobial consumption
available for proper monitoring against targets.