Key words
sequence-defined macromolecules - shape-defined macromolecules - Sonogashira coupling
- iterative exponential growth - density functional theory - π-conjugation
Introduction
Poly(p-phenylene ethynylenes) (PPEs)[2] are special in that they belong (together with other poly(p-phenylene)s)[3] to a class of conjugated, non-ladder polymers, whose backbone structures are fully
shape-defined. This shape persistence arises from the fact that, with fully linear
triple bonds, rotation around any of the single/triple bonds present in the backbone
of a PPE does not change a PPE's overall end-to-end distance. With other macromolecules,
a similar degree of shape persistence can only be obtained by introducing rings into
the backbones, for example, with chirality-assisted synthesis.[4]
Due to their linearity, high degree of π-conjugation, and associated electronic communication
between the different phenylene units, π-conjugated macromolecules[5] (including PPEs) have found applications in the fields of sensing,[3b]
[3e]
[3j]
[6] organic electronics,[3h]
[7] and biological imaging.[2d]
[3j]
[8] However, open questions still remain as to how the geometrical and photophysical
properties of PPEs are affected by electron-withdrawing substituents[3g]
[9] like ester groups. Initial studies in this regard have focused on ester-functionalized
PPE systems with a distribution of different lengths.[10] However, a size distribution in chain lengths can make it difficult to correlate
the detailed photophysical properties with chain length, since the spectra are naturally
broadened due to the inherent length distributions present in each sample. While more
challenging to access,[11] the study of unimolecular macromolecules offers valuable additional information,
in particular as to how absorption linewidths are affected by conformational disorder.[12] Yet, the prior literature investigating[13] unimolecular models of PPEs has been focused primarily on unsubstituted and/or alkoxy-substituted
oligo(p-phenylene ethynylenes) (OPEs), which behave quite differently from ester-functionalized
OPE systems, as detailed in the Results and Discussions section. Here we now synthesized
some of the largest, unimolecular, ester-functionalized OPEs with iterative exponential
growth[14] (IEG).
Results and Discussion
We started this work with density functional theory (DFT) calculations[15] to predict the exact geometries of the triple bonds in OPEs with various substituents.
To account for dispersion interactions, we utilized the B3LYP-MM functional[16] with the cc-pVDZ++ basis set (for single-point calculations) and the LACVP* basis
set (for geometry optimizations). The B3LYP-MM parameters were carefully optimized
with a large dataset of non-covalent interaction energies to accurately reproduce
dispersion interactions, even in the presence of basis set superposition error.[16e]
As a simple model for ester-functionalized OPEs, we utilized tetramethyl 2,2'-(ethyne-1,2-diyl)diterephthalate
(1) for our DFT analysis. To our surprise, we noted that in the optimized structure
of 1 (lowest energy structure in vacuum, see [Figure 3B] for an alternative low-energy conformation), the triple bonds are bent ([Figure 1A]), with C–C≡C angles of 171.7°. This finding is in stark contrast to the larger C–C≡C
angles of 180.0° and 177.9°, which we observed at the same level of theory for the
corresponding unsubstituted (1,2-diphenylethyne) as well as for methoxyl-substituted
(1,2-bis(2,5-dimethoxyphenyl)ethyne) systems (see the Supporting Information for the
optimized structures). We then calculated the critical points of the electron density
and used them to visualize ([Figure 1A]) the non-covalent interactions that are primarily responsible for the bending of
the triple bonds with the NCI code[17] implemented in the Jaguar[18] software package. The NCI critical points, which were calculated from the electron
density ([Figure 1B]), clearly demonstrate the presence of attractive, supramolecular interactions between
the carbonyl groups of the ester groups, and the triple bonds. This result is consistent
with triple-bond bending, driven by carbonyl-to-alkyne electron donation. Further
experimental evidence for these interactions stems from a published[19] crystal structure ([Figure 1C]) of a model compound (dimethyl 2,2'-(ethyne-1,2-diyl)bis(3-(2-((t-butoxycarbonyl)amino)-propanamido)benzoate), which also shows the bent triple bonds
arising from the carbonyl-to-alkyne interactions).
Figure 1
A. DFT-optimized tetramethyl 2,2'-(ethyne-1,2-diyl)diterephthalate (1) as a model for an OPE repeat unit. The DFT-optimized structure (lowest energy conformation
in vacuum, see [Figure 3B] for an alternate low-energy conformation) illustrates how the triple bonds in the
OPEs bend due to carbonyl-to-alkyne electron donation effects. NCI critical points,
calculated with the Jaguar software package from the electron density (see Panel B), are illustrated with blue spheres. As has been established by Johnson et al. see
Ref. ([17] these NCI critical points represent attractive supramolecular interactions (NCI
interaction strength = 9.0 kcal mol−1 in vacuum and 9.1 kcal mol−1 in CHCl3 with a PBF solvent model). B. DFT-calculated electron density (isosurface at 0.014 a.u.) of tetramethyl 2,2'-(ethyne-1,2-diyl)diterephthalate
(1). Arrows indicate the enhanced sections of the electron density, which correspond
to the attractive supramolecular interactions between the carbonyl groups and the
alkyne units of 1 identified by the NCI analysis shown in Panel A. C. Single-crystal X-ray structure of a model compound (dimethyl 2,2'-(ethyne-1,2-diyl)bis(3-(2-((t-butoxycarbonyl)amino)-propanamido)benzoate), reported in Ref. [19], CCDC 915930), which clearly shows the bent triple bonds arising due to carbonyl-to-alkyne
interactions.
Next, we discovered that the carbonyl-to-alkyne interactions also significantly alter
the barriers for rotation around the triple bonds in the OPEs. Notably, we found ([Figure 2]) the barrier for rotation around the triple bond in the ester-functionalized model
system tetramethyl-2,2'-(ethyne-1,2-diyl)diterephthalate (1) to be nearly twice as high as in the unsubstituted model system, 1,2-diphenylethyne
(2). This finding is explained by the carbonyl-to-alkyne interactions, which desymmetrize
([Figure 2C]) the two orthogonal π-bonds of the alkynes in the backbone of the OPEs.
Figure 2
A. Carbonyl-to-alkyne electron donation effects on the torsional profiles (triple bond
rotation) of 2,2'-(ethyne-1,2-diyl)diterephthalate (1) and 1,2-diphenylethyne. Torsional profiles were calculated at the B3LYP-MM/cc-pVDZ + +//B3LYP-MM/LACVP*
level of theory in vacuum. B. Definition of the dihedral angles ω used as the abscissa for the torsional plots.
C. Carbonyl-to-alkyne electron donation effects lead to angled triple bonds with non-degenerate
π-bonds.
Based on these computational results, which demonstrate the unique geometrical and
conformational properties of ester-functionalized OPEs, we next set out to synthesize
such macromolecules in a unimolecular fashion. As shown in [Scheme 1], the synthesis of up to ∼10 nm long, unimolecular OPEs was accomplished with Sonogashira
coupling-based IEG synthesis.[20]
Scheme 1 Iterative convergent/divergent (a.k.a. iterative-exponential growth – IEG) synthesis
of unimolecular oligo(p-phenylene ethynylenes) (OPEs), substituted with up to 32 ester functional groups.
Conditions for activation (see the Supporting Information for details): i) diazotization:
NaNO2, HCl, H2O, CH3CN, toluene (used for the synthesis of the longer oligomers 4, 5, and 6 to enhance solubility), 0° C. ii) Iodination: KI, 0° C. Conditions for triisopropylsilyl
(TIPS) deprotection (see the Supporting Information for details): iii) tetrabutylammonium
fluoride (TBAF), CH2Cl2, room temperature. Conditions for Sonogashira couplings (see the Supporting Information
for details): iv) Pd(PPh3)4 (3 mol%), CuI (6 mol%), NEt3, DMF, 70 °C. Notably, all intermediates, including the unprotected acetylenes with
free amino groups, are air stable. Furthermore, the carbonyl groups of the ester substituents
assist the oxidative addition step of the Sonogashira couplings.
The starting material, bis(2-ethylhexyl)-2-amino-5-((triisopropylsilyl)ethynyl)terephthalate
(3), was synthesized as detailed in the Supporting Information. Briefly, 2-amino-5-iodo-1,4-benzenedicarboxylic
acid (synthesized as described previously in the literature)[21] was deprotonated with potassium carbonate, and the resulting bis(carboxylate) derivative
alkylated with 3-(bromomethyl)heptane. Sonogashira coupling with (triisopropylsilyl)acetylene
then afforded bis(2-ethylhexyl)-2-amino-5-((triisopropylsilyl)ethynyl)terephthalate
(3) as the starting point for IEG growth.
As detailed in [Scheme 1], IEG growth of the OPEs then consisted of three simple steps, which were applied
iteratively.[22] (i) About half of the triisopropylsilyl (TIPS)-protected sample at each growth stage
is deprotected with tetrabutylammonium fluoride (TBAF) to afford the terminal alkyne
derivative (which can directly engage as the alkyne donor in a Sonogashira cross-coupling).
(ii) The other half of the sample is then activated to become the alkyne acceptor
for the Sonogashira coupling step by converting the terminal aniline group into an
aryl iodide, via a one-pot diazotization/iodination[23] reaction sequence. (iii) Finally, the aryl iodide component is linked to the component
containing the free acetylene group in a Sonogashira coupling step to double the chain
length. Notably, the presence of the electron-withdrawing ester groups along the OPE
backbone renders all the intermediates (including the unprotected acetylenes) fully
air-stable. Related intermediates for alkoxy-substituted OPE derivatives can show
air-sensitivity for increased polymer lengths, a challenge[24] which seems to be completely avoided by our ester-functionalized backbones.
With this IEG approach we were able to isolate the OPEs 4–7.[25]
[26]
[27]
[28]
[29]
7 represents, to the best of our knowledge, the longest fully ester-functionalized
OPE synthesized to date. With 7 in hand, we set out to investigate the effects of the ester substituents on the photo-physics
of the unimolecular OPEs. The UV/Vis absorption spectrum of 7 displayed ([Figure 3A]) a similar absorption maximum (at 405 nm) as the previously reported[30] heptadecameric OPE 8, which contains both unsubstituted phenylenes and alkoxy-substituted phenylene units.
Interestingly, however, the UV/Vis absorption spectrum of 7 was clearly broadened ([Figure 3A]), compared to the UV/Vis absorption spectrum of 8. Significant line-broadening was also observed (see [Supplementary Figures S15] and [S16]) for the shorter oligomers 5 and 6.
Figure 3 Enhanced conformational disorder resulting from carbonyl-to-alkyne-derived alkyne-bending
contributes to broadening of the UV/Vis absorption spectrum of the hexadecamer 7. A. Comparison of the UV/Vis absorption spectrum (CHCl3) of 7 to the UV/Vis absorption spectrum (CHCl3) of the mixed unsubstituted/alkoxy-substituted OPE 8. The UV/Vis absorption data for 8 were extracted with the WebPlotDigitizer from Ref. [30]. Broadening of the UV/Vis absorption spectrum for the OPE 7 with the ester groups is observed, compared to the OPE 8, which lacks the ability to engage in carbonyl-to-alkyne electron donation. B. Alternative low-energy conformation of the OPE model compound 1. Relative energy (relative to the conformation shown in [Figure 1A]) in vacuum, E
rel, vacuum = 0.05 kcal mol−1. Relative energy with the CHCl3 Poisson–Boltzmann finite element (PBF) solvent model implemented in Jaguar, E
rel, CHCl3 = –0.38 kcal mol−1. We hypothesize that this secondary low-energy conformation (which is accessible
to each of the 15 internal triple bonds of the ester-functionalized OPE 7) contributes to the observed ([Figure 3A]) line broadening of the UV/Vis absorption spectrum of 7. The relative energies were calculated at the B3LYP-MM/cc-pVDZ + +//B3LYP-MM/LACVP*
level of theory. Similar line broadening is observed for the shorter oligomers 5 and 6 (see [Supplementary Figures S15] and [S16]).
DFT calculations (performed like before at the B3LYP-MM/cc-pVDZ++//B3LYP-MM/LACVP*
level[16] of theory to account for dispersion interactions as well as basis set superposition
error) were able to explain the observed broadening of the UV/Vis absorption spectrum
caused by the ester substituents on the OPE 7. Specifically, the DFT calculations showed that, due to the bent triple bonds, an
alternate low-energy conformation exists for each triple bond. This secondary low-energy
conformation is only 0.05 kcal mol−1 higher in energy than the most stable conformation (shown in [Figure 1]) in vacuum, while it becomes slightly favored in energy when applying a Poisson–Boltzmann
finite element (PBF) solvent model in CHCl3. In general, solvation favors the alternate low-energy conformation shown in [Figure 3B], as it possesses a larger dipole moment (3.4 debye) than the conformation shown
in [Figure 1A] (0.0 debye). The alternate conformation of the triple bond, in which both ortho-ester groups are located on the same side of the triple bond, is stabilized by [C–H…O]-hydrogen bonds,[31] which are shown as critical points of the electron density (blue spheres) in [Figure 3B]. Given the small energetic differences between these two very distinct conformations,
we conclude that both of these low-energy conformations very likely coexist in solution
for each of the 15 triple bonds in 7, which induces significant conformational disorder, and associated conformational
line broadening of the UV/Vis absorption spectrum of 7.[32]
Conclusions
We investigated the effects of electron-withdrawing ester functions on the geometry
and photophysical properties of OPEs, for the first time with unimolecular, ester-functionalized
OPEs up to ∼10 nm in length (with up to 16 repeating units). We demonstrated that
– in contrast to unsubstituted and alkoxy-substituted OPEs – the triple bonds in the
ester-functionalized OPEs have a tendency to bend, departing from their idealized,
fully linear conformations. The observed bending of the triple bonds in the ester-functionalized
OPEs is driven by carbonyl-to-alkyne electron donation effects, which also increase
the rotational barriers around the triple bonds, and lead to enhanced conformational
disorder and broadening of the UV/Vis absorption spectra. Our results advance the
fundamental understanding of how the geometrical and associated photophysical properties
of unimolecular, π-conjugated oligomers and polymers can be tuned with electron-withdrawing
ester substituents. We are currently utilizing our new unimolecular, ester-functionalized
macromolecules as templates for polymer replication, as well as for sensing applications.