Keywords
perioperative protocols in COVID-19 - neurosurgery practices and outcome - health
care worker infection
Introduction
Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) is a life-threatening illness caused by severe
acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) virus that manifests as fever,
cough, and breathlessness, but may rapidly progress to pneumonia, respiratory failure,
septic shock, multiorgan dysfunction, and death; cardiac, gastrointestinal, dermatological,
and neurological manifestations are also reported.[1] Due to its rapid human-to-human transmission via direct aerosols dispersion or fomites,
COVID-19 has now evolved into a pandemic that has crippled the entire world. Most
hospitals, including ours, have deferred the management of chronic ailments and elective
surgeries; however, we continued to undertake emergency neurosurgeries due to the
devastating consequences of delaying them.[2]
Conducting neurosurgery during the COVID pandemic raises important concerns related
to its risks and outcome. These include, the dreaded risk of transmitting this highly
contagious disease among the health care workers (HCWs) of neurosurgical wards, operating
theaters (OTs), and intensive care unit (ICU), and the possible perioperative deterioration
of the surgical patient due to either, a newly acquired infection, or worsening of
an existing infection; a 20 to 27% increase in critical postoperative complications
and mortality has been reported in COVID positive surgical patients.[3]
[4] Further, neurosurgical patients may be misdiagnosed with COVID illness due to overlapping
respiratory symptoms, or COVID patients may be mistaken to have neurological disease
due to manifestations like altered sensorium, seizures, unsteady gait, stroke, cognitive
impairment, and localized neuralgia; the resultant mismanagement of both these conditions
can be disastrous.[5]
[6] A good knowledge of COVID illness and its perioperative implications in neurosurgery,
and formulation of workplace protocols that address the safety concerns of HCWs and
surgical patients is thus necessary; medical literature including perioperative management
guidelines for this novel disease are still limited.[7]
[8]
[9]
[10]
[11]
[12] We have devised our own Neurosurgical Standard Operating Procedures (NS-SOPs) for
preventing infection transmission among the HCWs, and promptly managing any postoperative
COVID-related worsening of neurosurgical patients ([Table 1]). We describe here our institutional experience in the perioperative management
of neurosurgical patients using these NS-SOPs and present observations from a retrospective
study undertaken by us to evaluate, (1) the incidence of workplace-acquired COVID
infection among the neurosurgical HCWs and (2) the outcome of neurosurgery done at
our hospital during this pandemic.
Table 1
Standard operating procedures for neurosurgical patients
Abbreviations: AGPs, aerosol-generating procedures; CT, computed tomography; DVT,
deep vein thrombosis; HCWs, health care workers; HME, heat moisture exchanger; HP,
histopathological; ICU, intensive care unit; OT, operating theater; PPE, personal
protective equipment; RSI, rapid sequence induction.
|
Preanesthetic check-up:
|
Transfer of patients:
-
COVID-dedicated lift used; minimum personnel utilized for transport
-
Patients transferred with surgical/N95 mask, gloves, and disposable drapes
-
Intubated patients transferred using manual ventilation with disposable circuit and
HME filter
-
Lift, trolley sanitized after every transfer
|
OT personnel:
-
Staff to use PPE with N95 mask, face shield, water-resistant hooded gown, double gloves,
shoe covers
-
Regular training of HCWs for correct technique of PPE donning/doffing and reuse of
N-95 masks
-
Entry/exit from OT and shift changes restricted during surgery; Outside runner staff
to assist inside staff
-
Two teams of anesthetists and technicians, one only for airway management with no
interchange allowed
|
OT preparation:
-
OT fully prepared before patient transfer; Donning and doffing in designated areas
with illustrations
-
Minimum personnel and equipment inside OT; Maximum use of disposable items
-
Two anesthesia trolleys inside OT, one for drugs, fluids, and other only for airway
equipment
-
Fill suction canister, dip scavenging port in 1% sodium hypochlorite
|
Conduct of surgery:
-
Negative room pressure maintained, exhaust fans to keep running, split AC switched
off before patient transfer and restarted 30 minutes after intubation; doors closed
during surgery
-
Patient positioning only by OT staff; Surgical team to enter OT 15 minutes after intubation/extubation
-
AGPs to be avoided inside OT; All record keeping outside OT; minimize surgical time
-
OT sanitization for 1 hour; Supervision by senior staff; Wear full PPE; Use disposable
cleaning items; Discard airway disposables, dip other items in 1% hypochlorite for
30 minutes; Hydrogen peroxide fogging
-
Waste disposal in bins with double bags, linen in sealed 2 bags; bins/trolleys sprayed
with 1% hypochlorite
|
COVID-specific anesthesia protocol: Avoid anesthetic AGPs
-
Avoid coughing; Use anti-sialagogues, antiemetics; Preoxygenate, RSI; Experienced
intubating anesthetist
-
Video-laryngoscope, intubation box; 2 HME filters on circuit; Closed suctioning; Postextubation
mask
|
COVID-specific neurosurgical protocol: Avoid neurosurgical AGPs
-
Bone drilling inside plastic cover; avoid Mayfield head clamp; use dedicated OT surgical
markers
-
Send specimen in tight-fit plastic box sealed inside plastic bag; Wear lead apron
under PPE and disinfect
|
Postoperative management:
-
Oxygen therapy, early DVT prophylaxis for all patients; no AGPs in ICU
-
Close monitoring for early detection of COVID-related clinical deterioration, new-onset
COVID illness; Urgent chest X-ray and CT scan available; low threshold for intubation/
ventilation
-
Restricted attendant entry in the ICU; Patient discharge as per prevailing government
guidelines
-
Postdischarge telephonic follow-up of patients
|
Lifestyle changes and home safety measures for HCWs:
-
Ensure good personal hygiene, balanced diet and 8 hours sleep
-
Avoid belts, wallets, cash inside OT, minimize cellphone use; clean with 70% alcohol
-
Avoid keeping beard to allow proper N-95 mask seal
-
Change footwear before entering home; Leave keys/wallet in a separate box at entrance
-
Frequent hand hygiene, shower, change of clothes; separate linen and utensils at home
-
Maintain social distancing from family members
-
Curtail/quit smoking, manage comorbidities like diabetes, hypertension
|
Methods
From April 1, 2020 onwards, all patients admitted for emergency/semi-emergency neurosurgeries
were managed using the NS-SOPs ([Table 1]). The preoperative protocol included evaluation of neurological disease and triaging
to determine surgical priorities, and screening of patients for COVID infection using
a COVID Screening Proforma devised by us ([Table 2]). COVID suspects were identified based on well-defined criteria and confirmation
was done using the real-time reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR)
and TrueNat tests, as per the prevailing government guidelines. However, due to nonavailability
of our own testing facilities and delayed test results from elsewhere, COVID suspects
requiring emergent surgery were operated upon without testing, considering them as
COVID positives.[13] Mid-June onwards, all COVID suspects were tested in-house and confirmed positives
identified. The risk–benefit ratio for neurosurgery in COVID positives was ascertained
by comparing the hazards of operating during a pandemic with the adverse consequences
of deferment[14]; thus, surgery was undertaken either immediately, or after the patients recovered
in a COVID center. The intraoperative protocol included modifications in neurosurgical
and neuroanesthesia practices to prevent infection transmission, especially avoiding
the aerosol-generating procedures (AGPs).[15] These intraoperative SOPs were also followed in COVID negatives as false negative
RT-PCR results have been reported in up to 30 to 50% of tested patients.[16] The postoperative protocol included close patient monitoring for newly developed
or worsening features of COVID illness like fever, breathlessness, hypoxia, secondary
pulmonary infection, multisystem involvement, and unexplained clinical deterioration
and death; RT-PCR testing, X-ray chest, and computed tomography (CT) scan chest were
done promptly for confirmation. Patients discharged from hospital were advised isolation
at home for 10 days. They were contacted on phone after 2 weeks for any development
of COVID-related manifestations, and if confirmed, were referred to a COVID center.
Table 2
COVID screening proforma for neurosurgical patients (salient features)
Abbreviations: CKD, chronic kidney disease; COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease;
CT, computed tomography; CBC, complete blood count; ESW, essential services worker;
HCW, health care worker; IL-6, interleukin 6; ILI, influenza-like illness; KFT, kidney
function test; LFT, liver function test; NIV, noninvasive ventilation; RR, respiratory
rate; SpO2, oxygen saturation of blood.
|
General information:
Name/Age/Sex; CR No; Address; Whether in Hotspot/Containment area; Occupation; Whether
HCW/ESW; Admission date; Diagnosis; Proposed surgery: Emergency/Urgent
COVID-relevant recent history (within past 14 days):
-
Episodes of fever, cough, breathing difficulty, ILI in patient/ family members
-
Contact of patient/ family members with symptomatic/ confirmed COVID Positive persons
-
Patient sharing same household with symptomatic/confirmed COVID positive persons
-
Foreign travel by patient/family members/close contacts
-
Visit of patient/family members to hotspot/containment areas
-
Patient/family members attended religious/social gatherings
-
Family members are HCWS/ESWs handling patients with acute respiratory illness
-
Family members/neighbors are quarantined (sticker in front of house)
-
Is patient critically ill requiring ICU management for neurological condition, sepsis,
multiorgan dysfunction, life-threatening malignancy, others
-
Additional manifestations: Diarrhea/headache/myalgia/arthralgia/fatigue/stuffy nose/red
eyes/abdominal pain/stroke/angina
-
COVID-relevant examination:
Coughing/febrile/breathless/hoarseness/ nasal and conjunctival congestion
-
Appears sick-looking/respiratory distress (RR above 25/min)/hypoxia (SpO2 below 94)
-
Patient on room air/O2 support/NIV/mechanical ventilation
Comorbidities: Diabetes mellitus/hypertension/cancer/cardiac disease/CKD/bronchial
asthma/COPD/medication with steroids/anticancer drugs/immunosuppressants
-
COVID-relevant investigations:
RT-PCR/TrueNat test
-
Chest X-ray (bilateral lung infiltrates/consolidation)/CT scan chest (ground glass
opacification)
-
CBC/LFT/KFT/serum electrolytes/Procalcitonin, creatinine-kinase, D-dimer, IL-6 (not
mandatory)
COVID status of patient:
COVID suspect/nonsuspect (based on screening); COVID positive/negative (based on test
result)
|
Anesthesia risk stratification in COVID positives. High risk for perioperative complications in the following:
-
Age more than 60 years/presence of comorbidities
-
Serious manifestations and rapid worsening (fever/respiratory distress/hemodynamic
instability/stroke/cardiac disorder/liver and kidney involvement/coagulation abnormality
-
Patient on NIV/ventilatory support due to COVID
-
Presence of COVID-induced deranged investigations
-
Surgery within 21 days of infection in symptomatic patient (highest risk 7–21 days)
|
The NS-SOPs also included specific measures for enhancing the physical and mental
well-being of our overstressed HCWs. Counseling and motivational sessions were conducted,
and lifestyle changes and home safety measures advised ([Table 1]). The HCWs were diligently monitored for development of COVID illness, and those
testing positive, were isolated and referred to COVID centers. Aggressive contact
tracing of COVID positives was done to determine the source of infection.
The data of the initial 5-month period was collected and analyzed. This included preoperative
patient profile and clinical condition; COVID screening and testing results; neurosurgical
details; perioperative course and complications; postdischarge follow-up of the patients;
occurrences of COVID infection in HCWs; postinfection course; details of contact tracing;
instances of breach in compliance of NS-SOPs; and number of unmotivated, careless,
or frequently absent HCWs.
Results
Between April 1 and August 31, 2020, 175 patients were admitted for various neurosurgical
emergencies/semi-emergencies in our hospital. The surgeries were triaged as emergent,
if needed within 2 days, and urgent, if could be deferred for 2 weeks.[14]
[Table 3] depicts the demographic profile and preoperative COVID-specific data of the admitted
patients. Patients at high risk for developing COVID infection included those above
60 years (11 patients; 6.3%), below 1 year (18 patients; 10.5%), and having comorbidities
(102 patients; 58.3%). COVID screening detected 48 patients (27.6%) as COVID suspects,
of which 8 patients could not be tested due to their emergent surgery and were considered
as COVID positives. Testing in the remaining 40 COVID suspects revealed 9 COVID positives
who were shifted to a COVID center to recover. While 3 patients underwent surgery
after testing negative, 6 patients did not report back; the 31 negatives out of the
40 COVID suspects also underwent subsequent surgery. The 127 COVID nonsuspects on
screening were not tested as per the prevailing government guidelines and were considered
as COVID negatives for surgery. In all, 169 neurosurgeries were undertaken at our
institution during this period ([Table 4]).
Table 3
Demographic profile of admitted neurosurgical patients (n = 175)
Abbreviations: COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; ESWs, essential services
workers; HCWs, health care workers; SD, standard deviation.
|
Age (y), mean ± SD
Age, n (%)
-
Age < 1 y
-
Age < 18 y
-
Age 18–60 y
-
Age > 60 y
|
29.6 ± 20.7
18 (10.5%)
61 (34.8%)
85 (48.6%)
11 (6.3%)
|
Sex, n (%): Males; Females
|
99 (56.8%); 76 (43.4%)
|
Patients with comorbidities, n (%)
|
41 (23.4%)
29 (16.6%)
6 (3.4%)
11 (6.3%)
15 (8.6%)
|
Patients with COVID status on screening, n (%)
-
COVID suspects
-
COVID nonsuspects
|
48 (27.4%)
127 (72.6%)
|
COVID suspects as per screening criteria, n (%)
-
Residing in hotspots/containment zones
-
HCWs, ESWs
-
Self-symptomatic
-
Symptomatic close contacts
-
Attended social/religious gatherings
|
26 (14.7%)
4 (2.2%)
7 (3.2%)
7 (3.2%)
4 (1.1%)
|
Testing status of 48 COVID suspects, n (%):
– COVID positives
– COVID negatives
|
8 (3.2%)
40 (28.6%)
9 (8.6%)
31 (16.8%)
|
Table 4
Neurosurgeries undertaken at our institute during the initial 5 months
Abbreviations: ETV, endoscopic third ventriculostomy; VP, ventriculo-peritoneal.
|
Aneurysmal surgeries
-
Craniotomy and clipping
-
Endovascular coiling
|
29 (17.1%)
9 (5.3%)
20 (11.8%)
|
Craniotomy and tumor excision
-
Meningiomas
-
Glioblastomas
-
Pituitary adenomas
-
Schwannomas
-
Pineal gland tumors
-
Metastatic brain tumors
|
66 (39.1%)
26 (15.4%)
14 (8.2%)
7 (4.1%)
6 (3.5%)
2 (1.1%)
1 (0.6%)
|
Surgeries for hydrocephalous
-
Primary V-P shunting
-
Revision V-P shunting
-
ETV
|
46 (27.2%)
12 (7.1%)
16 (9.5%)
18 (10.7%)
|
Burr-hole surgeries
|
6 (3.5%)
|
Spine surgeries
|
7 (4.1%)
|
Decompressive craniotomies
|
3 (1.8%)
|
Workplace-Acquired COVID Infection among Our Neurosurgical HCWs
Out of the 215 HCWs in neurosurgery and neuroanesthesia, 19 developed clinical features
resembling COVID illness like cough (17; 89.5%), fever (7; 36.8%), myalgia (4; 21.1%),
and breathlessness (2; 10.5%). Testing detected 19 HCWs (8.83%) to be COVID positive,
out of which 10 (53%) were nurses, 4 (21%) were OT technicians, 2 (10%) were doctors,
and 3 (16%) were nursing orderlies and sweepers ([Fig. 1A]). Contact tracing revealed that 11 58% HCWs acquired the infection from external
sources like infected family members/neighbors or from attending social/religious
gatherings. The source was uncertain in 5 (26%) HCWs. The infection was clearly workplace-acquired
in 3 (16%) nurses who worked and lunched together; they developed symptoms sequentially
within 2 to 3 days after the first sick nurse got infected from a family member ([Fig. 1B]). Infections at our hospital were sporadic with no cluster of infections observed
at any time. The infected HCWs were mostly home-quarantined, but 2 of them were shifted
to a COVID center after developing breathlessness and hypoxia; all the HCWs returned
to work after full recovery. There were approximately 20 instances of carelessness
in adhering to the NS-SOPs but no report of any unmotivated or frequently absenting
HCWs.
Fig. 1 Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19)infection among Health Care Workers. (A) Distribution of COVID positive health care workers. (B) Source of infection among health care workers.
Course and Outcome of Neurosurgery at Our Hospital during the COVID Pandemic
Among the 8 COVID suspects considered as positives for surgery, 1 patient developed
fever and pneumonia-like features on the second postoperative day (POD), and his CT
scan chest showed bilateral lower-lobe ground-glass opacities typical of COVID infection;
but he died without getting COVID tested. Another patient on ventilator developed
unexpected hypoxia and extensive bilateral lung infiltrates on CT scan suggestive
of COVID and died; he had tested negative. Among the 31 COVID negatives, 3 patients
died after surgery due to neurosurgical complications, but 1 patient developed sudden,
unexplained clinical deterioration on the first POD and died before COVID testing.
Out of the 127 COVID nonsuspects who were not tested before surgery, 9 patients died
from identifiable neurosurgical complications, but 2 patients had unexpected early
death, of which, 1 patient had clinical and radiographic features of acute respiratory
distress syndrome (ARDS). The overall perioperative mortality rate was 10.1% (17/169
patients); mortality in COVID suspects was 12.5% (6/48 patients) and in COVID nonsuspects
was 8.6% (11/127 patients). Out of the total 17 deaths, 5 postoperative deaths were
unexpected and quick; their cause, though strongly suspected to be due to COVID illness
by the typical clinical manifestations, could not be ascertained in the absence of
confirmatory testing. None of the discharged patients developed COVID illness within
2 weeks of leaving hospital. Our observations are summarized as a flowchart in ([Fig. 2]).
Discussion
The HCWs are at high risk of developing COVID illness due to their proximity to infected
patients and involvement in AGPs; a 12 time increased risk of testing positive is
reported in frontline HCWs.[17] The neurosurgical HCWs are particularly vulnerable due to their increased handling
of untested emergency patients, repeated intubations, prolonged ventilations, and
frequent chest physiotherapies. COVID-specific teaching and training programs and
implementation of precautionary measures at work are thus needed to ensure their safety
during the pandemic. We dispersed medical literature and conducted hands-on workshops
on COVID-related issues, particularly the preventive measures and correct donning/doffing
methods. Perioperative NS-SOPs were devised and applied starting from admission to
discharge/death of the patients ([Tables 1] and [2]). AGPs in the OT and ICU were identified and avoided. These included bag-mask ventilation,
awake intubation, bronchoscopy, tracheostomy, nebulization, noninvasive ventilation,
high-flow nasal oxygen delivery, chest physiotherapy, open suctioning, open bone-drilling,
use of cavitron ultrasonic surgical aspirator, awake craniotomies, and endoscopic
procedures; [10]
[11]
[18] emergency transsphenoidal hypophysectomy has been shown to cause viral transmission
to multiple HCWs even with appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE).[18] Specific modifications were made in our routine neurosurgical practice like using
OTs with high air change frequencies and particulate air filters[7] and use of intubation boxes, performing bone drilling with low-speed electric drills
inside a plastic cover and with copious irrigation, use of electrocautery at low power,
and preventing sinus breach during surgery.[11] We preferred endovascular coiling (11.8%) over aneurysm clipping (5.3%) and endoscopic
third ventriculostomy (10.7%) over ventriculoperitoneal shunt surgery (7.1%) and avoided
resection of pituitary adenomas through the transsphenoidal route and instrumentation
of spine. Delaying of definitive surgeries, advising palliative care, performing emergency
procedures under local anesthesia, and use of alternate treatments like external ventricular
drainage, antiedema measures, and radiosurgery for brain tumors are further neurosurgical
recommendations.[10]
[12]
[14]
[15]
[18] HCWs on duty during this COVID pandemic are facing immense psychological stress
due to the fear of getting infected, the challenges of remembering and strictly following
the evolving SOPs, enduring the discomfort of working in PPEs, extended working hours,
and the anxiety of carrying the infection to their homes. To cope with these worries,
our HCWs were counseled repeatedly and encouraged to adopt the hospital and home lifestyle
changes incorporated in our NS-SOPs ([Table 1]).
Prior literature on neuroanesthesia and neurosurgery SOPs is available, though limited.[7]
[8]
[9]
[10]
[11]
[12] Few authors have evaluated the impact of SOPs in preventing workplace-acquired COVID
infection among the HCWs, like done in this study. The incidence of infection among
our HCWs was 8.83% in the 5-month period under study, and only sporadic instances
were found. Alajmi et al reported a 10.6% incidence of COVID infection among their
HCWs; most HCWs acquired the infection at a non-COVID facility like ours.[19] In another study, 9.8% of HCWs had prevalence of antibodies for SARS-CoV-2 infection
during a 14-day period.[20] Most of our COVID positive HCWs attributed their infection to an outside source
with only 3 out of 19 (15.7%) instances of workplace-acquired infection. A similar
incidence (16.7%) was reported from Singapore during the initial period of pandemic,[21] and from Netherland, where no in-hospital transmission was observed, and most instances
were acquired from a community outbreak[22]; the risk of HCWs acquiring infection from an outside source was seen to rise significantly
with increased community transmission.[23] We found the highest infection among staff nurses (53%) and least among doctors
(10%); similar observations were also reported previously.[24] To prevent future instances of HCWs infection we imposed stricter social distancing
and sanitizing norms and ensured stringent compliance with NS-SOPs.
COVID-infected patients needing emergent surgical intervention were found to have
poorer outcomes compared with their matched controls. In a study conducted among various
surgical disciplines, including neurosurgery, a significantly higher mortality was
reported in the COVID-19 group compared with the control group (8 patients: 19.51%
vs. 2 patients: 2.44%; odds ratio 9.5; 95% confidence interval, 1.77–96.53).[25] Other authors reported surgical patients who acquired perioperative COVID infection
to have an overall 30-day mortality of 23.8% (268 of 1,128 patients), with a high
incidence of pulmonary complications (577 patients: 51.2%).[26] The high mortality in COVID-infected patients is attributed to inflammatory mediators
causing lung injury and ARDS, and this may be more pronounced in neurosurgical patients
with preexisting pulmonary complications[27]; the resultant hypoxia and hemodynamic instability may jeopardize cerebral oxygenation
and worsen the outcome of neurosurgery.[28] We observed postoperative development of unexplained severe respiratory complications
strongly suggestive of COVID illness that resulted in the death of 5 patients. The
fact that one of these patients was COVID negative and 2 patients were nonsuspects
reiterates that screening and testing may not be sufficient to identify patients infected
with SARS-CoV-2 virus.[16] We kept a high level of suspicion for COVID throughout the perioperative period,
and on appearance of early signs and symptoms, the patients were immediately isolated
and treated. These measures are important to contain the mortality and further spread
of the virus.
Conclusion
Thus, implementing distinct perioperative protocols in neurosurgery is essential to
minimize the adverse impact of COVID illness on staff and patients, as was experienced
by us. Preoperative screening, intraoperative avoidance of AGPs, vigilant postoperative
monitoring, close postdischarge patient follow-up, and surveillance of HCWs were the
highlights of our NS-SOPs. This was the initial evaluation of our neurosurgical protocols
and practices. With progression of the pandemic and added knowledge of the COVID illness,
frequent reassessments and modifications of such protocols is required.
Fig. 2 Flowchart depicting the course and outcome of the study.