Keywords
spontaneous intracranial hypotension - recurrent subdural hematomas - bilateral subdural
hematomas - spontaneous spinal dural leaks
Key Message
In the hustle of the emergency room, a diagnosis of chronic subdural bleeds, especially
bilateral ones can imply immediate surgical evacuation. Such a course of action may
be detrimental to the patient, as described below in our experience. Therefore, to
prevent other neurosurgeons from reinventing the wheel, we present our own protocol
for recurrent bilateral subdural hematomas to improve patient outcomes and reduce
mistakes.
Introduction
Chronic subdural hemorrhage (CSDH) is a common surgical condition, owing to a collection
of blood degradation products and plasma in the subdural space, which cause mass effect
and midline shift inside the rigid calvarium.[1]
[2]
[3]
[4] [The procedure of making burrholes over the calvarium overlying the collection,
opening the dura and drainage accompanied by lavage is widely acknowledged as an effective
and simple strategy to effect good recovery. Bilateral CSDH (bCSDH) is infrequent
but not uncommon due to the cerebral atrophy, leading to tension on the bridging veins
of the subdural space and trivial trauma which may go unnoticed.[5]
[6]
[7]
[8] Recurrent CSDHs are also not uncommon as the subdural membrane can form, especially
in the elderly and infirm, and persist despite repeated attempts at drainage. Craniotomy
and membrane excision, instead of medical therapy such as calcium channel blockers,
is widely acknowledged again as successful in treating this problem.
When one encounters recurrent bilateral chronic subdural hematomas, then the alarm
bells ring as all procedures and medical therapies listed above fail to reduce recurrences
and morbidity among the patients.[9]
[10]
[11] Investigation of deeper and more sinister causes like coagulation abnormalities,
hematological malignancies, and dural vascular malformations, although pertinent,
would have been detected earlier in the preoperative workup itself. Thus, recurrent
bCSDHs are difficult to manage, as the root cause often remains obscure. Such a disease
is spontaneous intracranial hypotension (SIH).[12]
[13]
SIH has been known for many decades and is acknowledged to contribute to postural
headaches usually without the history of trauma, which succeed lumbar puncture of
spinal dural trauma. Most of these patients eventually recover with abdominal binders,
epidural blood patch (EBP)therapy, caffeine and analgesics. Recalcitrant SIH is a
novelty reported in a handful of reports. SIH leading to bilateral CSDHs while reported
in literature are noted to be the rarest of rare presentations for this rare disease.
Recurrent bCSDHs due to this phenomenon and presenting with decreased sensorium without
significant headache is noteworthy, since it changes the management protocol and is
not reported elsewhere to our knowledge.[14]
[15]
[16]
[17]
We present the case report, where a surgical perspective is offered to what started
off as a purely surgical situation, but morphed into a complex series of events which
threatened to cause major problems to the patient. Timely intervention led to the
detection and rescue of the situation, leading to an ultimately positive outcome for
the patient. The series of events however made us extensively analyze our own attempt
as well as published literature for answers regarding faster and perhaps less traumatic
algorithms for the detection and treatment of this disease. The result was our own
protocol, which we feel helps to shorten the diagnostic time and ease the dilemma
in treating such disorders. We present both the case report and its discussion and
analysis below.
Case Report
A 50-year-old male patient, who presented with progressive drowsiness without significant
headache, was diagnosed to have bCSDH. After a usual preoperative checkup which included
brain MRI and CT imaging, he was slated for surgery the next day, but a rapid deterioration
occurred over the course of the night with a drop in Glasgow coma scale (GCS) score
and urinary incontinence. He was therefore taken up for emergency surgery, and bilateral
frontal and parietal burrholes with lavage and evacuation of the bCSDH was done. No
subdural membrane was seen, and the brain surfaced well immediately after decompression.
The subdural bleeds were under moderate pressure and egressed quickly on opening of
the dura. Immediately after surgery, the patient was alert and pain-free. He was discharged
in 2 days on antiepileptics and antibiotics.
The same patient was back after 2 weeks with altered sensorium but no headache. A
scan revealed a mild residual subdural hematoma and pneumocephalus. It was presumed
that the recollection with tension pneumocephalus had led to a raise in intracranial
pressure (ICP), causing the symptoms. Hence, after explaining the risks, he was taken
up for a repeat drainage and lavage. As a membrane was suspected, a minicraniotomy
was done, and the subdural membrane was excised. The membrane was not thick or vascular
but was found to be in the early stages of formation. Despite these findings, the
procedure was completed in good faith, and the patient was shifted to recovery. Immediately
postop, he was alert and conscious, but his sensorium gradually deteriorated the next
day. The peculiar aspect of this deterioration was the complete absence of any significant
associated headaches at all, although urinary incontinence was present.
Another CT scan showed pneumocephalus with a small remnant of the subdural collections
present. The pneumocephalus was not massive enough to cause tension but seemed to
cause compression of the brain. No hyponatremia, hyperglycemia or metabolic and endocrine
causes of sensorium fluctuation were seen. Due to the diffuse brain edema and accompanying
pneumocephalus, and as a desperate attempt to decompress what was considered a high
ICP situation, a bilateral decompressive craniectomy was done. This time the patient
did not improve postsurgery, and repeat imaging showed persistent pneumocephalus.
The persistent pneumocephalus along with no improvement in sensorium despite all decompressive
measures, and normal metabolic parameters, made us suspect other pathologies. The
patient was subjected to a CT myelogram. The early films did not show any abnormality,
but a delayed sequence showed a large lateral cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leak at the
C1–C2 level ([Fig. 1]). Hence, the patient was diagnosed with spontaneous intracranial hypotension, and
was taken up for an EBP. As the spinal needle was placed into the C7 space, the patient
went into a sudden episode of bradycardia, leading to hypotension. The procedure was
immediately abandoned, and the patient was successfully resuscitated.
Fig. 1 Myelography delayed images in sagittal, axial, and coronal views, demonstrating the
egress of contrast and confirming the presence of a leak.
Due to the unstable nature of the disease, along with the risk of herniation through
the foramen magnum, the patient was taken up after stabilization for a C2 laminectomy
and leak occlusion using fibrin glue. The patient was placed under general anesthesia
with an arterial line to monitor blood pressure, carefully monitored, and placed prone
with head in flexion. A 5 cm linear vertical incision was made in the midline and
the C2 lamina was dissected out. A C2 laminectomy and fenestration of the C1 were
performed. Large venous malformations were seen on the left side just adjacent to
the C2 lamina. The veins were examined, and the leak was detected. Fibrin glue was
generously placed all over the area. No leak was seen ([Fig. 2]). At the same time, a bilateral titanium mesh cranioplasty was done to cover the
open calvarial defects and ensure the pressure differential was reduced, enabling
recalibration of ICP and expedient normalizing of symptoms. The patient was shifted
on tube under sedation and placed in intensive care. His sedation was removed after
12 hours, and he was extubated. He showed significant improvement, was eventually
shifted out of the ICU to the ward and mobilized.
Fig. 2 A large dural defect on the left C2 root sleeve.
To ensure documentation of the repair and confirm the treatment efficacy before discharge,
the myelogram was repeated to show the occlusion of the leak. The myelogram showed
admirable occlusion of the leak, suggesting complete success of the open procedure.
However, after the myelogram, the patient showed sudden and drastic deterioration
of sensorium. Another round of investigations showed a recurrence of pneumocephalus
with cerebral edema. We concluded that the lumbar puncture from the myelogram might
have led to another CSF leak, perpetuating the hypotension. Hence, an EBP was applied
at the lumbar region above the site of the myelogram. The patient improved remarkably
and was able to walk without support within 12 hours, awake, and alert, as he was
responding normally to stimuli.
The patient was discharged to review in OPD. He was slated for a detailed investigation
of possible collagen vascular disorders such as Ehler–Danlos syndrome or Marfan at
a later date, allowing him to recover from his ordeal. He was seen 2 months later
in OPD, showing complete recovery with no recurrence of the bCSDH for which he initially
visited the hospital. The tests for connective tissue disorders are ongoing, and therefore
the cause of his extremely pressure-sensitive and fragile dura remains to be detected.
Discussion
Spontaneous Intracranial Hypotension
Spontaneous Intracranial Hypotension (SIH) as the name implies, is caused by low CSF
pressure, usually secondary to an occult leak.[17]
[18] Occasional damage to the dura occurs due to tears caused by osteophytes protruding
into the canal or around the nerve sheaths. Some studies have reported that connective
tissue disorders such as Marfan syndrome, Ehlers–Danlos syndrome type 2, and autosomal
dominant polycystic kidney disease play a significant role in causing SIH.[18]
[19]
[20]
While the pathophysiology of SDH in patients with SIH remains unknown, studies have
proposed several mechanisms.[20]
[21]
[22]
[23] Downward displacement of the brain due to low CSF pressure may produce tears in
the bridging veins of the dural border cell layer, causing these veins to rupture.
Alternatively, as subdural CSF collections gradually enlarge the subdural space, the
bridging veins may stretch and rupture in some cases·
Although the most common presenting symptom in SIH is orthostatic headaches, the presentation
of bCSDH without significant postural headaches requires careful assessment of the
pathology.[23] Although the SIH induced bCSDH is due to the stretch on the bridging veins secondary
to spinal CSF egress, unusual clinical variation should prompt for more imaging.[24]
[25]
Radiology
MR imaging represents the method of choice to depict intracranial manifestations;
the neuroimaging features include diffuse meningeal enhancement, acquired Chiari malformation,
and subdural fluid collections.[23]
[24]
[25] The Monro–Kellie hypothesis is the mechanism frequently used to explain MRI findings
with aforementioned conditions.[23]
[24] A reduction in the volume of the CSF requires an increase in volume of one or both
of the other components. The most reliably demonstrated area of increased volume on
imaging is the pachymeninges, which show diffuse thickening and enhancement with gadolinium-enhanced
MRI due to lack of a blood–brain barrier and an increase in the volume of venous blood
in this compartment.[24]
[25] In cases of SIH, the site of the CSF leak rests predominantly in the cervical or
thoracic region, and the diagnosis is typically established by CT myelography or radionuclide
imaging.[25]
In our patient, CT myelography was instrumental in identifying the leak site. But
the difficulty was in suspecting such a leak in the first place, where such MR features
were absent and the deteriorating patient condition with recollecting subdural collections
and pneumocephalus suggested unusual origins.[24]
[25]
Although supportive measures and medical therapy such as hydration, bed rest, caffeine,
steroid, and parenteral fluid may provide temporary relief, a more durable treatment
is to seal the site of the leak. The mainstay of the treatment is the injection of
autologous blood (10–20 mL) into the spinal epidural space. Relief of symptoms is
often dramatic after EBP. If EBP fails the first time, it can be repeated· Complications
of cervical EBP include spinal cord and nerve root compression, chemical meningitis,
intrathecal injection of blood, seizures, and stiffness of the neck.[24]
[25].
High-Cervical Dural Leaks
Cases of large subdural hemorrhage require surgical drainage and treatment of the
underlying cause of SIH.[25] With the current technology, we can perform imaging-guided procedures in the spine
with relative safety and minimal discomfort to the patient. In cases of cervical leaks,
it is reasonable to offer a cervical blood patch as the initial treatment.[25] The problem is when patients have high-cervical fistulae. This makes blood patch
placement dangerous. Experienced anesthetists or pain specialists who are well-versed
in cisternal puncture may attempt the procedure. There are anecdotes of epidural catheters
advanced under C-arm guidance from C7 upward to the craniovertebral (CV) junction
for EBP placement. Such procedures are risky and are associated with frequent vasovagal
attacks due to the high-concentration sympathetic nerves present in the upper cervical
region.[24]
[25] Such an episode occurred with our patient, which emphasized the danger of this approach.
Some reports have suggested an EBP delivered at C7 and the patient placed in Trendelenburg
position for variable periods of time to allow the blood to trickle down to the CV
junction and block the leak. Such an approach was unacceptable to us, as we felt it
was unreliable and vague.[25]
[26]
[27]
The deteriorating condition of our patient also emphasized the need for urgent and
successful intervention. Thus, microsurgery was planned, and under vision, the leak
was sealed with fibrin glue. Spontaneous epidural leaks, especially in the cervical
region, are reported to be in close proximity to large engorged venous channels.[27]
[28] Locating such channels and looking in their vicinity enable detection of the leak;
during surgery, Valsalva maneuvers were not done, owing to the propensity of the pressure
difference to worsen the hypotension and thereby effect tonsillar herniation. Thus,
the venous channels are vital in identifying the leak.[28]
[29] A generous application of fibrin glue all around the leak helped completely seal
the rent. The patient was not extubated postsurgery. He was shifted to the ICU and
slowly extubated. Postop, he improved rapidly.
Recurrent Dural Leaks at Different Levels
Recurrent SIH due to different dural rents and leaks is extremely rare.[29] Hence, to confirm the efficacy of the surgery, myelogram was repeated. The SIH created
by the lumbar puncture was unexpected and astonishing. Pressure sensitive dura of
this nature has not been reported. Such as it was, the sealing of the rent resulted
almost instantaneous improvement. The absence of any reported literature or explanation
for this phenomenon remains a cause of concern. In the past 20 years, the reports
of SIH with recurrent SDHs which underwent successful treatment are listed below.[29] But many cases have been diagnosed retrospectively upon nonimprovement of symptoms
or frank deterioration after surgery. The sheer numbers and the difficult nature of
diagnosis in this scenario makes it necessary to devise a protocol for quick diagnosis
and treatment ([Table 1]).
Table 1
Reports of spontaneous intracranial hypotension presenting as recurrent bilateral
chronic subdural hematomas in the past 20 years from 2000 to 2020
S. No.
|
Study
|
Year of publication
|
Journal
|
1.
|
Mikawa S, Ebina T. [Spontaneous intracranial hypotension complicating subdural hematoma:
unilateral oculomotor nerve palsy caused by epidural blood patch]. No Shinkei Geka
2001; 29(8):747–753
|
2001
|
No Shinkei Geka
|
2.
|
Murakami M, Morikawa K, Matsuno A, Kaneda K, Nagashima T. Spontaneous intracranial
hypotension associated with bilateral chronic subdural hematomas--case report. Neurol
Med Chir (Tokyo) 2000; 40(9):484–488
|
2000
|
Neurological Medicine and Chirugery
|
3.
|
Kim MO, Kim J, Kang J, et al. Spontaneous intracranial hypotension as a cause of subdural
hematoma in a patient with cerebral venous thrombosis on anticoagulation treatment.
J Clin Neurol 2020; 16(2):327–329
|
2020
|
Journal of Clinical Neurology
|
4.
|
Shin HS, Lee SH, Ko HC, Koh JS. Extended pneumocephalus after drainage of chronic
subdural hematoma associated with intracranial hypotension: case report with pathophysiologic
consideration. J Korean Neurosurg Soc 2016; 59(1):69–74
|
2016
|
Journal of Korean Neurosurgery Ssociety
|
5.
|
Takahashi K, Mima T, Akiba Y. Chronic subdural hematoma associated with spontaneous
intracranial hypotension: therapeutic strategies and outcomes of 55 cases. Neurol
Med Chir (Tokyo) 2016; 56(2):69–76
|
2016
|
Neurological Medicine and Chirugery
|
6.
|
Platz J, Glücker T, Gratzl O, Woydt M. Spontaneous intracranial hypotension: case
report with subdural hematomas, steroid dependency and clinical improvement after
myelography. Zentralbl Neurochir 2007; 68(2):87–90
|
2007
|
Zentralbl Neurochirugy
|
7.
|
Takahashi T, Senbokuya N, Horikoshi T, Sato E, Nukui H, Kinouchi H. [Refractory chronic
subdural hematoma due to spontaneous intracranial hypotension]. No Shinkei Geka 2007;
35(8):799–806
|
2007
|
No Shinkei Geka
|
8.
|
Su CS, Lan MY, Chang YY, Lin WC, Liu KT. Clinical features, neuroimaging and treatment
of spontaneous intracranial hypotension and magnetic resonance imaging evidence of
blind epidural blood patch. Eur Neurol 2009; 61(5):301–307
|
2009
|
European Journal of Neurology
|
9.
|
Zhang J, Jin D, Pan KH. Epidural blood patch for spontaneous intracranial hypotension
with chronic subdural haematoma: a case report and literature review. J Int Med Res
2016; 44(4):976–981
|
2016
|
Journal of Internal Medicine Residents
|
10.
|
Mikawa S, Ebina T. [Spontaneous intracranial hypotension complicating subdural hematoma:
unilateral oculomotor nerve palsy caused by epidural blood patch]. No Shinkei Geka
2001; 29(8):747–753
|
2001
|
No Shinkei Geka
|
11.
|
Rettenmaier LA, Park BJ, Holland MT, et al. Value of targeted epidural blood patch
and management of subdural hematoma in spontaneous intracranial hypotension: case
report and review of the literature. World Neurosurg 2017; 97:27–38
|
2017
|
World Neurosurgery
|
12.
|
Wang HK, Liliang PC, Liang CL, Lu K, Hung KC, Chen HJ. Delayed subdural hematoma after
epidural blood patching in a patient with spontaneous intracranial hypotension--case
report. Neurol Med Chir (Tokyo) 2010; 50(6):479–481
|
2010
|
Neurological Medicine and Chirugery
|
13.
|
Lai TH, Fuh JL, Lirng JF, Tsai PH, Wang SJ. Subdural haematoma in patients with spontaneous
intracranial hypotension. Cephalalgia 2007; 27(2):133–138
|
2007
|
Cephalgia
|
14.
|
Chen YC, Wang YF, Li JY, et al. Treatment and prognosis of subdural hematoma in patients
with spontaneous intracranial hypotension. Cephalalgia 2016; 36(3):225–231
|
2016
|
Cephalgia
|
15.
|
Schievink WI. Spontaneous spinal cerebrospinal fluid leaks and intracranial hypotension.
JAMA 2006; 295(19):2286–2296
|
2006
|
JAMA
|
16.
|
Zhang D, Wang J, Zhang Q, He F, Hu X. Cerebral venous thrombosis in spontaneous intracranial
hypotension: a report on 4 cases and a review of the literature. Headache 2018; 58(8):1244–1255
|
2018
|
Headache
|
Bangalore Neurological Society Protocol (BNS) for Recurrent Bilateral Subdural Bleeds
Therefore, in an attempt to standardize the management of this rare and puzzling disease,
we, from the point of neurosurgeons, wish to offer our own diagnostic protocol to
prevent reinventing the wheel every time a patient presents with such symptoms, thereby
saving time,
hospital stay and agony all around. Our BNS protocol begins from the stage of bilateral
recurrent subdural bleeds, which is seen occasionally in neurosurgery outpatient clinics
and emergency rooms. The progress to decide on intervention proceeds as shown in [Fig. 3].
Fig. 3 The BNS protocol for management of spontaneous intracranial hypotension presentng
as bilateral recurrent chronic subdural hemorrhage.
When patients present with bilateral subdural bleeds, rather than immediately proposing
surgery, an MRI is advised to rule out features of SIH. MRIs are particularly important
as clinical features of raised and low ICT may overlap. In the absence of such features,
the collections maybe evacuated. But a recurrence of collections, low sensorium, worsening
pneumocephalus, and an absence of a subdural membrane should always point toward a
spinal dural leak. Myelography is diagnostic, and management is done as discussed.
Recurrence is very rare, but possible. Hence, a keen eye must be kept for dip in sensorium.
A longer than expected stay in the hospital under observation is recommended to ensure
no delayed deterioration occurs. Fortunately, recurrent spontaneous leaks are unheard
of; thus, follow-ups are generally an uneventful for both patient and neurosurgeon
alike.
Red Flags to Suspected SIH
Red Flags to Suspected SIH
-
Classical postural headache.
-
Worsening of bCSDHs/sensorium in erect position.
-
Postdural puncture headache (strong correlation).
-
Postspinal anesthesia subdural bleeds.
-
Postdural puncture cranial nerve palsy.
Conclusion
SIH is a rare chameleon which may mimic the simplest of neurosurgical emergencies.
A keen understanding of intracranial pressure dynamics will assist in diagnosis and
early management of this difficult disease. The BNS protocol suggested by us helps
to reduce trial and error, thereby improving patient outcomes and reducing hospital
stay simultaneously.