Key words
head/neck - thyroid - ablation procedures - radionuclide imaging
Introduction
Thyroid nodules can be found in a very high percentage of patients [1]. In some cases remaining completely asymptomatic, thyroid nodules might also cause
symptoms such as hoarseness, dyspnea or foreign body sensations. In some circumstances
they do not remain benign but have the potential of malignant transformation [2]. Besides surgical intervention and radioiodine therapy, there are several options
in treating these thyroid nodules in order to reduce their volume. Particularly in
the last decade, some innovations and novelties in the treatment of thyroid nodules
were developed. Promising results were described using minimally invasive therapy
approaches such as radiofrequency ablation [3] or microwave ablation [4]
[5]
[6]
[7] to reduce thyroid nodule volumes.
Microwave ablation is a very recent development in treating benign thyroid nodules,
but it has also gained an important role in treating pathologies of other parenchyma.
The first encouraging results of microwave ablation treatments have been reported
in the therapy of hepatocellular carcinoma [8]. Microwave ablation offers several advantages in comparison to other ablation techniques:
shorter ablation time, it is able to generate larger ablation zones and it is less
susceptible to heat sink effects [9]. The underlying principle of microwave ablation is the thermal heating of tissue
via agitation of water molecules using electromagnetic microwaves [10].
While scintigraphic imaging is well established in the assessment of the consistency
of thyroid nodules [11], elastography is a more recent diagnostic tool and its efficacy as a sole diagnostic
method for detecting thyroid pathologies and malignancies is controversially discussed
[12]. Quasi-static [13] ultrasound elastography is a new technique measuring tissue stiffness by detecting
tissue distortion under manual compression [14].
Studies on liver tissue in a porcine model using radiofrequency ablation (RFA) as
a thermal ablation method detected that elastographic tests show a decreased tissue
elasticity following ablation [15]. Other studies on RFA in in vivo porcine liver tissue showed that elastography is superior to B-mode ultrasound since
it is less susceptible to artifacts [16]. In comparison to the results of gross specimen evaluation, elastography slightly
underestimates the size of the ablation zone [17].
Evaluating the result of thermal ablation procedures using scintigraphic imaging and
elastography as a diagnostic follow-up is a novel approach. There were no studies
yet reported on elastography and scintigraphic imaging after microwave ablation of
thyroid nodules.
Considering that microwave ablation has an influence on tissue characteristics, these
transformations ought to be detected using elastography and scintigraphic imaging
as two different imaging methods. The aim of this study was to elucidate observable
alterations of thyroid tissue after microwave ablation via strain elastography and
scintigraphic imaging and to evaluate the feasibility of these diagnostics for the
follow-up of microwave ablated thyroid nodules.
Materials and Methods
Patients
35 patients (18 male, 17 female, age range 29 – 81 years) with 39 thyroid nodules
were included in this study and underwent microwave ablation.
The inclusion criteria were: (a) symptomatic thyroid nodules or cosmetic concerns,
(b) contraindication for surgical intervention or patient’s preference, (c) nodules
detected as “cold” by scintigraphic imaging. The exclusion criteria were: (a) asymptomatic
nodules, (b) retrosternal location and excessive nodule volume, (c) nodules highly
suspicious or proven to be malignant, (d) vicinity of critical structures such as
blood vessels, nerves, esophagus or trachea.
Written informed consent was obtained from all patients. The local ethics committee
approved the study protocol.
Pre-assessment
All nodules were pre-evaluated using laboratory tests, B-mode ultrasound (Sonix Touch
Ultrasound system, Ultrasonix Medical Corporation, Richmond, Canada), elastography,
scintigraphic imaging and fine-needle aspiration cytology to exclude patients with
malignant thyroid nodules.
Strain elastography was performed using the elastography imaging software of the Sonix
Touch Ultrasound system (Ultrasonix Medical Corporation, Richmond, Canada) and a linear
transducer.
Prior to microwave ablation, all patients underwent elastography. A color-coded ultrasound
elastography output was used. Color ranges were then classified as elasticity scores
(ES) [18]. Nodules with high elasticity (color-coded as blue) were classified as ES1, predominantly
soft nodules with mixed elasticity as ES2, predominantly hard nodules with mixed elasticity
as ES3 and nodules with low elasticity as ES4. The elastosongraphic ultrasound system
provided a compression feedback chart to control the amount of manual compression
in real-time and enabled reproducible conditions.
Scintigraphic imaging was performed using two different types of tracers, 99 mTc-pertechnetate and 99 mTc-MIBI. All patients underwent 99 mTc-pertechnetate imaging prior to microwave ablation and nodules were then classified
as “cold” (reduced tracer uptake), “indifferent” (neutral tracer uptake) and “hot”
(increased tracer uptake) with respect to the 99 mTc-pertechnetate uptake compared to the surrounding thyroid tissue.
Thyroid nodules classified as cold were subjected to fine-needle aspiration cytology
in order to exclude cold nodules of malignant pathology. Additionally, cold nodules
then gained scintigraphic 99 mTc-MIBI imaging prior to and after microwave ablation. 99 mTc-MIBI is expected to detect malignant thyroid nodules with high sensitivity [19]. In thyroid nodules, previously diagnosed as “indifferent” or “hot”, 99 mTc-pertechnetate imaging was used for scintigraphic imaging after microwave ablation.
Scintigraphic imaging scans were taken 20 minutes after intravenous injection of a
dose of 75 MBq of 99 mTc-pertechnetate. In cases of scintigraphic imaging using MIBI, the dosage and time
were 500 MBq and 10 and 60 minutes, respectively. Scintigraphic images were recorded
using a gamma camera (Mediso Ketronic Nucline® TH/22, Mediso GmbH, Medical Imaging Systems, Münster, Germany; Software InterView
XP121) equipped with a LETH collimator.
In total, 27 thyroid nodules were classified as “cold”; 11 as “indifferent” and a
single nodule in one patient was detected as “hot”, according to the pertechnetate
scan.
Microwave ablation procedure
For microwave ablation, patients were placed in a supine position with a hyper-extended
neck. Microwave ablation procedures were all performed by the same operator under
ultrasound guidance (Sonix Touch Ultrasound system; Ultrasonix Medical Corporation,
Richmond, Canada).
The puncture site was anesthetized by injecting Scandicain (1 %) subcutaneously prior
to the procedure. If thyroid nodules showed cystic components, fluid was aspirated
prior to microwave ablation. The skin was then incised and the probe was positioned
under ultrasound guidance using a preferential transisthmic access to spare critical
structures [20]. In exceptional cases of adverse conditions, craniocaudal access was chosen as an
alternative. If more than one symptomatic nodule was found in one patient, nodules
were ablated consecutively during the same procedure.
The microwave ablation system used in the present study (Avecure MWG881, MedWaves
Incorporated, San Diego, CA, USA) generates frequencies of 902 – 928 MHz and maximum
temperatures of 140 °C. The ablation time, wattage and temperature were adapted individually
for each patient due to ultrasound findings. Probes with different diameters (14 to
16 gauge with respect to nodule size) with an uncooled tip and integrated temperature
sensor were used. The temperature was monitored continuously in order to prevent the
temperature from reaching over 90° or under 60° C. The wattage output was individually
adapted from 24 to 32 W.
During the ablation process real-time ultrasound was sustained until the end of microwave
ablation to assure accurate positioning of the microwave ablation probe. Frequent
communication between the patient and operator enabled constant monitoring of voice
changes in order to prevent nerve palsies.
Post-assessment
Elastography was performed immediately after microwave ablation. Laboratory tests
were examined 24 hours post procedure. Scintigraphic imaging was performed the day
after microwave ablation. B-mode ultrasound examination of the nodule was repeated
one day after microwave ablation to detect potential complications.
Statistical analysis
Elastographic and scintigraphic results were carried out using the “BIAS”, software
version 10.04 (epsilon Verlag, 1989 – 2013 Hochheim, Darmstadt, Germany). Wilcoxon’s
matched pairs test was performed to compare scintigraphic measurements before and
after microwave ablation. Elastographic results were tested using Wilcoxon’s matched
pairs test. Statistical significance was indicated with p-values of less than 0.05.
Descriptive statistical analyses are given as median ± standard deviation.
Results
Elastography
Before microwave ablation, 3 thyroid nodules were assigned to ES1 by strain elastography,
17 nodules to ES2, 16 nodules to ES3, 3 nodules to ES4 ([Table 1]). The median elasticity score prior to ablation procedure was ES 2 ± 0.7.
Table 1
Diagnostic characteristics of thyroid nodules before and after microwave ablation
procedure.
Tab. 1 Diagnostische Kriterien aller evaluierten Schilddrüsenknoten vor und nach der Mikrowellenablation.
nodule
|
type of nodule (based on scintigraphic assessment using 99mTc-pertechnetate)
|
elastography
|
scintigraphic imaging
|
elasticity score prior to MWA
|
elasticity score after MWA
|
percentage tracer uptake in ablation zone prior to MWA [%]
|
percentage tracer uptake in ablation zone after MWA [%]
|
percentage reduction of tracer uptake in ablation zone [%]
|
1
|
cold
|
2
|
3
|
17.9
|
10.7
|
40.4
|
2
|
cold
|
2
|
3
|
3.2
|
2.8
|
13.4
|
3
|
indifferent
|
2
|
3
|
3.6
|
2.2
|
38.7
|
4
|
cold
|
1
|
2
|
12.1
|
11.2
|
7.5
|
5
|
hot
|
2
|
3
|
41.0
|
25.4
|
38.1
|
6
|
indifferent
|
2
|
3
|
8.7
|
7.1
|
18.7
|
7
|
cold
|
2
|
2
|
12.8
|
7.1
|
44.5
|
8
|
cold
|
3
|
4
|
11.2
|
0.0
|
100.0
|
9
|
cold
|
3
|
3
|
15.3
|
6.9
|
54.7
|
10
|
cold
|
3
|
4
|
23.2
|
6.5
|
71.9
|
11
|
indifferent
|
3
|
4
|
20.8
|
8.1
|
61.4
|
12
|
indifferent
|
3
|
4
|
38.7
|
24.0
|
37.9
|
13
|
cold
|
1
|
3
|
15.5
|
0.0
|
100.0
|
14
|
cold
|
2
|
4
|
9.0
|
3.6
|
59.8
|
15
|
cold
|
4
|
3
|
17.4
|
10.4
|
40.1
|
16
|
cold
|
3
|
4
|
6.0
|
5.5
|
9.6
|
17
|
indifferent
|
3
|
4
|
5.0
|
3.3
|
33.1
|
18
|
indifferent
|
3
|
4
|
7.5
|
3.3
|
55.8
|
19
|
indifferent
|
2
|
3
|
6.1
|
4.2
|
31.5
|
20
|
cold
|
2
|
4
|
7.5
|
6.6
|
12.6
|
21
|
cold
|
3
|
4
|
25.9
|
9.3
|
64.2
|
22
|
cold
|
2
|
3
|
13.2
|
12.3
|
7.0
|
23
|
cold
|
2
|
4
|
10.3
|
9.1
|
11.7
|
24
|
cold
|
2
|
3
|
17.4
|
15.9
|
8.6
|
25
|
cold
|
2
|
3
|
30.7
|
5.5
|
82.2
|
26
|
indifferent
|
2
|
3
|
4.9
|
4.7
|
3.5
|
27
|
indifferent
|
3
|
4
|
5.8
|
4.6
|
21.1
|
28
|
cold
|
1
|
2
|
32.1
|
9.2
|
71.4
|
29
|
cold
|
2
|
3
|
35.4
|
14.4
|
59.3
|
30
|
cold
|
3
|
4
|
7.0
|
5.0
|
29.5
|
31
|
cold
|
2
|
3
|
15.0
|
9.7
|
35.2
|
32
|
indifferent
|
4
|
4
|
9.3
|
7.5
|
19.3
|
33
|
indifferent
|
3
|
3
|
19.8
|
15.7
|
20.6
|
34
|
cold
|
3
|
4
|
7.5
|
2.9
|
61.4
|
35
|
cold
|
3
|
3
|
18.3
|
5.6
|
69.3
|
36
|
cold
|
3
|
4
|
18.3
|
1.9
|
89.5
|
37
|
cold
|
3
|
4
|
12.8
|
1.2
|
90.3
|
38
|
cold
|
4
|
4
|
45.6
|
19.3
|
57.6
|
39
|
cold
|
2
|
4
|
13.8
|
11.4
|
17.4
|
After microwave ablation the median ES was 3 ± 0.6. No more thyroid nodules were classified
as ES1, 3 nodules were classified as ES2, 17 were classified as ES3 and 19 nodules
could be classified as ES4. Overall, 32 of 39 thyroid nodules showed an increased
elasticity score by one or two units. The median decrease in elasticity referring
to all nodules was ES 1 ± 0.6 (p < 0.01).
Scintigraphic imaging
The results of pre and post ablation scintigraphic imaging of the ablated area were
evaluated and analyzed. A median decline of 38.7 %± 27.5 (p < 0.01) in tracer uptake
was found in ablated thyroid tissue. In ablated cold nodules a median reduction of
uptake by 54.7 %± 29.9 was observed, in indifferent nodules by 31.5 %± 16.2 and in
the single hot nodule tracer uptake reduced by 38.1 % ([Table 1]).
With respect to the used tracers, 99 mTc-MIBI scans showed a median reduction of uptake in ablated thyroid nodules of 54.7 %± 29.2
and in 99 mTc-pertechnetate scans the median tracer uptake in the ablated area was reduced by
26.3 %± 16.3.
Discussion
Due to the very recent development of microwave ablation as a minimally invasive procedure
for reducing the volume of thyroid nodules, studies on the thermal effects on treated
tissue are still rather scarce. A study by Zhou et al. [21] compared the effect of microwave ablation on different parenchyma ex vivo in a porcine model and showed that the size of the ablation zone does not vary much
between muscle, liver and adipose tissue. There have neither been studies performed
on the impact of microwave ablation on thyroid tissue at the molecular level nor on
the histopathologic alterations on thyroid parenchyma after microwave ablation, so
it can only be presumed that the effects of microwave ablation on thyroid tissue might
be comparable to those of other parenchyma.
Scintigraphic imaging is an important diagnostic tool in the characterization of thyroid
pathology. Etzel et al. stated in a previous study that scintigraphic imaging could
not be replaced by elastography with respect to the accuracy of diagnosing thyroid
pathologies [18]. In the past, technical innovations in other diagnostic tools have not been able
to displace the importance of scintigraphic imaging in thyroid diagnostics [11].
In the present study two different types of tracers were used, 99 mTc-pertechnetate and 99 mTc-MIBI. As a substrate of the sodium iodide symporter [22] in thyroid cells, the tracer 99 mTc-pertechnetate is taken up into iodine storing cells of the thyroid gland. The scintigraphic
findings of the present study show a reduction of tracer uptake in thyroid tissue
volume after microwave ablation. This can be explained by the effect of microwave
ablation as a thermal treatment. Due to thermal heating of the ablated tissue, iodine
storing and hormone-producing thyroid tissue is destroyed. In the case of 99 mTc-pertechnetate, “indifferent” or “hot” thyroid nodules, comprising intact iodine
storing cells, are destroyed and subsequently scintigraphic imaging shows reduced
tracer uptake in ablated tissue. Comparable results have been described in a number
of cases by a study by Baek et al. [23] after radiofrequency ablation.
Since “cold nodules” do not show any uptake of 99 mTc-pertechnetate, 99 mTc-MIBI has to be used as an alternative tracer to provide a comparison of uptake
in “cold” nodules prior to and after microwave ablation. Previous studies have demonstrated
the high potential of MIBI in detecting malignant thyroid nodules with high sensitivity,
especially when combined with fine-needle aspiration cytology [24]. However, the uptake of 99 mTc-MIBI is not only present in nodules of suspected malignancy, but also in benign
cold nodules. The diagnostic interpretation of malignant potential mainly refers to
the observable time periods of 99 mTc-MIBI uptake, retention and washout [25]. Its uptake and accumulation are assumed to be associated with the presence of intact
mitochondria [26]. The accumulation of 99 mTc-MIBI is dependent on specific mitochondrial membrane potentials; necrosis destroys
these mitochondrial membrane potentials and therefore reduces accumulation [27]. Microwave ablation creates such necrotic tissue in the ablated areas. This explains
why 99 mTc-MIBI uptake is reduced after microwave ablation ([Fig. 1]), giving rise to a quantifiable measurement even in cold nodules after treatment.
Since scintigraphic imaging can provide high resolution imaging, the comparison of
before and after scans can provide numeric analysis and a percentage reduction of
tracer uptake in tissue. Hence, it allows the drawing of conclusions on the volume
of necrotic tissue evoked by microwave ablation.
Elastography is a newly developed technique featured by many ultrasound systems and
was appraised enthusiastically as a new method for the diagnostic evaluation of thyroid
nodules. However, does the method achieve the required accuracy?
Van Vledder et al. [16] described elastography as a reasonable monitoring method after radiofrequency ablation
on hepatic tissue, assuming that the thermal ablation procedure will lead to elevated
tissue stiffness due to protein denaturation and dehydration. A study by DeWall et
al. [28] also suggests evaporation of free water as an explanation for the observed reduction
of tissue elasticity. Another study by Varghese et al. [29] compared the results of histopathology and elastography in size and found a high
correlation. Despite these convincing correlations, in some cases elastography seems
to slightly underestimate the size of the ablation zone [17], which increases the risk of incomplete ablation and subsequent recurrence. Nevertheless,
none of the previously mentioned studies used microwave ablation but rather other
ablation methods.
Strain elastography as a color-coded imaging method provides hardly quantifiable results.
The necessary reduction of results to a single elasticity score for each nodule leads
to imprecise diagnostics. In most of our studied cases (32 nodules out of 39 nodules),
the elasticity score was elevated by one or two units in the score after microwave
ablation, suggesting an increase in tissue stiffness in the ablated region ([Fig. 2]). Six nodules showed no difference in elasticity score after microwave ablation.
In contrast, scintigraphic imaging detected a clear reduction of tracer uptake in
the ablated zone also of these six nodules, which leads to the assumption that scintigraphic
imaging provides superior sensitivity in detecting alterations of thyroid tissue following
microwave ablation. In the present study elastography was performed using a strain
elastography system based on manual compression. Although a real-time feedback chart
allowed constant monitoring of the intensity of the applied manual compression, minor
variations in force application are difficult to recognize but might negatively affect
the results in correct imaging. Improvements in elastographic imaging, particularly
with respect to unbiased and reliable quantitative measurements, are of utmost importance.
Although shear wave elastography and other novelties might provide a promising perspective,
at present the commonly applied elastography systems do not seem to be technically
mature and reliable enough to justify the use of elastography as a sole diagnostic
method in detecting thyroid lesions of malignancy and should therefore be considered
with suspicion [30].
It remains to be seen whether any future technical developments will make elastography
more applicable and the extent to which its reliability and diagnostic significance
might develop.
Therefore, it can be suggested that scintigraphic imaging, which provides a more differentiated
diagnostic tool for the tissue alteration following microwave ablation, is currently
the method of choice.
In the present study functional imaging was assessed to detect early-stage postablative
effects. These effects are most likely to occur on molecular and not structural levels.
Tracer uptake is based on molecular processes, as described by Kogai et al. [22] and Arbab et al. [26], and may display necrosis even before structural alterations happen. Therefore,
it makes even early-stage evaluation feasible. Elastography and other ultrasound-based
technologies, such as conventional B-mode sonography, may not reflect these molecular-based
alterations but rather detect structural alterations of ablated tissue. Correa-Gallego
et al. [31] and Pareek et al. [32] showed that ultrasound and elastography, as a technique based on ultrasound, tend
to underestimate the size of ablated areas. Zhou et al. [33] found that B-mode ultrasound is not capable of reflecting the proper shape of thermal
lesions.
To verify that the observed size of ablation in functional imaging correlates with
the real necrotic area, histopathology and gross specimen examination of the thyroid
parenchyma would be needed. The present study is limited by a small sample size and
short follow-up times. Future studies including longer follow-up periods will show
the extent to which treated tissue develops over time after microwave ablation.
Conclusion
In order to achieve the most accurate diagnostic results for follow-up diagnostics
after microwave ablation, scintigraphic imaging is a promising and superior diagnostic
method, as it provides quantifiable results indicated by the reduction of tracer uptake
in thyroid tissue. Further research will be necessary to decide whether scintigraphic
imaging might be used as a sole method for follow-up or should be combined with other
diagnostic indicators. In this study it was observed that strain elastography using
color-coded imaging is able to detect an increase in tissue stiffness in ablated thyroid
tissue. However, the given technical abilities limit its utility in supplying reliable
and quantifiable results at present.
In contrast to the measurement of tissue stiffness in elastography, which might be
altered for very different reasons, scintigraphic diagnostics are based on the evaluation
of cell integrity expressed in terms of tracer uptake in iodine storing cells or in
cells providing intact mitochondrial membrane potentials.
-
Scintigraphic imaging is a promising diagnostic option for the evaluation of treatment
success.
-
Strain elastography detects tissue alterations but its accuracy is limited.
-
Microwave ablation induces a reduction of tracer uptake in ablated thyroid nodules.
-
Tissue elasticity is decreased in ablated thyroid nodules after microwave ablation.
Fig. 1 a Example of scintigraphic imaging using 99m-Technetium-MIBI prior to microwave ablation. The thyroid nodule is located at the
caudal part of the left thyroid lobe. b Scintigraphic imaging of the same nodule after microwave ablation. The tracer uptake
is decreased after microwave ablation in the ablated thyroid nodule.
Abb. 1 a Szintigrafische Bildgebung eines Schilddrüsenknotens (kaudaler Anteil des linken
Schilddrüsenlappens) vor der Mikrowellenablation unter Verwendung von 99m-Technetium-MIBI. b Szintigrafie desselben Knoten nach erfolgter Mikrowellenablation. Die Anreicherung
des Tracers im abladierten Schilddrüsenknoten ist im Vergleich zu vorher deutlich
reduziert.
Fig. 2 a Elastographic imaging of a thyroid nodule before microwave ablation, showing a hypoechoic
cystic component. b Imaging of the same nodule after aspiration of fluid content and microwave ablation.
Abb. 2 a Beispiel für eine elastografische Darstellung eines Schilddrüsenknotens mit hypoechogenem
zystischen Anteil vor Mikrowellenablation. b Elastografie des Schilddrüsenknotens nach Punktion des flüssigen Anteils und nach
erfolgter Mikrowellenablation.