Long-Term Analysis of Chronic Broca's Aphasia: An Illustrative Single Case

ABSTRACT

In this article, a longitudinal case study of a client (whose initials are TH) with chronic Broca's aphasia is presented. The language data encompass test and therapy data over a 7-year period, during which TH's language performance and verbal communicative behavior have improved and continue to improve. A carryover from oral to written sentence production and to verbal communication in everyday life has been observed. The long-term provision of therapy has not only lead to improved verbal communication skills, but has also enhanced his quality of life.

The case study discussed in this article demonstrates the value of long-term treatment and research on the evolution of language deficits across time. This approach provides a window for examining the dynamic processes of language recovery—the quantitative and qualitative changes that can be achieved when language therapy is provided long term in the chronic phase. Long-term analysis of the manner in which language functions respond to therapeutic intervention also provides detailed basic information required for a realistic characterization of the spectrum of language deficits for each symptom complex and/or aphasia type, not only for a single test time. This will lead to a better understanding of the recovery process and to development of therapy protocols in better accordance with the deficits at a particular point in the recovery process.

KEYWORDS

Long-term case study - recovery process - language improvement - language therapy protocols - ELA-syntax therapy

REFERENCES

• 1 Morris J, Howard D, Kennedy S. The value of therapy: what counts?. In: Duchan J, Byng S Challenging Aphasia Therapies Broadening the Discourse and Extending the Boundaries. Hove, UK; Psychology Press 2004: 134-157
• 2 Code C. Multifactorial processes in recovery from aphasia: developing the foundations for a multileveled framework.  Brain Lang. 2001;  77(1) 25-44
• 3 Whitworth A, Webster J, Howard D. A Cognitive Neuropsychological Approach to Assessment and Intervention in Aphasia. A Clinician's Guide. Hove, United Kingdom; Psychology Press 2005
• 4 Kaplan E, Goodglass H, Weintraub S. Boston Naming Test. 2nd ed. Philadelphia, PA; Lea Febiger 1983
• 5 Blomert L. The Amsterdam-Nijmegen Everyday Language Test. In: von Steinbuechel L, von Cramon DY, Poeppel E Neuropsychological Rehabilitation. Berlin, Germany; Springer 1992: 121-127
• 6 Goodglass H, Kaplan E. The Assessment of Aphasia and Related Disorders. Philadelphia, PA; Lea Febiger 1983
• 7 Norden I. Binetarium Intelligenzprüfung nach Binet-Bobertag. Göttingen, Germany; Verlag für Psychologie 1953
• 8 Wechsler D. The Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children. New York, NY; PsychCorp 1949
• 9 Stark J. ELA-Sentence Production Task and Sentence Comprehension Task. In: Stark J, Everyday Life Activities. Manual Set 1. Vienna, Austria; Bösmueller 1992
• 10 Kay J, Lesser R, Coltheart M. PALPA Psycholinguistic Assessments of Language Processing in Aphasia. Hove, United Kingdom; Lawrence Erlbaum Associates 1992
• 11 Swinburn K, Porter G, Howard D. Comprehensive Aphasia Test (CAT). Hove, United Kingdom; Psychology Press 2004
• 12 Stark J. Everyday Life Activities Photo Series. Manual for Set 1. Vienna, Austria; Bösmüller 1992
• 13 Stark J. Everyday Life Activities Photo Series. Manual for Set 2. Vienna, Austria; Jentzsch Verlag 1995
• 14 Stark J. Everyday Life Activities Photo Series. Manual for Set 3. Vienna, Austria; Jentzsch Verlag 1998
• 15 Stark J. Facilitation of written sentence production: a longitudinal case study of a Broca's aphasic.  Brain Lang. 2005;  95 181-182
• 16 Stark J. Analyzing the therapy process: the implicit role of learning and memory.  Aphasiology. 2005;  19(10/11) 1074-1089
• 17 Stark J, Stark H K, Pons C. Anatomy of a language therapy session aimed at improving oral sentence production – comparison of an early session with a late session.  J Neurolinguist. 2000;  13 318-322
• 18 Boazman S. A time of transition: a matter of confidence and control. In: Parr S, Duchan J, Pound C Aphasia Inside Out Reflections on Communication Disability. Maidenhead, United Kingdom; Open University Press 2004: 32-40
• 19 Lafond D, DeGiovani R, Joanette Y, Ponzio J, Sarno MT Living with Aphasia Psychosocial Issues. San Diego, CA; Singular Publishing 1993
• 20 Herrmann M, Johannsen-Horbach H, Wallesch C. The psychosocial aspects of aphasia. In: Lafond D, DeGiovani R, Joanette Y, Ponzio J, Sarno MT Living with Aphasia Psychosocial Issues. San Diego, CA; Singular 1993: 187-205
• 21 Robertson I H, Murre J MJ. Rehabilitation of brain damage: brain plasticity and principles of guided recovery.  Psychol Bull. 1999;  125(5) 544-575
• 22 Kleim J A, Jones T A. Principles of experience-dependent neural plasticity: implications for rehabilitation after brain damage.  J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2008;  51(1) S225-S239
• 23 Pound C, Parr S, Lindsay J, Woolf C. Beyond Aphasia Therapies for Living with Communication Disability. Bicester, Oxen, United Kingdom; Speechmark 2002
• 24 Lyon J. Evolving treatment methods for coping with aphasia that make a difference in everyday life. In: Duchan J, Byng S Challenging Aphasia Therapies: Broadening the Discourse and Extending the Boundaries. Hove, United Kingdom; Psychology Press 2004
• 25 Duchan J, Byng S Challenging Aphasia Therapies: Broadening the Discourse and Extending the Boundaries. Hove, United Kingdom; Psychology Press 2004: 54-82
• 26 Gonzalez Rothi L J, Musson N, Rosenbek J C, Sapienza C M. Neuroplasticity and rehabilitation research for speech, language, and swallowing disorders.  J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2008;  51(1) S222-S224
• 27 Saur D, Lange R, Baumgaertner A et al.. Dynamics of language reorganization after stroke.  Brain. 2006;  129(Pt 6) 1371-1384