Keywords
thyroid hormones - insulin resistance - diabetes mellitus - thyroid disorder - hyperglycemia
AKT/PKB Protein kinase B
AMPK Adenosine monophosphate activated protein kinase
ATPase Adenosine triphosphatase
BATs Brown adipose tissues
D2- Deiodinase type 2
DM Diabetes mellitus
FT3 Free triiodothyronine
FT4 Free thyroxine
Gc1Q Globular head region of complement component C1q receptor
GIT Gastrointestinal tract
GLUT2 Glucose transporter 2
GLUT4 Glucose transporter 4
GO Graves orbitopathy
IGF1 Insulin- like growth factor 1
IL-6 Interleukin 6
MAFA Musculoaponeurotic fibrosarcoma oncogene homologue A
MetS Metabolic syndrome
MTC Medullary thyroid cancer
mTOR Mechanistic target of rapamycin
P53 Tumor protein 53
PCO Polycystic ovarian syndrome
PECK Phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase
PGC-1α Peroxisome proliferator activated receptor gamma coactivator 1
alpha
PPAR-γ Peroxisome proliferator activated receptor gamma
RAG Recombination activating genes
RHEB Ras homologue enriched in brain
ROS Reactive oxygen species
SCH Subclinical hypothyroidism/hyperthyroidism
SERCA 1b Sarcoplasmic endoplasmic reticulum 1b
SERCA 1a Sarcoplasmic endoplasmic reticulum 1a
SERCA Sarcoplasmic endoplasmic reticulum
SGLT2 Sodium glucose transporter 2
SIRT1 Sirtuin 1
T2DM Type 2 diabetes mellitus
T3 Triiodothyronine
T4 Thyroxine
TD Thyroid disorder
TG Thyroglobulin
TH Thyroid hormone
TNF-α Tumor necrosis factor alpha
TPO Thyroid peroxidase
TR α1 Thyroid receptor alpha 1
TR β1 Thyroid receptor beta 1
TRH Thyroid releasing hormone
TSC2 Tuberous sclerosis complex 2
TSH Thyroid stimulating hormone
TZDs Thiazolidinediones
UCP3 Uncoupling receptor 3
Introduction
Thyroid hormone is essential for normal development, growth, and calorigenic action.
While insulin helps in maintaining normal glucose level in body, hyperthyroidism is
a condition characterized by excessive metabolism, resulting in an elevated
requirement for glucose, causing insulin resistance in peripheral tissues and can
also lead to ketoacidosis. Whereas in diabetes mellitus (DM), thyroid stimulating
hormone (TSH) levels become abnormal. Resulting treatment of subclinical
hypothyroidism is difficult due to complications like diabetic retinopathy,
peripheral arterial disease, diabetic nephropathy, and diabetic peripheral
neuropathy. This interplay of both hormones makes treatment difficult as many
antidiabetic drugs worsen the thyroid condition and vice versa.
Overview of thyroid hormone action
Overview of thyroid hormone action
Thyroid hormone is important for metabolism and growth process. Including
facilitating an increase in carbohydrate, fat, and protein metabolism in peripheral
tissue, such activities are also brought in conjunction with other hormones such as
insulin, glucagon, catecholamines, and glucocorticoids [1]. It promotes growth by directly acting
on cells and indirectly influencing the growth hormones production, potentiating its
effect on its target tissue; calcitonin released from thyroid gland help in skeletal
development [2] and growth of central
nervous system [3].
Glucose homeostasis and the role of insulin
Glucose homeostasis and the role of insulin
A healthy life is linked with the balance of blood glucose levels in the body, as it
ensures proper regulation of energy balance, hormonal balance, metabolic activity,
brain and other organ function, etc. The increase in plasma concentration of glucose
is due to the rate of gastric emptying, glycogenolysis by the liver, and the
formation of glucose from non-carbohydrate substrates such as lactate, amino acids,
and glycerol (gluconeogenesis) [4].
Glucose present in the plasma is maintained by two main hormones insulin and
glucagon. Pancreatic β-cells releases insulin, which reduces the blood glucose
levels through three major distinct mechanisms. First, it facilitates the uptake of
glucose by peripheral tissues such as skeletal muscle and adipocytes, which are rich
in insulin receptors [5]
[6]. Second, it promotes the liver to store
glucose in the form of glycogen or by converting it into fatty acids [7]. Lastly, it effectively suppresses the
secretion of glucagon after a meal [8]
([Fig. 1]).
Fig. 1 Role of insulin in lowering blood glucose level.
Epidemiological statistics on the co-occurrence of TD and T2DM
Epidemiological statistics on the co-occurrence of TD and T2DM
Based on observational prevalence of thyroid disorder, a comprehensive meta-analysis
has estimated that these conditions impact approximately 3.82% of the overall
population [9]. While the most prevalent
endocrinopathy globally is diabetes mellitus (DM), which is caused due to insulin
resistance and/or low levels of insulin secretion, resulting in hyperglycemia.
According to the International Diabetes Federation, around 10.5% of the adult
population (537 million individuals) were affected by DM in 2021. Projections
indicate that this number will increase to 643 million by the year 2030 [IDF
diabetes atlas, 2021]. A correlation between both disorders is commonly observed, as
the occurrence of TD in T2DM patients is more comparatively to non-glycemic
patients, ranging from 9.9% to 48% [10]
[11]. This can be diagnosed
by the presence of antithyroglobulin antibody (anti-TG), anti-thyroid peroxidase
(anti-TPO), or both. Enhanced screening for thyroid disorder (TD) is crucial in
patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM), as numerous studies have revealed a
high prevalence of subclinical hypothyroidism (SCH) among them. Furthermore,
clinical evaluations have led to the identification of several new cases of TD in
T2DM patients, emphasizing the importance of thorough screening protocols [12].
Prevalence of TD in T2DM patients
Prevalence of TD in T2DM patients
Type 2 diabetes mellitus occurs due to a decrease in the secretion of insulin by β
cells of the pancreas and often accompanied by insulin resistance [13]. β Cell starts secreting more insulin
to cope up with early insulin resistance but due to hyperinsulinemia causes, cells
starts getting saturated, and the onset of T2DM is observed in adults [14]. Insulin resistance occurs when there
is an increase in glucose uptake and its utilization in peripheral tissues (skeletal
muscles, adipose tissue and liver) and cells are less sensitive to insulin binding
[15]. Conditions like PCO (polycystic
ovarian syndrome), atherosclerosis, and emergence hypertension arise due to
metabolic syndrome (MetS) and cardiovascular issues accompanying insulin resistance
conditions [16]. Thyroid disorder is more
prevalent in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus compared to the normal
population as observed in a study done on the goiter prevalence in normal and
diabetic patients [17]. Another study
suggests that the likeliness of thyroid disorder in T2DM patients is around 16.2%,
with hypothyroidism (14%) being more common compared to hyperthyroidism (2.2%).
Females have a higher risk of thyroid disorder compared to males [18]. Furthermore, the clinical features
that are observed in diabetic patients suffering from thyroid disorders are shown in
([Fig. 2]).
Fig. 2 Clinical features that are observed in diabetic patients
dext-linkng both hypothyroidism and hyperthyroidism.
Diabetes mellitus (DM) affecting thyroid hormones
Diabetes mellitus (DM) affecting thyroid hormones
Diabetes mellitus alters the TSH level due to insulin resistance, causing lower
production of triiodothyronine (T3) by reducing the conversion of T3 from
tetraiodothyronine (T4). In individuals who have diabetes mellitus (DM) and normal
thyroid function, it has been observed that the nocturnal peak of
thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) is either absent or weak. Additionally, their TSH
response to thyrotropin-releasing hormone (TRH) is also compromised [19]. Additionally, certain acute conditions
like diabetic ketoacidosis can complicate thyroid function tests by reducing T3 and
T4 levels while TSH levels remain unaffected. Changes in thyroid hormones are also
observed during medicating in T2DM patients. For instance, insulin therapy causes an
increase in free tetraiodothyronine or thyroxine (FT4), but free triiodothyronine
(FT3) levels and oral hypoglycemic agents disrupt TSH and TH levels. Both are
discussed in the article.
Subclinical hypo and hyperthyroidism and diabetes
Subclinical hypo and hyperthyroidism and diabetes
Hypothyroidism poses not only a threat of obesity and dyslipidemia but also increases
the risk of metabolic syndrome and diabetes mellitus. As previously stated, an
excess of thyroid hormone leads to insulin resistance and glucose intolerance.
Furthermore, a deficiency of thyroid hormone is also linked to insulin resistance
and glucose intolerance. It has been reported that treating hypothyroidism can
enhance insulin sensitivity [20]. The
complete elucidation of the specific mechanism behind the accelerated impact of
subclinical hypothyroidism on diabetic complications remains unclear. Individuals
with subclinical hypothyroidism might experience a reduction in cardiac output,
renal flow, glomerular filtration, and an elevation in vascular resistance. The
increased occurrence of diabetic nephropathy in individuals with subclinical
hypothyroidism could potentially be attributed to these alterations. Furthermore,
thyroid hormone plays a crucial role in the growth and development of the retina,
which is evident in the smaller and thinner retinas observed in hypothyroid rats
[21]. Moreover, there may exist a
correlation between hypothyroidism and elevated vascular resistance, impaired
endothelial function, and an increased tendency for blood clotting. Various factors
collectively play a role in the heightened occurrence of peripheral arterial disease
among diabetic individuals with subclinical hypothyroidism. Further, subclinical
hyperthyroidism is most commonly caused due to excessive thyroid hormone therapy or
Grave’s disease or autonomously functioning thyroid nodules. Subclinical
hyperthyroidism is also associated with diabetes mellitus [22]. Thus, treating the subclinical
hyperthyroidism may help in decreasing the risk of diabetes mellitus [23].
Hyperthyroidism and hypothyroidism on insulin resistance
Kim et al. (2002) has reported that thyroid hormones have a negative correlation
with insulin resistance, which indicates that thyroid hormones are associated
with sensitivity of tissues to insulin. Thyroid hormone and insulin have an
important role in glucose metabolism at the cellular and molecular levels [24]. Subclinical hypothyroidism is
reported to be associated with elevated fasting hyperinsulinemia before insulin
resistance becomes evident in patients with subclinical hypothyroidism [25]. Further, many reports suggest that
hyperthyroidism promotes insulin resistance. Diabetic patients with
hyperthyroidism have been shown to have poor glycemic control. Also, patients
with thyrotoxicosis have been shown to have increased glycemic index [26]. In patients with hyperthyroidism,
the half-life of insulin is reduced due to an increased rate of degradation as
well as enhanced release of biologically inactive insulin precursors [27]. Therefore, untreated
hyperthyroidism and hypothyroidism affect the management of diabetes in
patients. A systematic approach to thyroid testing in patients with diabetes is
recommended.
Thyroid hormone affecting glucose homeostasis
Thyroid hormone affecting glucose homeostasis
Thyroid hormone (TH) has been recognized for its impact on glucose regulation for a
considerable period [28]. It has been
documented that TH plays a role in influencing glucose metabolism across various
organs including the gastrointestinal tract, liver, pancreas, adipose tissue,
skeletal muscles, and the central nervous system [29]
[30]; additionally, in the development of pancreatic β cells [31]. A summary of thyroid hormone and its
effect on peripheral organs are listed in ([Table 1]).
Table 1 Effect of glucose on various organs during
hyperthyroidism and hypothyroidism [28]
[30].
Organ
|
Process
|
Hyperthyroidism
|
Hypothyroidism
|
GIT
|
Glucose absorption
Motility
|
Increases
Increases
|
Decreases
Decreases
|
Liver
|
GLUT2 expression
Glucose intake
Glucokinase activity
Glycogen synthesis
Glycogen storage
Enzyme’s activity in hexose Monophosphate shunt
Glycolysis
Pyruvate dehydrogenase Enzyme activity
Mitochondrial activity
Mitochondrial biogenesis
Gluconeogenesis
Glycogenolysis
|
Increases
Increases
Increases
Decreases
Decreases
Increases
No effect
Decreases
Greatly increases
Greatly increases
Greatly increases
Greatly increases
|
Decreases
Decreases
Decreases
Increases
Increases
Decreases
No effect
Decreases
Decreases
Decreases
Decreases
Decreases
|
Skeletal muscles
|
GLUT4
UCP3
Glucose uptake
Contractibility
|
Upregulates
Increases
Increases
Increases
|
Downregulates
Decreases
Decreases
Decreases
|
Adipose tissue
|
Lipolysis
Thermogenesis
|
Increases
Increases
|
Decreases
Decreases
|
Beta-cells
|
Insulin
|
Increases
|
Decreases
|
Gastrointestinal tract
Glucose and other monosaccharides are lipophobic and thus require a special
carrier for their transport. In the gastrointestinal tract glucose uptake is
facilitated against the concentration gradient by sodium glucose cotransporter 1
(SGLT1) present in the apical region of the intestinal lumen [32]. It transports 1 glucose molecule
with 2 Na+ ions inside the lumen. the balance of Na+ ions
in enterocytes are maintained by moving Na+ out from the lumen by the
Na+/K+ ATPase pump situated on the basolateral side
[33]. Then, the glucose enters the
blood stream via its movement in the basolateral membrane of the lumen aided by
GLUT2 transporters [34] ([Fig. 3]).
Fig. 3 Regulation of SGL1 in response to thyroid hormones. SGLT1
receptor is co-transporter meaning it transport both sodium and glucose
across the cell membrane against the concentration gradient located in
the apical region of intestinal lumen. An increase in thyroid hormone
up-regulates the receptor and a decrease in thyroid hormone
down-regulates the SGLT-1 receptor present in GIT.
Hyperthyroidism and gastrointestinal tract
T3 hormones elevate the glucose absorption by the lumen and raise glucose
levels in the blood. This is observed due to the upregulation of SGLT1 and
GLUT2 mRNA upregulation by the T3 hormones [35]. Excessive levels of thyroid
hormone lead to oxyhyperglycemia, which is characterized by a rapid rise in
blood glucose levels after consuming oral glucose. This is primarily caused
by the stimulation of gastrointestinal mobility and increased glucose
absorption by rapid phosphorylation and gastric emptying time [36]. While it is believed that the
enhancement of glucose absorption is a consequence of heightened
gastrointestinal mobility, it is also possible that thyroid hormone directly
affects the gastrointestinal tract [29].
Hypothyroidism and gastrointestinal tract
According to various studies, it is clear that the lower level of thyroid
hormones affects the gastro-intestinal absorption of glucose [36] and sluggish motility of the
lumen is also observed in conditions like hypothyroidism [37]. Hypothyroidism indirectly
contributes to patient’s decreased blood sugar level, because the thyroid
hormones affect break down of glucose and energy production. Patients with
hypothyroidism have reduced metabolic processes. Therefore, when this
metabolic process slows down, excess circulating insulin may cause blood
sugar levels to descend and result it led to hypoglycemia [38]. A person with both diabetes
and hypothyroidism may experience challenges because antidiabetic
medications may experience recurrent episodes of hypoglycemia.
Liver
The liver is the primary location for glucose utilization, with around 50–60% of
glucose absorbed from the intestines being processed there [39]. Initially, glucose is
phosphorylated to glucose 6-phosphate, which serves as a crucial molecule in
various metabolic pathways including oxidative pathways, the pentose phosphate
pathway, and glycogen synthesis. Additionally, the liver is responsible for
converting excess glucose into fatty acids. Moreover, during fasting, the liver
is the sole organ capable of supplying glucose to the bloodstream either through
glycogenolysis, where stored glycogen is broken down, or via gluconeogenesis,
which involves synthesizing glucose from non-carbohydrate sources such as
glycerol, lactate, and alanine [40].
GLUT2 transporter and thyroid disorders
Transport of the glucose into and out of the hepatocytes is done via glucose
transporter-2. Thyroid hormones are crucial for controlling the activity of
the GLUT2 glucose transporter. They increase the transporter’s activity in
hyperthyroidism and decrease it in hypothyroidism [41]
[42].
Glucokinase activity and thyroid disorders
In order to maintain the balance, storage and utilization of the glucose in
liver, phosphorylation of glucose takes place. In hepatocytes, the glucose
gets phosphorylated and gets converted into glucose 6-phosphate. This
conversion is done by glucokinase, an isoenzyme of hexokinase, which is the
major responsible enzyme of this process [43]. TH plays an important role in
glucokinase activity. In hyperthyroid conditions, the elevated level of T3
hormones increases glucokinase activity, while the reverse is observed in
hypothyroid conditions [44]
[45].
Glycogen synthesis and thyroid disorders
Hepatic glycogen metabolism is tightly controlled by hormones such as insulin
and glucagon, glucocorticoids, and catecholamines [46]. Excess of thyroid hormones
causes an increase in glycogen phosphorylase activity [47]. Thus, hyperthyroidism results
in less glycogen storage while many evidences suggests that glycogen
synthesis increases in hypothyroidism [48].
Glucose oxidation and thyroid disorders
Unlike brain and skeletal muscles, liver is not predominant organ for further
oxidization of glucose [44].
Thyroid hormones exert their effects on the mitochondrial oxidization of
glucose based on the observation of no rate change of enzymatic activity
during the glycolysis process [49]
[49]
[51] activity and expression of
enzyme pyruvate dehydrogenase are significantly reduced in hypothyroid
condition [52] and hyperglycemic
condition is observed during long-term hyperthyroidism due to under
expression of pyruvate dehydrogenase leading to the conversion of pyruvate
into glucose via gluconeogenesis process [53]
[54] ([Fig. 4]).
Fig. 4 Fate of glucose molecule in cytoplasm and mitochondria
of hepatocyte. In cytoplasm thyroid hormone increases and decreases
the glucokinase activity based on over and under secretion of
hormones respectively. In mitochondria thyroid hormone regulates the
pyruvate dehydrogenase enzyme activity.
Mitochondrial oxidation in TCA cycle and thyroid disorders
Thyroid hormones have reported effects on mitochondrial oxidation through
direct (binding to the binding site of mitochondria) and indirect (binding
to another site such as the nucleus) methods [55]. Thyroid hormone is the major
responsible hormone for the growth of mitochondria [56]. In hypothyroidism number and
size of mitochondria are reduced [57]. Conversely, excess amount of TH is linked with accelerated
carbohydrate metabolism leading to energy generation and increased in
catabolic and anabolic processes. Both the number and size of mitochondria
increase in hyperthyroid conditions [58]. In hepatocytes the mitochondrial biogenesis is induced by TH
through activation of peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma
coactivator 1 alpha (PGC-1alpha) [59]
[60].
Gluconeogenesis and thyroid disorder
The liver experiences an increase in gluconeogenesis due to the presence of
thyroid hormone. This increase can occur either directly through the effects
of thyroid hormone or indirectly through the influence of glucagon or
catecholamine. The activity of the enzyme phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase
(PEPCK) is heightened by THs, resulting in an enhancement of hepatic
gluconeogenesis [61]. This leads
to an increase in glycogenolysis and hepatic glucose output, ultimately
causing hyperinsulinemia and glucose intolerance, which in turn leads to
insulin resistance [62].
Skeletal muscles
Skeletal muscles are the major site for the storage of glucose, transported in
response to insulin. Initiating glucose phosphorylation, glycogen synthesis, and
glucose oxidation are also facilitated by the insulin [5]
[63].
GLUT4 transporter and effect of TH
Skeletal muscle is the main tissue that contributes to systemic glucose
depletion in postprandial conditions in order to maintain normal glycemia.
GLUT4 is the main glucose carrier for skeletal muscles [64]. Thyroid hormones upregulate
the GLUT4 transporter, showing some action of TH synergistic to insulin
[65].
UPC3 and thyroid disorder
Another target for the T3 in skeletal muscles is mitochondrial uncoupling
receptor 3 (UCP3), which is important to note because the reduction of UCP3
results in insulin resistance along with decreased fatty acid oxidation and
a less stimulated AKT/PKB and 5 adenosine monophosphate-activated protein
kinase (AMPK) signaling [66].
Muscles contractibility, glycolysis, oxidative effect, and thyroid
hormones
The sarcoplasmic endoplasmic reticulum (SERCA) is responsible for the
contraction of skeletal muscles. It has been suggested that the TH increases
the contractibility of skeletal muscles by affecting SERCA1a and SERCA1b
protein along with a concomitant increase in glycolytic and oxidative
capacity of the muscles [67]
[68]. Recent research has
investigated the theory that heightened blood flow rates in hyperthyroidism
could potentially conceal a malfunction in insulin-triggered glucose
disposal within the muscle. This could be attributed to abnormalities in the
intracellular pathways of glucose metabolism [69]. Thus hyperthyroidism leads to
an increase in GLUT4 expression and glucose uptake in skeletal muscle [70].
Adipose tissue
In the adipose tissues, the presence of thyroid hormone stimulates the process of
lipolysis [71]. This results in an
elevation of serum free fatty acid levels, which in turn leads to the
development of insulin resistance. According to various studies, it has been
found that thyroid hormones play a crucial role in the mobilization of tissue
lipids, particularly in brown adipose tissues (BATs), which serve as the primary
source of fuel for heat production. Adipocytes releases proinflammatory
mediators like IL-6, TNF-α, and several adipokines under the influence of
hyperthyroidism causing peripheral insulin resistance [72]. The condition of hypothyroidism
and reduced levels of thyroid hormones are directly linked to a decrease in
thermogenesis within BAT [73]. The
combination of heightened lipolysis increased hepatic β-oxidation, and an
insulin deficiency can potentially lead to the occurrence of ketoacidosis [74].
Hormone release from adipose tissue: Adiponectin
Adiponectin, the predominant adipokine released by the adipose tissue,
possesses significant insulin-sensitizing properties by enhancing glucose
uptake and diminishing glucose production by augmenting the insulin
sensitivity of both muscle and liver [75]. Reduced levels of adiponectin have been associated with an
increased susceptibility to developing type 2 diabetes. Additionally,
adiponectin and thyroid hormones exhibit similar biological characteristics,
such as promoting thermogenesis and lipid oxidation, leading to a decrease
in body fat [76]. There has been a
suggestion that the presence of adiponectin could potentially impact the
production of thyroid hormones by interacting with the gC1q receptor located
in the mitochondria of the thyroid gland [77]. Patients with autoimmune
hyperthyroidism have been observed to exhibit elevated levels of circulating
adiponectin in the majority of the conducted studies [78]. In patients with Graves’
disease, there is a correlation between elevated levels of adiponectin in
the bloodstream and the severity of hyperthyroidism as well as the
autoimmune response [79]. However,
some studies have reported that adiponectin did not correlate with thyroxin
levels, which indicates that insulin resistance associated with
hyperthyroidism is not attributed to adiponectin levels [80]. In addition, another study has
reported that appropriate treatment of hyperthyroidism is not accompanied by
significant changes in circulating adiponectin levels [78].
Skeletal muscles and adipose tissue synergistic effect
There is well-known communication between skeletal muscles and adipose tissue
through fatty acids, but adipose tissue can also crosstalk with skeletal muscle
through adipokines. These are responsible for the insulin sensitivity of
skeletal muscles and similarly, skeletal muscles also release myokines, which in
excess amounts cause insulin resistance. Interestingly, both hypothyroidism and
hyperthyroidism affects the adipokines-myokines interaction and contributes in
insulin resistance [72].
Pancreas
Thyroid hormones are responsible for the growth of pancreatic islet cells, and TH
binds to TR α1 and TR β1 receptors [81]. The secretion of insulin by beta cells is directly regulated by
thyroid hormones. In cases of hypothyroidism, the secretion of insulin in
response to glucose is reduced, while hyperthyroidism enhances the beta cells’
response to glucose. T3 has a significant impact on insulin production by
pancreatic beta cells within the normal range. This is because neonatal beta
cells possess TH receptors, and their exposure to T3 facilitates the activation
of the transcription factor MAFA, which in turn stimulates the maturation of
beta cells [82]. However, in
hyperthyroid rats, the pancreas enlarges, but both the capacity of the islets
and the overall number of insulin-positive cells decrease [83]. The decline in islet function and
reduced production of insulin in response to glucose are primarily attributed to
a decrease in beta cell mass and dysfunction of the insulin secretory pathway.
This pathway involves two crucial components: ATP-sensitive K+
channels and L-type Ca2+ channels. It is important to note that
abnormal glucose tolerance in this case is not a result of insulin resistance,
but rather a defective response of pancreatic beta cells to glucose [81]. Additionally, thyroid hormone
increases the degradation of insulin and thyrotoxicosis leads to an increase in
insulin clearance. Furthermore, thyroid hormone stimulates the secretion of
glucagon by pancreatic alpha cells [84].
Thyroid disorders and its effect on insulin
Thyroid disorders and its effect on insulin
Hyperthyroidism
During hyperthyroidism, the degradation rate of insulin is accelerated, leading
to a decrease in its half-life. This is primarily caused by an augmented release
of biologically inactive insulin precursors [85]. Increased proinsulin levels in response to a meal were observed
in individuals with untreated Graves’ disease. Additionally, untreated
hyperthyroidism was found to be linked with a decreased C-peptide to proinsulin
ratio, indicating a potential underlying issue in proinsulin processing.
Additionally, individuals with hyperthyroidism exhibit heightened insulin
degradation and expedited insulin clearance. Individuals with hyperthyroidism
have a higher likelihood of experiencing severe hyperglycemia. In cases where
there is a lack of insulin, increased lipolysis and hepatic β-oxidation can lead
to the development of ketoacidosis [86]. Thyrotoxicosis has the potential to trigger diabetic
complications, including endothelial dysfunction, which in turn elevates the
likelihood of cardiovascular comorbidities [87].
Hypothyroidism
Patients suffering from hypothyroidism may experience insulin resistance.
Diminished levels of thyroid hormones have a significant impact on multiple
organs. In hypothyroidism, various mechanisms impact glucose metabolism, leading
to a decrease in liver glucose production and decrease in glucose uptake by the
gastrointestinal tract [88]; also
causes insulin resistance, and leads to decreased insulin-stimulated glucose
transport, glucose disposal, and utilization in peripheral tissues.
Additionally, there is a reduction in the rate of glucose oxidation and glycogen
production [89]. About beta cell
function, there is an augmentation in glucose-induced insulin secretion, and
numerous research studies have indicated a rise in insulin levels in individuals
with hypothyroidism [90].
Additionally, the renal system plays a role in prolonging the half-life of
insulin by reducing insulin clearance. For individuals with both diabetes
mellitus (DM) and hypothyroidism who are undergoing insulin treatment, it may be
necessary to make adjustments to the insulin dosage. The decreased renal insulin
clearance results in elevated insulin levels, which in turn may lead to lower
requirements for externally administered insulin [91].
Thyroid hormones and their interaction with other hormones
Thyroid hormones and their interaction with other hormones
The interaction between thyroid hormones and adipose tissue hormones namely
adiponectin and leptin can potentially impact carbohydrate mechanisms in two ways.
First, thyroid hormones have a significant impact on the metabolism of adipose
tissue. Second, as thyroid hormones lead to insulin resistance, studying the
production rates and plasma levels of these cytokines could offer valuable insights
into the underlying mechanism [92].
Adiponectin, which is already discussed above, being the most abundant adipokine
released by adipose tissue, plays a crucial role in enhancing insulin sensitivity.
It has been observed that individuals with low levels of adiponectin are at a
greater risk of developing type 2 diabetes [93].
Leptin
The hormone leptin is believed to have a role in regulating energy balance and
body weight through neuroendocrine mechanisms. It has demonstrated the ability
to enhance the activity of peripheral type 2 deiodinase, resulting in an
increased availability of T3 to peripheral tissues. Consequently, leptin might
contribute to the elevation of T3 levels, potentially exacerbating
hyperthyroidism [94]. In patient with
DM there has been increased in leptin hormones, leading to increase in TSH
level, which amplifies the production of T3.
Clinical complications in patients suffering from both TD and DM
Clinical complications in patients suffering from both TD and DM
Glycated albumin
In addition to glycated hemoglobin, glycated albumin is also utilized as a marker
for glycemic control in individuals with diabetes. However, it is important to
note that glycated albumin is influenced not only by glycemic control but also
by albumin metabolism. Furthermore, thyroid hormone plays a role in albumin
catabolism. As a result, patients with hypothyroidism tend to exhibit higher
levels of serum glycated albumin, while those with hyperthyroidism tend to have
lower levels. A significant positive correlation has been observed between serum
glycated albumin and TSH levels, while an inverse correlation has been found
between serum glycated albumin and free T3 or free T4 levels. Therefore, it is
crucial to carefully evaluate serum glycated albumin levels in diabetic patients
with thyroid dysfunction [95].
Dietary plan
The diet therapy designed for individuals with diabetes strongly advises the
consumption of seaweed due to its low-calorie content and abundance of minerals
and dietary fiber. Nevertheless, it is important to note that certain types of
seaweed, particularly Kombu or kelp, contain high levels of iodine. Excessive
intake of iodine can potentially lead to thyroid dysfunction in susceptible
patients, particularly those with autoimmune thyroid diseases [28]
[29].
Various hypoglycemic agents affecting the interplay
Various hypoglycemic agents affecting the interplay
Treatment of type 2 diabetes mellitus with insulin therapy and drugs like metformin,
sulfonylureas, and thiazolidinediones affects the thyroid hormone regulation and may
cause thyroid dysfunction or related disorders ([Table 2]).
Table 2 Effect of antidiabetic agents and insulin therapy on
thyroid function in type 2 diabetes mellitus patient.
Drugs
|
Effects
|
Reference
|
Metformin
|
Reduces TSH levels in serum.
Inhibits mTOR pathway.
Downregulation of hypothalamic AMPK resulting in reduced T3 and
TSH.
|
[97]
[103]
|
Sulfonylureas
|
Reduces iodine uptake by the thyroid gland.
Goitrogenic and hypothyroidism effect in the first generation of
sulfonylurea.
|
[109]
[111]
|
Thiazolidinediones
|
Increases eye protrusion in Graves orbitopathy when taking
pioglitazone.
Reduces risk of thyroid cancer in T2DM patients taking
rosiglitazone.
|
[118]
[120]
|
Dipeptidyl peptidase-4 inhibitors
|
Administration of DPP4 inhibitors increases the severity of
Graves’ disease.
|
[122]
[123]
|
SGLT-2 inhibitors
|
SGLT-2 inhibitors have a significant protecting effect on thyroid
dysfunction, particularly hyperthyroidism.
|
[125]
[126]
|
Glucagon-like peptide-1 agonists
|
GLP-1 receptor agonists do not have any significant effect on the
risk of thyroid cancer, hyperthyroidism, hypothyroidism,
thyroiditis, and goiter.
|
[128]
[129]
|
Insulin Therapy
|
Insulin treatment restores thyroid status in diabetic
patients.
Insulin enhances the levels of FT4 and suppresses the level of T3
by inhibiting the conversion of T4 to T3 in the liver.
Hypothyroidism slows down the metabolism of insulin therefore a
person with diabetes and hypothyroidism may require a lower dose
of insulin for their treatment.
|
[131]
|
Metformin
Metformin is the first choice of drug for T2DM with only a few adverse effects like
abdominal pain, diarrhea, nausea, and indigestion. In 2006, it was noted that the
TSH level in the patient with T2DM and primary hypothyroidism decreased upon using
the metformin [96]. Other studies also
suggest that the metformin decreases the serum TSH levels [97]
[98]. A meta-analysis study of before and after treatment of metformin and
TSH levels resulted in reduced serum TSH levels in hypothyroidism and subclinical
hypothyroidism [99]
[100]. There is no alteration in FT4 and FT3
levels during metformin treatment. Moreover, a reversible effect was observed when
the metformin was discontinued [101].
Metformin mainly acts by suppressing hepatic gluconeogenesis via activation of
AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) and sirtuin 1 (SIRT1). In the hypothalamus, AMPK
also plays an important role and the blood-brain barrier property of metformin is
well established [102] suggesting the
inhibition of central AMPK resulting in lower secretion of T3 and TSH [103]. Deiodinase type 2 (D2) catalyzes T4
to T3 in glial cells, astrocytes, and tanycytes in the mediobasal hypothalamus
region. During insulin resistance, polymorphism of D2 takes place, and conversion of
T3 from T4 decreases. It was observed that metformin enhances the activity of D2 at
pituitary levels in hypothyroid patients [104]
[105]. Hyperinsulinemia and
insulin resistance are the major reasons for the high prevalence of thyroid cancer.
Metformin has been recorded with antimitogenic and proapoptotic effects in thyroid
carcinoma cell lines [106] along with a
30% reduction in thyroid nodule size [107]. Furthermore, observation of treatment with metformin in diabetic
patients has suggested downregulation of mTOR pathway, which can lead to metastatic
medullary thyroid cancer (MTC) [107]
[108] ([Fig. 5]).
Fig. 5 Metformin affecting mTOR pathway. AKT: Protein kinase B; ROS:
Reactive oxygen species; P53: Tumor protein 53; IGF1: insulin-like growth
factor 1; IRS-1: Insulin receptor substrate 1; RAG: Recombination activating
genes; TSC2: Tuberous sclerosis complex 2; RHEB: Ras homologue enriched in
brain.
Sulfonylurea
Sulfonylurea is reported to exhibit antithyroid effects [109]
[110] and iodine uptake by thyroid gland
reduces, while its weight gets increased [111]
[112]. The high
prevalence of hypothyroidism has been linked to long term use of first
generation sulfonylurea medication [111]. First generation sulfonylureas (chlorpropamide and tolbutamide)
inhibit the binding of T3 and T4 to T4 binding globulin through the IV route; no
effects are observed in the oral route [113] and chlorpropamide shows goitrogenic effects according to [114]. Second generation (glibenclamide
and gliclazide) do not influence TH regulation [115]
[116].
Thiazolidinediones
The thiazolidinediones (TZDs) are one of the most commonly used oral hypoglycemic
agents. They are agonist of nuclear hormone receptors, peroxisome
proliferator-activated receptor γ (PPAR-γ) [117]. In graves orbitopathy (GO) the expression of PPAR-γ is observed
in adipose and connective tissue. TZD brings and differentiate orbital
fibroblast into mature lipid-laden adipocytes, suggesting that accelerated level
of PPAR-γ is involved in pathogenesis of GO induced by TZDs [118]
[119]. An increase in eye protrusion
with GO was observed in T2DM in patients taking pioglitazones while
rosiglitazone in patients might reduce the risk of thyroid cancer [120]. Patients with active Graves’
orbitopathy (GO) should avoid thiazolidinediones due to the increased risk they
pose. Additionally, individuals with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) and Graves’
disease should receive thiazolidinediones with caution to prevent adverse
effects, as discontinuation of these medications can lead to irreversible
exacerbations of GO [121].
Dipeptidyl peptidase-4 inhibitors
Dipeptidyl peptidase-4 inhibitors stimulate pancreatic insulin secretion by
elevating glucose-dependent insulinotropic polypeptide levels. Studies reported
dipeptidyl peptidase-4 inhibitors exacerbate Graves’ disease. Dipeptidyl
peptidase-4 is expressed on the surface of T cells and T cells have been
implicated in the initiation and amplification of autoimmunity [122]. Moreover, Graves’ disease is an
autoimmune disease that occurs due to the overproduction of thyroid hormone due
to upregulated thyroid stimulation by thyroid-stimulating hormone receptor
antibodies. Therefore, inhibition of dipeptidyl peptidase-4 might affect the
thyroid function [123].
SGLT-2 inhibitors
SGLT2 inhibitors bind to SGLT2 receptors present in proximal tubules of the
kidney, which results in beneficial effects in patients of T2DM by preventing
its reabsorption of glucose from the urine [124]. Interestingly, thyroid dysfunction has also been linked to
cognition and depression. The thyroid gland plays a vital role in regulating
metabolism and have profound effects on the CNS. There is a complex interplay
between glucose metabolism, thyroid function, and brain health. Both
hyperthyroidism and hypothyroidism can manifest with cognitive impairment and
mood disorders. There are many studies showing that SGLT2 inhibitors increased
risk of mood disturbances and cognitive decline in patients with T2DM by
increasing TSH levels and these changes in TSH levels can influence cognitive
function [125]
[126].
Glucagon-like peptide-1 agonists
Glucagon-like peptide 1 receptor agonists have shown significant improvement in
hyperglycemia and diabetes-related outcomes such as overweight, obesity,
cardiovascular and renal impairment, and nonalcoholic fatty liver disease. A
preclinical study reported that GLP-1 receptors are widely expressed on
parafollicular C-cells membrane and binding to the GLP-1 receptor induces cell
proliferation. It also stimulates the synthesis and secretion of calcitonin in a
cAMP-dependent manner. Therefore, GLP-1 may promote thyroid carcinogenesis [127]. However, insufficient evidence
indicates the potential cancerogenic effect in humans’ glucagon-like peptide 1
receptor agonists. Therefore, possible cause-effect and dose-dependent
relationships between chronic administration of glucagon-like peptide 1 receptor
agonists and the risk of thyroid cancer in T2DM have not been ruled out [128]. Further, glucagon-like peptide 1
is also associated with increase in T3 levels by upregulation of iodothyronine
deiodinase expression. In addition, a clinical study showed that Glucagon-like
peptide 1 receptor agonists reduce serum TSH levels in diabetic patients without
thyroid disease [129].
Insulin therapy
Insulin resistance causes increases in T3 compared to insulin sensitivity [130]. The administration of exogenous
insulin can have an impact on thyroid function in individuals with T2DM. Insulin
enhances the levels of FT4 and suppresses the level of T3 by inhibiting the
hepatic conversion of T4 to T3. Insulin modulates TRH and TSH levels by exerting
a negative regulatory effect [131].
Therefore, insulin treatment should be adjusted in patients with diabetes after
the occurrence of thyroid dysfunction.
Drugs used in thyroid disorders
Drugs used in thyroid disorders
Various adverse effects related to diabetes mellitus and blood glucose regulation of
hyperthyroidism and hypothyroidism disorder treatments are listed in [Table 3].
Table 3 Drugs used in thyroid disorders and their effect on
glucose metabolism [133]
[137].
Drugs
|
Effects
|
Methimazole or carbimazole
|
Causes hypoglycemia
Increases risk of insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS)
|
Levothyroxine
|
Reduces TSH levels
Increases glucose clearance
|
Methimazole or carbimazole
Antithyroid drugs like methimazole and carbimazole are most widely used in two
ways, primarily for treating hyperthyroidism and as a preparative treatment
before radiotherapy and surgery. They are widely used in the treatment of grave
disorders [132]. The use of
methimazole or carbimazole in Graves disorder causes hypoglycemia and the
sulfhydryl group present in the drug suggests a risk of insulin autoimmune
syndrome [133]
[134]. This observation is also
strengthened by the case reports [135]
[136].
Levothyroxine
Thyromimetics is a promising therapy in treating hypothyroidism. The long term
supplementation with levothyroxine is observed to enhance glucose clearance and
decrease the onset of type 1 diabetes mellitus [137]. Along with effects like a
significant reduction in TSH and blood glucose levels [138].
Conclusion
All the studies and observations conducted suggest strong nexus of thyroid disorder
and diabetes mellitus interplay. The factor amounts of glycated albumin present in
hypo- and hyperthyroidism is linked with diabetic conditions. Furthermore, it is
advisable to avoid dietary sources such as kelp in patients with diabetes mellitus
and thyroid disorder due to the presence of high iodine. Both facts serve as
additional evidence of the co-occurrence of both endocrinopathies. Outcomes like
increases in the severity of diseases in patients, various metabolic changes
altogether make treatment difficult. Both high and low level of thyroid hormones
results in insulin resistance. Elevated levels increase glucose uptake and
regulation in peripheral tissues, further leading to ketoacidosis, while reduced
levels result in decreased glucose absorption resulting in prolonged insulin
clearance in hepatic system. Similarly, type 2 diabetes mellitus interferes with
thyroid hormone levels by reducing thyroid stimulating hormone levels, making
management of disorders difficult, along with the rise in prevalence of comorbid
conditions of both. Among medications, only metformin shows positive results in
treating thyroid disorder, other oral hypoglycemic agents and insulin worsen the
disorder, resulting in more chances of hypothyroidism because of a decrease in TSH
and serum T3 levels compared to hyperthyroidism in diabetic patients, while
antithyroid drug worsens diabetic conditions.