Key words
cartilage - T2 mapping - pediatric - volleyball - knee
Introduction
Both the patellofemoral cartilage and the covering cartilage of the femoral condyles
and tibial plateau are composed of hyaline cartilage. Due to its structure, hyaline
cartilage is ideally suited to absorb the strong forces acting on the knee joint,
to distribute them, and to transmit them to the underlying bone. Its integrity is
essential for the proper functioning of the knee joint. Because hyaline cartilage
is a bradytrophic tissue with a low regenerative capacity [1], once damage occurs, it often does not result in complete healing, but instead results
in defective healing with less resilient reparative cartilage. Secondary damage may
then occur to the subchondral bone [2]. This cascade leads to premature wear and tear, that, if left untreated, can result
in knee joint osteoarthritis [3]. The gradual degeneration of cartilage can be visualized through T2 mapping on magnetic
resonance imaging (MRI). A high level of free water, not bound to glycosaminoglycans,
within the cartilage leads to an increase in the T2 relaxation time [4]. These alterations in T2 relaxation time can be seen even before they become visible
as cartilage damage in conventional T1, T2, or proton density (PD)-weighted sequences
[5]
[6]
[7]
[8].
Changes to cartilage and the knee joint are common among young adults involved in
competitive sports [9] and are due to factors such as trauma and repetitive stress associated with short-term
overuse of the joints [10]. In the worst case, competitive sports lead to knee joint arthrosis [11]. A few studies have demonstrated the value of T2 mapping in the detection of early
cartilage changes in the case of competitive sports such as ballet dance [12] and soccer [13]. A recent study on the menisci of adult female volleyball players in competitive
sports was able to show changes in the menisci already in young adulthood with quantitative
MRI (qMRI) T1 rho and T2* mapping, highlighting the relevance of early monitoring
of adolescents in competitive sports [14]. No such studies are available for the pediatric group of volleyball players at
a competitive level, where, depending on the player’s position, long distances of
more than 1.5 km are covered within a narrow space of the court, with many changes
in direction and load, or high jumps are executed [15]
[16]. In addition, volleyball is an impact sport in which repetitive and suprathreshold
stresses are experienced, especially on the knee joints, due to numerous and great-altitude
jumps: which may increase the likelihood of early degenerative processes.
Aim of the Study
The aim of this study was to figure out whether subclinical cartilage damage is already
detectable by T2 mapping on MRI among adolescents playing volleyball as a competitive
sport.
Materials and Methods
A positive vote by the local ethics committee was received before the start of the
study. Written informed consent was obtained from the participants or their legal
representatives.
Screening and Preparation of Participants
Healthy male adolescents aged 12 to 17 years were enrolled for this prospective, monocenter
study between March 2019 and May 2019. The exclusion criteria were history of surgeries,
known previous orthopedic conditions, or lower extremity injuries in the last six
months. The studied subjects had none of the above characteristics. The competitive
athletes were defined as those who played volleyball for at least 3 years with more
than 700 minutes of playing time per week. They were students at a sports school and
together in one class with volleyball as the performance focus. Contact was made through
the coach. The control subjects should not participate in any impact sport except
at an age-average activity level. They were recruited via a longitudinal study of
civilization diseases in childhood and adolescence. Both groups received an evaluation
of their knee MRI examinations that was understandable for laypersons and a subsequent
gait analysis with tips for optimizing movement as a motivation. The extent of sporting
activity and non-sporting activity was estimated through the standardized Motor Module
Questionnaire [17]. Acute or prolonged knee joint complaints as an exclusion criterion were determined
through the modified standardized knee injury osteoarthritis outcome score questionnaire
for children [18]. At the time of MRI, all the athletes had the same training status, i. e., the same
number of training sessions or participation in competitions and at least 48 hours
of time interval after the last training session in order to minimize acute load-induced
effects on cartilage and bone marrow [19]
[20]. Since hormonal status may affect cartilage maturation [21], only male subjects were included to keep the collective as homogeneous as possible.
Magnetic Resonance Imaging
All MRI examinations were performed on a Philips Ingenia 3 T MRI (Philips Medical
Systems International BV, Best, the Netherlands) with a 16-channel knee coil. In each
session, both knees of the subject were examined. For anatomic assessment, a PD turbo
spin-echo (TSE) sequence with fat suppression (fs) in 3 planes (slice thickness 3 mm,
echo time 35 ms, repetition time 2000 ms, and flip angle 90°) and a sagittal T1 TSE
sequence (slice thickness 3 mm, echo time 10 ms, repetition time 573 ms, and flip
angle 90°) were acquired. T2 mapping was acquired using multi-echo T2 TSE sequences
with six echo trains each (echo times 13, 26, 39, 52, 65, and 78 ms, repetition time
2000 ms, and flip angle 90°) transversely over the patellofemoral cartilage. In addition,
to simultaneously assess all four cartilage compartments (i. e., both femoral condyles
and both cartilages of the tibial plateau), a coronal sequence was performed.
Evaluation
T2 mapping sequences were analyzed using the IntelliSpace Portal software (Philips,
Best, The Netherlands). In the axial slices of the patellofemoral cartilage, one region
of interest per slice was placed by hand over the entire cartilage visible in this
slice ([Fig. 1c]), and the T2 relaxation times (mean and maximum) were recorded and averaged. The
measured value for the T2 relaxation time was displayed by the software in milliseconds
(ms). A similar procedure was performed on the coronal slices of the articular cartilage,
each separated according to the four compartments (medial femoral, lateral femoral,
medial tibial, and lateral tibial) ([Fig. 4c]). Focal cartilage changes were evaluated according to their location and geometry.
Fig. 1 Patellofemoral cartilage in a competitive volleyball athlete in a axial proton density with fat saturation (PD fs), b a T2 map, and c the measurement ROI. The focal cartilage alteration with increased T2 relaxation
time (85 ms) in the medial facet (arrow), which is well delineated in the T2 map,
is almost not visible in the PD fs.
Abb. 1 Retropatellarer Knorpel bei einem Volleyball-Leistungssportler in a einer axialen PD fs, b einer T2-Mapping-Karte und c die Mess-ROI: Die in der T2-Mapping-Karte gut abgrenzbare fokale Knorpelveränderung
mit erhöhter T2-Relaxationszeit (85 ms) an der medialen Facette (Pfeil) ist in der
PD fs nahezu nicht sichtbar.
Statistics
Statistical analysis was performed with SPSS 27 (IBM Corp, Armonk, USA). Both knee
joints of each subject were examined. Differences in central tendency were assessed
with a two-tailed T-test or a Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney test, depending on whether normal
distribution was present in the Shapiro-Wilk test. Qualitative characteristics were
evaluated independently by two experienced radiologists with 10 and 16 years of professional
experience, respectively, and subjected to the chi-square test and Fisher exact test
(for n < 5). Interrater reliability was determined using Cohenʼs kappa coefficient.
Results
Participant Data
30 male adolescents (60 knee joints) with a median age of 16.1 years (IQR 17.0–15.1
years) participated in this study. 15 subjects were competitive athletes that played
volleyball, and the other 15 subjects were controls without an increased activity
level. The mean activity duration of the competitive athletes (everyday life, school,
club sports, and leisure time) was 1518 minutes per week (mpw) in total. The mean
activity of the control subjects was 851 mpw (p = .02). The group of competitive athletes is very homogeneous, as the group composition
and training regime are constant for more than two years for all fifteen athletes.
This includes seven training sessions per week (together about 940 mpw, each > 120
minutes per day (mpd)). A prevention program is completed twice per week to reduce
the risk of trauma. The age distribution of the athletes is: mean 16.07 +/– 1.12 years,
range 14–17 (14 years, n = 2; 15 years n = 3; 16 years n = 3; 17 years n = 7). The
two groups differed from each other with respect to height, but not age, weight, and
body mass index (BMI) ([Table 1], [2]).
Table 1
Demographic parameters (statistical significance indicated by *).
|
Controls (n = 15)
|
Volleyball players (n = 15)
|
p-value
|
Median
|
Interquartile range (IQR)
|
Median
|
Interquartile range (IQR)
|
Age (years)
|
16.0
|
16.1–14.8
|
16.1
|
17.1–15.1
|
p = .10
|
Weight (kg)
|
72.7
|
75.0–58.0
|
74.8
|
84.6–69.3
|
p = .13
|
BMI
|
21.0
|
23.6–18.4
|
21.4
|
22.6–19.8
|
p = .80
|
Height (cm)
|
178
|
184–171
|
187
|
193–184
|
p <.001*
|
Table 2
Demographic parameters per subject.
|
Age
|
BMI
|
Weight (kg)
|
Height (cm)
|
Handedness:
1 right, 2 left
|
Volleyball
players
(n = 15)
|
17
|
21.32
|
73.3
|
185
|
1
|
17
|
19.06
|
69.3
|
190
|
1
|
16
|
24.42
|
92.2
|
194
|
1
|
17
|
22.24
|
74.8
|
183
|
1
|
17
|
21.53
|
79.8
|
192
|
1
|
14
|
17.27
|
60.6
|
187
|
1
|
16
|
21.38
|
88.1
|
203
|
2
|
17
|
19.83
|
69.5
|
187
|
1
|
17
|
20.28
|
75.7
|
193
|
1
|
17
|
21.51
|
71
|
181
|
1
|
16
|
17.83
|
62.4
|
187
|
2
|
16
|
22.56
|
76.8
|
184
|
1
|
16
|
22.71
|
84.6
|
193
|
1
|
15
|
30.49
|
113.1
|
192
|
1
|
14
|
20.27
|
64.6
|
178
|
2
|
Controls
(n = 15)
|
15
|
23.18
|
75.1
|
180
|
1
|
17
|
29.95
|
88.2
|
171
|
1
|
15
|
18.41
|
53.4
|
170
|
1
|
16
|
18.38
|
56.3
|
175
|
2
|
14
|
19.28
|
63.8
|
1.82
|
2
|
16
|
21.91
|
75
|
185
|
1
|
14
|
16.97
|
45.3
|
163
|
1
|
14
|
28.52
|
88.35
|
1.76
|
1
|
15
|
19.77
|
63.9
|
180
|
1
|
15
|
20.95
|
58
|
166
|
2
|
15
|
21.47
|
72.7
|
184
|
1
|
16
|
18.52
|
74.9
|
201
|
2
|
17
|
18
|
64.1
|
188
|
1
|
16
|
23.62
|
75
|
178
|
1
|
14
|
23.74
|
72.7
|
175
|
1
|
Patellofemoral cartilage
In 12 of 60 knee joints (5 competitive athletes, 1 control, p = .01), the transition of the medial to lateral facet of the patellofemoral cartilage
showed areas with increased T2 relaxation times compared to the rest of the cartilage
([Fig. 1b], [2] and [Table 3]). The normal gradient of T2 relaxation times from the cartilage-bone interface towards
the articular surface [22] was abolished within the lesions. In each case, the changes affected both knee joints
of the subjects symmetrically. Of the ten affected knees of five competitive athletes,
eight belonged to four players who played the position of middle blocker ([Fig. 3]) (p = .10). The interrater reliability was excellent, with a κ value of 1.0.
Table 3
Local distribution of T2 relaxation times (ms) and focal lesions.
Cartilage location
|
Volleyball players
|
Controls
|
T2-values (ms)
mean/max.
|
Number of focal lesions
|
T2-values (ms)
mean/max.
|
Number of focal lesions
|
Left
|
Femoral media
|
38.7/97.6
|
8
|
41.0/91.6
|
3
|
Femoral lateral
|
42.7/94.5
|
0
|
43.4/90.4
|
0
|
Tibial medial
|
31.3/88.0
|
0
|
32.7/87.5
|
0
|
Tibial lateral
|
33.3/89.2
|
0
|
34.0/88.9
|
0
|
Patellofemoral
|
37.0/93.4
|
5
|
36.9/86.3
|
1
|
Right
|
Femoral media
|
40.6/100.1
|
6
|
41.1/90.1
|
2
|
Femoral lateral
|
42.8/101.7
|
0
|
44.3/94.2
|
0
|
Tibial medial
|
35.6/98.9
|
0
|
35.7/94.1
|
0
|
Tibial lateral
|
31.6/93.6
|
0
|
32.2/94.2
|
0
|
Patellofemoral
|
38.0/94.9
|
5
|
37.6/87.4
|
1
|
Fig. 2 Number of knees of volleyball athletes and controls with focal lesions of the covering
patellofemoral and medial femoral cartilage. Both types of lesions are more common
in volleyball players.
Abb. 2 Häufigkeit von fokalen Knorpelveränderungen retropatellar und medial femoral am Deckknorpel
bei Knien von Volleyballern und Kontrollen. Beide Läsionen treten signifikant häufiger
bei Volleyballern auf.
Fig. 3 Percentage frequency of focal cartilage changes of the patellofemoral and medial
femoral cartilage in knees of volleyball players of different player positions. Middle
blockers standing at the net show greater changes in the patellofemoral articular
cartilage than players in the other player positions, whereas in the latter group
more changes are observed in the medial femoral covering cartilage.
Abb. 3 Prozentuale Häufigkeit des Auftretens fokaler Knorpelveränderungen retropatellar
und medial femoral am Deckknorpel in Knien von Volleyballern in Abhängigkeit von der
Spielerposition. Am Netz stehende Mittelblocker zeigen mehr Veränderungen am retropatellaren
Knorpel als die übrigen Spielerpositionen, wohingegen bei Letzteren die Befunde am
Deckknorpel medial femoral überwogen.
Femoral knee cartilage
In 19 of 60 knee joints (8 competitive athletes, 3 controls, p <.05), an increase in focal T2 relaxation time was found in the cartilage of the
medial femoral condyle. Again, the zonal division of T2 times was abolished. The findings
were sharply bordered bilaterally with respect to the surrounding cartilage and presented
in anterior-posterior extension as elongated, band-like areas narrowing dorsally ([Fig. 2], [4], [5] and [Table 3]). An association of the femoral knee cartilage lesions was seen in the remaining
player positions. The interrater reliability was excellent with a κ value of 1.0.
Fig. 4 Coronal a PD fs and b T2 mapping images of the knee of a volleyball player with focally increased T2 relaxation
time in the covering cartilage of the medial femoral condyle (arrow). The finding
is almost not visible in PD fs. c The four measurement ROIs per coronal slice: green – femoral lateral; blue – femoral
medial; red – tibial lateral and yellow – tibial medial. Measurements were taken in
each slice from ventral to dorsal as long as articular cartilage was visible.
Abb. 4 Koronare a PD fs und b T2-Mapping-Bilder des Knies eines Volleyballers mit fokal erhöhter T2-Relaxationszeit
im Deckknorpel der medialen Femurkondyle (Pfeil). Der Befund ist in der konventionellen
Sequenz nahezu nicht sichtbar. c Die 4 Mess- ROIs pro coronarer Schicht: grün – femoral lateral; blau – femoral medial;
rot – tibial lateral und gelb – tibial medial. Die Messungen wurden in jeder Schicht
von ventral nach dorsal durchgeführt, solange Deckknorpel sichtbar war.
Fig. 5 Zoomed version of T2 mapping image of the knee of a volleyball player with focally
increased T2 relaxation time in the covering cartilage of the medial femoral condyle.
The focally increased T2 relaxation time extends in a band-like fashion over the cartilage
of the entire condyle. It is wider ventrally and narrower dorsally (arrowhead).
Abb. 5 Der Befund erstreckt sich im T2-Mapping bandförmig über den Deckknorpel der gesamten
medialen Femurkondyle und ist ventral breiter um nach dorsal schmaler zu werden (Pfeilspitze).
Diffuse Cartilage Changes
Dividing the knee joint cartilage into four quadrants, the lateral femoral compartment
showed the highest mean T2 times of 43 ms, followed by the medial femoral compartment
with 40 ms. The medial and lateral tibial compartments showed the lowest T2 relaxation
times at 34 ms and 33 ms, respectively. The only difference in mean T2 relaxation
time between competitive athletes and controls was found in the medial femoral cartilage
in the left knee (38.7 ms and 41.0 ms, respectively, p <.05; CI 95 %, -4.6–0 ms) ([Fig. 6, ]
[Table 3]), with the athletes having shorter T2 times than the controls. In addition, the
maximum T2 relaxation times of the competitive athletes exceeded those of the controls
in the medial (97.6 ms and 91.6 ms, p = .05; CI 95 %, 0 ms – 11.9 ms) femoral covering cartilage on the left, and in the
medial (100.8 ms and 91.1 ms, p <.04; CI 95 %, 0.8–17.6 ms) and lateral (101.7 ms and 94.1 ms, p <.02; CI 95 %, 1.6–13.5 ms) femoral covering cartilage on the right ([Fig. 7, ]
[Table 3]).
Fig. 6 Comparison of the mean values of the T2 relaxation times of the covering cartilage
between volleyball players (red) and controls (blue), separated according to the four
compartments (femoral medial, femoral lateral, tibial medial, and tibial lateral).
Differences were only found on the left medial femur.
Abb. 6 Vergleich der Mittelwerte der T2-Relaxationszeiten (in ms) des Deckknorpels zwischen
Volleyballern (rot) und Kontrollen (blau) getrennt nach den 4 Kompartimenten (femoral
medial, femoral lateral, tibial medial und tibial lateral). Signifikante Unterschiede
ergaben sich medial femoral.
Fig. 7 Comparison of the maximum values of the T2 relaxation times of the covering cartilage
between volleyball players (red) and controls (blue), separated according to the four
compartments (femoral medial, femoral lateral, tibial medial, and tibial lateral).
Significant differences were found on both sides in the medial femoral compartment
and additionally femoral lateral on the right side with an increase in T2 times in
the volleyball players in the compartments through which the main load-bearing axis
runs.
Abb. 7 Vergleich der Maximalwerte der T2-Relaxationszeiten (in ms) des Deckknorpels zwischen
Volleyballern (rot) und Kontrollen (blau) getrennt nach den 4 Kompartimenten (femoral
medial, femoral lateral, tibial medial und tibial lateral). Signifikante Unterschiede
ergaben sich bds. jeweils im medial femoralen Kompartiment und femoral lateral rechts
mit einer Erhöhung der T2-Zeiten bei den Volleyballern in den Kompartimenten, durch
die die Haupttraglastachse verläuft.
Discussion
This is the first cross-sectional study to demonstrate early cartilage changes in
adolescent competitive volleyball athletes using T2 mapping. There were more focal
changes in the cartilage of the knee joint in the competitive athletes compared to
those in a control population. Furthermore, the maximum T2 relaxation times were significantly
higher in the athletes’ medial femoral cartilage on both sides compared to the controls,
which is discussed further below ([Fig. 7]). The above-described findings could be the first signs of cartilage degeneration,
possibly based on an overuse syndrome as described in young athletes [10]. In this case, tissue stress occurs with repetitive subclinical overload peaks whose
temporal intervals are so short that the necessary regeneration time of the affected
tissue is undercut. Thus, the cartilage changes could be interpreted as local reactions
of the patellofemoral cartilage to frequently recurring, focal suprathreshold stress,
for example, during the jumping and landing phases. This would also be supported by
the fact that four of the five affected athletes in our study played as middle blockers,
a position characterized by multiple high jumps [16]. The fact that the changes were laterally symmetrical, occurring on both knees,
also speaks in favor of this.
Patellofemoral cartilage
Cartilage changes in our adolescent collective were almost not visible in the conventional
sequences (PD-TSE fs and T1-TSE). This is consistent with a study by Boeth et al.
in adolescent and adult volleyball players: while cartilage damage was observed in
more than half of the adult volleyball players, no lesions were found in adolescents
[15]. The higher percentage of cartilage damage in adult players in their study suggests
that playing volleyball at a professional level predisposes athletes to cartilage
damage. However, the early form of these changes, i. e., T2 relaxation time change,
was not examined in the study, which may explain the lack of changes in the adolescents.
Apprich et al. highlight the high value of T2 mapping, especially in the early phase
of cartilaginous degeneration of the patellofemoral cartilage [23]. They also address the issue of load distribution in the patellofemoral joint. During
walking, the gliding motion leads to a diffuse load distribution rather than a point
load distribution. However, the situation in the case of impact sports such as volleyball
appears to be different as the patellofemoral cartilage is subjected to high physical
loads. This is especially true for the transition from the medial to the lateral facet,
as this zone is pressed against the femoral sulcus during jumps and is thus susceptible
to degenerative changes. Liess et al. showed a close temporal relationship between
athletic stress and its effect on patellofemoral cartilage [24]. They reported a reduction in both cartilage thickness and T2 relaxation time immediately
after 60 squats, which was reversed following a 45-minute rest, at which time an increase
in both parameters was observed. The authors attributed this to a reabsorption of
water into the matrix of the cartilage. Through histological studies with dogs that
had to run 20 km per day for 15 weeks, Säämämen et al. showed that there was a significant
increase in the cartilaginous water content in the femoropatellar groove, while the
collagen content decreased [25]. These histomorphologic findings were interpreted as correlates of the initial cartilage
degeneration. In humans, Kim et al. detected the highest T2 relaxation times in the
middle third of the patellofemoral cartilage at the transition from the medial to
lateral facet already under physiological conditions on axial MRI slices of the patella
in adolescents [21]. This observation supports our findings that the first cartilage changes occurred
here.
The relationship between increased physical activity and increased T2 relaxation times
or focally increased cartilage water content is consistent with the findings of Stahl
et al. and Stehling et al. [26]
[27]. In an adult collective they showed on the one hand the relationship between greater
T2 relaxation time, which has been diffusely detectable throughout the patellofemoral
cartilage, and increased physical activity, and on the other hand also a relationship
between activity and focally circumscribed cartilage changes. The knowledge of regional
changes in T2 relaxation time is particularly important because the increase in the
T2 relaxation time of cartilage precedes the cartilage damage detected several years
later [7]. In addition, once focal signal enhancements of the cartilage become visible in
standard MR sequences, they are very likely to develop into cartilage defects [8].
Covering cartilage
Lesions on the covering cartilage of the medial femoral condyle in our competitive
sports collective occurred predominantly not in athletes who played the position of
middle blocker, but rather in the running-intensive positions, i. e., outside attacker,
setter, and the libero. These positions are characterized by substantial running of
over 1.5 km with abrupt changes in direction and load in a confined space [16]. The predisposition to the medial femoral compartment can be explained by the course
of the main load axis of the body through this structure. Due to the high biomechanical
forces there, changes in T2 mapping and later cartilage degeneration can occur at
an early stage [13]
[28].
The mean T2 relaxation times of the four compartments of the femorotibial joint (medial
femoral, lateral femoral, medial tibial, and lateral tibial) showed a typical distribution
pattern of T2 relaxation times, consistent with the literature for the pediatric [29] and the adult population [30], with the femoral being the highest and the tibial being the lowest. The mean T2
relaxation times differed between competitive athletes and controls only for the left
medial femur and were lower in the athletes. This contradicts other recent studies
in young adults, where the T2 relaxation times were higher. There could be two reasons
for this: firstly, better muscular stabilization of the knee joint with resulting
relief of the cartilage. All subjects of the study received a gait analysis after
the MR examination [31]. The competitive athletes maintained a largely neutral leg axis compared to the
controls even during strong loads, such as the counter movement jump, which indicates
ideal physiological loading of all cartilage compartments. Secondly, despite being
the same median age, the adolescent volleyball players were taller. This suggests
that they were already ahead in their skeletal development compared to the controls,
which in turn would explain the lower mean T2 values. These values decrease continuously
from childhood to young adulthood with increasing skeletal maturity [21]
[29]. The maximum T2 relaxation times were significantly increased in both medial femoral
compartments of the athletes but not the mean T2 relaxation times. This could be due
to the fact that the band-like focal lesions with increased T2 relaxation times (> 80 ms)
described above cross the sectional planes perpendicularly. As this affects the total
ROI in the coronal plane only to a small extent, the mean T2 relaxation times do not
respond to the focal changes, but the maximum T2 relaxation times. A smaller layout
of the ROIs might solve this issue, but also leads to less stable measurements. Perifocally
around the center of the lesions, a zone with likewise increased T2 relaxation times
was seen, although it was less severe than in the center. The latter could be an early
diffuse cartilage response to athletic loading, which could be interpreted as a first
sign of incipient alteration of the complex cartilage matrix [5]
[6]. This hypothesis is also supported by the finding of Kretschmar et al. that in addition
to focal changes, diffuse changes in cartilage precede later cartilage damage, sometimes
by several years [32]. To prevent this sequence from preclinical to clinical cartilage changes in competitive
volleyball athletes, prevention programs, such as “The 11” which already exists for
amateur soccer players [33], could be useful.
Limitations
We acknowledge that our study has a few possible limitations:
-
The two groups differed significantly in terms of height, but not in terms of weight
and especially BMI. The T2 relaxation time is codependent on BMI [30]. Yet, since in our study the BMIs of the two groups did not differ significantly,
this factor is unlikely to skew the results.
-
The results of our male cohorts cannot readily be applied to female adolescents. For
example, female volleyball players often have more valgus of the leg axis during landing
[34], so their medial femorotibial joint may be less loaded than is the case in male
adolescents. Furthermore, there is a close correlation between gender, age, and the
T2 relaxation time of the knee joint cartilage [21].
-
It is a small number of cases, with limited significance for the overall population.
In order not to compromise the homogeneity of the group of competitive athletes, an
entire volleyball class with fifteen pupils at a sports school was studied. This ensures
equal training levels, equal distances to competitions, and the support of the coach.
An enlargement of the group with test subjects from other cities would have affected
these identical conditions. Therefore, the number of subjects could not be increased
arbitrarily.
Conclusion
In adolescent volleyball players in competitive sports, early cartilage lesions are
detectable by T2 mapping in both patellofemoral and medial femoral cartilages, with
the distribution of lesions depending on player position.
Since the cascade from T2 relaxation time increase to conspicuous cartilage damage
is well established, an early counter-regulation (e. g., through an adapted training
profile, targeted physiotherapy, and appropriate muscle building training) could possibly
prevent later damage. To allow wide availability of the method to as many athletes
as possible, the well-established method of T2 mapping was used in this study to assess
knee cartilage.
Clinical relevance of the study
-
Since the progression from initial diffuse or focal T2 relaxation time increases of
knee joint cartilage to cartilage damage and subsequent osteoarthritis is well documented,
early counter-regulation, e. g., through an adapted training profile, targeted physiotherapy,
and appropriate muscle building training, could possibly prevent later cartilage damage.
-
The results show that training should be accompanied by medical monitoring even in
adolescents who are active at a competitive sport level.
-
For this purpose, T2 mapping is well suited as a widely available, well-established
and robust MRI examination method.
Klinische Relevanz der Studie
-
Da die Entwicklung von initial diffusen oder fokalen T2-Relaxationszeiterhöhungen
des Kniegelenkknorpels hin zu manifesten Knorpelschäden und nachfolgender Arthrose
gut belegt ist, könnte eine frühe Gegenregulation z. B. durch ein angepasstes Trainingsprofil,
gezielte Physiotherapie und entsprechendes Muskelaufbautraining eventuell spätere
Knorpelschäden verhindern.
-
Die Ergebnisse zeigen, dass auch Jugendliche, die auf Leistungssportniveau aktiv sind,
eine trainingsbegleitende medizinische Überwachung erhalten sollten.
-
Zu diesem Zweck ist das T2-Mapping als breitflächig verfügbare, gut etablierte und
robuste Untersuchungsmethode im MRT gut geeignet.