A brief history of mastoidectomy

Summary

Aim: To describe to the new generation of otologists the origins of mastoidectomy as well as the difficulties our predecessors encountered and the solutions they devised to improve otologic surgery.

Method: Retrospective literature review-based study.

Results: Before the mid-19th century, mastoidectomy was performed only sporadically and in most cases as a desperate attempt to save the lives of people suffering from complications of infectious otitis. The drainage of acute abscesses became a common procedure at the beginning of the 20th century, within the pre-antibiotic era. The first documented surgical incision to drain an infected ear was described by the French physician Ambroise Paré in the 16th century. The credit for performing the first mastoidectomy for the removal of purulent secretions went to Jean-Louis Petit. Mastoidectomies were normally performed to treat infections. However, mastoidectomies were also carried out for other purposes, particularly for the treatment of deafness and tinnitus, during various periods. Sir Charles Ballance credited Johannes Riolanus with recommending mastoidectomy for the treatment of tinnitus. William Wilde began the era of modern mastoidectomy with his introduction of the eponymous retroauricular incision.

Conclusion: Mastoidectomy has evolved significantly throughout its history. Improvements in mastoidectomy have relied on the introduction of more elaborate surgical procedures, especially the advances in surgical equipment during the last century. Mastoidectomy continues to be a life-saving surgical procedure.

Keywords

Mastoid - History - Otolaryngology

• References

• 1 Sunder S, Jackler RK, Blevins NH. Virtuosity with the mallet and goug: the brilliant triumph of “ the modern” mastoid operation. Otolaryngol Clin North Am 2006; Dec; 39 (6) 1191-210
• 2 Politzer A. Geschichte des ohrenheilkunde. Stuttgart (Germany): Verlag von Ferdinand Enke; 1913
• 3 Lustig L, Jackler R. The history of otology through Eponyms II: the clinical examination. Am J Otol 1999; 20: 535-50
• 4 Duckworth WLH. Galen on anatomical procedures: the later books. Cambridge (MA): University Press; 1962
• 5 Galen C. Galen: on the usefulness of the parts of the body, vol. 1. Ithaca (NY): Cornell University Press; 1968
• 6 Galen C. Galen: on the usefulness of the parts of the body, vol. 2. Ithaca (NY): Cornell University Press; 1968
• 7 Siegel RE. Galen on sense perception. Basel (Switzerland): S. Karger; 1970
• 8 Millstein S. The history of mastoid surgery. Am J Otol 1980; 1 (3) 174-8
• 9 Cawthorne T. The surgery of the temporal bone. J Laryngol Otol 1953; 67: 377-91
• 10 Mudry A. Contribution of Ambroise Paré (1510–1590) to otology. Otol Neurotol 1999; 20: 809-13
• 11 Liston SL. Ambroise Paré and the King's Mastoiditis. Am J Surg 1994; Apr; 167 (4) 440-2
• 12 Singer DW. Selections from the works of Ambroise Pare. London: John Bale, Sons & Danielsson, Ltd; 1924
• 13 Pare A. The apologie and treatise of Ambroise Pare. New York: Dover Publications; 1968
• 14 Sonnenschein R. A brief consideration of the history of the development of the mastoidectomy. Ann Med Hist 1935; 8: 500-10
• 15 Riolan J. A sure guide, or, The best and nearest way to physick and chyrurgery [Encheiridium anatomicum et pathologicum]. London: John Streater; 1671
• 16 Riolan J. Anthropographia et Osteologia. Paris: Moreau; 1626
• 17 Louis A. Extraits de l'eloge de Jean-Louis Petit lus dans la seance publique de l'Academie royale de chirurgie du 26 mai 1750 par A. Louis. Chirurgie 2001; 126: 475-81
• 18 Ballance B. Essays on the surgery of the temporal bone, vol. 1. London: MacMillan & Co, Ltd.; 1919
• 19 Petit J-L. Traité des maladies chirurgicales, et des operations qui leur conviennent. Nouvéedition. Paris: 1790
• 20 Schmucker JS. Vermischte Chirurgische Schriften, vol. 3. Berlin; 1782
• 21 von Trö ltsch AF. Treatise on the diseases of the ear, including the anatomy of the organ. New York: William Wood, Co.; 1869
• 22 Dezeimeris JE. De la perforation de L'apophyse mastoide. Dans diverses affections de ses cellules, et dans quelques cas de surdité. L'Experience. Jounral de Medecine et de Chirurgie 1838; 33: 497-501
• 23 Dezeimeris JE. De la perforation de L'apophyse mastoide. Dans diverses affections de ses cellules, et dans quelques cas de surdité. L'Experience. Jounral de Medecine et de Chirurgie 1838; 33: 513-20
• 24 Wilson TG. Historical vignette - Sir William Wilde. Arch Otol 1965; 81: 626-9
• 25 Wilson T. Victorian doctor: being the life of Sir William Wilde. New York: Fischer; 1946
• 26 Robins AH, Sellars SL. Oscar Wilde's terminal illness: reappraisal after a century. Lancet 2000; 356: 1841-3
• 27 Wilde WR. Practical observations on aural surgery and the nature and treatment of diseases of the ear. Philadelphia: Blanchard & Lea; 1853
• 28 Kramer W. An exposure of ”Wilde's Aural Surgery.”. Lancet 1853; 62 (1575): 446-7
• 29 Toynbee J. Diseases of the ear. London: J. Churchill; 1860
• 30 Mawson SR. Surgery of the mastoid: the first centenary. Proc R Soc Med 1975; 68 (6) 391-5
• 31 Schwartze H, Eysell C. Uber die kunstliche eroffnung des warzenfortsatzes. Arch Ohrenheilkd 1873; 7: 157-62
• 32 Pappas DG. Hermann Hugo Rudolf Schwartze (1837–1910). Ear Nose Throat J 1996; 75 (11) 708-9
• 33 Ohlroggen M, Lustig L. Atranslation of: The scientific progress of otology in the past decennium (until late 1862) by Hermann Schwartze: pathology and therapy of the external ear. Otol Neurotol 2003; 24 (6) 952-7
• 34 Pappas D. Hermann Hugo Rudolf Schwartze (1837–1910). Reintroduction of paracentesis and mastoid surgery. Ear Nose Throat J 1996; 75: 708-9
• 35 Obituary. Lancet 1890; 135 (3467): 328-9
• 36 Küster E. Uber die Grundsä tze der Behandlung von Eiterungen in starrwandigen Höhlen. Deutsch med Wochenschr 1889; 13: 254-7
• 37 Von Bergmann E. Berl klin Wchnschr 1888; 36: 1054
• 38 Von Bergmann E. Die chirurgische Behandlung von Hirnkrankheiten. Berlin; 1889
• 39 Hartmann A. Historical remarks upon the operation for exposing the tympanic cupola-space (attic) and the mastoid antrum. In: Knapp H, Moos S, Pritchard U, , editors. Archives of otology. New York: GP Putnam's Sons; 1895. p. 1–11
• 40 Zaufal E. Technik der Trepanation des Proc. Mastoid. Nach Kuster'schen Grundsatzen. Arch Ohrenheilkd 1890; 30: 291
• 41 Stacke L. Indicationen betreffend de Excision von Hammer und Amboss. Arch Ohrenheilkd 1890; 31: 201-15
• 42 MacEwen W. Pyogenic and infective diseases of the brain and spinal cord. Glasgow: MacLehose & Sons; 1893
• 43 Tumarkin A. Mastoid surgery - old and new. Lancet 1948; 251 (6506): 708-11
• 44 Heath C. The restoration of hearing after removal of the drum and ossicles by a modification of the radical mastoid operation for suppurative ear disease. Lancet 1904; 164: 1767-9
• 45 Heath C. A short paper (founded upon an experience of 400 operations) on the restoration of hearing after removal of the drum and ossicles by a modification of the radical mastoid operation for suppurative ear disease. In: Horne J, , editor. Transactions of the Otological Society of the United Kingdom. London: J & A Churchill; 1905
• 46 Heath CJ. Diagnosis and treatment in cases of otitis media (mastoid disease). London: Baillière, Tindall and Cox; 1919
• 47 Heath CJ. The conservative mastoid operation. Lancet 1928; 211 (5450): 279-81
• 48 Bryant WS. The radical mastoid operation modified to allow the preservation of normal hearing. Trans Am Otol Soc 1906; 9: 292-5
• 49 Richards GL. The so-called conservative mastoid operation, with a description of the technic of Heath, Bondy, and Siebenmann. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1911; 20: 578-94
• 50 Bondy G. Totalaufmeisselung mit Erhaltung von Trommelfell und Gehorknochelchen. Monatsschr Ohrenheilk 1910; p. 15–23
• 51 Pappas DG. Bondy's modified radical mastoidectomy revisited. Ear Nose Throat J 1994; 73 (1) 15-8
• 52 Bondy G. Beiträ ge zur Vergleichenden Anatomiedes Goroha Gohorogans. Anat Hette. 1907;
• 53 House WF. The Struggles of a Medical Innovator: Cochlear Implants and Other Ear Surgeries. [place unknown]: CreateSpace; 2011. 208 p.
• 54 Hitselberger WE, Pulec JL. Trigeminal nerve (posterior root) retrolabyrintine selective section-operative procedure for intractable pain. Arch. Otolaryng 1972; 96: 412-5
• 55 Bogar P, Miniti A, Bento RF. The transmastoid, retrolabyrintine and presigmoid approach and hearing preservation. In: 2nd International Conference on Acoustic Neuroma Surgery and 2nd European Skull Base Society Congress, Paris, França, Final Program; 1995, p. 104.
• 56 Bento RF, Brito Neto RV, Sanchez TG, Miniti A. The transmastoid retrolabyrinthine approach in vestibular schwannoma surgery. Otolaryngology-Head Neck Surgery 2002; 127 (5) 437-41