The Type and Intensity of Exercise Have Independent and Additive Effects on Bone Mineral Density

Abstract

Previous research on the effects of running and swimming on areal bone mineral density (aBMD) is inconclusive. This study examined the putative roles of the type and intensity of exercise in this respect, by measuring aBMD (adjusted for age, weight, and height) of the total body and of various subregions in 52 males aged 17 - 30 yr (21 runners, 16 swimmers, 15 controls). The athletes were competing at either long-distance (“endurance”, n = 17) or short-distance (“sprint”, n = 20) events. Compared with controls, runners had significantly higher leg aBMD (+ 6.7 %, p < 0.05), while swimmers had significantly lower leg and total body aBMD (- 9.8 % and - 7.0 %, respectively, p < 0.05). Endurance athletes had significantly lower total body aBMD than controls (- 4.9 %, p < 0.05). Sprint athletes did not differ significantly from controls at any site, but they had significantly higher aBMD than endurance athletes throughout the skeleton (p < 0.05). Compared with controls, endurance swimmers had significantly lower aBMD at the legs and total body (- 14.8 % and - 10.4 %, respectively, p < 0.05), while sprint runners had significantly higher values for the legs, trunk, and total body (+ 8.0 %, + 10.0 %, and + 6.3 %, respectively, p < 0.05). Sprint swimmers and endurance runners did not differ from controls at any site or the total body. These results suggest that the type and intensity of exercise have independent and additive effects on bone density.

Key words

skeleton - swimming - running - endurance - sprint - distance

References

• 1 Ammann P, Rizzoli R. Bone strength and its determinants.  Osteoporos Int. 2003;  14 (Suppl 3) S13-S18
• 2 Beck B R, Shaw J, Snow C M. Physical activity and osteoporosis. Marcus R, Feldman D, Kelsey J Osteoporosis. 2nd edn. San Diego, CA; Academic Press 2001: 701-720
• 3 Bellew J W, Gehrig L. A comparison of bone mineral density in adolescent female swimmers, soccer players, and weight lifters.  Pediatr Phys Ther. 2006;  18 19-22
• 4 Bennell K L, Malcolm S A, Khan K M, Thomas S A, Reid S J, Brukner P D, Ebeling P R, Wark J D. Bone mass and bone turnover in power athletes, endurance athletes, and controls: a 12-month longitudinal study.  Bone. 1997;  20 477-484
• 5 Bilanin J E, Blanchard M S, Russek-Cohen E. Lower vertebral bone density in male long distance runners.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1989;  21 66-70
• 6 Bouxsein M L, Marcus R. Overview of exercise and bone mass.  Rheum Dis Clin North Am. 1994;  20 787-802
• 7 Brahm H, Strom H, Piehl-Aulin K, Mallmin H, Ljunghall S. Bone metabolism in endurance trained athletes: a comparison to population-based controls based on DXA, SXA, quantitative ultrasound, and biochemical markers.  Calcif Tissue Int. 1997;  61 448-454
• 8 Cappozzo A. Force actions in the human trunk during running.  J Sports Med Phys Fitness. 1983;  23 14-22
• 9 Carter D R. Mechanical loading history and skeletal biology.  J Biomech. 1987;  20 1095-1109
• 10 Chilibeck P D, Sale D G, Webber C E. Exercise and bone mineral density.  Sports Med. 1995;  19 103-122
• 11 Crossley K, Bennell K L, Wrigley T, Oakes B W. Ground reaction forces, bone characteristics, and tibial stress fracture in male runners.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1999;  31 1088-1093
• 12 Duncan C S, Blimkie C J, Cowell C T, Burke S T, Briody J N, Howman-Giles R. Bone mineral density in adolescent female athletes: relationship to exercise type and muscle strength.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2002;  34 286-294
• 13 Duncan R L, Turner C H. Mechanotransduction and the functional response of bone to mechanical strain.  Calcif Tissue Int. 1995;  57 344-358
• 14 Einhorn T A. Bone strength: the bottom line.  Calcif Tissue Int. 1992;  51 333-339
• 15 Frost H M. Why do marathon runners have less bone than weight lifters? A vital-biomechanical view and explanation.  Bone. 1997;  20 183-189
• 16 Giangregorio L, Blimkie C J. Skeletal adaptations to alterations in weight-bearing activity: a comparison of models of disuse osteoporosis.  Sports Med. 2002;  32 459-476
• 17 Groothausen J, Siemer H, Kemper H CG, Twisk J, Welten D C. Influence of peak strain on lumbar bone mineral density: an analysis of 15-year physical activity in young males and females.  Pediatr Exerc Sci. 1997;  9 159-173
• 18 Hetland M L, Haarbo J, Christiansen C. Low bone mass and high bone turnover in male long distance runners.  J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 1993;  77 770-775
• 19 Karlsson M K, Magnusson H, Karlsson C, Seeman E. The duration of exercise as a regulator of bone mass.  Bone. 2001;  28 128-132
• 20 Kelley G A, Kelley K S, Tran Z V. Exercise and bone mineral density in men: a meta-analysis.  J Appl Physiol. 2000;  88 1730-1736
• 21 Kemper H C, Twisk J W, van Mechelen W, Post G B, Roos J C, Lips P. A fifteen-year longitudinal study in young adults on the relation of physical activity and fitness with the development of the bone mass: The Amsterdam Growth And Health Longitudinal Study.  Bone. 2000;  27 847-853
• 22 Lanyon L E. Using functional loading to influence bone mass and architecture: objectives, mechanisms, and relationship with estrogen of the mechanically adaptive process in bone.  Bone. 1996;  18 37S-43S
• 23 Layne J E, Nelson M E. The effects of progressive resistance training on bone density: a review.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1999;  31 25-30
• 24 Leblanc A D, Schneider V S, Evans H J, Engelbretson D A, Krebs J M. Bone mineral loss and recovery after 17 weeks of bed rest.  J Bone Miner Res. 1990;  5 843-850
• 25 Lee E J, Long K A, Risser W L, Poindexter H B, Gibbons W E, Goldzieher J. Variations in bone status of contralateral and regional sites in young athletic women.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1995;  27 1354-1361
• 26 MacDougall J D, Webber C E, Martin J, Ormerod S, Chesley A, Younglai E V, Gordon C L, Blimkie C J. Relationship among running mileage, bone density, and serum testosterone in male runners.  J Appl Physiol. 1992;  73 1165-1170
• 27 Mussolino M E, Looker A C, Orwoll E S. Jogging and bone mineral density in men: results from NHANES III.  Am J Public Health. 2001;  91 1056-1059
• 28 Nilsson B E, Westlin N E. Bone density in athletes.  Clin Orthop. 1971;  77 179-182
• 29 Orwoll E S, Ferar J, Oviatt S K, McClung M R, Huntington K. The relationship of swimming exercise to bone mass in men and women.  Arch Intern Med. 1989;  149 2197-2200
• 30 Robinson T L, Snow-Harter C, Taaffe D R, Gillis D, Shaw J, Marcus R. Gymnasts exhibit higher bone mass than runners despite similar prevalence of amenorrhea and oligomenorrhea.  J Bone Miner Res. 1995;  10 26-35
• 31 Smith R, Rutherford O M. Spine and total body bone mineral density and serum testosterone levels in male athletes.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 1993;  67 330-334
• 32 Snow C M, Rosen C J, Robinson T L. Serum IGF‐I is higher in gymnasts than runners and predicts bone and lean mass.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2000;  32 1902-1907
• 33 Stewart A D, Hannan J. Total and regional bone density in male runners, cyclists, and controls.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2000;  32 1373-1377
• 34 Suominen H, Rahkila P. Bone mineral density of the calcaneus in 70- to 81-yr-old male athletes and a population sample.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1991;  23 1227-1233
• 35 Suominen H. Bone mineral density and long term exercise. An overview of cross-sectional athlete studies.  Sports Med. 1993;  16 316-330
• 36 Taaffe D R, Snow-Harter C, Connolly D A, Robinson T L, Brown M D, Marcus R. Differential effects of swimming versus weight-bearing activity on bone mineral status of eumenorrheic athletes.  J Bone Miner Res. 1995;  10 586-593
• 37 Taaffe D R, Robinson T L, Snow C M, Marcus R. High-impact exercise promotes bone gain in well-trained female athletes.  J Bone Miner Res. 1997;  12 255-260
• 38 Taaffe D R, Marcus R. Regional and total body bone mineral density in elite collegiate male swimmers.  J Sports Med Phys Fitness. 1999;  39 154-159
• 39 Winters K M, Adams W C, Meredith C N, Loan M D, Lasley B L. Bone density and cyclic ovarian function in trained runners and active controls.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1996;  28 776-785
• 40 Wosk J, Voloshin A. Wave attenuation in skeletons of young healthy persons.  J Biomech. 1981;  14 261-267