Perseveration or the Tower of Babel

ABSTRACT

The purpose of this article is twofold: (1) to present a study of perseveration in a continuous series of 50 left brain-damaged aphasic subjects and (2) to describe the treatment of 2 patients with high rates of perseveration. In the group of 50 subjects, 20 showed two or more perseverations in one or more language tasks. No difference in number of perseverations was found between fluent and nonfluent subjects, but perseverations in global aphasic subjects with stereotyped speech were less varied than they were in fluent aphasic subjects and were not unlike other types of recurrent utterances. Of the two patients who received treatment, subject 1 had severe semantic disruption and perseverated in all production and comprehension tasks, except in repetition, reading aloud, and writing to dictation, all of which could be performed by the undamaged sublexical routines. Treated subject 2 had writing disorders that were ascribed to damage to the output buffer. She perseverated in all writing tasks. Rehabilitation of the semantic system in subject 1 and of the output buffer in subject 2 greatly reduced the number of perseverations in both subjects. It is argued that recovery of the underlying functional damage reduces the perseverative behavior.

KEYWORDS

Perseveration - stereotypy - semantic damage - orthographic output buffer

REFERENCES

• 1 Christman S S, Boutsen F R, Buckingham H W. Perseveration and other repetitive verbal behaviors: functional dissociations.  Semin Speech Lang. 2004;  25 295-308
• 2 Alajouanine T. L’aphasie et le langage pathologique. Paris; Baillière 1968
• 3 Goldberg E, Tucker D. Motor perseveration and long-term memory for visual forms.  J Clin Neuropsychol. 1979;  1 273-288
• 4 Sandson J, Albert M L. Varieties of perseveration.  Neuropsychologia. 1984;  22 715-732
• 5 Santo Pietro M J, Rigrodsky S. Patterns of oral-verbal perseveration in adult aphasics.  Brain Lang. 1986;  19 1-17
• 6 Yamadori A. Verbal perseveration in aphasia.  Neuropsychologia. 1981;  19 591-594
• 7 Helm-Estabrooks N, Ramage A, Bayles K A, Cruz R. Perseverative behavior in fluent and non-fluent aphasic adults.  Aphasiology. 1998;  12 689-698
• 8 Helm-Estabrooks N, Emery P, Martin A. Treatment of Aphasic Perseveration (TAP) program. A new appraoch to aphasia therapy.  Arch Neurol. 1987;  44 1253-1255
• 9 Goodglass H, Kaplan E. The Assessement of Aphasia and Related Disorders, 2nd ed. Philadelphia; Lea & Febiger 1983
• 10 De Renzi E, Faglioni P. Normative data and screening power of a shortened version of the Token Test.  Cortex. 1978;  14 41-49
• 11 Basso A, Capitani E, Vignolo L A. Influence of rehabilitation on language skills in aphasic patients. A controlled study.  Arch Neurol. 1979;  36 190-196
• 12 Cohen L, Dehaene S. Competition between past and present. Assessment and interpretation of verbal perseverations.  Brain. 1998;  121 1641-1659
• 13 Papagno C, Basso A. Perseveration in two aphasic patients.  Cortex. 1996;  32 67-82
• 14 Basso A. Aphasia and Its Therapy. New York; Oxford University Press 2003
• 15 Raven J C. Guide to Using the Coloured Progressive Matrices Sets A, Ab, B. London; HK Lewis 1965
• 16 Leicester J, Sidman M, Stoddart L T, Mohr J P. The nature of aphasic responses.  Neuropsychologia. 1971;  9 141-155
• 17 Sandson J, Albert M L. Perseveration in behavioral neurology.  Neurology. 1987;  37 1736-1741
• 18 Buckingham H W, Whitaker H, Whitaker H. On linguistic perseveration. In: Whitaker H, Whitaker H Studies in Neurolinguistics, 4. New York; Academic Press 1979: 329-352
• 19 Gotts S J, Plaut D C. Connectionist approaches to understanding aphasic perseveration.  Semin Speech Lang. 2004;  25 323-334
• 20 Snodgrass J G, Vanderwart M. Standardized set of 260 pictures: norms for name agreement, image agreement, familiarity and visual complexity.  J Exp Psychol Hum Learning Memory. 1980;  6 174-215
• 21 Laiacona M, Barbarotto R, Trivelli C, Capitani E. Dissociazioni semantiche intercategoriali: descrizione di una batteria standardizzata e dati normative.  Arch Psicol Neurol Psichiatr. 1993;  54 209-248
• 22 Helmick J, Berg C. Perseverations in brain injured adults.  J Commun Dis. 1976;  9 143-156
• 23 Goldberg E. Varieties of perseveration: comparison of two taxonomies.  J Clin Exp Neuropsychol. 1986;  8 710-726
• 24 Martin N, Dell G S. Perseveration and anticipations in aphasia: primed intrusions for the past and future.  Semin Speech Lang. 2004;  25 349-362
• 25 Albert M L, Sandson J. Perseveration in aphasia.  Cortex. 1986;  22 103-115
• 26 Lebrun Y. Repetitive phenomena in aphasia. In: Blanken G, Dittman J, Grimm H, Marshall JC, Wallesh CW Linguistic Disorders and Pathologies. Berlin; Walter de Gruyten 1993: 225-231
• 27 Neils-Strunjas J, Shuren J, Roeltgen D, Brown C. Perseverative writing errors in a patient with Alzheimer's disease.  Brain Lang. 1998;  3 303-320
• 28 Caccappolo-van Vliet E, Miozzo M, Marder K, Stern Y. Where do perseverations come from?.  Neurocase. 2003;  9 297-307