Similar to any novel treatment strategy for hemophilia, gene therapy faces the question
of the risk of formation of inhibitory antibodies to the therapeutic factor VIII or
factor IX protein. Activation of CD4+ or CD8+ T cells could lead to antibody formation or cytotoxic T lymphocyte responses to transgene-expressing
cells. Preclinical studies in animal models of hemophilia A and B with different mutations
in the dysfunctional gene shed light on the risk for such immune responses and point
toward strategies to avoid immune activation or even promote tolerance induction.
The impacts of variables such as choice and design of gene transfer vector, underlying
gene mutation, route of vector administration, and transient immune suppression are
discussed. Maintenance of immunological hyporesponsiveness to the therapeutic gene
product is critical for successful gene therapy. Recent studies provide evidence for
tolerance induction to coagulation factor antigens by viral hepatic or neonatal in
vivo gene transfer, by in utero gene delivery, and by oral or nasal administration
of protein or peptides.
KEYWORDS
Immune response - inhibitor - T cell - B cell - cytotoxic T lymphocyte
REFERENCES
1 Gianelli F, Green P M. The molecular basis of hemophilia A and B. In: Lee CA Clinical
Haematology: Haemophilia. Vol. 9 London, UK; Bailliere Tindall 1996: 211-228
2
Fijnvandraat K, Bril W S, Voorberg J.
Immunobiology of inhibitor development in hemophilia A.
Semin Thromb Hemost.
2003;
29
61-68
3
Astermark J.
Treatment of the bleeding inhibitor patient.
Semin Thromb Hemost.
2003;
29
77-86
4
Mariani G, Siragusa S, Kroner B L.
Immune tolerance induction in hemophilia A: a review.
Semin Thromb Hemost.
2003;
29
69-76
5
Monnahan P E, White G C.
Hemophilia gene therapy.
Update Curr Opin Hematol.
2002;
9
430-436
6
Fields P A, Kowalczyk D W, Arruda V R et al..
Choice of vector determines T cell subsets involved in immune responses against the
secreted transgene product factor IX.
Mol Ther.
2000;
1
225-235
7
Brown B D, Lillicrap D.
Dangerous liaisons: the role of “danger” signals in the immune response to gene therapy.
Blood.
2002;
100
1133-1140
8
Jooss K, Yang Y, Fisher K J, Wilson J M.
Transduction of dendritic cells by DNA viral vectors directs the immune response to
transgene products in muscle fibers.
J Virol.
1998;
72
4212-4223
9
Yang Y, Xiang Z, Ertl H C, Wilson J M.
Upregulation of class I major histocompatibility complex antigens by interferon gamma
is necessary for T-cell-mediated elimination of recombinant adenovirus-infected hepatocytes
in vivo.
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA.
1995;
92
7257-7261
10
Weiner H L.
Induction and mechanism of action of transforming growth factor-beta-secreting Th3
regulatory cells.
Immunol Rev.
2001;
182
207-214
11
Roncarolo M G, Bacchetta R, Bordignon C, Narula S, Levings M K.
Type 1 T regulatory cells.
Immunol Rev.
2001;
182
68-79
12
Liu Y J.
Dendritic cell subsets and lineages, and their functions in innate and adaptive immunity.
Cell.
2001;
106
259-262
13
Mellman I, Steinman R M.
Dendritic cells: specialized and regulated antigen processing machines.
Cell.
2001;
106
255-258
14
Gallucci S, Lolkema M, Matzinger P.
Natural adjuvants: endogenous activators of dendritic cells.
Nat Med.
1999;
5
1249-1255
15
Schnell M A, Zhang Y, Tazelaar J et al..
Activation of innate immunity in nonhuman primates following intraportal administration
of adenoviral vectors.
Mol Ther.
2001;
3
708-722
16
Zhang Y, Chirmule N, Gao G P et al.
Acute cytokine response to systemic adenoviral vectors in mice is mediated by dendritic
cells and macrophages.
Mol Ther.
2001;
3
697-707
17
Liu Q, Zaiss A K, Colarusso P et al..
The role of capsid-endothelial interactions in the innate immune response to adenovirus
vectors.
Hum Gene Ther.
2003;
14
627-643
18
Muruve D A, Barnes M J, Stillman I E, Libermann T A.
Adenoviral gene therapy leads to rapid induction of multiple chemokines and acute
neutrophil-dependent hepatic injury in vivo.
.
Hum Gene Ther.
1999;
10
965-976
19
Tao N, Gao G P, Parr M et al..
Sequestration of adenoviral vector by Kupffer cells leads to a nonlinear dose response
of transduction in liver.
Mol Ther.
2001;
3
28-35
20
Fields P A, Armstrong E, Hagstrom J N et al..
Intravenous administration of an E1/E3-deleted adenoviral vector induces tolerance
to factor IX in C57BL/6 mice.
Gene Ther.
2001;
8
354-361
21
Brown B D, Shi C X, Rawle F E et al..
Factors influencing therapeutic efficacy and the host immune response to helper-dependent
adenoviral gene therapy in hemophilia A mice.
J Thromb Haemost.
2004;
2
111-118
22
Gallo-Penn A M, Shirley P S, Andrews J L et al..
Systemic delivery of an adenoviral vector encoding canine factor VIII results in short-term
phenotypic correction, inhibitor development, and biphasic liver toxicity in hemophilia
A dogs.
Blood.
2001;
97
107-113
23
VandenDriessche T, Schiedner G, Thorrez L et al..
Induction of long-term immune tolerance for neo-antigens following gene therapy with
high capacity adenoviral vectors by transient elimination of Kupffer cells.
Mol Ther.
2003;
7
S193 (abst)
24
Sarukhan A, Camugli S, Gjata B, von Boehmer H, Danos O, Jooss K.
Successful interference with cellular immune responses to immunogenic proteins encoded
by recombinant viral vectors.
J Virol.
2001;
75
269-277
25
VandenDriessche T, Thorrez L, Naldini L et al..
Lentiviral vectors containing the human immunodeficiency virus type-1 central polypurine
tract can efficiently transduce nondividing hepatocytes and antigen-presenting cells
in vivo.
Blood.
2002;
100
813-822
26
Pfeifer A, Kessler T, Yang M et al..
Transduction of liver cells by lentiviral vectors: analysis in living animals by fluorescence
imaging.
Mol Ther.
2001;
3
319-322
27
De Geest B R, Van Linthout S A, Collen D.
Humoral immune response in mice against a circulating antigen induced by adenoviral
transfer is strictly dependent on expression in antigen-presenting cells.
Blood.
2003;
101
2551-2556
28
Pastore L, Morral N, Zhou H et al..
Use of a liver-specific promoter reduces immune response to the transgene in adenoviral
vectors.
Hum Gene Ther.
1999;
10
1773-1781
29
Kafri T, Morgan D, Krahl T, Sarvetnick N, Sherman L, Verma I.
Cellular immune response to adenoviral vector infected cells does not require de novo
viral gene expression: implications for gene therapy.
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA.
1998;
95
11377-11382
30
Zaiss A K, Liu Q, Bowen G P, Wong N C, Bartlett J S, Muruve D A.
Differential activation of innate immune responses by adenovirus and adeno-associated
virus vectors.
J Virol.
2002;
76
4580-4590
31
Fisher K J, Jooss K, Alston J et al..
Recombinant adeno-associated virus for muscle directed gene therapy.
Nat Med.
1997;
3
306-312
32
Sarkar R, Xiao W, Kazazian H H.
A single adeno-associated virus (AAV)-murine factor VIII vector partially corrects
the hemophilia A phenotype.
J Thromb Haemost.
2003;
1
220-226
33
Sarkar R, Gao G P, Chirmule N, Tazelaar J, Kazazian Jr H H.
Partial correction of murine hemophilia A with neo-antigenic murine factor VIII.
Hum Gene Ther.
2000;
11
881-894
34
Scallan C D, Lillicrap D, Jiang H et al..
Sustained phenotypic correction of canine hemophilia A using an adeno-associated viral
vector.
Blood.
2003;
102
2031-2037
35
Balague C, Zhou J M, Dai Y F et al..
Sustained high-level expression of full-length human factor VIII and restoration of
clotting activity in hemophilic mice using a minimal adenovirus vector.
Blood.
2000;
95
820-828
36
Ehrhardt A, Mikkelsen J G, Meuse L, Pham T, Kay M A.
A new adenoviral helper-dependent vector results in long-term therapeutic levels of
human coagulation factor IX at low doses in vivo.
Nat Biotechnol.
2002;
20
999-1005
37
Chuah M KL, Scheidner G, Thorrez L et al..
Therapeutic factor VIII levels and negligible toxicity in mouse and dog models of
hemophilia A following gene therapy with high-capacity adenoviral vectors.
Blood.
2003;
101
1734-1743
38
Fields P A, Arruda V R, Armstrong E et al..
Risk and prevention of anti-factor IX formation in AAV-mediated gene transfer in the
context of a large deletion of F9.
Mol Ther.
2001;
4
201-210
39
Lin H F, Maeda N, Smithies O, Straight D L, Stafford D W.
A coagulation factor IX-deficient mouse model for human hemophilia B.
Blood.
1997;
90
3962-3966
40
Herzog R W, Mount J D, Arruda V R, High K A, Lothrop Jr C D, Fields P A.
Muscle-directed gene transfer and transient immune suppression result in sustained
partial correction of canine hemophilia B caused by a null mutation.
Mol Ther.
2001;
4
192-200
41
Mauser A E, Whitney K M, Lothrop Jr C D.
A deletion mutation causes hemophilia B in Lhasa apso dogs.
Blood.
1996;
88
3451-3455
42
Herzog R W, High K A.
AAV-mediated gene transfer of factor IX for treatment of hemophilia B by gene therapy.
Thromb Haemost.
1999;
82
540-546
43
Evans J P, Brinkhous K M, Brayer G D, Reisner H M, High K A.
Canine hemophilia B resulting from a point mutation with unusual consequences.
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA.
1989;
86
10095-10099
44
Manno C S, Chew A J, Hutchinson S et al..
A phase I safety study in patients with severe hemophilia B using adeno-associated
viral (AAV) vector to deliver the gene for human factor IX to skeletal muscle.
Blood.
2003;
101
2963-2972
45 High K A. Factor IX: molecular structure, epitopes, and mutations associated with
inhibitor formation. In: Aledort LM, Hoyer LW, Lusher JM, Reisner HM, White GC Advances
in Experimental Medicine and Biology. Vol. 386 New York; Plenum Press 1995: 79-86
46
Goodeve A C, Peake I R.
The molecular basis of hemophilia A: genotype-phenotype relationships and inhibitor
development.
Semin Thromb Hemost.
2003;
29
23-30
47
Ljung R, Petrini P, Tengborn L, Sjorin E.
Haemophilia B mutations in Sweden: a population-based study of mutational heterogeneity.
Br J Haematol.
2001;
113
81-86
48
Bi L, Lawler A M, Antonarakis S E, High K A, Gearhart J D, Kazazian H H.
Targeted disruption of the mouse factor VIII gene: a model for hemophilia A.
Nat Genet.
1995;
10
119-121
49
Lozier J N, Dutra A, Pak E et al..
The Chapel Hill hemophilia A dog colony exhibits a factor VIII gene inversion.
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA.
2002;
99
12991-12996
50
Hough C, Kamisue S, Cameron C et al..
Aberrant splicing and premature termination of transcription of the FVIII gene as
a cause of severe canine hemophilia A: similarities with the intron 22 inversion mutation
in human hemophilia.
Thromb Haemost.
2002;
87
659-665
51
Nathwani A C, Davidoff A, Hanawa H, Zhou J, Vanin E F, Nienhuis A W.
Factors influencing in vivo transduction by recombinant adeno-associated viral vectors
expressing the human factor IX cDNA.
Blood.
2001;
97
1258-1265
52
Mount J D, Herzog R W, Tillson D M et al..
Sustained phenotypic correction of hemophilia B dogs with a factor IX null mutation
by liver-directed gene therapy.
Blood.
2002;
99
2670-2676
53
Mingozzi F, Liu Y L, Dobrzynski E et al..
Induction of immune tolerance to coagulation factor IX antigen by in vivo hepatic
gene transfer.
J Clin Invest.
2003;
111
1347-1356
54
Snyder R O, Miao C, Meuse L et al..
Correction of hemophilia B in canine and murine models using recombinant adeno-associated
viral vectors.
Nat Med.
1999;
5
64-70
55
Lozier J N, Donahue R E, Donahue B A et al..
AAV-mediated expression of human factor IX in rhesus macaques.
Mol Ther.
2000;
1
S289 (abst)
56
Mizukami H, Mimuro J, Ogura T et al..
Muscle-mediated human factor IX expression in Cynomolgus monkey using AAV serotype-derived
vectors.
Mol Ther.
2003;
7
S81 (abst)
57
Nathwani A C, Davidoff A M, Hanawa H et al..
Sustained high-level expression of human factor IX (hFIX) after liver-targeted delivery
of recombinant adeno-associated virus encoding the hFIX gene in rhesus macaques.
Blood.
2002;
100
1662-1669
58
Kootstra N A, Matsumura R, Verma I M.
Efficient production of human FVIII in hemophilic mice using lentiviral vectors.
Mol Ther.
2003;
7
623-631
59
Herzog R W, Fields P A, Arruda V R et al..
Influence of vector dose on factor IX-specific T and B cell responses in muscle-directed
gene therapy.
Hum Gene Ther.
2002;
13
1281-1291
60
Arruda V R, Schuettrumpf J, Herzog R W et al..
Safety and efficacy of factor IX gene transfer to skeletal muscle in murine and canine
hemophilia B models by adeno-associated viral vector serotype 1.
Blood.
2004;
103
85-92
61
Chao H, Monahan P E, Liu Y, Samulski R J, Walsh C E.
Sustained and complete phenotype correction of hemophilia B mice following intramuscular
injection of AAV1 serotype vectors.
Mol Ther.
2001;
4
217-222
62
Qian J, Collins M, Sharpe A H, Hoyer L W.
Prevention and treatment of factor VIII inhibitors in murine hemophilia A.
Blood.
2000;
95
1324-1329
63
Rossi G, Sarkar J, Scandella D.
Long-term induction of immune tolerance after blockade of CD40-CD40L interaction in
a mouse model of hemophilia A.
Blood.
2001;
97
2750-2757
64
Mayumi H, Umesue M, Nomoto K.
Cyclophosphamide-induced immunological tolerance: an overview.
Immunobiology.
1996;
195
129-139
65
Arruda V R, Stedman H, Nichols T C et al..
Sustained correction of hemophilia B phenotype following intravascular delivery of
AAV vector to skeletal muscle.
Mol Ther.
2002;
5
S157
66
Zhang J, Wong F, Gao C, Xu L, Ponder K P.
CTLA4-Ig and cyclophosphamide can inhibit an antibody response to human factor X in
BALB/c mice after retroviaral vector-mediated gene therapy.
Mol Ther.
2002;
5
S82-S83
67
Walter J, You Q, Hagstrom J N, Sands M, High K A.
Successful expression of human factor IX following repeat administration of adenoviral
vector in mice.
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA.
1996;
93
3056-3061
68
Xu L, Gao C, Sands M S et al..
Neonatal or hepatocyte growth factor-potentiated adult gene therapy with a retroviral
vector results in therapeutic levels of canine factor IX for hemophilia B.
Blood.
2003;
101
3924-3932
69
Zhang J, Xu L, Haskins M E, Parker Ponder K.
Neonatal gene transfer with a retroviral vector results in tolerance to human factor
IX in mice and dogs.
Blood.
2004;
103
143-151
70
VandenDriessche T, Vanslembrouck V, Goovaerts I et al..
Long-term expression of human coagulation factor VIII and correction of hemophilia
A after in vivo retroviral gene transfer in factor VIII- deficient mice.
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA.
1999;
96
10379-10384
71
Ponder K P.
Should gene therapy be used for newborns with hemophilia?.
Mol Ther.
2003;
7
7-8
72
Anderson M S, Venanzi E S, Klein L et al..
Projection of an immunological self shadow within the thymus by the aire protein.
Science.
2002;
298
1395-1401
73
Waddington S N, Buckley S M, Nivsarkar M et al..
In utero gene transfer of human factor IX to fetal mice can induce postnatal tolerance
of the exogenous clotting factor.
Blood.
2003;
101
1359-1366
74
Bagley J, Tian C, Sachs D H, Iacomini J.
Induction of T-cell tolerance to an MHC class I alloantigen by gene therapy.
Blood.
2002;
99
4394-4399
75
Bagley J, Wu Y, Sachs D H, Iacomini J.
Defining the requirements for peptide recognition in gene therapy-induced T cell tolerance.
J Immunol.
2000;
165
4842-4847
76
Kang E-S, Iacomini J.
Induction of central deletional T cell tolerance by gene therapy.
J Immunol.
2002;
169
1930-1935
77
Tian C, Bagley J, Iacomini J.
Expression of antigen on mature lymphocytes is required to induce T cell tolerance
by gene therapy: induction of central deletional T cell tolerance by gene therapy.
J Immunol.
2002;
169
3771-3776
78
Heim D A, Hanazono Y, Giri N et al..
Introduction of a xenogeneic gene via hematopoietic stem cells leads to specific tolerance
in a rhesus monkey model.
Mol Ther.
2000;
1
533-544
79
Evans G L, Morgan R A.
Genetic induction of immune tolerance to human clotting factor VIII in a mouse model
for hemophilia A.
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA.
1998;
95
5734-5739
80
Fry J W, Morris P J, Wood K J.
Adenoviral transfer of a single donor-specific MHC class I gene to recipient bone
marrow cells can induce specific immunological unresponsiveness in vivo.
Gene Ther.
2002;
9
220-226
81
Wong W, Billing J S, Stranford S A et al..
Retroviral transfer of donor MHC class I or MHC class II genes into recipient bone
marrow cells can induce operational tolerance to alloantigens in vivo.
Hum Gene Ther.
2003;
14
577-590
82
Weiner H L.
Oral tolerance: immune mechanisms and treatment of autoimmune diseases.
Immunol Today.
1997;
18
335-343
83
Chen Y H, Weiner H L.
Dose-dependent activation and deletion of antigen-specific T cells following oral
tolerance.
Ann N Y Acad Sci.
1996;
778
111-121
84
Chen Y, Inobe J-I, Marks R, Gonnella P, Kuchroo V K, Weiner H L.
Peripheral deletion of antigen-reactive T cells in oral tolerance.
Nature.
1995;
376
177-180
85
Alpan O, Kamala T, Velander W et al..
Milky way: An inexpensive and easy method of inducing tolerance to human FIX.
Blood.
2001;
98
3430
, (abst)
86
Sabatino D E, Arruda V R, Liu Y-L et al..
Induction of oral tolerance to human factor IX in neonatal hemophilia B mice.
Mol Ther.
2002;
5
S89
, (abst)
87
Roy K, Mao H Q, Huang S K, Leong K W.
Oral gene delivery with chitosan-DNA nanoparticles generates immunologic protection
in a murine model of peanut allergy.
Nat Med.
1999;
5
387-391
88
Karachunski P I, Ostlie N S, Okita D K, Conti-Fine B M.
Prevention of experimental myasthenia gravis by nasal administration of synthetic
acetylcholine receptor T epitope sequences.
J Clin Invest.
1997;
100
3027-3035
89
Reding M T, Wu H, Krampf M et al..
CD4+ T cells specific for factor VIII as a target for specific suppression of inhibitor
production.
Adv Exp Med Biol.
2001;
489
119-134
90
Shi F D, Li H, Wang H et al..
Mechanisms of nasal tolerance induction in experimental autoimmune myasthenia gravis:
identification of regulatory cells.
J Immunol.
1999;
162
5757-5763
91
Monfardini C, Milani M, Ostlie N et al..
Adoptive protection from experimental myasthenia gravis with T cells from mice treated
nasally with acetylcholine receptor epitopes.
J Neuroimmunol.
2002;
123
123-134
92
Jacquemin M, Vantomme V, Buhot C et al..
CD4+ T-cell clones specific for wild-type factor VIII: a molecular mechanism responsible
for a higher incidence of inhibitor formation in mild/moderate hemophilia A.
Blood.
2003;
101
1351-1358
93
Reding M T, Wu H, Krampf M et al..
Sensitization of CD4+ T cells to coagulation factor VIII: response in congenital and
acquired hemophilia patients and in healthy subjects.
Thromb Haemost.
2000;
84
643-652
94
Reding M T, Okita D K, Diethelm-Okita B M, Anderson T A, Conti-Fine B M.
Human CD4+ T-cell epitope repertoire on the C2 domain of coagulation factor VIII.
J Thromb Haemost.
2003;
1
1777-1784
95
Pugliese A.
Peptide-based treatment for autoimmune diseases: learning how to handle a double-edged
sword.
J Clin Invest.
2003;
111
1280-1282
Roland W HerzogPh.D.
The Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, Abramson Research Center 302
34th St. and Civic Center Blvd.
Philadelphia, PA 19104
Email: rwherzog@mail.med.upenn.edu