Cost-Effectiveness of Currently Accepted Strategies for Pulmonary Embolism Diagnosis

ABSTRACT

Improvements in the methods of clinical trials combined with the use of objective tests to detect venous thrombosis have enhanced the clinician's ability to diagnose pulmonary embolism and venous thrombosis (venous thromboembolism).

The authors updated a previous cost-effectiveness analysis of the commonly recommended strategies for pulmonary embolism diagnosis and management to reflect current clinical practice. Two criteria of effectiveness were used: correct identification of venous thromboembolism and correct identification of venous thromboembolism and correct identification of patients for whom treatment was unnecessary. The cost of each diagnostic alternative was defined as the direct cost of administering the diagnostic tests plus the treatment costs associated with a positive test result. A strategy based on the combined use of ventilation-perfusion lung scanning, serial ultrasonography, cardiorespiratory evaluation, and pulmonary angiography was the most cost-effective. This strategy also necessitated pulmonary angiography in the fewest number of patients. The safety of this strategy relates to two important biologic concepts: 1) local extension of submassive pulmonary embolism in the lung is not an important cause of morbidity or mortality in patients with adequate cardiorespiratory reserve, and 2) in most patients, proximal vein thrombi of the lower extremities are the source of recurrent pulmonary embolism.

KEYWORD

Pulmonary embolism - diagnosis - cost-effectiveness - venous thromboembolism

REFERENCES

• 1 Weinstein M C. Economic assessment of medical practices and technologies.  Med Decis Making . 1981;  1 309-330
• 2 Weinstein M C, Stason W B. Foundations of cost-effectiveness analysis for health and medical practices.  N Engl J Med . 1977;  296 716-721
• 3 Drummond M F, Stoddart G L, Torrance G W. Methods for the Economic Evaluation of Health Care Programs.  Oxford, England: Oxford University Press; 1987
• 4 Eddy D M. Principles for making difficult decisions in difficult times.  JAMA . 1989;  271 1792-1798
• 5 Eisenberg J M. Clinical economics: A guide to economic analysis of clinical practices.  JAMA . 1989;  262 2879-2886
• 6 Detsky A S, Naglie I G. A clinical guide to cost-effectiveness analysis.  Ann Intern Med . 1990;  113 147-154
• 7 Moser K M. Venous thromboembolism.  Am Rev Respir Dis . 1990;  141 235-249
• 8 Kelley M A, Carson J L, Palevsky H I, Schwartz J S. Diagnosing pulmonary embolism: New facts and strategies.  Ann Intern Med . 1991;  114 300-306
• 9 Stein P D, Saltzman H A, Weg J G. Clinical characteristics of patients with acute pulmonary embolism.  Am J Cardiol . 1991;  68 1723-1724
• 10 Prospective Investigation of Pulmonary Embolism Diagnosis Investigators. Value of the ventilation-perfusion scan in acute pulmonary embolism: results of the Prospective Investigation of Pulmonary Embolism Diagnosis (PIOPED).  JAMA . 1990;  263 2753-2759
• 11 Hull R, Raskob G. Low probability lung scan findings: a need for change.  Ann Intern Med . 1991;  114 142-143
• 12 Hull R D, Hirsh J, Carter C J. Diagnostic value of ventilation-perfusion lung scanning in patients with suspected pulmonary embolism.  Chest . 1985;  88 819-828
• 13 Hull R D, Hirsh J, Carter C J. Pulmonary angiography, ventilation lung scanning and venography for clinically suspected pulmonary embolism with abnormal perfusion lung scan.  Ann Intern Med . 1983;  98 891-899
• 14 Gottschalk A. Lung scan interpretation: a physiologic, user-friendly approach.  J Nucl Med . 1992;  33 1422-1424
• 15 Secker-Walker R H. On purple emperors, pulmonary embolism and venous thromboembolism.  Ann Intern Med . 1983;  98 1006-1008
• 16 Cheely R, McCartney W H, Perry J R. The role of noninvasive tests versus pulmonary angiography in the diagnosis of pulmonary embolism.  Am J Med . 1981;  70 17-22
• 17 McNeil B J. Ventilation-perfusion studies and the diagnosis of pulmonary embolism: concise communication.  J Nucl Med . 1980;  21 319-323
• 18 Biello D R, Mattar A G, McKnight R C, Siegel B A. Ventilation-perfusion studies in suspected pulmonary embolism.  Am J Roentgenol . 1979;  133 1033-1037
• 19 Alderson P O, Rujanaveen N, Secker-Walker R H, McKnight R C. The role of 133Xe ventilation studies in the scintigraphic detection of pulmonary embolism.  Radiology . 1976;  120 633-640
• 20 Dalen J E, Brooks H L, Johnson L W. Pulmonary angiography in acute pulmonary embolism: indications, techniques, and results in 367 patients.  Am Heart J . 1971;  81 175-185
• 21 Stein P D, Athanasoulis C, Alavi A. Complications and validity of pulmonary angiography in acute pulmonary embolism.  Circulation . 1992;  85 462-468
• 22 Anderson F A, Wheeler H B, Goldberg R J. A population-based perspective of the hospital incidence and case fatality rate of deep vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism: the Worcester DVT Study.  Arch Intern Med . 1991;  151 933-938
• 23 Stein P D, Huang H-L, Afzal A, Noor H. Incidence of acute pulmonary embolism in a general hospital: Relation to age, sex, and race.  Chest . 1999;  116 909-913
• 24 Stein P D, Henry J W. Prevalence of acute pulmonary embolism among patients in a general hospital and at autopsy.  Chest . 1995;  108 978-981
• 25 Moser K M, Fedullo P F, Littlejohn J K. Frequent asymptomatic pulmonary embolism in patients with deep venous thrombosis.  JAMA . 1994;  223-225
• 26 Huisman M V, Büller H R, ten Cate W J. Unexpected high prevalence of silent pulmonary embolism in patients with deep venous thrombosis.  Chest . 1989;  95 498-502
• 27 Hull R D, Raskob G E, Brant R F. Low-molecular-weight heparin versus heparin in the treatment of patient with pulmonary embolism.  Arch Intern Med . 2000;  160 229-236
• 28 Bone R C. Ventilation-perfusion scan in pulmonary embolism: the emperor is incompletely attired. JAMA .  1990;  263 2794-2795
• 29 Dalen J. When can treatment be withheld in patients with suspected pulmonary embolism?.  Arch Intern Med . 1993;  153 1415-1418
• 30 Girard P, Musset D, Parent F. High prevalence of detectable deep venous thrombosis in patients with acute pulmonary embolism.  Chest . 1999;  116 903-908
• 31 Hull R, Raskob G, Ginsberg J. A noninvasive strategy for the treatment of patients with suspected pulmonary embolism?.  Arch Intern Med . 1994;  154 289-297
• 32 Stein P D, Hull R D, Pineo G. Strategy that includes serial noninvasive leg tests for diagnosis of thromboembolic disease in patients with suspected acute pulmonary embolism based on data from PIOPED.  Arch Intern Med . 1995;  155 2101-2104
• 33 Hull R D, Raskob G E, Pineo G F. Subcutaneous low-molecular-weight heparin compared with continuous intravenous heparin in the treatment of proximal-vein thrombosis.  N Engl J Med . 1992;  326 975-982
• 34 Hull R D, Feldstein W, Stein P D, Pineo G F. Cost-effectiveness of pulmonary embolism diagnosis.  Arch Intern Med . 1996;  156 68-72
• 35 Oupkerk M, Van Beek J R E, Van Putten L J W, Büller H R. Cost-effectiveness of various strategies in the diagnostic management of pulmonary embolism.  Ann Intern Med . 1993;  153 947-954
• 36 Heijboer H, Büller H R, Lensing A WA. A randomized comparison of the clinical utility of real-time compression ultrasonography versus impedance plethysmography in the diagnosis of deep-vein thrombosis in symptomatic outpatients.  N Engl J Med . 1993;  329 1365-1369
• 37 Huisman M V, Büller H R, ten Cate W J, Vreeken J. Serial impedance plethysmography for suspected deep venous thrombosis in outpatients: the Amsterdam General Practitioner Study.  N Engl J Med . 1986;  814 823-828
• 38 Kearon C, Hirsh J. Factors influencing the reported sensitivity and specificity of impedance plethysmography for proximal deep vein thrombosis.  Thromb Haemost . 1994;  72 652-658
• 39 Wells P S, Ginsberg J S, Anderson D R. Use of a clinical model for safe management of patients with suspected pulmonary embolism.  Ann Intern Med . 1998;  129 997-1005
• 40 Birdwell B G, Raskob G E, Whitsett T L. The clinical validity of normal compression ultrasonography in outpatients suspected of having deep venous thrombosis.  Ann Intern Med . 1998;  128 1-7
• 41 Cogo A, Lensing A W, Koopman M M. Compression ultrasonography for diagnostic management of patients with clinically suspected deep vein thrombosis: prospective cohort study.  BMJ . 1998;  316 17-20
• 42 Freyburger G, Trillaud H, Labrouche S. D-dimer strategy in thrombosis exclusion. A gold standard study in 100 patients suspected of deep vein thrombosis or pulmonary embolism: 8 DD methods compared.  Thromb Haemost . 1998;  79 32-37
• 43 Perrier A, Bounameaux H, Morabia A. Diagnosis of pulmonary embolism by a decision analysis-based strategy including clinical probability, D-dimer levels, and ultrasonography: a management study.  Arch Intern Med . 1996;  92 725-732
• 44 De Moerloose P, Desmarais S, Bounameaux H. Contribution of a new, rapid, individual, and quantitative automated D-dimer ELISA to exclude pulmonary embolism.  Thromb Haemost . 1996;  75 11-13
• 45 Ginsberg J S, Wells P S, Kearon C. Sensitivity and specificity of a rapid whole-blood assay for D-dimer in the diagnosis of pulmonary embolism.  Ann Intern Med . 1998;  129 1006-1011
• 46 Ginsberg J S, Wells P S, Brill-Edwards P. Application of a novel and rapid whole blood assay for D-dimer in patients with clinically suspected pulmonary embolism.  Thromb Haemost . 1995;  73 35-38
• 47 Becker D M, Philbrick J T, Bachhuber T L, Humphries J E. D-dimer testing and acute venous thromboembolism.  Arch Intern Med . 1996;  156 939-946
• 48 Kutinsky I, Blakley S, Roche V. Normal D-dimer levels in patients with acute pulmonary embolism.  Arch Intern Med . 1999;  159 1569-1572
• 49 Raimondi P, Bongard O, de Moerloose P. D-dimer plasma concentration in various clinical conditions: Implication for the use of this test in the diagnostic approach of venous thromboembolism.  Thromb Res . 1993;  69 125-130
• 50 Cadroy Y, Pierrejean D, Fontan B, Sie P, Boneu B. Influence of aging on the activity of the hemostatic system: prothrombin fragment 1+2, thrombin-antithrombin III complexes and D-dimers in 80 healthy subjects with age ranging from 20 to 94 years.  Nouv Rev Fr Hematol . 1992;  34 43-46
• 51 Goodman L R, Curtin J J, Mewissen M W. Detection of pulmonary embolism in patients with unresolved clinical and scintigraphic diagnosis: helical CT versus angiography.  Am J Roentgenol . 1995;  164 1369-1374
• 52 Teigen C L, Maus T P, Sheedy P F. Pulmonary embolism: Diagnosis with contrast enhanced electron-beam CT and comparison with pulmonary angiography.  Radiology . 1995;  194 313-319
• 53 Teigen C L, Maus T P, Sheedy II F P. Pulmonary embolism: diagnosis with electron-beam CT.  Radiology . 1993;  188 839-845
• 54 Van Rossum B A, Treurniet F EE, Kieft G H. Role of spiral volumetric computed tomographic scanning in the assessment of patients with clinical suspicion of pulmonary embolism and an abnormal ventilation/perfusion lung scan.  Thorax . 1996;  51 23-28
• 55 Drucker E A, Rivitz S M, Shephard J AO. Assessment of helical tomography in the diagnosis of acute pulmonary embolism.  Radiology . 1998;  209 235-241
• 56 Sostman H D, Layish D R, Tapson V F. Prospective comparison of helical CT and MR imaging in patients with clinically suspected pulmonary embolism.  J Magnetic Reson Imaging . 1996;  6 275-281