Survey of Hospital Chargemaster Transparency

Abstract

Background In January 2019, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) required hospitals to list their standard charges (chargemasters) publicly in an effort to increase price transparency in health care. Surveying hospital chargemasters may be informative to assess the implementation of this rule and its utility to consumers.

Objective We aimed to compare hospital chargemaster data within a local hospital market where patients would reasonably try to shop or compare services.

Methods We identified and aggregated Dallas County hospital chargemasters available in a database compatible format in May 2019. We manually examined a convenience sampling of 10 common laboratory tests, medications, and procedures.

Results Thirteen hospital chargemasters were identified. Eleven hospitals had chargemasters available in a database compatible format (xlsx or csv). These 11 chargemasters were aggregated into a single file containing 155,576 chargeable items, prices, and descriptions. We observed heterogeneous names and descriptions of synonymous items across institutions, preventing automated comparisons. The examined items revealed a high variation in charges. The largest charge variation for laboratory tests examined included a 2,606% difference (partial thromboplastin time: $18.70–506.00), for medications an 18,617% difference (5-mg tablet of amlodipine: $0.23–43.05), and for procedures a 2,889% difference (circumcision: $252.00–7,532.10). One institution accounted for 27% of the lowest prices and another accounted for 60% of the highest prices.

Conclusion Chargemaster data presentation varied among the hospitals surveyed, making automatic comparison impossible. Chargemaster data are difficult to interpret for health care decisions. Refining the minimum requirements for publishing chargemaster data could increase their utility.

Keywords

price transparency - chargemaster - health policy - Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services - U.S.

Protection of Human and Animal Subjects

This study did not include human or animal subjects.

Publikationsverlauf

Eingereicht: 19. November 2020

Angenommen: 26. März 2021

Artikel online veröffentlicht:
05. Mai 2021

• References

• 1 Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Medicare Program: Proposed Changes to Hospital Outpatient Prospective Payment and Ambulatory Surgical Center Payment Systems and Quality Reporting Programs; Price Transparency of Hospital Standard Charges; Proposed Revisions of Organ Procurement Organizations Conditions of Coverage; Proposed Prior Authorization Process and Requirements for Certain Covered Outpatient Department Services; Potential Changes to the Laboratory Date of Service Policy; Proposed Changes to Grandfathered Children's Hospitals-Within-Hospitals. Fed Regist 2019; 39398-39644
• 2 Tompkins CP, Altman SH, Eilat E. The precarious pricing system for hospital services. Health Aff (Millwood) 2006; 25 (01) 45-56
• 3 Adepoju O, Mask A, McLeod A. Factors associated with health insurance literacy: proficiency in finding, selecting, and making appropriate decisions. J Healthc Manag 2019; 64 (02) 79-89
• 4 Villagra VG, Bhuva B, Coman E, Smith DO, Fifield J. Health insurance literacy: disparities by race, ethnicity, and language preference. Am J Manag Care 2019; 25 (03) e71-e75
• 5 Braun RT, Barnes AJ, Hanoch Y, Federman AD. Health literacy and plan choice: implications for Medicare managed care. Health Lit Res Pract 2018; 2 (01) e40-e54
• 6 Bai G, Anderson GF. US hospitals are still using chargemaster markups to maximize revenues. Health Aff (Millwood) 2016; 35 (09) 1658-1664
• 7 Appleby J. Congress Acts To Spare Consumers From Costly Surprise Medical Bills. Accessed January 26, 2021 at: https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2020/12/22/949047358/congress-acts-to-spare-consumers-from-costly-surprise-medical-bills
• 8 Richman BD, Kitzman N, Milstein A, Schulman KA. Battling the chargemaster: a simple remedy to balance billing for unavoidable out-of-network care. Am J Manag Care 2017; 23 (04) e100-e105
• 9 Whaley CM. Provider responses to online price transparency. J Health Econ 2019; 66: 241-259
• 10 Bernstein JR, Bernstein J. Availability of consumer prices from Philadelphia area hospitals for common services: electrocardiograms vs parking. JAMA Intern Med 2014; 174 (02) 292-293
• 11 Saloner B, Cope LC, Hempstead K, Rhodes KV, Polsky D, Kenney GM. Price transparency in primary care: can patients learn about costs when scheduling an appointment?. J Gen Intern Med 2017; 32 (07) 815-821
• 12 Follow-Up Survey Finds Hospitals Still Fall Short on Price Transparency. Pioneer Institute. 2017 . Accessed January 26, 2021 at: https://pioneerinstitute.org/healthcare/follow-survey-finds-hospitals-still-fall-short-price-transparency/
• 13 Desai S, Hatfield LA, Hicks AL, Chernew ME, Mehrotra A. Association between availability of a price transparency tool and outpatient spending. JAMA 2016; 315 (17) 1874-1881
• 14 Desai S, Hatfield LA, Hicks AL. et al. Offering a price transparency tool did not reduce overall spending among California public employees and retirees. Health Aff (Millwood) 2017; 36 (08) 1401-1407
• 15 Survey: Price Information Difficult to Obtain From Massachusetts Hospitals. Pioneer Institute. 2016 . Accessed January 26, 2021 at: https://pioneerinstitute.org/healthcare/survey-price-information-difficult-to-obtain-from-massachusetts-hospitals/
• 16 Mehrotra A, Brannen T, Sinaiko AD. Use patterns of a state health care price transparency web site: what do patients shop for?. Inquiry 2014; 51: 51
• 17 Williams J. Massachusetts' “Price Transparency” Resolution to Surprise Facility Fees, Consumer Protection Laws Yield to Health Care Complexity. Health Affairs. 2019 . Accessed October 1, 2019 at: https://www.healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/hblog20190108.78905/full/
• 18 White CGP, Tu HT, Reschovsky JD, Smith JM, Liao K. Healthcare Price Transparency: Policy Approaches and Estimated Impacts on Spending. West Health Policy Center. 2014 . Accessed January 26, 2021 at: https://www.westhealth.org/resource/healthcare-price-transparency-policy-approaches-estimated-impacts-spending/
• 19 Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), HH. Medicare Program; Hospital Inpatient Prospective Payment Systems for Acute Care Hospitals and the Long-Term Care Hospital Prospective Payment System and Policy Changes and Fiscal Year 2019 Rates; Quality Reporting Requirements for Specific Providers; Medicare and Medicaid Electronic Health Record (EHR) Incentive Programs (Promoting Interoperability Programs) Requirements for Eligible Hospitals, Critical Access Hospitals, and Eligible Professionals; Medicare Cost Reporting Requirements; and Physician Certification and Recertification of Claims. Fed Regist 2018; 83 (160) 41144-41784
• 20 Gass Kandilov AM, Pope GC, Kautter J, Healy D. The national market for Medicare clinical laboratory testing: implications for payment reform. Medicare Medicaid Res Rev 2012; 2 (02) mmrr.002.02.a04
• 21 The 50 Most Commonly Prescribed Drugs in America and Their Average Price. Accessed January 25, 2021 at: https://www.drugreport.com/50-commonly-prescribed-drugs-in-america/
• 22 Pfuntner A, Wier LM, Stocks C. Most Frequent Procedures Performed in U.S. Hospitals. 2011 . Accessed January 25, 2021 at: https://www.hcup-us.ahrq.gov/reports/statbriefs/sb165.jsp
• 23 Clinical Laboratory Fee Schedule Files. 2020 Accessed January 26, 2021 at: https://www.cms.gov/Medicare/Medicare-Fee-for-Service-Payment/ClinicalLabFeeSched/Clinical-Laboratory-Fee-Schedule-Files
• 24 Febbo J, Little B, Fischl-Lanzoni N. et al. Analysis of out-of-pocket cost of lung cancer screening for uninsured patients among ACR-accredited imaging centers. J Am Coll Radiol 2020; 17 (09) 1108-1115
• 25 Glover IV M, Whorms D, Singh R. et al. A Radiology-focused analysis of transparency and usability of top U.S. hospitals' chargemasters. Acad Radiol 2020; 27 (11) 1603-1607
• 26 Ward C, Reeder T. The evolution and impact of Hospital Price Transparency in North Carolina. N C Med J 2020; 81 (02) 95-99
• 27 Medicare and Medicaid Programs, CY 2020 Hospital Outpatient PPS Policy Changes and Payment Rates and Ambulatory Surgical Center Payment System Policy Changes and Payment Rates. Price Transparency Requirements for Hospitals To Make Standard Charges Public. In: Federal Register; 2019: 65524-65606
• 28 U.S. Department of Health & Human Services. Trump Administration Announces Historic Price Transparency Requirements to Increase Competition and Lower Healthcare Costs for All Americans. 2019 . Accessed January 26, 2021 at: https://www.hhs.gov/about/news/2019/11/15/trump-administration-announces-historic-price-transparency-and-lower-healthcare-costs-for-all-americans.html
• 29 Diamond PA. A model of price adjustment. J Econ Theory 1971; 3 (02) 156-168
• 30 The Economist. Costly Comparison: Price-Comparison Websites Should Help Lower Prices. But Left Unchecked, They May Raise Them. 2015 https://www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2015/07/09/costly-comparison . Accessed January 26, 2021
• 31 Stetson C, Cook SM. AHA Hospital Group Brief in Support of Their Motion for Summary Judgment Disclosure of Negotiated Charges. Accessed January 26, 2021 at: https://www.aha.org/system/files/media/file/2019/12/aha-hospital-group-brief-in-support-of-their-motion-for-summary-judgment-disclosure-of-negotiated-charges-12-9-19.pdf
• 32 Morse S. American Hospital Association to appeal ruling on Price Transparency Lawsuit: A Federal Judge Today Sided with the Department of Health and Human Services and Rejected Providers' Claims. Healthcare Finance. 2020 https://www.healthcarefinancenews.com/news/american-hospital-association-appeal-ruling-price-transparency-lawsuit . Accessed January 26, 2021