CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 · Yearb Med Inform 2021; 30(01): 200-209
DOI: 10.1055/s-0041-1726486
Section 7: Consumer Health Informatics and Education
Working Group Contribution

Role of Participatory Health Informatics in Detecting and Managing Pandemics: Literature Review

Elia Gabarron*
1   Norwegian Centre for E-health Research, University Hospital of North Norway, Troms⊘, Norway
,
Octavio Rivera-Romero*
2   Department of Electronic Technology, Universidad de Sevilla, Spain
,
Talya Miron-Shatz
3   Faculty of Business Administration, Ono Academic College, Israel
4   Winton Centre for Risk and Evidence Communication, Cambridge University, England
,
Rebecca Grainger
5   Department of Medicine, University of Otago, Wellington, New Zealand
,
Kerstin Denecke
6   Institute for Medical Informatics, Bern University of Applied Sciences, Bern, Switzerland
› Author Affiliations

Summary

Objectives: Using participatory health informatics (PHI) to detect disease outbreaks or learn about pandemics has gained interest in recent years. However, the role of PHI in understanding and managing pandemics, citizens’ role in this context, and which methods are relevant for collecting and processing data are still unclear, as is which types of data are relevant. This paper aims to clarify these issues and explore the role of PHI in managing and detecting pandemics.

Methods: Through a literature review we identified studies that explore the role of PHI in detecting and managing pandemics. Studies from five databases were screened: PubMed, CINAHL (Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature), IEEE Xplore, ACM (Association for Computing Machinery) Digital Library, and Cochrane Library. Data from studies fulfilling the eligibility criteria were extracted and synthesized narratively.

Results: Out of 417 citations retrieved, 53 studies were included in this review. Most research focused on influenza-like illnesses or COVID-19 with at least three papers on other epidemics (Ebola, Zika or measles). The geographic scope ranged from global to concentrating on specific countries. Multiple processing and analysis methods were reported, although often missing relevant information. The majority of outcomes are reported for two application areas: crisis communication and detection of disease outbreaks.

Conclusions: For most diseases, the small number of studies prevented reaching firm conclusions about the utility of PHI in detecting and monitoring these disease outbreaks. For others, e.g., COVID-19, social media and online search patterns corresponded to disease patterns, and detected disease outbreak earlier than conventional public health methods, thereby suggesting that PHI can contribute to disease and pandemic monitoring.

* Contributed equally and share first authorship


Supplementary Material



Publication History

Article published online:
21 April 2021

© 2021. IMIA and Thieme. This is an open access article published by Thieme under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonDerivative-NonCommercial License, permitting copying and reproduction so long as the original work is given appropriate credit. Contents may not be used for commercial purposes, or adapted, remixed, transformed or built upon. (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/)

Georg Thieme Verlag KG
Rüdigerstraße 14, 70469 Stuttgart, Germany

 
  • References

  • 1 Kaiser R, Coulombier D, Baldari M, Morgan D, Paquet C. What is epidemic intelligence, and how is it being improved in Europe?. Euro Surveill 2006; 11 (02) E060202.4
  • 2 Freifeld CC, Mandl KD, Reis BY, Brownstein JS. HealthMap: global infectious disease monitoring through automated classification and visualization of Internet media reports. J Am Med Inform Assoc 2008; 15 (02) 150-7
  • 3 Rortais A, Belyaeva J, Gemo M, Van derGoot E, Linge JP. MedISys: An early-warning system for the detection of (re-) emerging food-and feed-borne hazards. Food Research International 2010; 43 (05) 1553-6
  • 4 Samaras L, García-Barriocanal E, Sicilia MA. Syndromic surveillance using web data: a systematic review. Innovation in Health Informatics 2020; 39-77
  • 5 Castillo-Sánchez G, Marques G, Dorronzoro E, Rivera-Romero O, Franco-Martín M, De la Torre-Díez I. Suicide Risk Assessment Using Machine Learning and Social Networks: a Scoping Review. J Med Syst 2020; 44 (12) 205
  • 6 Syed-Abdul S, Gabarron E, Lau AY, Househ M. Chapter 1 - An introduction to participatory health through social media. In: Participatory Health Through Social Media. Academic Press; 2016 Jan 1. p. 1-9
  • 7 Chen Q, Min C, Zhang W, Wang G, Ma X, Evans R. Unpacking the black box: How to promote citizen engagement through government social media during the COVID-19 crisis. Comput Human Behav 2020; 110: 106380
  • 8 Lohiniva AL, Sane J, Sibenberg K, Puumalainen T, Salminen M. Understanding coronavirus disease (COVID-19) risk perceptions among the public to enhance risk communication efforts: a practical approach for outbreaks, Finland, February 2020. Euro Surveill 2020; 25 (13) 2000317
  • 9 World Health Organization. Coronavirus (COVID-19) events as they happen. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2020: 1 –0. Available from: https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2019/interactive-timeline/
  • 10 Liberati A, Altman DG, Tetzlaff J, Mulrow C, G⊘tzsche PC, Ioannidis JP. et al. The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: explanation and elaboration. J Clin Epidemiol 2009; 62 (10) e1-34
  • 11 Shin SY, Seo DW, An J, Kwak H, Kim SH, Gwack J. et al. High correlation of Middle East respiratory syndrome spread with Google search and Twitter trends in Korea. Sci Rep 2016; 6: 32920
  • 12 Comito C, Forestiero A, Pizzuti C. Improving influenza forecasting with web-based social data. In: 2018 IEEE/ACM International Conference on Advances in Social Networks Analysis and Mining (ASONAM) 2018 Aug 28; IEEE; 2018. p. 963-70
  • 13 Moberley S, Carlson S, Durrheim D, Dalton C. Flutracking: Weekly online community-based surveillance of influenza-like illness in Australia. 2017 Annual Report. Commun Dis Intell 2019;43
  • 14 Wang S, Ding S, Xiong L. A New System for Surveillance and Digital Contact Tracing for COVID-19: Spatiotemporal Reporting Over Network and GPS. JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2020; 8 (06) e19457
  • 15 Wakamiya S, Kawai Y, Aramaki E. After the boom no one tweets: microblog-based influenza detection incorporating indirect information. In: Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference on Emerging Databases: Technologies, Applications, and Theory 2016 Oct 17. p. 17-25
  • 16 Allen C, Tsou MH, Aslam A, Nagel A, Gawron JM. Applying GIS and Machine Learning Methods to Twitter Data for Multiscale Surveillance of Influenza. PLoS One 2016; 11 (07) e0157734
  • 17 Chen Y, Zhang Y, Xu Z, Wang X, Lu J, Hu W. Avian Influenza A (H7N9) and related Internet search query data in China. Sci Rep 2019; 9 (01) 10434
  • 18 Liu K, Li L, Jiang T, Chen B, Jiang Z, Wang Z. et al. Chinese Public Attention to the Outbreak of Ebola in West Africa: Evidence from the Online Big Data Platform. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2016; 13 (08) 780
  • 19 Zhao Y, Cheng S, Yu X, Xu H. Chinese Public‘s Attention to the COVID-19 Epidemic on Social Media: Observational Descriptive Study. J Med Internet Res 2020; 22 (05) e18825
  • 20 Samaras L, García-Barriocanal E, Sicilia MA. Comparing Social media and Google to detect and predict severe epidemics. Sci Rep 2020; 10 (01) 4747
  • 21 Daughton AR, Chunara R, Paul MJ. Comparison of Social Media, Syndromic Surveillance, and Microbiologic Acute Respiratory Infection Data: Observational Study. JMIR Public Health Surveill 2020; 6 (02) e14986
  • 22 Li J, Xu Q, Cuomo R, Purushothaman V, Mackey T. Data Mining and Content Analysis of the Chinese Social Media Platform Weibo During the Early COVID-19 Outbreak: Retrospective Observational Infoveillance Study. JMIR Public Health Surveill 2020; 6 (02) e18700
  • 23 Yom-Tov E, Borsa D, Cox IJ, McKendry RA. Detecting disease outbreaks in mass gatherings using Internet data. J Med Internet Res 2014; 16 (06) e154
  • 24 Huang J, Zhao H, Zhang J. Detecting flu transmission by social sensor in China. In: 2013 IEEE International Conference on Green Computing and Communications and IEEE Internet of Things and IEEE Cyber, Physical and Social Computing 2013 Aug 20. IEEE; 2013. p. 1242-7
  • 25 Lee B, Yoon J, Kim S, Hwang BY. Detecting social signals of flu symptoms. In: 8th International Conference on Collaborative Computing: Networking, Applications and Worksharing (CollaborateCom) 2012 Oct 14. IEEE; 2012. p. 544-5
  • 26 Yom-Tov E. Ebola data from the Internet: An opportunity for syndromic surveillance or a news event?. In: Proceedings of the 5th international conference on digital health 2015; May 18. p. 115-9
  • 27 Kagashe I, Yan Z, Suheryani I. Enhancing Seasonal Influenza Surveillance: Topic Analysis of Widely Used Medicinal Drugs Using Twitter Data. J Med Internet Res 2017; 19: e315
  • 28 Sharpe JD, Hopkins RS, Cook RL, Striley CW. Evaluating Google, Twitter, and Wikipedia as Tools for Influenza Surveillance Using Bayesian Change Point Analysis: A Comparative Analysis. JMIR Public Health Surveill 2016; 2 (02) e161
  • 29 Khatua A, Khatua A. Immediate and long-term effects of 2016 Zika Outbreak: A Twitter-based study. In: 2016 IEEE 18th International Conference on e-Health Networking, Applications and Services (Healthcom) 2016 Sep 14. IEEE; 2016. p. 1-6
  • 30 Al-Mohrej A, Agha S. Are Saudi medical students aware of middle east respiratory syndrome coronavirus during an outbreak?. J Infect Public Health 2017; 10 (04) 388-95
  • 31 Gu H, Chen B, Zhu H, Jiang T, Wang X, Chen L. et al. Importance of Internet surveillance in public health emergency control and prevention: evidence from a digital epidemiologic study during avian influenza A H7N9 outbreaks. J Med Internet Res 2014; 16 (01) e20
  • 32 Barata G, Shores K, Alperin JP. Local chatter or international buzz? Language differences on posts about Zika research on Twitter and Facebook. PLoS One 2018; 13 (01) e0190482
  • 33 Mackey T, Purushothaman V, Li J, Shah N, Nali M, Bardier C. et al. Machine Learning to Detect Self-Reporting of Symptoms, Testing Access, and Recovery Associated With COVID-19 on Twitter: Retrospective Big Data Infoveillance Study. JMIR Public Health Surveill 2020; 6 (02) e19509
  • 34 Byrd K, Mansurov A, Baysal O. Mining Twitter Data for Influenza Detection and Surveillance. In: 2016 IEEE/ACM International Workshop on Software Engineering in Healthcare Systems (SEHS) May 14. IEEE; 2016. p. 43-9
  • 35 Broniatowski DA, Paul MJ, Dredze M. National and local influenza surveillance through Twitter: an analysis of the 2012-2013 influenza epidemic. PLoS One 2013; 8 (12) e83672
  • 36 Collier N, Son NT, Nguyen NM. OMG U got flu? Analysis of shared health messages for bio-surveillance. J Biomed Semantics 2011; 2 (Suppl 5): S9
  • 37 Chew C, Eysenbach G. Pandemics in the age of Twitter: content analysis of Tweets during the 2009 H1N1 outbreak. PLoS One 2010; 5 (11) e14118
  • 38 Zhang K, Arablouei R, Jurdak R. Predicting prevalence of influenza-like illness from geo-tagged tweets. In: Proceedings of the 26th International Conference on World Wide Web Companion 2017 Apr 3; p. 1327-34
  • 39 Garazzino S, Montagnani C, Donà D, Meini A, Felici E, Vergine G. et al. Italian SITIP-SIP SARS-CoV-2 paediatric infection study group. Multicentre Italian study of SARS-CoV-2 infection in children and adolescents, preliminary data as at 10 April 2020. Euro Surveill 2020; 25 (18) 2000600
  • 40 He Z, Zhang CJ, Huang J, Zhai J, Zhou S, Chiu JW. , Sheng, et al. A New Era of Epidemiology: Digital Epidemiology for Investigating the COVID-19 Outbreak in China. J Med Internet Res 2020; 22 (09) e21685
  • 41 Yousefinaghani S, Dara R, Poljak Z, Bernardo TM, Sharif S. The Assessment of Twitter‘s Potential for Outbreak Detection: Avian Influenza Case Study. Sci Rep 2019; 9 (01) 18147
  • 42 Nagel AC, Tsou MH, Spitzberg BH, An L, Gawron JM, Gupta DK. et al. The complex relationship of realspace events and messages in cyberspace: case study of influenza and pertussis using tweets. J Med Internet Res 2013; 15 (10) e237
  • 43 Aslam AA, Tsou MH, Spitzberg BH, An L, Gawron JM, Gupta DK. et al. The reliability of tweets as a supplementary method of seasonal influenza surveillance. J Med Internet Res 2014; 16 (11) e250
  • 44 Abd-Alrazaq A, Alhuwail D, Househ M, Hamdi M, Shah Z. Top Concerns of Tweeters During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Infoveillance Study. J Med Internet Res 2020; 22 (04) e19016
  • 45 Culotta A. Towards detecting influenza epidemics by analyzing Twitter messages. In Proceedings of the 1st Workshop on Social Media Analytics (SOMA’10), 2010 Jul 25. p. 115-22
  • 46 Ofoghi B, Mann M, Verspoor K. Ealry discovery of salient health threats: a social media emotion classification technique. Pac Symp Biocomput 2016; 21: 504-15
  • 47 Mowery J. Twitter Influenza Surveillance: Quantifying Seasonal Misdiagnosis Patterns and their Impact on Surveillance Estimates. Online J Public Health Inform 2016; 8 (03) e198
  • 48 Wakamiya S, Kawai Y, Aramaki E. Twitter-Based Influenza Detection After Flu Peak via Tweets With Indirect Information: Text Mining Study. JMIR Public Health Surveill 2018; 4 (03) e65
  • 49 Comito C, Forestiero A, Pizzuti C. Twitter-based Influenza Surveillance: An Analysis of the 2016-2017 and 2017-2018 Seasons in Italy. In: Proceedings of the 22nd International Database Engineering & Applications Symposium 2018 Jun 18. p. 175-82
  • 50 Kanhabua N, Nejdl W. Understanding the diversity of tweets in the time of outbreaks. In: Proceedings of the 22nd International Conference on World Wide Web 2013 May 13; p. 1335-42
  • 51 Gui X, Wang Y, Kou Y, Reynolds TL, Chen Y, Mei Q. et al. Understanding the Patterns of Health Information Dissemination on Social Media during the Zika Outbreak. AMIA Annu Symp Proc 2018; 2017: 820-9
  • 52 Shen C, Chen A, Luo C, Zhang J, Feng B, Liao W. Using Reports of Symptoms and Diagnoses on Social Media to Predict COVID-19 Case Counts in Mainland China: Observational Infoveillance Study. J Med Internet Res 2020; 22 (05) e19421
  • 53 Han X, Wang J, Zhang M, Wang X. Using Social Media to Mine and Analyze Public Opinion Related to COVID-19 in China. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2020; 17 (08) 2788
  • 54 Broniatowski DA, Dredze M, Paul MJ, Dugas A. Using Social Media to Perform Local Influenza Surveillance in an Inner-City Hospital: A Retrospective Observational Study. JMIR Public Health Surveill 2015; 1 (01) e5
  • 55 Corley CD, Cook DJ, Mikler AR, Singh KP. Adv Exp Med Biol 2010; 680: 559-64
  • 56 Odlum M, Yoon S. What can we learn about the Ebola outbreak from tweets?. Am J Infect Control 2015; 43 (06) 563-71
  • 57 Li HO, Bailey A, Huynh D, Chan J. YouTube as a source of information on COVID-19: a pandemic of misinformation?. BMJ Glob Health 2020; 5 (05) e002604
  • 58 Mollema L, Harmsen IA, Broekhuizen E, Clijnk R, DeMelker H, Paulussen T. et al. Disease detection or public opinion reflection? Content analysis of tweets, other social media, and online newspapers during the measles outbreak in The Netherlands in 2013. J Med Internet Res 2015; 17 (05) e128
  • 59 Corley CD, Cook DJ, Mikler AR, Singh KP. Text and structural data mining of influenza mentions in web and social media. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2010; 7 (02) 596-615
  • 60 Bragazzi NL, Mahroum N. Google Trends Predicts Present and Future Plague Cases During the Plague Outbreak in Madagascar: Infodemiological Study. JMIR Public Health Surveill 2019; 5 (01) e13142
  • 61 Deiner MS, McLeod SD, Wong J, Chodosh J, Lietman TM, Porco TC. Google Searches and Detection of Conjunctivitis Epidemics Worldwide. Ophthalmology 2019; 126 (09) 1219-1229
  • 62 Al-Garadi MA, Khan MS, Varathan KD, Mujtaba G, Al-Kabsi AM. Using online social networks to track a pandemic: A systematic review. J Biomed Inform 2016; 62: 1-11
  • 63 Bernardo TM, Rajic A, Young I, Robiadek K, Pham MT, Funk JA. Scoping review on search queries and social media for disease surveillance: a chronology of innovation. J Med Internet Res 2013; 15 (07) e147
  • 64 Kazemi DM, Borsari B, Levine MJ, Dooley B. Systematic review of surveillance by social media platforms for illicit drug use. J Public Health (Oxf) 2017; 39 (04) 763-76
  • 65 Sousa-Pinto B, Anto A, Czarlewski W, Anto JM, Fonseca JA, Bousquet J. Assessment of the Impact of Media Coverage on COVID-19–Related Google Trends Data: Infodemiology Study. J Med Internet Res 2020; 22 (08) e19611
  • 66 Low DM, Rumker L, Talkar T, Torous J, Cecchi G, Ghosh SS. Natural Language Processing Reveals Vulnerable Mental Health Support Groups and Heightened Health Anxiety on Reddit During COVID-19: Observational Study. J Med Internet Res 2020; 22 (10) e22635
  • 67 Campos-Castillo C, Laestadius LI. Racial and Ethnic Digital Divides in Posting COVID-19 Content on Social Media Among US Adults: Secondary Survey Analysis. J Med Internet Res 2020; 22 (07) e20472
  • 68 Caldwell WK, Fairchild G, DelValle SY. Surveilling Influenza Incidence With Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Web Traffic Data: Demonstration Using a Novel Dataset. J Med Internet Res 2020; 22 (07) e14337
  • 69 Hung M, Lauren E, Hon ES, Birmingham WC, Xu J, Su S. et al. Social Network Analysis of COVID-19 Sentiments: Application of Artificial Intelligence. J Med Internet Res 2020; 22 (08) e22590
  • 70 Wilson SL, Wiysonge C. Social media and vaccine hesitancy. BMJ Global Health 2020; 5 (10) e004206
  • 71 Rivera-Romero O, Konstantinidis S, Denecke K, Gabarrón E, Petersen C, Househ M. et al. Ethical Considerations for Participatory Health through Social Media: Healthcare Workforce and Policy Maker Perspectives: Contribution of the IMIA Participatory Health and Social Media Working Group. Yearb Med Inform 2020; 29 (01) 71-6
  • 72 Golinelli D, Boetto E, Carullo G, Nuzzolese AG, Landini MP, Fantini MP. Adoption of Digital Technologies in Health Care During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Systematic Review of Early Scientific Literature. J Med Internet Res 2020; 22 (11) e22280
  • 73 Almeida BD, Doneda D, Ichihara MY, Barral-Netto M, Matta GC, Rabello ET. et al. Personal data usage and privacy considerations in the COVID-19 global pandemic. Ciência & Saúde Coletiva 2020; 25: 2487-92
  • 74 Castillo-Sánchez G, Marques G, Dorronzoro E, Rivera-Romero O, Franco-Martín M, De la Torre-Díez I. Suicide Risk Assessment Using Machine Learning and Social Networks: a Scoping Review. J Med Syst 2020; 44 (12) 205
  • 75 Al-Garadi MA, Khan MS, Dewi K, Varathan GM, Al-Kabsi AM. Using online social networks to track a pandemic: A systematic review. J Biomed Inform 2016; 62: 1-11
  • 76 Salathé M, Bengtsson L, Bodnar TJ, Brewer DD, Brownstein JS, Buckee C. et al. Digital epidemiology. PLoS Comput Biol 2012; 8 (07) e1002616
  • 77 Denecke K, Gabarron E, Grainger R, Konstantinidis ST, Lau A, Rivera-Romero O. et al. Artificial Intelligence for Participatory Health: Applications, Impact, and Future Implications. Yearb Med Inform 2019; 28 (01) 165-73