Homeopathic Potencies May Possess an Electric Field(-like) Component: Evidence from the Use of Encapsulated Solvatochromic Dyes
01 May 2019
30 May 2019
27 August 2019 (online)
Background Homeopathic potencies have been shown to interact with a range of solvatochromic dyes to produce spectroscopic changes in the visible region of the electromagnetic spectrum. Furthermore, the nature of the changes observed under different experimental conditions is beginning to limit the number of possible hypotheses that can be put forward regarding the fundamental identity of potencies.
Aims and Methods The present study uses β-cyclodextrins to encapsulate solvatochromic dyes of widely varying structures. The purpose of this approach is to de-couple the primary dye–potency interaction from any subsequent aggregation effects.
Results Despite large differences in molecular structure between dyes, results show that potencies affect all dyes according to the same fundamental principles. Specifically, positively and negatively solvatochromic dyes collectively respond in opposite and complementary ways to potencies in accordance with the differential stabilisation of their excited and ground electronic states. Under the conditions of encapsulation, positively solvatochromic dyes display a bathochromic shift of, on average, 0.4 nm with a 2% absorbance change, and negatively solvatochromic dyes display a hypsochromic shift of, on average, 0.2 nm with a 1% absorbance change. This behaviour is only ever seen in two situations—where solvent becomes more polar or where an electric field is applied to solutions of dyes.
Conclusions The conditions used in this and previous studies to investigate the interaction of potencies with solvatochromic dyes preclude increased polarity of solvent as being responsible for the observed effects and that an explanation in which potencies carry an electric field (or electric field-like) component is by far the more likely. From the magnitude of the spectral changes induced in the dye Brooker's merocyanine by Arsenicum 10M, an estimate of the strength of the postulated electric field of 1.16 × 107 V/m can be made, which is comparable with the potential difference across cell membranes.
• Encapsulation of solvatochromic dyes by β-cyclodextrins allows the de-coupling of initial dye–potency interactions from any subsequent processes.
• Examination of this primary interaction shows that positively and negatively solvatochromic dyes collectively respond in opposite and complementary ways to Arsenicum 10M in accordance with the differential stabilisation of their excited and ground electronic states.
• This response can only be explained by concluding that Arsenicum 10M possesses an electric field(-like) component.
• Using solvatochromic and electrochromic data for Brooker's merocyanine, it is possible to assign a value of 1.16 × 107 V/m to the strength of the postulated electric field of Arsenicum 10M.
• Electric fields require separated charges and consequently a prediction can be made that potencies should emit photons under conditions that favour charge recombination.
- 1 Cartwright SJ. Solvatochromic dyes detect the presence of homeopathic potencies. Homeopathy 2016; 105: 55-65
- 2 Cartwright SJ. Interaction of homeopathic potencies with the water soluble solvatochromic dye bis-dimethylaminofuchsone. Part 1: pH studies. Homeopathy 2017; 106: 37-46
- 3 Cartwright SJ. Degree of response to homeopathic potencies correlates with dipole moment size in molecular detectors: implications for understanding the fundamental nature of serially diluted and succussed solutions. Homeopathy 2018; 107: 19-31
- 4 Mota HMG, Aparicio AC, Oliveira LH. , et al. Cartwright's method as a physico-chemical marker of Antimonium crudum biological effect. Int J High Dilution Res 2018; 17: 14
- 5 Martin Del Ville EM. Cyclodextrins and their uses: a review. Process Biochem 2004; 39: 1033-1046
- 6 Arunkumar E, Forbes CC, Smith BD. Improving the properties of organic dyes by molecular encapsulation. Eur J Org Chem 2005; 4051-4059
- 7 Misra R, Bhattacharyya SP. Intramolecular Charge Transfer: Theory and Applications. Weinheim: Wiley-VCH; 2018
- 8 Davis F, Higson S. Cyclodextrins. In: Macrocycles: Construction, Chemistry and Nanotechnology Applications. Chichester: Wiley; 2011: 190-244
- 9 Holt JS, Campitella A, Rich A, Young JL. Spectroscopic characterization of the binding and isomerization cycle of Brooker's merocyanine with α-, β-, and γ-cyclodextrins. J Incl Phenom 2008; 61: 251-258
- 10 Hirai H, Toshima N, Uenoyama S. Inclusion complex formation of γ-cyclodextrin. One host-two guest complexation with water-soluble dyes in ground state. Bull Chem Soc Jpn 1985; 58: 1156-1164
- 11 Shaikh M, Mohanty J, Sundararajan M, Bhasikuttan AC, Pal H. Supramolecular host-guest interactions of oxazine-1 dye with β- and γ-cyclodextrins: a photophysical and quantum chemical study. J Phys Chem B 2012; 116: 12450-12459
- 12 Jara F, Mascayano C, Rezende MC, Tirapegui C, Urzua A. A spectral and molecular dynamics simulation study of β-cyclodextrin inclusion complexes with solvatochromic dyes derived from barbituric acid. J Incl Phenom Macroc Chem 2006; 54: 95-99
- 13 Zia V, Rajewski RA, Stella VJ. Thermodynamics of binding of neutral molecules to sulfobutyl ether beta-cyclodextrins (SBE-beta-CDs): the effect of total degree of substitution. Pharm Res 2000; 17: 936-941
- 14 Zhang G, Shuang S, Dong Z, Dong C, Pan J. Investigation on the inclusion behaviour of neutral red with hydroxypropyl cyclodextrin and sulfobutylether cyclodextrin. Anal Chim Acta 2002; 474: 189-195
- 15 Saokham P, Muankaew C, Jansook P, Loftsson T. Solubility of cyclodextrins and drug/cyclodextrin complexes. Molecules 2018; 23: 1161-1176
- 16 Szablewski M, Thomas PR, Thornton A. , et al. Highly dipolar, optically nonlinear adducts of tetracyano-p-quinodimethane: synthesis, physical characterization, and theoretical aspects. J Am Chem Soc 1997; 119: 3144-3154
- 17 Bönninghausen CMF. Therapeutic Pocketbook. Munster: Coppenrath’sche Buch- und Kunsthandlung; 1846
- 18 Reichardt C, Welton T. Solvent effects on the absorption spectra of organic compounds. In: Solvents and Solvent Effects in Organic Chemistry. 4th ed. Weinheim: Wiley-VCH; 2011: 365-367
- 19 Liptay W. Electrochromism and solvatochromism. Angew Chem Int Ed 1969; 8: 177-188
- 20 Albert IDL, Marks TJ, Ratner MA. Rational design of molecules with large hyperpolarizabilities: electric field, solvent polarity, and bond length alternation effects on merocyanine dye linear and nonlinear optical properties. J Phys Chem 1996; 100: 9714-9725
- 21 Callis PR. Electrochromism and solvatochromism in fluorescence response of organic dyes: a nanoscopic view. In: Advanced Fluorescence Reporters in Chemistry and Biology. Heidelberg: Springer; 2010: 309-330
- 22 Niedbalska M, Gruda I. Effect of substituents on the solvatochromism of stilbazolium merocyanines. Can J Chem 1990; 68: 691-695
- 23 Davidenko NA, Derevyanko NA, Ishchenko AA, Pavlov VA. Effect of electric field on the optical absorption of amorphous molecular semiconductors doped with polymethine dyes. Phys Solid State 2001; 43: 1426-1432
- 24 Xu XF, Kahan A, Zilberg S, Haas Y. Photoreactivity of a push-pull merocyanine in static electric fields: a three-state model of isomerization reactions involving conical intersections. J Phys Chem A 2009; 113: : 9779-9791
- 25 Loew LM. Design and Use of Organic Voltage Sensitive Dyes. In: Canepari M, Zecevic D. , eds., Membrane Potential Imaging in the Nervous System: Methods and Applications. New York, NY: Springer; 2011: 13-23
- 26 Miller EW. Small molecule fluorescent voltage indicators for studying membrane potential. Curr Opin Chem Biol 2016; 33: 74-80
- 27 Mazurkiewicz J, Tomasik P. Effect of external electric field upon selected proteogenic amino acids. Adv Nat Sci 2013; 6: 35-50
- 28 Mazurkiewicz J, Tomasik P. Effect of external electric field upon selected model dipeptides. Adv Nat Sci 2014; 7: 6-11
- 29 Abdel-Halim ST, Awad MK. Absorption, fluorescence, and semiempirical ASED-MO studies on a typical Brooker's merocyanine dye. J Mol Struct 2005; 754: 16-24
- 30 Bruce A. Molecular Biology of the Cell. 6th ed. New York, NY: Taylor and Francis; 2015
- 31 Fried SD, Boxer SG. Electric fields and enzyme catalysis. Annu Rev Biochem 2017; 86: 387-415
- 32 Fried SD, Bagchi S, Boxer SG. Extreme electric fields power catalysis in the active site of ketosteroid isomerase. Science 2014; 346: 1510-1514
- 33 Lenger K, Bajpai RP, Drexel M. Delayed luminescence of high homeopathic potencies on sugar globuli. Homeopathy 2008; 97: 134-140
- 34 Assumpção R. Electrical impedance and HV plasma images of high dilutions of sodium chloride. Homeopathy 2008; 97: 129-133
- 35 Rey L. Can low-temperature thermoluminescence cast light on the nature of ultra-high dilutions?. Homeopathy 2007; 96: 170-174