A Biomechanical Comparison of Screw and Plate Fixations for Scaphoid Fractures
15 June 2017
15 July 2017
14 August 2017 (eFirst)
Background Headless screw fixation is the current gold standard of surgical repair for scaphoid fractures. However, maintaining reduction of certain types of scaphoid fractures is challenging with a compression screw. Plate fixation may offer superior fixation in some scaphoid fractures, particularly those with comminution, nonunion, segmental bony defects, and osteopenic or osteoporotic bone.
Purpose This study questions whether method of fixation is a determinant in load to failure in segmental scaphoid fractures, and whether any fixation provides a greater mechanical advantage in simulated normal versus osteoporotic bone.
Materials and Methods Polyurethane models were fashioned to simulate scaphoids with 3-mm segmental defects. Defects were bridged by one of three constructs: a locking plate, a nonlocking plate, or a headless compression screw. Three models for each fixation construct were tested for both simulated normal and osteoporotic bone density. Load to failure was recorded as the load at which the 3-mm segmental defect was closed.
Results Gap closure occurred in all trials. In simulated normal bone, there were no statistically significant differences in load to failure between fixation methods. In simulated osteoporotic bone, the locking plate had a 28% greater load to failure as compared with screw fixation.
Conclusion While biomechanical testing shows that plate and screw fixations are equivalent in normal density bone for fixation of a segmental scaphoid defect, locking plates are superior to screw fixation in simulated osteoporotic bone models.
Clinical Relevance Plate fixation may provide superior fixation for complex scaphoid fractures, particularly in osteopenic bone.
- 1 Smith DK, Cooney III WP, An KN, Linscheid RL, Chao EY. The effects of simulated unstable scaphoid fractures on carpal motion. J Hand Surg Am 1989; 14 (2 Pt 1): 283-291
- 2 Ruby LK, Stinson J, Belsky MR. The natural history of scaphoid non-union. A review of fifty-five cases. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1985; 67 (03) 428-432
- 3 Watanabe K. Analysis of carpal malalignment caused by scaphoid nonunion and evaluation of corrective bone graft on carpal alignment. J Hand Surg Am 2011; 36 (01) 10-16
- 4 Kawamura K, Chung KC. Treatment of scaphoid fractures and nonunions. J Hand Surg Am 2008; 33 (06) 988-997
- 5 Leixnering M, Pezzei C, Weninger P. , et al. First experiences with a new adjustable plate for osteosynthesis of scaphoid nonunions. J Trauma 2011; 71 (04) 933-938
- 6 Amadio PC, Berquist TH, Smith DK, Ilstrup DM, Cooney III WP, Linscheid RL. Scaphoid malunion. J Hand Surg Am 1989; 14 (04) 679-687
- 7 Reigstad O, Grimsgaard C, Thorkildsen R, Reigstad A, Rokkum M. Long-term results of scaphoid nonunion surgery: 50 patients reviewed after 8 to 18 years. J Orthop Trauma 2012; 26 (04) 241-245
- 8 Moon ES, Dy CJ, Derman P, Vance MC, Carlson MG. Management of nonunion following surgical management of scaphoid fractures: current concepts. J Am Acad Orthop Surg 2013; 21 (09) 548-557
- 9 Cooney WP, Linscheid RL, Dobyns JH, Wood MB. Scaphoid nonunion: role of anterior interpositional bone grafts. J Hand Surg Am 1988; 13 (05) 635-650
- 10 Daly K, Gill P, Magnussen PA, Simonis RB. Established nonunion of the scaphoid treated by volar wedge grafting and Herbert screw fixation. J Bone Joint Surg Br 1996; 78 (04) 530-534
- 11 Huene DR, Huene DS. Treatment of nonunions of the scaphoid with the Ender compression blade plate system. J Hand Surg Am 1991; 16 (05) 913-922
- 12 Dodds SD, Patterson JT, Halim A. Volar plate fixation of recalcitrant scaphoid nonunions with volar carpal artery vascularized bone graft. Tech Hand Up Extrem Surg 2014; 18 (01) 2-7
- 13 Ghoneim A. The unstable nonunited scaphoid waist fracture: results of treatment by open reduction, anterior wedge grafting, and internal fixation by volar buttress plate. J Hand Surg Am 2011; 36 (01) 17-24
- 14 Muller M, Allgower M, Schneider R. Buttress Plate Manual of Internal Fixation, 3rd ed. Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag; 1991
- 15 Kakar S, Einhorn T. Biology and enhancement of skeletal repair. In: Skeletal Trauma, 4th ed. Philadelphia: Saunders; 2009: 33-50
- 16 Madeley NJ, Stephen AB, Downing ND, Davis TR. Changes in scaphoid bone density after acute fracture. J Hand Surg [Br] 2006; 31 (04) 368-370
- 17 Wagner MA, Frigg R. Locking plates: development, biomechanics, and clinical application. In: Skeletal Trauma, 4th ed. Philadelphia: Saunders; 2009: 143-176
- 18 Nakamura R, Horii E, Watanabe K, Tsunoda K, Miura T. Scaphoid non-union: factors affecting the functional outcome of open reduction and wedge grafting with Herbert screw fixation. J Hand Surg [Br] 1993; 18 (02) 219-224
- 19 Radford PJ, Matthewson MH, Meggitt BF. The Herbert screw for delayed and non-union of scaphoid fractures: a review of fifty cases. J Hand Surg [Br] 1990; 15 (04) 455-459
- 20 Patel PSD, Shepherd DET, Hukins DWL. Compressive properties of commercially available polyurethane foams as mechanical models for osteoporotic human cancellous bone. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 2008; 9: 137
- 21 Li B, Aspden RM. Composition and mechanical properties of cancellous bone from the femoral head of patients with osteoporosis or osteoarthritis. J Bone Miner Res 1997; 12 (04) 641-651
- 22 Sugathan HK, Kilpatrick M, Joyce TJ, Harrison JW. A biomechanical study on variation of compressive force along the Acutrak 2 screw. Injury 2012; 43 (02) 205-208
- 23 Crawford LA, Powell ES, Trail IA. The fixation strength of scaphoid bone screws: an in vitro investigation using polyurethane foam. J Hand Surg Am 2012; 37 (02) 255-260
- 24 Schmitt R, Lanz U. Diagnostic Imaging of the Hand. New York: Georg Thieme Verlag; 2008
- 25 McCallister WV, Knight J, Kaliappan R, Trumble TE. Central placement of the screw in simulated fractures of the scaphoid waist: a biomechanical study. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2003; 85-A (01) 72-77
- 26 Koh I-H, Kang H-J, Kim J-S, Park S-J, Choi Y-R. A central threadless shaft screw is better than a fully threaded variable pitch screw for unstable scaphoid nonunion: a biomechanical study. Injury 2015; 46 (04) 638-642